Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This set of writ applications arose from admissions to the First Year M.B.B.S. classes of various State-controlled medical colleges in Bihar and the First Year B.D.S. class of Patna Dental College for the 1979-1980 session. A Board of Principals (convened by Shri R.P. Singh) issued a prospectus and held a combined Pre-Medical and Dental Test in July 1979. First and second lists of successful candidates were published (13-4-1980 and 12-10-1980), but after those admissions some seats remained vacant (disputed numbers: petitioners stated 48 vacancies across institutions; respondents' counter-affidavit referred to about 29).

To fill the remaining vacancies, the Convenor issued a notice dated 4-12-1980 calling 62 candidates to appear for interview on 15-12-1980; the appended list of 62 candidates was arranged in order of merit. The petitioners (Brij Kishore Prasad; Samir Kumar Das; Satish Chandra Gupta) appeared at that interview but no result of the interview was announced and no admissions followed. The petitioners filed writ petitions seeking mandamus to direct the respondents to declare the result of the interview of 15-12-1980 and to admit eligible petitioners to the vacant seats.

Respondents filed counter-affidavits and argued, inter alia, that further admission was stopped because the academic session had advanced and late admissions would prevent students from completing required course attendance and eligibility for examination; a Government letter dated 3-3-1981 (Annexure A to respondents' counter-affidavit) was relied upon as communicating the decision to stop further admissions and to dissolve the Board of Principals. The Court, by common order dated 5-5-1981, allowed the three applications in part, quashed the Government order (letter dated 3-3-1981) and directed the respondents to fill the vacant seats on the basis of the Pre-Medical and Dental Test results and the interview held on 15-12-1980. The present opinion gives reasons for that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State and the Board of Principals (and their convenor) had a public duty to fill up all available vacant seats in the State-run medical and dental colleges for the 1979-1980 session and to consider applications of eligible candidates who had appeared at the prescribed test and interview.
  2. Whether candidates called for and who appeared at the interview on 15-12-1980 were entitled to have their applications considered and results published, despite the lateness of the interview relative to the session and despite the possibility that late admission might impair eligibility to appear in examinations.
  3. Whether dereserved seats (seats originally reserved for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes but subsequently thrown open) must be treated as general seats for purposes of consideration and admission.
  4. Whether practical administrative concerns (time required to assess candidates' records, risk of derecognition by the Medical Council of India, inability of late-admitted students to complete required course/attendance) can justify refusing to fill vacant seats or refusing consideration of candidates already assessed and interviewed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Board and State had a public and legal duty to publish the result of the interview conducted on 15-12-1980 and to admit eligible candidates to the remaining vacant seats on the basis of the competitive test and interview held.
  • The respondents' claim that late admission would prevent completion of course/examination eligibility is a mere pretence and arbitrary; it resulted in unfair and discriminatory treatment because others were admitted in December 1980 and even in January–February 1981.
  • The petitioners were prepared to take any risks associated with belated admission and only sought due consideration of their applications on merit.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The evaluation and scrutiny of the 62 candidates' claims would take a long time, and because the 1979-1980 session (which commenced July 1980) had advanced, candidates admitted late would not be able to complete courses or meet minimum attendance/eligibility to sit the First Year M.B.B.S. examination.
  • The Government decided to stop further admissions for the session and dissolved the Board of Principals; the letter dated 3-3-1981 of the Special Secretary (Health Department) communicated this decision.
  • Medical education is regulated by the Medical Council of India (and by recommendations under the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956); admitting late entrants could risk derecognition of degrees by the Central Government on recommendation of the Council.
  • Some argued that petitioners could not claim seats that were reserved for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (i.e., petitioners should not be considered for those reserved seats unless the Government lawfully dereserved them).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Miss Zeenat Tej v. The Principal of the Prince of Wales Medical College, Patna (A.I.R. 1971 Patna 43) Describes conditions for a right to admission to arise: (i) applicant must have actually applied; (ii) vacancies must exist; (iii) there must be an obligation on authorities to fill vacancies. The Court relied on this test to conclude petitioners had applied, vacancies existed, and therefore the pivotal question was whether authorities were under a duty to fill the vacancies.
Ajay Hasia etc. v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi (A.I.R. 1981 Supreme Court 487) Principle that Article 14 strikes at arbitrariness; arbitrariness negates equality. The Court invoked this authority to support the proposition that arbitrary refusal to admit eligible candidates would violate equality principles (the opinion uses this to argue against arbitrary denial of available seats).
G.P. Hemantha Kumar v. The Selection Committee for Admission to Govt. Medical College, Bangalore (A.I.R. 1981 Karnataka 22) Where a seat had become vacant within the prescribed quota and could be filled by an eligible candidate, the seat should not be allowed to go waste; medical education's importance means vacant quota seats should be filled. The Court relied on this decision as supporting authority for the proposition that no seat in the prescribed quota should go waste and that vacant seats ought to be filled by eligible candidates.
Umesh Chandra Sinha v. V.N. Singh (A.I.R. 1968 Patna 3) Distinguishes the right to due consideration of an application for admission from the right to actual admission; due consideration is justiciable and must be afforded even if subsequent consequences (e.g., examination eligibility) remain for authorities to decide. The Court applied this distinction to hold petitioners were entitled to have their applications considered on merits and could not be denied consideration because of possible later consequences relating to examination eligibility.
Anitha Chandraish v. Selection Committee for M.B.B.S [1981 (1) Karnataka Law Journal 301] Refusal to admit selected candidates solely because admission was sought after formal closure is unacceptable if the candidates cannot be blamed for the delay; late-selected candidates who accept risk may still be entitled to admission. The Court cited this case to support the view that late admission cannot be denied when the delay is not the fault of the selected candidates and when they are prepared to take the risks of late admission.
A.I.R. 1979 Delhi 87 (Delhi High Court decision) Held that the right to receive professional education is part of Article 19(1)(f) of the Constitution (as noted by the Court in this opinion). The Court referred to this decision to underline the constitutional importance of access to professional education when discussing the State's duty under Directive Principles and other constitutional provisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court set out a step-by-step analysis constrained to the facts and authorities in the record:

