AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These four writ applications arise from a judgment delivered by the Central Government Industrial Tribunal, Dhanbad, concerning four Bonus Appeals under sub-paragraph (4) of paragraph 8 of the Coal Mines Bonus Scheme. The appeals challenged the order of the Regional Labour Commissioner (Central), Dhanbad, dated 14th November 1963. The petitioner, owner of Bhelatand and Sijua Collieries, had changed the weekly day of rest from Sunday to other weekdays due to power shortages, issuing notices accordingly. The employees did not attend work on Sundays following this change, which the petitioner alleged was an illegal strike and sought a declaration to that effect from the Regional Labour Commissioner. The Commissioner and the Industrial Tribunal rejected the employer's claims, holding that the employer had not complied with statutory provisions in effecting the change in weekly holidays, and thus the employees were justified in not working on those Sundays.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the cessation of work by employees on Sundays, after the employer changed the weekly day of rest, amounted to a "strike" under clause (q) of Section 2 of the Industrial Disputes Act.
  2. Whether the employer complied with the provisions of sub-section (4) of Section 36 of the Mines Act and Section 9-A of the Industrial Disputes Act in changing the weekly day of rest.
  3. Whether the employer's failure to comply with statutory provisions rendered the employees' refusal to work lawful and not a strike.
  4. Whether the writ jurisdiction should be exercised to interfere with the appellate order of the Industrial Tribunal confirming the Regional Labour Commissioner's order.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner-Employer's Arguments

  • The employer contended that the employees committed an illegal strike by not attending work on Sundays after the weekly holidays were changed to other days.
  • Mr. Balbhadra Prasad Singh, representing the petitioner, argued that the weekly day of rest might not fall within the scope of "rest intervals" under sub-section (4) of Section 36 of the Mines Act, suggesting possible non-application of this provision.

Respondent-Employees' Position

  • The employees justified their non-attendance on Sundays because the employer failed to comply with the statutory requirements for changing weekly holidays.
  • The refusal to work was not a strike since the order to work on Sundays was unlawful due to non-compliance with Section 9-A of the Industrial Disputes Act and relevant provisions of the Mines Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed whether the cessation of work by employees on Sundays qualified as a "strike" under clause (q) of Section 2 of the Industrial Disputes Act, which requires a concerted action aimed at enforcing an industrial demand. The Court noted that Sundays were traditionally weekly holidays under Section 28 of the Mines Act, which mandates no work on more than six days a week.

The employer's attempt to change weekly holidays to Wednesdays or Thursdays, or to treat Sunday as a working day in lieu of a holiday on 2nd October, 1963, required compliance with statutory provisions. The Regional Labour Commissioner found non-compliance with sub-section (4) of Section 36 of the Mines Act (which concerns rest intervals) and Section 9-A of the Industrial Disputes Act (which governs changes to conditions of service listed in the Fourth Schedule).

While there was some ambiguity whether weekly holidays fall strictly within "rest intervals" as per Section 36, the Court emphasized that the change clearly affected conditions of service under items 5 (holidays) and 8 (change in usage) of the Fourth Schedule to the Industrial Disputes Act. Since the employer did not comply with Section 9-A, the change was unlawful.

Consequently, employees' refusal to work on Sundays was lawful and did not constitute a strike. The Court found no grounds to interfere with the orders of the Regional Labour Commissioner and the Industrial Tribunal.

Holding and Implications

The writ petitions are dismissed with costs.

The Court upheld the decisions of the Regional Labour Commissioner and the Industrial Tribunal that the employer's failure to comply with statutory provisions rendered the change of weekly holidays unlawful, and thus the employees' non-attendance did not amount to an illegal strike. The decision directly affects the parties by affirming the legality of the employees' actions under the circumstances. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing statutory provisions to the facts.

    Tata Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. Workmen Of Tata Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. And Others

    Narasimham, C.J:— These four writ applications arise out of one judgment delivered by the Central Government Industrial Tribunal, Dhanbad in four Bonus Appeals under sub-paragraph (4) of paragraph 8 of the Coal Mines Bonus Scheme (hereafter referred to as the Scheme), against the order of the Regional Labour Commissioner (Central), Dhanbad, dated the 14th November, 1963. As the points in controversy are the same, all the four writ petitions are disposed of in one judgment.

    2. The petitioner is the owner of the two collieries, namely. Bhelatand Colliery and Sijua Colliery. In both the collieries, according to well established usage, Sundays were observed as weekly days of rest. But on the 1.0th September, 1963, due to power shortage, the petitioner-employer desired to stagger the days of the weekly holidays in all its collieries. Accordingly, a notice was issued on the 10th September, 1963, to all the workmen concerned, informing them that in Sijua Colliery Wednesdays will be treated as the weekly days of rest and Sundays will be treated as working days. In Bhelatand Colliery the weekly day of rest was fixed as a Friday, but on the representation of the parties concerned it was changed to every Thursday. It was alleged that the employees did not attend the collieries on the 22nd September, 1963, which was a Sunday. The petitioner-employer thought that the workmen had committed an illegal strike, and hence applied to the Regional Labour Commissioner under sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 8 of the Scheme for a declaration that there was an illegal strike by the workers of the two collieries on the 22nd September, 1963. The decision of the Regional Commissioner went against the employer. He held that there was no strike at all inasmuch as the employer did not comply with the provisions either of sub-section (4) of Section 36 of the Mines Act or of the provisions of Section 9-A of the Industrial Disputes Act in changing the weekly day of rest from a Sunday to a Wednesday or Thursday, as the case may be. Hence according to him, the employees were justified in refusing to work on Sunday, the 22nd September, 1963, and as there was no strike, the question as to whether the strike was legal or illegal for the purpose of paragraph 8 of the Scheme did not arise. His decision was upheld in appeal by the learned Industrial Tribunal. C.W.J.C 346 and 347 of 1965 relate to Bhelatand and Sijua Collieries, respectively, in respect of the absence of the employees from work on Sunday, the 22nd September, 1963.

