AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Act read with sub-rule (7) of rule 3 of the Orissa Forest Produce (Control of Trade) Rules, 1983,
  • Sub-sec. (3) of S. 1 of the Orissa Forest Produce (Control of Trade) Act, 1981,
  • provisions of S. 25-F of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
  • INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES ACT 1947
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Act read with sub-rule (7) of rule 3 of the Orissa Forest Produce (Control of Trade) Rules, 1983,
  • Sub-sec. (3) of S. 1 of the Orissa Forest Produce (Control of Trade) Act, 1981,
  • provisions of S. 25-F of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
  • INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES ACT 1947
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Susanta Chatterji, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

Five workmen, including P.V. Raman Rao, who had been employed by Straw Products, Ltd. (Forest Organisation) at Rayagada, challenged an award of the Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Jeypore (I.D. Case No. 73 of 1991) that held their retrenchment to be justified and denied them relief.

Relevant factual sequence (as recorded in the opinion): the State Government issued a notification dated 21 September 1988 (effective 1 October 1988) nationalising the trade and extraction of bamboo under the Orissa Forest Produce (Control of Trade) Act, 1981; the Orissa Forest Corporation (later renamed Orissa Forest Development Corporation) was appointed sole agent for bamboo extraction and trade.

The Straw Products Forest Employees' Union filed a writ (O.J.C No. 3686 of 1988) to protect employees who faced retrenchment; that writ was withdrawn on 28 September 1989 with liberty to approach the Court later. The petitioners later made representations alleging illegal retrenchment and non-compliance with mandatory provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Conciliation failed, a failure report was submitted and the Government referred a title dispute to the Labour Court asking whether the retrenchment of the five named employees from 4 July 1989 was legal and/or justified under Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and what relief they were entitled to.

The Labour Court framed a series of issues, heard the matter and concluded that retrenchment was justified and that the category-wise seniority list prepared by the management was proper, denying relief to the workmen. The petitioners then sought writ relief from this Court challenging the Labour Court award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reference to the Labour Court was valid and maintainable.
  2. Whether the industrial dispute was barred by any prior judgment/order of the Hon'ble High Court.
  3. Whether there was a retrenchment of the workmen within the meaning of Section 2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
  4. Whether the retrenchment was justified and valid under Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
  5. Whether Straw Products, Ltd. (Forest Organisation) is a separate unit from J.K. Paper Mills and whether either unit is independent within its sphere of work (i.e., questions about the corporate/organizational relationship and transferability of service).
  6. Whether the category-wise seniority list prepared by the management of Straw Products, Ltd. (Forest Organisation) alone was valid and proper.
  7. What relief, if any, the workmen were entitled to.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners were workmen regularly appointed by Straw Products, Ltd. (Forest Organisation) and thus entitled to protection.
  • Their services were transferable across multiple units or sister concerns of the management (several units including J.K. Paper Mills, Laxmi Cement, and J.K. Magnetics were identified), and appointment letters permitted transfer; therefore management could have adjusted them in other units instead of retrenching them.
  • The retrenchment purportedly justified by bamboo nationalisation was not bona fide and the gradation (seniority) list challenged as not true and correct.
  • They claimed non-compliance with mandatory provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 in relation to the retrenchment process.

Opposite Parties' (Management / State) Arguments

  • The State Government's notification (21 September 1988) nationalised bamboo trade and appointed the Orissa Forest Corporation as sole agent for extraction and trade with effect from 1 October 1988; consequently the Forest Organisation of Straw Products had no further bamboo-extraction activity and work effectively ceased by operation of law.
  • The challenge to the State notification (by opposite party 1) failed in this Court and was confirmed by the Supreme Court; hence the nationalisation was valid and effective.
  • Because extraction/trading work stopped, there was no further work for the Forest Organisation except removal of bamboos felled prior to nationalisation; the management therefore retrenched employees as a consequence of the cessation of work.
  • The Labour Court considered these aspects and found retrenchment justified; the seniority list was correctly prepared and the petitioners' challenge to the award is misconceived.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the pleadings and the Labour Court award and identified the principal legal and factual points it considered determinative:

  1. The Court accepted that the State notification nationalising bamboo trade (dated 21 September 1988, effective 1 October 1988) was not in dispute and that challenges to it had failed in higher fora. This establishes the factual backdrop that extraction and trade of bamboo by the Forest Organisation ceased by operation of law.
  2. The Court observed that the appointment letters for the petitioners contained express conditions of service that permitted the management to transfer employees to any of its units or sister concerns. The Court treated the terms of appointment as legally important for assessing the propriety of retrenchment.
  3. Although the Labour Court had framed several issues and considered the matter, the Court found that the Labour Court had failed to take note of the terms of appointment — specifically the transferability clause — and failed to frame or decide an issue on whether the petitioners' services could have been transferred to other units or sister concerns instead of retrenchment.
  4. Because multiple units of the management existed and the appointment letters allowed transfers, the Court concluded that the Labour Court's award upholding retrenchment and denying relief suffered from an irregularity and constituted an erroneous exercise of jurisdiction in refusing to consider accommodation of the petitioners in other units.
  5. In consequence, the Court determined that the impugned award should be set aside and that the matter should be remitted to the Labour Court for rehearing specifically on the question whether the management ought to have taken steps to transfer the petitioners into vacancies in its other units so far as practicable.
  6. The Court imposed a timeline: the directed exercise (rehearing and consideration of transfers/accommodation) must be completed within four months of the issuance of the writ.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ application was allowed; the impugned award of the Labour Court was set aside and the matter remanded to the Labour Court for rehearing on whether the management ought to have transferred the petitioners to vacancies in its other units so far as practicable.