  1. Existence of statutory/instrumental facts: The Court accepted (and noted that petitioners' averments on this point were not controverted) that the petitioners had applied, the combined test had been held, and there remained vacancies after initial admissions. The notice of 4-12-1980 calling 62 candidates to interview (with the appended merit-ordered list) was treated as evidence that the Board had already assessed relative merit of the 62 candidates called for interview.
  2. Public duty to fill vacancies: The Court analysed the State's duty in light of the Prospectus provisions, constitutional provisions and precedent. It observed (a) these colleges are State instrumentalities (Article 12 / Part IV), (b) Article 41 imposes a duty on the State to make provision for education (including medical education) within its economic capacity, and (c) once the State makes provision for medical education, it acquires a legal duty to make available seats to eligible persons on reasonable principles.
  3. Prospectus obligations: The Court examined the Prospectus clauses (notably Paragraphs A, O, P, W and Y) and interpreted Paragraph P's “Candidates will be selected for admission strictly on the basis of merit” as imposing an obligation that eligible candidates selected on merit should not be denied admission to available seats. Paragraph O made the Board's decisions final in matters relating to test and admission. The Prospectus thus reinforced a public duty to fill available seats consistent with merit and reservation rules.
  4. Reliance on precedent: The Court relied on earlier decisions (including Miss Zeenat Tej, G.P. Hemantha Kumar, Umesh Chandra Sinha and others) to support the proposition that (i) applicants have a right to consideration where vacancies exist and an obligation to fill vacancies may exist, and (ii) seats in medical education should not be allowed to go waste; also distinguishing the right to consideration from the right to immediate examination eligibility.
  5. Addressing respondents' factual and administrative defenses:
    • The Court rejected the respondents' contention that merits could not be assessed in time: the notice and appended list showed the Board had already arranged the 62 candidates in order of merit; the stated purpose of interview was primarily verification of original documents rather than assessment of relative merit.
    • The Court held that if the Government had lawfully dereserved SC/ST seats and thrown them open, those dereserved seats must be treated as general seats and candidates should have equal entitlement to compete for them.
    • The Court considered and rejected the argument that late admission per se violated the Medical Council's recommendations or would necessarily lead to derecognition: the Medical Council recommendations relied upon concerned prescribed periods of certified study and the sequencing of phase subjects, not a categorical bar on admissions after a certain date; further, a letter from the inter-university Board indicated the 18-month counting is for the class as a whole from commencement, not an individual student's joining date.
    • The Court accepted the principle (from Umesh Chandra Sinha and other authorities) that the petitioners' present claim is for due consideration and admission, and any later consequences relating to examination eligibility are matters for the authorities to address under rules/regulations; petitioners were prepared to take risks associated with belated admission.
  6. Futility and discrimination arguments: The Court rejected the contention that relief would be futile. It noted that even if petitioners could not sit the immediate examination, admission would give them a chance to complete the course and qualify for subsequent examinations. The Court also observed that some other candidates had been admitted in December 1980 and even in January–February 1981, which suggested unfair discrimination against the petitioners if they were denied admission on the same ground.
  7. Conclusion of reasoning: On the combined analysis of constitutional duty, prospectus obligations, precedents, and the factual record (merit-ordered list and the stated purpose of interview as certificate verification), the Court concluded that the State and the Board were under a public duty to fill the available seats and to consider and admit eligible petitioners selected on the basis of the test and interview held on 15-12-1980, unless compelling reasons were shown to restrain such a direction.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