    3. The petitioner-employer further gave notice to his employees that Sunday, the 29th September, 1963, should be treated as a working day inasmuch as the 2nd October, 1963, was declared a holiday, being Mahatma Gandhi's birthday. On this occasion also the employees did not attend at the collieries for work, and in respect of their non-attendance the employer raised a dispute before the Regional Labour Commissioner under paragraph 8(1) of the Scheme for a declaration that there was an illegal strike. This application was also rejected by the Regional Labour Commissioner and also by the appellate authority, namely, the Industrial Tribunal. C.W.J.C 348 and 349 of 1965 deal with the question about the absence of workmen on Sunday, the 29th September, 1963, in Sijua and Bhelatand Collieries, respectively.

    4. The crucial question for consideration now is whether in exercise of our writ jurisdiction we should interfere with the appellate order of the Industrial Tribunal confirming the order of the Regional Labour Commissioner passed under sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 8 of the Scheme. Admittedly the workmen did not attend to their work in the collieries either on Sunday, the 22nd September, 1963, or on Sunday, the 29th September, 1963. But mere cessation of work will not come within the definition of “strike” as given in clause (q) of Section 2 of the Industrial Disputes Act, unless it can be further shown that such cessation of work was a concerted action for the purpose of enforcing an industrial demand. Formerly Sundays were invariably treated as weekly days of rest as required by Section 28 of the Mines Act. Unless the employer could first satisfy the Tribunal concerned that the change in the weekly holiday from a Sunday to a Wednesday or a Thursday, or the declaration of Sunday, the 29th September, 1963, as a working day in lieu of the declaration of holiday on Mahatma Gandhi's birthday (2nd October, 1963) was done by him in accordance with law the omission of the workmen to attend to work on those two Sundays will not amount to strike. The Regional Labour Commissioner therefore, rightly addressed himself to the question as to whether proper notice of the change in the weekly holiday was given. He thought that the employer had contravened sub-section (4) of Section 36 of the Mines Act and also Section 9-A of the Industrial Disputes Act, and the Tribunal has endorsed his findings on these mailers. So far as sub-section ??? of Section 36 of the Mines Act is concerned there may be some room for argument. That sub-section refers to alteration in the “rest intervals” Section 28 of that Act refers to weekly day of rest, and it is to the effect that “no person shall be allowed to work in a mine on more than six days in any one week”. Section 30 deals with hours for work above ground, and sub-section (2) of that section says:

    “The periods of work of a ivy such adult shall be so arranged that, along with his interval for rest, they shall not in any day spread over more than twelve hours, and that he hall not work for more than five hours continuously before he has had an interval for rest of at least half an hour.”

    5. The words “interval for rest” occur in sub-section (2) of Section 30, and they deal with daily intervals sub-section (4) of Section 36 also refers to “rest intervals” which may be construed to refer to daily rest intervals as referred to in sub-section (2) of S. 30. The weekly holiday referred to in S. 28 as “weekly day of rest” may not strictly speaking, come within the scope of “rest interval” Some support for this view is found in the language of Sub. paragraph (3) of paragraph 6 of the Scheme, which refers to “weekly holiday” There seems to be, therefore, some force in the contention of Mr. Balbhadra Prasad Singh for the petitioner that the learned lower Tribunals were not ??? in examining whether there was compliance with sub-section (4) of Section 36 of the Mines Act. It is, however, not necessary to decide this question finally here in view of my holding that there was non compliance with Section 9-A of the Industrial Disputes Act.

    6. In my opinion, both the Tribunals were justified in holding that there was non-compliance with Section 9-A of the Industrial Disputes Act. That section says that if any of the conditions in the service of workmen specified in the Fourth Schedule of that Act is intended to be changed, the employer must comply with the provisions of that section Eleven items are included in the Fourth Schedule Item 4 deals with hours of work and rest intervals Item 5 deals with leave with wages and holidays Item 8 refers to withdrawal of any customary concession or privilege or change in usage.

    7. Hence, even if I accept the contention of Mr. Balbhadra Prasad Singh that weekly day of rest is not “rest interval” it will undoubtedly come within “holidays” referred to in item 5 of the Fourth Schedule. Then again it is not denied that until the present change was made Sundays were always treated as weekly days of rest, and if workers were required to work on that day they were entitled to extra overtime allonge. Hence by changing the weekly day of rest from Sunday to Wednesday or Thursday there was a change in usage referred to in item 8 of the Fourth Schedule I must therefore, hold that by changing the day of rest the employer altered the conditions of service/of the workmen described items 5 and 8 of the Fourth Schedule and as this was done-without complying in the provisions of Section 9-A of the Industrial Disputes Act the em plover's action in making the change was un-lawful. If therefore, the workmen refused to obey such an unlawful order, it cannot be said that there was any strike, and the question of illegality of strike does not arise. There is therefore, no ground for interference with the orders under challenge. These four writ petitions are dismissed with costs. There will be one consolidated hearing fee of Rs. 200 to be divided equally between respondents 1 and 2 who are the same in all the four writs.

    8. Anwar Ahmad, J.:— I agree.

    EK/VPP/G.G.M

    9. Petitions dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tata Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. Workmen Of Tata Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. And Others
    (Nov 16, 1966)