Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub-rule (1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub-rule (1)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The case arises from Title Suit No. 5 of 1984 filed by plaintiffs (opposite parties 1 to 3) in the Court of the Munsif, Dhenkanal, challenging an eviction order issued by the Tahasildar, Dhenkanal. Defendants 1, 2, and 3 denied the plaintiffs' possession claims and asserted possession through defendant No. 3. The suit hearing commenced on August 19, 1985, and concluded on October 15, 1985, with arguments heard on November 5, 1985, and judgment scheduled for November 20, 1985. On November 16, 1985, defendant No. 3 sought to amend his written statement by adding paragraphs constituting a counter-claim regarding possession and title to the suit land. The plaintiffs objected, arguing that the amendment would alter the suit's nature and should be rejected. The trial Court rejected the amendment application on grounds of belatedness, holding it should have been filed before the defence was delivered or the deadline for the defence expired. Defendant No. 3 filed a revision application challenging this order, which was referred to the Division Bench for consideration of the correctness of the trial Court’s decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a defendant can file a counter-claim after filing the written statement or after the time fixed for filing the defence has expired under Order 8, Rule 6A(1) of the Civil Procedure Code.
  2. Whether the trial Court was correct in rejecting the application for amendment of the written statement to include a counter-claim at a belated stage.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant No. 3's Arguments

  • Proposed amendment sought to add paragraphs constituting a counter-claim based on possession and title to the suit land.
  • Willingness to pay court fee as per valuation of the suit was expressed.

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • Opposed the amendment on the ground that it would change the nature and character of the suit.
  • Contended that the amendment application was belated and should be rejected.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shri Shri Kashi Biswanath Dev v. Paramananda Routrai, (1985) 1 OLR 256 : AIR 1985 Ori 260 Interpretation of Order 8, Rule 6A regarding the timing of filing counter-claims. The Court held that a counter-claim must be filed before the defendant delivers his defence or before the time for delivering defence expires; however, this decision was overruled by the present Court.
Prafulla Kumar Samantaray v. Smt. Ranjita Samantaray, (1987) 63 Cut LT 337 Same as above, concerning the timing and permissibility of counter-claims. The Court had held similarly to the above precedent, but this was also overruled in the present opinion.
Dipnarain Sinha v. Dinanath Singh, AIR 1981 Pat 69 Support for the limitation that counter-claims must be filed before delivery of defence or expiry of time for defence. Used to support the interpretation of the timing restrictions on counter-claims.
Mahendra Kumar v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1987 SC 1395 Clarified that Order 8, Rule 6A(1) does not bar filing of a counter-claim after filing the written statement but limits the cause of action to those accruing before delivery of defence or expiry of time. The Court relied on this Supreme Court decision to overrule previous conflicting decisions of this Court and establish the correct interpretation of the rule.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the language of Order 8, Rule 6A(1) of the Civil Procedure Code, noting that it permits a defendant to file a counter-claim with respect to any cause of action accruing either before or after the filing of the suit but strictly before the defendant has delivered his defence or before the time for delivering defence expires. The Court emphasized that the limitation on the timing of the cause of action is a sound public policy to prevent indefinite delays caused by successive counter-claims filed after the defence stage. It found that earlier decisions of this Court restricting counter-claims to before the filing of the written statement were incorrect and overruled them, relying on the authoritative Supreme Court decision in Mahendra Kumar v. State of Madhya Pradesh. However, the Court also considered the facts of the present case, noting the amendment application was filed at a very late stage—after arguments had closed and judgment was imminent. Allowing such a belated amendment would cause injustice to the plaintiffs and delay the suit. The Court further noted that no substantial new facts were pleaded beyond the assertion of possession as a counter-claim. The Court declined to address the issue whether counter-claims in suits of this nature can be other than money claims, as it was unnecessary for the decision.

Holding and Implications

The Court dismissed the revision application filed by defendant No. 3, thereby upholding the trial Court’s rejection of the amendment application. The Court held that although a counter-claim can be filed after the written statement is filed, it must relate to a cause of action accruing before delivery of defence or expiry of the defence period. The belated amendment sought at the stage after closure of arguments was rightly refused to avoid injustice and delay. The parties were directed to bear their own costs. No new precedent was created beyond overruling prior inconsistent decisions of this Court in light of the Supreme Court ruling. The direct effect is that the defendant’s attempt to amend the written statement to include a counter-claim at a late stage failed, and the suit proceeds without that amendment.

    Mangulu Pirai v. Prafulla Kumar Singh

    Agrawal, C.J:— This application in revision filed by defendant 3 is directed against an order of the trial Court rejecting his application for amendment of the written statement by incorporating certain statements in the nature of a counter-claim.

    2. Opposite parties 1 to 3 as plaintiffs filed Title Suit No. 5 of 1984 in the Court of the Munsif, Dhenkanal, against the order of the Tahasildar, Dhenkanal, directing their eviction from the suit land. Defendants 1 and 2 as well as defendant 3 filed written statements denying the plaintiffs' claim of possession over the suit land and claiming the possession of defendant No. 3.

    The hearing of the suit commenced on 19-8-1985 and was closed on 15-10-1985. Arguments were also fully heard on 5-11-1985, and 20-11-1985 was fixed for judgment. In the meantime, on 16-11-1985, defendant No. 3 filed an application for amendment of the written statement under the label of O. 8, R. 6A(1) of the Civil P.C (for short ‘the Code’) with a prayer for addition of two paragraphs as paras 24 and 25 to the written statement reading as follows:—

    “24. That the defendant after getting delivery of possession from the aforesaid Subas Dei has been possessing the land till Dec., 1983 and thereby he has acquired title in respect of the suit land and this may be treated as a counter-claim against the plaintiff.