APPLICATIONS ALLOWED IN PART; the Government letter dated 3-3-1981 (Special Secretary, Health Department) was quashed; the respondents were directed to fill the vacant seats in the First Year M.B.B.S. classes and the First Year B.D.S. class of Patna Dental College for the 1979-1980 session on the basis of the results of the Pre-Medical and Dental Test and the interview held on 15-12-1980, without further delay.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The immediate consequence was that the respondents were ordered to consider and fill existing vacant seats by reference to the established merit list and the interview of 15-12-1980, and to admit eligible petitioners accordingly. The Government's decision to stop further admissions (as communicated in the 3-3-1981 letter) was quashed insofar as it prevented filling those vacancies on the stated basis.
  • On broader precedent: The opinion applied and relied upon established High Court and other judgments concerning (a) the right to due consideration of applications for admission, (b) the duty to fill vacant medical-education seats so as not to let quota seats go waste, and (c) the impermissibility of arbitrary refusals affecting equality. The Court did not purport to lay down novel legal doctrine beyond these applications of existing authority.
  • On administrative concerns: The Court rejected respondents' contentions that administrative delay, possible non-eligibility for immediate examination, or speculative derecognition by the Medical Council objectively justified refusing consideration and admissions where candidates had already been assessed and interviewed.

Note: This summary is limited to the matters expressly contained in the opinion and does not infer or add information that is not present in the provided text.

Applications allowed.

    Brij Kishore Prasad v. Samir Kumar Das

    S. Sarwar Ali and S. Narain, JJ.:— By a common order dated 5.5.1981, we allowed all these three application in part, quashed the order of the Government of Bihar contained in the letter dated 3.3.1981 of the Special Secretary to Government, Health Department, a copy whereof is Annexure ‘A’ to the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the Respondents in C.W.J.C No. ??? and directed the respondent to fill up the ??? cant seats in the First Year M.B.B.S Class of Medical Colleges in the State of Bihar and in the First Year B.D.S Course of Patna Dental College for the Session 1979-1980 on the basis of the result of the Pre Medical and Dental Test Bihar for the aforesaid Session and of an interview held on 15.12.1980 without further delay. We now proceed to give the reasons for that Order.

    2. Brij Kishore Prasad in the petitioner in C.W.J.C No. 403/81, Samir Kumar Das and Satish Chandra Gupta are the petitioners in C.W.J.C Nos. 404/81 and 653/81, respectively. The State of Bihar is the Respondent no. 1 in all the applications and Dr. R.P Singh, Principal of the Patna Dental College and Convenor of the Board of Principal for selecting candidates for admission to the 1st year course of the M.B.B.S and B.D.S Course for the session in 1979-1980 is Respondent no. 2 in C.W.J.C Nos. 408 and 494 of 1931 and was also Respondent no. 2 in C.W.J.C No. 658/81. The Director of Health Services, Bihar is respondent no. 3 in C.W.J.C No. 403.

    3. Admission of students to the First Year of the M.B.B.S Course of the various Medical Colleges in the State of Bihar, namely, Patna Medical College, Patna, Darbhanga Medical College, Laheriasarai, Rajendra Medical College, Ranchi, Bhagalpur Medical College, Bhagalpur, Mahatma Gandhi Memorial Medical College, Jamshedpur, S.K Medical College, Muzaffapur, Nalanda Medical College, Patna, Magadh Medical College, Gaya, Patliputra Medical College, Dhanbad and to the First Year B.D.S Course of Patna Dental College, Agamkuan, Patna, is made on the basis of a combined test held for that purpose by the Board of Principal consisting of some of the Principals of the aforesaid colleges. For admission to the First year M.B.B.S Class of the aforesaid Pre Medical Colleges and the first year B.D.S class of the Dental College for the Session 1979-1980, the State Government appointed a Board of Principals consisting of several Principals including Shri R.P Singh, Principal, Patna Dental College, Patna, who was appointed as the Convenor of that Board. The Board issued a prospectus calling for applications from eligible candidates for admission to the aforesaid courses for the Session 1979-1980. Paragraph ‘A’ of the Prospectus, copy whereof is Annexure-5 in C.W.J.C No. 403/81 provided: Candidates for admission to the first Year M.B.B.S Course and to the First Year B.D.S Course shall have to appear at a competitive test and will be selected on the basis of merit according to the results of the test. The Prospectus specifies the conditions for the competitive test, the last date for receipt of the application forms and the documents which were required to accompany the application forms. The Prospectus provided for issue of admit card, and fixed the date of the test examination. Paragraph ‘O’ of the Prospectus provides “in all matters relating to the test and admission, the decision of the Board of the Principals shall be final—Paragraph ‘P’ runs thus: “Candidates will be selected for admission strictly on the basis of merit as given (A), subject to reservations of seats as per Government rules. Paragraph ‘W’ provides that in case of a candidate being selected provisionally for admission, interview letter will be sent by registered post”. Paragraph ‘Y’ declares “interview does not entitle a candidate for admission”, 14% of seats, according to the Prospectus were reserved for Scheduled Castes, 9% for Scheduled Tribes, 10% for Backward Classes and 20% for ladies.

