Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Bihar Sales Tax Act, 1959 (hereinafter referred to as the Act).
  • sub-section (5) of section 16
  • sub-section (8) of section 3,
  • sub-section (3) of section 4
  • section 7(2)(b)
  • section 18(1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Bihar Sales Tax Act, 1959 (hereinafter referred to as the Act).
  • sub-section (5) of section 16
  • sub-section (8) of section 3,
  • sub-section (3) of section 4
  • section 7(2)(b)
  • section 18(1)
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Common Judgment in C.W.J.C. Nos. 1505–1507 of 1973

Factual and Procedural Background

The three writ petitions (C.W.J.C. No. 1505 of 1973, C.W.J.C. No. 1506 of 1973 and C.W.J.C. No. 1507 of 1973) were disposed of by a common judgment because a common legal question arose. The petitioners (Bhimraj Madan Lal in each petition) had, through their Arhatia, sold manufactured pulses outside the State of Bihar during the following periods and amounts:

  • C.W.J.C. No. 1505 of 1973 — sales worth Rs. 10,09,040.71 (period 1968–1969);
  • C.W.J.C. No. 1506 of 1973 — sales worth Rs. 22,77,666.44 (period 1970–1971);
  • C.W.J.C. No. 1507 of 1973 — sales worth Rs. 16,17,876.85 (period 1969–1970).

The petitioners claimed deduction/exemption for sales made outside the State under the Bihar Sales Tax Act, 1959 (the Act). The Sales Tax authorities issued a common notice identified as Annexure '3' under section 18(1) of the Act to reopen earlier assessments on the ground that deductions/exemptions (claimed on account of sales outside the State, and linked to production of form IX) had been wrongly allowed. The petitioners sought quashing of Annexure '3'. B.P. Jha, J. authored the principal reasoning; S. Sarwar Ali, J. concurred in the result and main reasoning.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Sales Tax authorities can reopen an earlier assessment under section 18(1) of the Bihar Sales Tax Act, 1959 in respect of materials that were already available at the time of the earlier assessment order, merely for the purpose of changing or revising their opinion?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners contended that the sales of manufactured pulses were made outside the State of Bihar and therefore exempt under section 4(1)(b) of the Act.
  • The petitioners relied on their registration certificates (which described dealings in manufactured pulses) and production of form No. IX (declaration form) to support entitlement to purchase raw pulses without payment of sales tax and to claim the deductions/exemptions made in the original assessments.

State / Sales Tax Authorities' Arguments

  • The Sales Tax authorities contended that they had erred in allowing deductions/exemptions on the basis of form IX and that, under the second proviso to section 7(2)(b) of the Act, the amount of purchase should be included in the taxable turnover of the purchasing dealer if the conditions in section 7(2)(b)(i) & (ii) were not fulfilled.
  • On that basis the Sales Tax authorities issued Annexure '3' and sought to reopen the assessments under section 18(1) of the Act, asserting that the original assessments had not properly applied the second proviso to section 7(2)(b).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Income-tax Officer, Income-tax-cum-Wealth-Tax Circle-II, Hyderabad v. Nawab Mir Barket Ali Khan Bahadur (97 I.T.R. 239) Where all material facts were before the assessing officer at the time of the original assessment, authorities cannot reopen the assessment to give a second thought or change opinion on the same material. The court relied on this authority to support the proposition that reopening assessments under section 18(1) is impermissible where the same material existed at original assessment and no new information had come into the authority's possession.
Commissioner of Income Tax, West Bengal v. Dinesh Chandra H. Shah (82 I.T.R. 367) Second thoughts on the same material do not justify reopening an assessment. The court cited this decision (as a supporting precedent) for the principle that re-opening merely to reconsider the same material is not permissible.
Bankipur Club Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bihar and Orissa (82 I.T.R. 831) Reopening is not justified where there is merely an attempt to change opinion on the basis of the same material available at the time of original assessment. The court referred to this authority to reinforce the principle that reassessment cannot be initiated solely to re-evaluate materials already considered.
Full Bench judgment dated 23.1.1984 (Full Bench interpreting section 18(1) of the Act) Interpreted the word "information" in section 18(1) to mean information from external sources not previously in possession of the Sales Tax authorities; the Full Bench also held that information can be gathered from the record as well (i.e., the concept of "information" may include material from the record acquired after assessment). The court applied this interpretation to conclude that Annexure '3' did not show the receipt of any new information from external sources or any new information found in the record after the assessment; therefore the statutory prerequisite for reopening under section 18(1) was not satisfied.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in distinct steps, confined to the materials and statutory provisions cited in the opinion:

  1. Statutory foundation and facts:
    • Section 4(1)(b) of the Bihar Sales Tax Act, 1959 provides that no tax shall be payable on sales or purchases of goods which have taken place outside the State. The petitioners admitted that manufactured pulses were sent to the Arhatia for sale outside Bihar.
    • The petitioners were registered dealers whose registration certificates showed that they dealt in manufactured pulses, and they produced form No. IX to the selling dealers to claim exemption at the time of purchase of raw pulses.
  2. Action taken by Sales Tax authorities:
    • Annexure '3' was issued by the Superintendent of Commercial Taxes to reopen prior assessments under section 18(1) of the Act on the ground that deductions/exemptions on account of sales outside Bihar were wrongly granted, and that, in the assessment authority's view, amounts should have been included under the second proviso to section 7(2)(b).
  3. Interpretation of section 18(1):
    • The court relied on the Full Bench interpretation that "information" under section 18(1) ordinarily means information from external sources which were not earlier in the possession of the Sales Tax authorities; the Full Bench also acknowledged that information could be gathered from the record if it comes into possession after assessment.
    • Section 18(1) contains the condition precedent that, upon information coming into the prescribed authority's possession, the authority must be satisfied that reasonable grounds exist to believe that turnover has escaped assessment, before reopening is permissible.
  4. Application of principles to the facts:
    • The court examined Annexure '3' and the prior assessment records and found that the materials on which the Sales Tax authorities relied (i.e., that manufactured pulses were sent outside the State, that the petitioners were registered dealers in manufactured pulses, and that form No. IX had been produced) were already available and had been considered at the time of the original assessments.
    • Because those materials were already on the record and had been applied by the assessing authorities, the attempted reopening amounted to reappraising the same material or giving a "second thought" — precisely the situation the cited precedents disallow.
    • Annexure '3' did not allege receipt of any new information from external sources nor did it demonstrate that any new information had come from the record subsequent to assessment; nor did it indicate that the prescribed authority was satisfied that reasonable grounds existed to believe that turnover had escaped assessment.
  5. Conclusion of legal analysis:
    • Given that the statutory preconditions for invoking section 18(1) were absent, reopening was impermissible. The Sales Tax authorities could not reopen assessments for the purpose of changing or revising their earlier opinion on the same materials.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court allowed the writ petitions and quashed the order contained in Annexure '3' in all the petitions. The parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: Annexure '3' (the notice/order reopening the assessments under section 18(1) of the Bihar Sales Tax Act, 1959) was quashed for each petition; the petitioners' original assessments as made prior to Annexure '3' were thereby protected from reopening on the same available materials.
  • Law applying to reopening under section 18(1): The decision reinforces that reopening an assessment under section 18(1) requires new information (from external sources or newly discovered in the record after assessment) and a satisfaction by the authority of reasonable grounds to believe that turnover escaped assessment. Mere dissatisfaction with or reconsideration of the original assessment on the same materials is not a permissible basis for reopening.
  • No new precedent beyond application: The court applied existing authorities (including a Full Bench interpretation and cited income-tax decisions) to the facts; the opinion does not assert that it is laying down a new principle beyond the application of those precedents to the present facts.

Disposition: The petitions were allowed; Annexure '3' in each petition was quashed; parties to bear their own costs. S. Sarwar Ali, J. concurred with B.P. Jha, J.'s formulation, reasoning and result.

