1. These two appeals have been filed by the insurance company against a common award passed in W.C Case No. 19 of 1986 and W.C Case No. 1 of 1987 which had been heard analogously by the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation (in short, the Commissioner).
2. W.C Case No. 19 of 1986 was filed by the legal heir of late Sukhdev Singh claiming that the deceased was the driver in respect of truck bearing No. ORJ-6665 belonging to the owner Sabyasachi Misra and due to accident on 15 June, 1986, the deceased expired. W.C Case No. 1 of 1987 was originally filed by the father and wife of deceased Rabindra Patra alias Paik, wherein it is also claimed that deceased Rabindra was the driver of the said ill-fated truck and expired in the accident, dated 15 June, 1986.
3. In W.C Case No. 19 of 1996, the owner in his written statement admitted that deceased Sukhdev Singh was the driver of the vehicle and died in course of employment. It was further admitted that the deceased was getting Rs. 1,200 as monthly wages. In W.C Case No. 1 of 1987, however, the owner claimed that deceased Rabindra was not a driver of the vehicle and had resisted me claim petition. In both the cases, the insurance company denied the allegations in the claim applications.
4. Both the cases were heard together. The Commissioner found that admittedly Sukhdev Singh was the driver and had died in course of employment. Keeping in view the age and wages, the Commissioner fixed a sum of Rs. 83,192 as compensation and further directed the insurance company to pay the said amount along with penalty at the rate of 30 per cent. In W.C Case No. 1 of 1987, the Commissioner after referring to the evidence on record including the evidence of the owner himself who had stated that deceased Rabindra Paik was working as a helper, held, that, in fact, deceased Rabindra was working as a helper. The Commissioner further held that deceased Rabindra must have been receiving a salary of Rs. 1,100 including Rs. 300 towards food charges and on that basis calculated Rs. 83,192 as compensation payable to the claimants on the basis that the deceased was aged about 30 years at the time of death.
5. In both these appeals, the learned counsel for the insurance company has contended that since born the claimants were claiming that deceased Sukhdev Singh as well as deceased Rabindra Paik were drivers, the claim applications of both the claimants should be rejected, as there could not have been two drivers in a truck. The Commissioner after referring to the materials on record and after referring to the admission of the owner as well as other evidence on record has held that deceased Sukhdev Singh was the driver whereas deceased Rabindra Paik was the helper in the truck. Such finding is essentially a finding of fact not liable to be disturbed in an appeal under S. 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act.
6. So far as M.A No. 414 of 1992 is concerned, the learned counsel for the insurance company has contended that even assuming that the deceased was a helper, the finding of the Commissioner regarding wages of deceased Rabindra Paik is based on surmises only. Such criticism of the counsel for the appellant appears to be justified. The Commissioner had concluded as follows:
“….It is evident that the offending vehicle was usually operating in the long route and the O.P I must be paying Rs. 800 per month because of this knowledge in driving besides bhatia for Rs. 300 per month …”.
On going through the record, I find that apart from the mere statement of the claimant Jagabandhu (father of the deceased), there was no other material, in support of the finding of the Commissioner. On the other hand, the owner of the vehicle as D.W 1 categorically stated that the deceased was getting Rs. 700 per month. Except a bald suggestion to the effect that the deceased was getting Rs. 800 per month and getting bhatia of Rs. 300. D.W 1 the owner, has not been cross-examined in any other manner. There was no basis for the Commissioner to surmise that since the truck was operating on long route and the deceased knew how to drive, he must have been getting Rs. 800. Since the finding of the Commissioner was based on surmises and conjectures, such finding is vulnerable. Differing from the conclusion of the Commissioner regarding wages, I hold on the basis of the unchallenged evidence of the owner himself that deceased Rabindra Paik was getting wages at the rate of Rs. 700 per month. The finding regarding age of both the deceased appears to be justified and there is no reason to interfere with the finding regarding age. As such on the basis of such finding, while sustaining the compensation payable in W.C Case No. 19 of 1986, I reduce the compensation payable in W.C Case No. 1 of 1987 by calculating the monthly wages of deceased Rabindra at the rate of Rs. 700. On such calculation at the rate of 40 per cent of the salary the relevant factor of 207.98, the amount payable is Rs. 58,234.40 paise.
7. The Commissioner has imposed penalty of 30 per cent in both the cases. Keeping in view the principle of law decided in the Full Bench decision of this Court reported in Divisional Manager, New India Assurance Company, Ltd. v. Biswanath Barman, [(1996) 82 C.L.T 712], the insurance company cannot be made liable for payment of penalty as well as interest. Accordingly, the direction regarding payment of penalty and interest is quashed.
8. In the result, both the appeals, are allowed to the extent indicated above. There will be no order as to costs.
Order accordingly.