    4. According to the averments in the petition in C.W.J.C No. 403/81 which has not been controverted the total number of seats in the First Year M.B.B.S Class in the various Medical Colleges aforeasid was 670 and the total number of seats in the First Year B.D.S Course in Patna Dental College was 15. It appears all the three petitioners along with others appeared at the Pre-Medical and Dental Test 1979 which was held sometime in July 1979. The first list of successful candidates was published on 13-4-1980 and the second list on 12.10.1980 It appears that even after the successful candidates of the first and second list had been admitted to the different Medical Colleges after interview, some seats in the Medical Colleges still remained vacant. According to the supplementary affidavit filed on behalf of the petitioner in C.W.J.C No. 403/81, the total number of seats that still remained vacant was 11 in the Patna Dental College and 37 in six of the aforesaid Medical Colleges. According to the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the respondent's in C.W.J.C No. 403/81 which has been adopted in the other writ applications also, the number of vacant seats was about 29. According to the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents which on this point has not been controverted, these vacant seats originally belonged to the quota reserved for students belonging to the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe but were later on released by the Government for being filled up by general students.

    5. It appears that to fill up these vacant seats, the Convenor of the Board of Principal issued a notice dated 4-12-1980 directing 62 of the candidates who had appeared at the test “to appear for an interview for scrutiny of documents etc. in connection with admission into First Year Glass of Medical and Dental Colleges Bihar (Session 1979-1980) on 15-12-1980 at 1 P.M at I.M.A Hall, South Gandhi Maidan, Patna”. The notice required the candidates to bring the documents in original at the time of interview and stated that provisional selection and calling for interview would not entitle a candidate to admission. The 62 candidates, who were called for interview on 15.12.1980, were arranged in order of merit. Brij Kishore Prasad's position in the list was at serial 50 of the list and hose of the petitioners in C.W.J.C No. 653 of 1981 and 404/81 at serial nos. 6 and 7, respectively. Admittedly, all the three petitioners appeared at the interview held on 15.12.1980 but the result of the interview held on 15.12.1980 was not announced inspite of representation made by the petitioners.

    6. According to the petitioners, it is the public duty of the Board of Principals, and the State and the other authorities concerned to publish the result of the interview and to admit students to the remaining vacant seats in the different Medical Colleges and Patna Dental College on the basis of the admission test and interiew held and the respondents were duty bound to publish the result of the test and interview held on 15.12.1980 and to fill up the vacant seats in the colleges on the aforesaid basis. The petitioners accordingly, have come to this Court and pray for a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents, the State of Bihar and the Principal, Patna Dental College, the Convenor of the Board of Principal, who conducted the test to declare the result of the test and interview held on 15.12.1980 and pass other consequential order, namely, direct the admission of the petitioners to the vacant seats if they are eligible for admission on the basis of the result of the admission test and the interview held.

    7. Cause has been shown on behalf of the respondent and a counter affidavit on behalf of the respondent, State of Bihar, and the Convenor of the Board of Principal and the Director of Health Services has been filed in C.W.J.C No. 403/81. Supplementary affidavits and supplementary counter-affidavits have also been filed. The counter-affidavits filed in C.W.J.C No. 403/81 have been adopted by the respondents in the other cases also. The main ground on which the prayer for the relief claimed by the petitioners has been opposed on behalf of respondents is that the determination of the claims for admission of the 62 students who were called for interview and were interviewed by the Board of Principals, would have taken a long time the Session for the aforesaid first Year M.B.B.S Course which had commenced in July 1980 had far advanced and the 62 students who were called for interview, if ultimately admitted, would not have been in a position to complete the necessary courses or attend the minimum number of classes prescribed in the First Year M.B.B.S Examination and the Government decided to stop any further admission to the First Year M.B.B.S Class and the First Year B.D.S Course and dissolved the Board of Principal canstituted for the porpose of selecting candidates for admission to the aforesaid classes for the 1979-1980 session. The order of the Government stopping further admission and dissolving the Board of Principal has not been filed in this Court but the said order is mentioned in the letter dated 3.3.1981 of the Special Secretary to the Government of Bihar Health Department, addressed to the Advocate General, Bihar, a copy of which has been annexed to the counter-affidavit of the respondents and marked Annexure—A.

    8. The further case of the respondents is that Medical Education, including the M.B.B.S and B.D.S Courses, is conducted under the supervision and direction of the Medical Council of India which has prescribed the course of study, the period of the courses and the conditions of eligibility to set for the examination and if students who were not in a position to qualify themselves for the purpose of appearance at the M.B.B.S Examination are admitted to the various colleges, the medical degree granted by the Universities to which the various colleges are affiliated may run the risk of dere cognition.