    M/S. Bhimraj Madan Lal Petitioner In All The Three Writ Petitions v. The State Of Bihar S In And Another All The Three Writ Petitions.

    B.P Jha, J.:— I shall dispose of these three writ petitions, i.e C.W.J.C No. 1505 of 1973, C.W.J.C No. 1506 of 1973 and C.W.J.C No. 1507 of 1973 by a common judgment, as a common point of law arises for consideration in these writ petitions.

    2. The relevant facts are these: In C.W.J.C No. 1505 of 1973, petitioners, Bhimraj Madan Lal, sold pulses worth, Rs. 10,09,040.71 outside the State of Bihar through its Arhatia during the period 1968–1969. Similarly in C.W.J.C No. 1506 of 1973 petitioners, Bhimraj Madan Lal, during the period 1970–1971 sold pulses worth Rs. 22,77,666.44 outside the State of Bihar through its Arhatia. In C.W.J.C No. 1507 of 1973 petitioners, Bhimraj Madan Lal, had, during the period 1969–1970, sold pulses worth Rs. 16,17,876.85 outside the State of Bihar through its Arhatia.

    3. The short point for consideration is:

    4. Whether the Sales Tax authorities can reopen the case in respect of the materials which were already available at their earlier assessment order simply for changing or revising their opinion? The answer must be given in the negative.

    5. These petitioners claimed deduction or exemption on account of sales outside the State of Bihar under the Bihar Sales Tax Act, 1959 (hereinafter referred to as the Act). Such sales are exempted from the purview of the Act. It is relevant to quote section 4(1)(a) & (b) of the Act which run as follows:—

    “4(1) No tax shall be payable under this Act on sales or purchases of goods which have taken place—

    (a) in the course of inter-State trade or commerce;

    (b) outside the State;

    xxxxxx

    6. On a perusal of section 4(1)(b) of the Act, it is clear that no tax shall be paid under the Act on sales or purchase of goods which have taken place outside the State of Bihar. In this case it is an admitted position that manufactured pulses have been sent to the Arhatia for selling them outside the State of Bihar.

    7. In these writ petitions, the petitioners have prayed for quashing annexure ‘3’. Annexure ‘3’ is common in all the writ petitions. Annexure ‘3’ is a notice issued by the Superintendent of Commercial Taxes, Patna upon these petitioners. On a perusal of annexure ‘3’, it is clear that by virtue of annexure ‘3’, the Sales Tax authorities reopened the assessments under section 18(1) of the Act. It is relevant to quote section, 18(1) of the Act, which runs as follows:—

    “Turnover of registered dealer escaping assessment:

    “If upon information which has come into his possession, the prescribed authority is satisfied that reasonable grounds exist to believe that any turnover of a registered dealer in respect of any period has, for any reason, escaped assessment or any turnover of any such dealer or a dealer assessed under sub-section (5) of section 16 has been under-assessed or assessed at a rate lower than that which was correctly applicable or any deductions therefrom have been wrongly made, the prescribed authority may, subject to such rules as may be made by the State Government under this Act, and,

    xxxxxx

    8. Annexure ‘3’ has been issued by the Sales Tax authorities in order to reopen the earlier assessment order on the ground that the Sales Tax authorities erred in giving deductions on account of the sales outside the State of Bihar. In other words the Sales Tax authorities are of opinion that the authority ought not to have granted deduction on the basis of form IX. As such the petitioners ought to have shown in their turnover such sales on the basis of second proviso to section 7(2)(b) of the Act.

    9. In C.W.J.C No. 1506 of 1973 annexure ‘3’ does not mention about form IX, nor about proviso to section 7(2)(b) of the Act. It simply states that these petitioners purchased raw pulses and they sent the manufactured pulses to outside the State of Bihar. In C.W.J.C Nos. 1505 and 1507 of 1973, annexure ‘3’ disclosed that the Sales Tax authorities ought not to have granted exemption on the basis of form No. IX (declaration form) as such purchase amount was taxable in view of 2nd proviso to section 7(2)(b) of the Act.