    25. That this Honourable Court has jurisdiction to decide the counter-claim of this defendant against the plaintiff and the defendant is willing to pay the Court-fee as per the valuation of the suit and if the claim of the defendant 3 succeed, he may given delivery of possession of the suit land.”

    The plaintiffs filed objection to this petition for amendment contending, inter alia, that the proposed amendment would change the nature and character of the suit and, therefore, it should be rejected.

    The trial Court by the impugned order has rejected the petition on the ground that it was belated and that it should have been filed either before the defendant had delivered his defence or before the time limited for delivering his defence had expired.

    3. When the revision application was taken up by a learned Judge of this Court and some decisions of this Court were cited in support of the Order of the trial Court, he entertained doubt regarding their correctness and referred the matter to the Division Bench. That is how it has been placed before us.

    4. The question that arises for consideration is as to whether a counter-claim can be filed after the filing of the written statement or after the time fixed for the said purpose had expired.

    5. There was no provision for filing a counter-claim by a defendant before the amendment of the Code in the year 1976 when R. 6A was inserted. Sub-rule (1) which is relevant reads as follows:—

    “A defendant in a suit may, in addition to his right of pleading a set-off under R. 6, set up, by way of counter-claim against the claim of the plaintiff, any right or claim in respect of a cause of action accruing to the defendant against the plaintiff either before or after the filing of the suit but before the defendant has delivered his defence or before time limited for delivering his defence has expired, whether such counter-claim is in the nature of a claim for damages or not:

    Provided that such counter-claim shall not exceed the pecuniary limits of the jurisdiction of the Court.”

    6. Two decisions of this Court which have considered the matter are Shri Shri Kashi Biswanath Dev v. Paramananda Routrai, (1985) 1 OLR 256 : (AIR 1985 Ori 260), and Prafulla Kumar Samantaray v. Smt. Ranjita Samantaray, (1987) 63 Cut LT 337. The learned Judges in both the above cases have held that the provision of R. 6A was clear to the effect that a counter-claim must be filed with respect to a cause of action either arising before or after the filing of the suit, but before the defendant delivers his defence or before the time limited for delivering his defence has expired.

    7. In my opinion, the words “either before or after filing of the suit but before the defendant has delivered his defence or before the time limited for delivering his defence has expired” appearing in O. 8, R. 6A(1) mean to limit the right of the defendant to set up by way of counter-claim in respect of a cause of action which arose after he delivered his defence or after the expiry of the date for filing his defence only. In other words, the enabling provision introduced by the 1976 amendment entitles a defendant in a suit to set up by way of counter-claim against the claim of the plaintiff any right or claim in respect of a cause of action accruing to him against the plaintiff “either before or after the filing of the suit but before the defendant has delivered his defence or before the time limited for delivering his defence has expired”. But any cause of action which may arise after the filing of the written statement by the defendant or after the expiry of the date for filing the defence will not come within the scope of R. 6A(1). There is no other limitation for filing a counter-claim as otherwise that would defeat the law of limitation. The restriction regarding the limit of the accrual of the period of the cause of action is based upon sound public policy, as otherwise the defendant may go on filing one counter-claim after another against the plaintiff in the same suit until it was disposed of and thus the suit may be indefinitely delayed. A similar view has been taken by a learned Judge of the Patna High Court in Dipnarain Sinha v. Dinanath Singh, AIR 1981 Pat 69.

    8. The above discussion explains the rigour regarding the filing of the counterclaim and thus I venture to hold that the decisions rendered by both the learned Judges of this Court is not correct. I find full support for this view from a recent decision of the Supreme Court in Mahendra Kumar v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1987 SC 1395, where it has been clearly laid down that R. 6A(1) does not bar the filing of a counter-claim by the defendant after filing of his written statement. It only provides with respect to the cause of action regarding which the defendant could file a counter-claim and that is that the cause of action must have accrued to the defendant before he had delivered his defence or before the time limited for delivering his defence has expired. In view of the above authoritative decision, the decisions of this Court referred to earlier must be deemed to be no longer good law and, therefore, they are hereby overruled.

    9. In that view of the matter, it is to be seen as to whether the proposed amendment should be allowed or not. The amendment was sought for at a very belated stage and no other statement of fact has been pleaded save and except that defendant 3 purported to set up a counter-claim with respect to his right to get delivery of possession from the plaintiff. As already held earlier, although no time limit could be fixed for filing a counter-claim, nonetheless at the stage at which it was filed i.e, after the close of argument when the matter was fixed for judgment, the amendment of the written statement even simpliciter would work out injustice to the plaintiff and is bound to delay the matter. Nor does it seem necessary for the purpose of determining the real question in controversy.

    10. A question has also been raised that a counter-claim can only be made with respect to money claims and not in suits of this nature. But on the facts of the present case, I do not enter into any discussion on this aspect of the matter.

    11. From the aforegoing discussions, I do not see any merit in this application and it is accordingly dismissed. In the facts and circumstances, however, the parties shall bear their own costs.

    S.C Mohapatra, J.:— 12. I agree.

    Revision dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mangulu Pirai v. Prafulla Kumar Singh
    (Jul 31, 1987)