    9. A rejoinder to the counter affidavit was filed on behalf of the petitioner in C.W.J.C No. 403 of 1981. According to the rejoinder the plea of the Government that the students were called for interview on 15.12.1980 could not be admitted because if admitted they could not have completed the course etc. was a mere pretence and the action of the Government taken at the instance of the Health Minister was completely arbitrary and discriminatory because some students were admitted to the different Medical Colleges in the State in October and December 1980 and even in January 1981.

    10. The first question for determination is if there is any public duty cast on the State of Bihar and the respondent convenor of the Board of Principals to decide who are the persons eligible to be admitted and to fill up all the vacant seats in the different medical colleges of the Bihar and also in the Patna Dental College for which applications were invited and admission test was held. It is well settled that an applicant for admission has a right to get his application considered in accordance with law. But as pointed out by A.B.N Sinha, J., speaking for a Bench of this Court in (1) Miss Zeenat Tej v. The Principal of the Prince of Wales Medical College, Patna and there (A.I.R 1971 Patna 43)- “this right, however, cannot arise unless the following conditions are satisfied: (i) The applicant concerned must have actually applied for admission into an educational institution (ii) there must be vacancies in the class into which admission is sought for and, further there must be an obligation on the part of the authorities to fill up these vacancies”. There is no doubt that all the petitioners had actually applied for admission into the different medical colleges. There is also no doubt that a certain number of vacancies in those colleges exist. Though there is dispute about the exact number of vacencies even according to the respondents there are about 29 vacancies. The only question for decision in this connection, therefore, is whether there is a duty or obligation imposed on the respondents, the authorities concerned, to fill up all the vacant seats in the medical colleges of the State of Bihar.

    11. All the aforesaid medical Colleges and the Patna Dental College are institutions maintained by or least managed and controlled by the State Government, and are therefore instrumentalities of the State and, therefore, ‘State’ within the meaning of the expression as used in Article 12 and also Part IV of the Constitution. The right to receive professional education being a prerequisite for carrying on the medical profession has been held by the Delhi High Court to be a part of the fundamental right under Article 19(1)(f) of the Constitution, vide the decision reported in A.I.R 1979 Delhi 87. Even if we do not go to that extent, there can be no doubt, that according to the directive principles of policy contained in Part IV of the Constitution, it is duty of the State to make provision for medical education. Article 41 of the Constitution commands: “The State shall, within the limits of its economic capacity and development, make effective provision for securing the right to work, the education……”. It is obvious that the right to education in Article 41 includes the right to medical education. And the duty of effectively securing the aforesaid right to medical education, establishment and maintenance medical colleges or institutions imparting medical education is not enough; provision must also be made for the admission to those institutions of people suitable for admission to those courses, selected on some reasonable principle. The duty of making effective provision for securing the right to education in Article 41, therefore, includes the duty of admitting students to the available seats in the various medical colleges established or maintained or controlled by the State.

    12. It is true that the duty imposed upon the State by Article 41 which forms part of the directive principles is not enforceable by any Court. But once the State, either by legislative or administrative action, provides facilities for medical education in performance of the duty imposed upon it by Article 41, it has the legal duty, subject to availability of the seats in the institutions, to make the right to medical education available to every eligible person desirous of exercising the right, selected; in case of limited number of seats, on some reasonable principle. It cannot arbitrarily refuse to fill up the seats in the various medical institutions and thus deny the opportunity to receive the medical education to person desirous of and eligible for the same. If it does so, it would be violating the fundamental right to equality guaranteed to that person by Article 1 of the Constitution. It is, as was pointed out by Bhagwati, J., speaking for the Supreme Court in (2) Ajay Hasia etc. v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi (A.I.R 1981 Supreme Court 487), “well settled that what Article 14 strikes at is arbitrariness, because an action that is Arbitrary, must necessarily involve negation of equality” (at page 499 of the report. It may, therefore, be reasonably concluded that when there are a number of seats in the medical college established, maintained or controlled by the State, a public duty is imposed upon the State to fill up all the available seats in those medical Colleges by persons seeking admission thereto who are eligible for admission and have been, in case of competition for the seats, selected on some rational principle.

    13. 12(A). Further, it must be remembered, that the establishment and maintenance of medical and Dental Colleges involves enormous investment and the creation of the infrastructure for medical education is a very costly affair. And, it is well known that medical facilities in this country and, more so in this State, are poor and the number of trained medical personnel grossly inadequate and, therefore, the need of the people for trained medical personnel is clear and urgent. In the circumstances, it will be completely contrary to reason to assume that the State is under no duty to fill up all the seats in the Medical Colleges, the creation and maintenance of which has involved huge expenditure and which if filled would produce trained medical personnel who are badly needed. In in the light of these general consideration that we proceed to examine the provisions of the Prospectus which regulate the admission.