    10. According to the Sales Tax authorities, such sale outside the State of Bihar ought not to have been deducted from the turnover of these petitioners in view of the second proviso to section 7(2)(b) of the Act. In this circumstance the Superintendent of Sales Tax decided to reopen the case under section 18(1) of the Act.

    11. section 18(1) of the Act has been interpreted by the Full Bench in these cases by a judgment]1 dated 23.1.1984 In these cases it has been held that the word “information” means, information from external sources which were not in earlier possession of the Sales Tax authorities. In other words the Full Bench has held that if any information has come into the possession of the Sales Tax authorities from the external sources and the Sales Tax authorities are satisfied that reasonable grounds exist to believe that any turnover of a dealer has escape assessment, then only the case can be reopened. The Full Bench has further held that information can also be gathered from the record as well. In the present case the admitted position is that the sales tax authorities did not receive any information from the external sources nor from the record. According to annexure ‘3’ the Sales Tax authorities reopened the matter simply on the basis of second proviso to section 7(2)(b) of the Act.

    12. It is relevant at this stage to quote section 7(2) and 7(2)(b) of the Act and the second proviso thereto:

    13. For the purposes of this Act the “Taxable turnover” of a dealer shall be:—

    “7(2) in respect of special sales tax, that part of the gross turnover which remains after deducting therefrom—

    “7(2)(b) sale prices on account of sales to a registered dealer other than a dealer liable to pay tax under sub-section (8) of section 3, of goods specified in his registration certificate as being required—

    (i) for reasale by him inside Bihar or in course of inter-State trade or commerce or export out of the territory of India, or

    (ii) for use by him in the packing of goods which he sells inside Bihar or in course of inter-State trade or commerce or export out of the territory of India:

    Provided further that where any goods exempted from the levy of tax by a notification issued by the State Government in this behalf under sub-section (3) of section 4 are purchased by a dealer after furnishing declaration mentioned in the notification or where any goods, specified in the certificate of registration of a dealer, are purchased by him after furnishing a declaration as provided in the first proviso of clause (2) but are utilised by him for any purpose other than those specified in such a notification or specified in item (i) or (ii) of sub-clause (b) of clause (2), as the case may be, the sale-price of the goods so purchased shall without prejudice to any action which is or may be taken under section 38, be deducted from the gross turnover of selling dealer but shall be included in the taxable turnover of the purchasing dealer”.

    14. The second proviso to section 7(2)(b) of the Act provides that if the purchaser does not full the conditions as laid down in section 7(2)(b)(i) and (ii), of the Act, then in that case the purchasing amount shall be included in the taxable turnover of the purchasing dealer. In other words, the State counsel contends that the petitioners-purchasers purchased these goods for manufacturing pulses. The purchasers, according to learned State counsel, purchased the goods for resale inside Bihar or in course of inter-State trade or commerce or export out of the territory of India and as the purchasers-petitioners did not fulfil the conditions as laid down under section 7(2)(b)(i) & (ii) of the Act; and as such, according to the second proviso to section 7(2)(b) of the Act the amount of purchase shall be included in the taxable turnover of the purchasing dealers (the petitioners).

    15. Even if this argument of the State counsel is correct, it cannot be said that the Sales Tax authorities have any authority to reopen the case on the facts and in the circumstances of the case. It has been held in Income-tax Officer, Income-tax-cum-Wealth-Tax Circle-II, Hyderabad v. Nawab Mir Barket Ali Khan Bahadur (97 I.T.R 239) that since all material facts were before the officer when he made the original assessments, the authorities cannot reopen the assessment orders for giving second thought on the same material or for changing the opinion. On this point see also (1) Commissioner of Income Tax, West Bengal v. Dinesh Chandra H. Shah (82 I.T.R 367); (2) Bankipur Club Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bihar and Orissa (82 I.T.R 831). It has been held specifically by the Supreme Court that having second thoughts on the same material did not warrant the initiation of the proceedings for reopening a case. This also is the opinion of the Full Bench in these cases.