Implications / Consequences:

  • The Labour Court's original award that held the retrenchment to be justified is vacated for the limited purpose of reconsideration on the transfer/accommodation question arising from the terms of appointment.
  • The remand directs the Labour Court to complete the reassessment within four months of the writ's issue.
  • No costs were awarded.
  • The opinion does not articulate any broader binding precedent beyond its application to the facts before the Court; it confines relief to remand and reconsideration rather than announcing a new general rule. (The opinion does not state that a new precedent was laid down.)

Judge C.R. Pal concurred with the judgment.

    P.V Raman Rao And Others v. J.K Corporation, Ltd., And Others

    Susanta Chatterji, J.:— One P.V Raman Rao and four others who were working previously with Straw Products, Ltd., have challenged the award passed by the Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Jeypore, in I.D Case No. 73 of 1991. Their prayer is:

    “Under the above circumstances the petitioners pray for the following reliefs:

    (a) writ of certiorari be issued quashing Annexure 4 that is the award of Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Jeypore in I.D Case No. 73 of 1991;

    (b) the petitioners may be declared to be in service without any break under opposite parties 1 and 2 and direction be issued for payment of the back-wages for the period they remained out of job;

    (c) writ of mandamus be issued to opposite parties 1 and 2 for their reinstatement in the service forthwith;

    (d) any other appropriate order be passed/direction be made or writ be issued which this Hon'ble Court deem just and proper;

    (e) the writ application be allowed with cost.”

    2. It is contended that all the petitioners are workmen and they were regularly appointed under opposite party 1, i.e, Straw Products, Ltd. (Forest Organisation) at Rayagada in the district of Koraput, Orissa. While they were in service, the State Government issued a notification on September 21, 1988, under Sub-sec. (3) of S. 1 of the Orissa Forest Produce (Control of Trade) Act, 1981, in pursuance of which the trade of bamboo was nationalised with effect from October 1, 1988. The Orissa Forest Corporation, Ltd, was entrusted with the work of extraction and trading in bamboos by the State Government. The Straw Products Forest Employees' Union then filed O.J.C No. 3686 of 1988 before this Court for protection of their livelihood as opposite parties 1 and 2 wanted to retrench near about 100 workmen under its establishment who at the relevant time had been engaged under the Forest Organisation Union of IK. Paper Mill owned by the Straw Products, Ltd. The union alternatively prayed for continuance of their services under the Orissa Forest Corporation, Ltd., in case opposite parties 1 and 2 refused to continue the workmen under different units of the same industrial undertaking, namely, J.K Paper Mill.

    3. On September 28, 1989, the above writ petition filed by the union was allowed to be withdrawn with liberty to approach this Court again if aggrieved by any subsequent action. It is stated that the union was persuaded to withdraw the writ application because the State Government in its letter, dated August 12, 1989, addressed to the Managing Director, Orissa Forest Corporation, Ltd., gave direction to give employment to the retrenched employees of different paper mills in some specified posts. In the said letter it was stated that due to pendency of writ petitions before this Court the Government was not able to take any action and with a hope of getting alternative employment the union wanted to withdraw the writ application.

    4. The petitioners thereafter made a representation to the Vice-President (Forest), Straw Products, Ltd., Rayagada against their illegal retrenchment alleging non-compliance with the mandatory provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. A copy of the said representation was also sent to the District Labour Officer, Rayagada, with a prayer to intervene in the matter. The District Labour Officer issued notice to the management and as conciliation failed, a failure report was submitted to Government who referred title dispute to the Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Jeypore. The said reference was made under the following terms:

    “Whether retrenchment of Sri P.V Raman Rao, Sri B. Rajeswar Rao, Sri H.K Dutta, Sri A.K Dutta and Sri S. Thomas by the management from July 4, 1989, in accordance with the provisions of S. 25-F of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, on the basis of the category-wise seniority list drawn for the purpose was legal and/or justified? If not, what relief were the workmen entitled to?”

    5. Upon such reference, the Presiding Officer, Labour Court, framed the following issues:

    “(i) Whether the reference is valid and maintainable?

    (ii) Whether the industrial dispute is barred by the judgment/order of the Hon'ble High Court?

    (iii) Whether mere was retrenchment of the workmen coming within the meaning of S. 2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act?

    (iv) Whether retrenchment was justified and valid?

    (v) Whether Straw Products, Ltd. (Forest Organisation), Rayagada, is a separate unit from J.K Paper Mills, Rayagada, and either of the units are, independent within their sphere of work?

    (vi) Whether the category-wise seniority list prepared by the management of Straw Products, Ltd (Forest Organisation), alone is valid and proper?