    14. We have already set out the relevant provisions of the Prospectus. It is manifest that the Prospectus required condidates eligible for admission to the First Year M.B.B.S and B.D.S Classes to file applications and to appear at the competitive test and subject to the reservation in favour of certain classes of candidates, lays down vide paragraph ‘P’ that “Candidates will be selected for admission strictly on the basis of merit” determined in accordance with the result of the competitive test. When Paragraph ‘P’ of the Prospectus is construed in the light of the consideration mentioned above the express provision that candidates “will be selected for admission ??? on the basis of merit” may well be interpreted to contain an explicit provision that the candidates who are eligible for admission on the basis of the merit shall not be denied admission to the seats available in the colleges. The Prospectus, therefore considered in the light of the consideration referred to above, clearly imposed a duty on the State to fill up all available seats which are not reserved for a particular category of students, by eligible candidates selected by the Board of Principals, whose decision in all matters relating to the test and the admission is made final-vide Paragraph ‘O’. This duty is in the nature of a public duty the performance of which can be compelled by a writ in the nature of mandamus.

    15. I am fortified in this conclusion by the decision in (3) G.P Hemantha Kumar v. The Selection High Court in Committee for Admission to Govt. Medical College, Bangalore (A.I.R 1981 Karnataka 22) in which relying on earlier decisions and the relevant rules for selection to the Medical Course, it was held by a learned single Judge of the Karnataka High Court that “if for any reason a seat had become vacant within the prescribed quota and that seat could be filled up by another candidate eligible for that seat, then the same could not be denied on any ground whatsoever as Medical Education being very important, no seat in the prescribed quota should go waste”. I may also state that in Zinat Tej's case (Supra) also, the Bench of this Court on a consideration of the relevant rules and the ordinances held that there was an obligation on the authorities of the Patna University to fill up all the casual vacancies during the session which might arise in the Prince of ??? Medical College, Patna, an institution maintained and controlled by the Patna University.

    16. It was argued by the learned Advocate General appearing for respondents that ??? of the petitioner were entitled to be selected for admission on the basis of ???, against the general seats and therefore, they had no legal right to be admitted or even considered for admission to the vacant seats which were reserved for candidates belonging to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. In our opinion, if, as in this case, the Government has taken a decision to dereserve some seats which were originally reserved for candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes and the reserved seats are thrown open for admission by students belonging to the general category, the dereserved seats stand on the same footing as other general seats, and a candidate has the same right in respect of those seats as he has in respect of the seats which were general seats from the, very beginning. And, if he was entitled to be considered for ad miss, ion to the original general seats, then he is equally entitled to be considered for admission to the dereserved seats and to be admitted, if selected against those seats. The petitioners, therefore, have a right to be considered for admission to the seats which are still vacant in the various Medical Colleges and Patna Dental College, unless there any compelling circumstances which would dissuade this Court to refrain from directing the State Govt. to carry out its duty of filling up the vacant seats in the aforsaid colleges and considering the case of the petitioners for admission to those vacant seats.

    17. One of the reasons given by the respondents for not filling up the vacant seats is that evaluation of the respective merits of the 6 candidates who were called for interview on 15.12.1980 would have been a time consuming process and could not have been completed with a reasonable time after the interview. In Paragraph ‘6’ of the counter-affidavit it is stated that “the claims of all the 62 candidates who had all obtained 80 marks were to be scrutinised in serial according to merit for which their records of other examination etc. and relevant papers have to be examined.” This plea is clearly untenable because the relative merits of all the 62 students who were called for interview held on 15.12.1980 had already been assessed by the Board of Principals. This is clear from the notice dated 4.12.1980, copy whereof is Annexure 4 to the supplementary affidavit of the petition in C.W.J.C No. 403/81, issued to the 62 candidates under the signature of respondent no. 2, the Convenor of the Board of Principals. The names of the 62 candidates who has been called for interview is arranged serially in order of merit in the list of candidates called for interview on 15-12-1980 which is appended to that notice. As I have stated, in the aforesaid merit list, the petitioners stand at serial nos. 6, 7 and 50. Though a reference to the supplementary affidavit has been made in the counter affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents, it has not been specifically denied therein that what is appended to the notice (Annexure 4) is the merit list of candidates called for interview, that is to say, the names of candidates called for interview had been arranged in order of merit. Thus the merit of the candidates called for interview on 15-12-1980 had already been assessed. Further, it is clear from the notice (Annexure-4) that the candidates were directed to appear for interview “for scrutiny of documents etc. in connection with admission” and the candidates were required to bring documents in original at the time of the interview. The main purpose of the interview, therefore, was not assessment of the respective merits of the candidates called for interview but the verification of their certificates etc. submitted with reference to their originals.