    16. The Sales Tax authorities are reopening the case on the ground that the Sales Tax authority did not apply his mind in respect of the second proviso to section 7(2)(b) of the Act. In this connection the Sales Tax authorities are relying upon form IX (declaration form). If a sale is made by a registered dealer to another registered dealer, the purchasing dealer is exempted from payment of sales tax under section 5(1) of the Act, provided he produces form no. IX. Registration certificate is granted by the Sales Tax authorities in respect of the goods in which he will deal in.

    17. In the present case, the registration certificates disclose that these petitioners will deal in manufactured pulses. It is for this reason that the petitioners are entitled to be exempted from the payment of sales tax to the registered dealer in respect of the goods mentioned in the registration certificate. It is for this reason that the petitioners can purchase raw pulses for manufacturing pulses from a registered dealer without payment of tax. In order to get exemption, the petitioners will have to produce form IX to show that they deal in goods mentioned in the registration certificate. It is an admitted position that the petitioners purchased the goods mentioned in the registration certificates for manufacturing pulses. The only question is that the Sales Tax authorities granted exemption without following the second proviso to section 7(2)(b) of the Act.

    18. It appears from annexure ‘3’ that all the materials, on which the Sales Tax authorities want to reopen the case, were available before the assessing authorities. In other words, these documents were available before the assessing authorities and they applied their mind to the following documents—

    (1) that the manufactured pulses were sent to the Arhatia for selling them outside the State;

    (2) that the petitioners were register-red dealers. Their registration certificates mentioned the fact that these petitioners are dealing in manufactured pulses; and

    (3) that the petitioners produced forms no. IX in order to show that the petitioners are entitled to purchase raw pulses from registered dealers without paying any sales tax.

    19. On these materials which were available at the time of original assessments, the Sales Tax authorities want to reopen the case. In my opinion that cannot be done. It will amount to revise the opinion or to give second thought on the materials which existed at the time of the passing of the original assessment orders. The assessment orders clearly suggest that these materials were available on the record. In view of the decisions of the Supreme Court, the Sales Tax authorities cannot give a second thought or revise opinion in respect of the materials which already existed. On the same materials which were available at the time of the original assessment orders, the Sales Tax authorities are reopening the case for bringing the case within the purview of second proviso to section 7(2)(b) of the Act. Can they do so? The answer must be given in the negative. Since all the materials are available at the time of original assessments, the Sales Tax authorities cannot reopen the case under section 18(1) of the Act.

    20. The word ‘information’ contemplated under section 18(1) of the Act is an ‘information’ which is available from the external source after passing of the assessment orders. No such information is available on the record. The Full Bench has held that the word ‘information’ contemplates ‘the information’ from the record as well. No such information is available from the record of the case.

    21. Annexure ‘3’ in all the petitions do not disclose that the Sales Tax authorities were satisfied that reasonable grounds exist to believe on the basis of the information which has come into their possession to the effect that these petitioners have escaped assessments. Therefore, the condition precedent for reopening the case does not exist at all. Hence I hold that the Sales Tax authorities have no authority, to reopen the case, as the condition, precedent, as laid down in section 18(1) of the Act, has not been fulfilled. The condition precedent for reopening a case under section 18(1) of the Act are these:—

    (1) That there must be an information either from external source or from the record which has come into possession of the Sales Tax authority subsequent to the assessment order; and

    (4) That the Sales Tax authority is satisfied that reasonable grounds exist to believe that any turnover of a registered dealer has escaped assessment.

    22. In the result these petitions are allowed and the order contained in annexure ‘3’ are hereby quashed. The parties will bear their own costs.

    S. Sarwar Ali, J.:— I agree that annexure ‘3’ in all the writ applications be quashed. My learned brother, if I say so with respect, has rightly formulated the question for consideration in paragraph 3 of the judgment. For the reasons given by him, I am also of the clear opinion that what the assessing authority is purporting to do in these cases is to reopen the assessment orders for giving second thought on the same materials or in other words for changing the opinion on the materials which have already been considered.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S. Bhimraj Madan L... v. The State Of Bihar S...
    (Apr 14, 1984)