    (vii) To what relief the workmen are entitled?”

    6. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court held that the retrenchment of the workmen was justified and valid and the category-wise seniority list prepared by the management was also proper. Ultimately the award was made observing that the workmen were not entitled to any relief from the management.

    7. Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said award of the Presiding Officer, Labour Court, the petitioners have come to this Court. Their grievance is that the management is having three units, namely:

    (1) J.K Paper Mills at Rayagada in Orissa;

    (2) Laxmi Cement, Jaykaypuram, Shirohi in Rajasthan; and

    (3) J.K Magnetics at Surajpur, Dist-Ghaziabad in Uttar Pradesh.

    Besides, the management has several other new and old establishments where thousands of employees are continuing and there are transfers and retirement. It is stated that there could have been absolutely no difficulty in adjusting the petitioner-workmen in other sections/units or sister concerns. The appointment orders issued by the company also clearly goes to show that the services of the employees could be transferred to any office/railway depot/forest organisation/transport division/mills or any sister concern that were in existence or might come into existence in future. In view of this it is alleged that the retrenchment of the workmen under the plea of bamboo nationalisation is not bona fide. They have also challenged the gradation list as not true and correct.

    8. The case of opposite parties 1 and 2 as stated in the counter-affidavit is that the State Government in exercise of powers under Sub-sec. (3) of S. 1 of the Orissa Forest Produce (Control of Trade) Act, 1981, issued a notification on September 21, 1988, as per Annexure A/1 to the counter-affidavit, and following the said notification Government also further notified on the said date that in public interest, an agent for extraction of bamboos of all species from Government forests and trade thereof was expedient to be appointed and, accordingly, in exercise of powers under the said Act read with sub-rule (7) of rule 3 of the Orissa Forest Produce (Control of Trade) Rules, 1983, the State Government appointed the Orissa Forest Corporation, Ltd., now renamed as “Orissa Forest Development Corporation, Ltd,” a public sector undertaking of the State, as the sole agent for extraction of and trade in bamboos of all species on behalf of the Government with effect from October 1, 1988. The challenge to the said notification by opposite party 1 in this Court in O.J.C No. 3100 of 1988 proved futile and the decision of this Court was also confirmed by the Supreme Court. Since the Forest Organisation of opposite party 1 had no further activities in the matter of felling, cutting and removing of bamboos, the extraction of bamboos from the forest was completely stopped by operation of law, with effect from October 1, 1988. No work remained for the Forest Organisation of opposite party 1 except for removal of bamboos already felled out from the leasehold forests prior to nationalisation of forest working. Opposite party 1 had to fight out for the said right of removal of the said property from forest. In the meantime, the Straw Products Forest Employees' Union apprehending termination of services of the workers by opposite party 1 approached this Court in O.J.C No. 3686 of 1988, but ultimately the said writ application was allowed to be withdrawn. It is stated that the Labour Court has considered all these aspects and found the retrenchment of the petitioners to be justified. The seniority list was correctly prepared and the challenge of the petitioners to the award of the Labour Court is stated to be misconceived.

    9. We have perused the pleadings of the parties. We have also perused the impugned award made by the Labour Court. We have considered the challenges to the said award

    10. There is no dispute that the petitioners were properly and validly appointed by Straw Products (Forest Organisation), Ltd., which is a J.K Enterprise/Organisation in terms of the letters of appointment. The said letters of appointment are very important. The conditions of service are incorporated therein. It was open to the management to transfer the services of the employees to any one of their units dealing with several types of business and multifarious diversification. The notification issued by the State Government is also not in dispute as to nationalisation of trade in bamboo and extraction of bamboo from forest areas. Although the said notification was challenged up to Supreme Court, the challenge failed. Though the Employees' Union filed a writ petition in this Court, yet a Division Bench of this Court by order, dated August 18, 1989, held that it was however open to the petitioners to challenge the order of retrenchment in appropriate manner before the proper forum. Pursuant thereto the industrial dispute arose relating to retrenchment and a proper reference was made as indicated above. The Labour Court had gone into the matter for effective adjudication by framing several issues and discussing the points. The Labour Court had failed to take note of the terms of appointment. If admittedly there are other units of Straw Products, Ltd., and the services of the petitioners were transferable, it is not appreciated as to why and how the Labour Court did not consider the failure of the management to transfer the employees thought to be retrenched No issue had been framed regarding this aspect as to whether the service of the petitioners could have been transferred to any other unit. The award holding the retrenchment to be justified thereby denying any relief to the petitioners, in our considered view, suffers from irregularity and there has been erroneous exercise of jurisdiction in refusing to accommodate the petitioners in any other units or sister concern of the principal management.

    11. Thus we allow the writ application. The impugned award of the Labour Court is set aside and we remand the matter to the Labour Court for rehearing and going into the question as to whether the opposite party management ought to have taken steps to transfer the petitioners in the vacancies in its other units so far as practicable. We direct this exercise to be complete within four months of issue of writ. No costs.

    12. C.R Pal, J.:— I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P.V Raman Rao And Others v. J.K Corporation, Ltd., And Others
    (Feb 13, 1998)