    18. The learned Advocate General appearing for the respondents referred to the provisions of Paragraph ‘Y’ of Prospectus and on that basis contended that the fact that the petitioners were called for interview did not entitle them to admission. That is so. But what the petitioners are seeking to enforce is not their right to admission but their right to have their applications for admission considered on merits in accordance with law. As was pointed out by Narasimham, C.J, speaking for a Full Bench of this Court in (4) Umesh Chandra Sinha v. V.N Singh (A.I.R 1968 Patna 3), “the right of a candidate for due consideration of his application for admission on the basis of valid law is distinct from the right of another candidate to be admitted on theft basis of such law. The two rights are ??? distinct and each of them is justiciable.’ (at page 7 of the report.)

    19. The learned Advocate General next argued that the decision of the State Government not to fill up the vacant seats in the Medical Colleges on the basis of the interview held on 15.12.1980 was, justified and legal because the students who would have been admitted, thereafter, would not have been able to complete the courses of study or be eligible to appear at the examination. On the other hand, it is argued on behalf of the petitioners that the question whether the petitioners, if admitted, would be able to complete the course and qualify themselves to appear at Examination held for students admitted earlier in the 1979-1980 session is completely irrelevant for what the petitioners are seeking to enforce is not their right to appear at the examination but their right to be considered for admission to classes. The learned counsel for all the three petitioners stated that all the petitioners were prepared to take all the risks involved in securing admission at sura a belated stage.

    20. The learned Advocate General is right to this extent that as the session commenced in July 1980, the petitioners if admitted on the interview held on 15 December 1980 would not in the normal ??? be able to complete their courses and be eligible to sit at the regular examination held for the students of 1979-1980 session. The Indian Medical Council (hereinafter called ‘the Council), constituted under the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, (herein, after called ‘the Act’) has in its Recommendations on Undergraduate Medical Education adopted by the Medical Council of Indian ??? 1977 laid down that a student ??? the Medical Curriculum ‘shall ??? a period of certified study extending ??? academic year form the date of commencement of his study for the subjects' and that “the first 18 months shall be occur pied in the study of the Phase I subjects and no student shall be permitted to join Phase, II group of subjects until he has passed in all the Phase I subjects” vide Paragraph III of the Recommendations. Even though it has not been shown that these recommendations have been incorporated in regulations framed in exercise of the power conferred on the Council by Section 32 of the Act, still no Medical Institution in India can afford to permit students who have not completed the course of studies in the manner recommended by the Council to appear at a Medical examination. Under Section 19 of the Act the Council has the power to recommend to the Central Government that the courses of study and examination to be undergone in any University or a medical institution in India in order to obtain a recognised medical qualification “are not such as to secure to persons holding such qualification the knowledge, and skill requisite for the efficient practise of medicine” and on the basis of such recommendation, which will generally be accepted, the Central Government may, after, following the procedure prescribed, derecognise the medical qualification granted be the institution after a specific date.

    21. But the learned counsel for the Petitioners are right in contending that the face that the petitioners, if admitted would not be eligible for appearing at the regular examination, is irrelevant for the purposes of these cases. In the Full Bench case of Umesh Chandra Sinha (Supra) the claim of the petitioner of that case for consideration of his application for admission to the First Year M.B.B.S class of the Patna Medical College was opposed by the learned Advocate general for the respondent on the ground that if the petitioner ultimately secured admission, he would not be able to complete the minimum percentage of attendance required by the rules of the University and that, consequently, he was not likely to be sent up for the examination. The argument was rejected and the Full Bench of this Court by its order passed on 10.4.1067 directed the admission of the petitioner, though the examination for the 1st year M.B.B.S Course was to be held on 10.5.67 The reasons for rejecting this contention were Mated thus: At this stage we are not concerned with whether the petitioner will be sent up for the examination or else whether the failure to secure the minimum attendance will be condoned (if ???) in view of the fact that the delay was due to circumstances beyond the control of the petitioner. There are matters to be dealt with by the authorities concerned in accordance with the rules and regulations in force in the University. The petitioner is prepared to take all the risks involved in securing admission at such a belated stage. Once we hold that the offending provisions are unconstitutional, we should not deny him the appropriate relief merely because some other consequence may ensure latter on (at page 11 of the report).

    22. In that case the validity of the certain provisions of an Ordinance governing the admission to the Medical institution concerned was impugned and it was asserted that if those provisions were ignored, the petitioners had preferential claim for admission over those who had been admitted. On a parity of reasoning if we hold as we have done the state Government and the Other authorities are bound to fill up the vacant eats, and to consider the application of the petitioners for those vacant seats and admit hem if they are entitled to admission, we cannot deny the petitioners “the appropriate belief merely because some other consequence may ensure later on”. It must be pointed but that for the late selection whoever-else may be responsible, the petitioners are not and they cannot be blamed at all.

    23. We may also refer to the decision in (5) Anitha Candraish v. Selection Committee for M.B.B.S [1981 (1) Karnataka Law Journal 301] in which the refusal to admit the petitioners of that case who were selected for admission to the concerned Medical College was supported on the ground that the petitioners had sought admission after the admission to the College had closed. This ground was negatived for the reason that for the late selection……the petitioners Cannot be blamed” and having been selected on ??? admission and being prepared to ??? at own risk, the petitioners could not be denied admission on the ground that admission to the College had closed. And the Karnataka High Court issued a writ on the ??? of mandamus directing the admission of the petitioned to the 1st Year M.B.B.S Course.

    24. Further, according to the averments in the supplementary affidavit filed on behalf of the petitioner in C.W.J.C No. 403/81, several students were admitted to the first year M.B.B.S course in the various medical colleges in December 1980 and even in January and February 1981. According to this supplementary-affidavit filed on 14.4.1981, Pradip Kumar Agrawal was admitted in the Magadh Medical College, Gaya, on 17.12.1980, and Rajesh Nandan Sahay and Satish Chandra Prasad were admitted to the same college on 16.1.1981 and 2.4.1981, respectively, and Sanjeeb Kumar was admitted in the Patliputra Medical College Dhanbad on 3.1.1981 According to another supplementary affidavit, admission to the first year M.B.B.S class in M.G.M College, Jamshedpur of Syed Mobarak Ahmad was made on 4.2.1981 and that of Miss Rita Jha on 11.2.1981 These facts have not been controverted on behalf of the State though a counter affidavit in rejoinder was filed on behalf of the respondents several days later, i.e on 27.4.1981 Prima facie, in refusing to fill up the vacant seats on the ground of delay in admission, the respondents are making unfair discrimination against the petitioners.

    25. The learned Advocate General also attempted to argue that if admissions are made at such a late stage in the Medical Colleges, the Medical degrees granted by the Universities of Bihar were likely to be derecognised by the Central Government on the recommendation of the Indian Medical Council because the admission would be in contravention of the recommendations of the Medical Council. In our opinion, this argument is completely untenable. Our attention has not been drawn to any provision in the Act or to any regulation made by the Indian Medical Council or even to any recommendation of the Medical Council to the effect that admission to the first year M.B.B.S Course could not be made beyond a certain date. Reference in this connection has been made by the learned Advocate General only to the Recommendations of the Indian Medical Council aforesaid to the effect that every student shall undergo the prescribed, period of certified study and that the first 18 months shall be occupied in the study of the phase I subjects and no students shall be permitted to join the Phase II group of subjects until he has passed in all the Phase I subjects. The prohibition aforesaid is not against admission of the students to the first year M.B.B.S course but again their being permitted to join Phase II group of subjects without studying case I subjects for 18 mouths. By admitting students at a late stage, the College would not contravene any provision of paragraph ‘I’ of the recommendation aforesaid. The provisions regulating admission to the Medical course are contained in paragraphs ‘1’ and ‘2’ of the aforesaid. Recommendations and it has not been argued, and in our opinion rightly that admission of the petitioners on the basis of the admission test for the determination of merit and interview would infringe any of those provisions. We may also, note that the period of 18 months of study which according to Para, graph III(3) of the Recommendation aforesaid of the Council shall be occupied study of Phase I subject does not, as stated in the Recommendation of the inter University and Board of Medical Regulation Committee in its meeting held on 20.9.1980 The recommendation is incorporated in the letter of the Deputy Secretary to the inter-university Board, a copy whereof is annexed as Annexure-8 to the reply to the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the petitioner in C.W.J.C No. 403/??? “apply to individual students, but it applies to the classes as a whole and is to be counted with effect from the date the classes commenced irrespective of when (“whom” is obviously mistake for when) any individual student joins the classes”. As the classes commenced in July, there will be no breach committed by the Colleges of this provision of the Recommendation aforesaid. This argument of the learned Advocate General must, therefore be rejected.

    26. The only other argument of the learned Advocate General which remains to be considered is that these petitions should be dismissed as the relief claimed, even if granted, would be futile. It is pointed tout that if the petitioners are directed to be admitted to the various medical colleges and the Patna Dental College for the first year M.B.B.S course or B.D.S course for the Session 1979-1980 now, they would not be in position to complete the course of study or the required percentage of attendance and would be ineligible to sit at the examination and, therefore, their admission to the first year course for the 1979-1980 session would serve no useful purpose. This argument, ignores that though they may not be eligible to sit at the first examination held for the student of the first year M.B.B.S class for the 1979-1980 session, the petitioner may became eligible to sit at subsequent examinations. Students who are not able to complete the requisite percentage of attendance and, therefore, are not permitted to appear at an examination do later on become eligible to sit at subsequent examination. It mull be remained that it is difficult to secure admission in a medical college and the admission is not valueless even if the candidate admitted may not be in a position to complete the course within the minimum permissible. If admitted, he would have a chance to complete the course and to qualify for a later examination. The application, therefore, cannot be rejected on the ground that it has become futile.

    27. These are the reasons for the order passed by us in all the three applications on 5.5.1981

    Applications allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Brij Kishore Prasad v. Samir Kumar Das
    (May 22, 1981)