AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs, partners of a firm, filed a suit on 17-6-1963 seeking recovery of Rs. 4068.75 from the defendants, also partners of a firm. The claim arose from an agreement under which the plaintiffs dispatched 93 bags of broken rice by train to the defendants for sale at Shalimar Railway Station. The defendants quoted a market rate but failed to pay, raising false pleas to avoid liability. The defendants denied the plaintiffs' version, contending among other things that they lacked the requisite license under the West Bengal Food Grains Licensing Order, that the consignment was unfit for human consumption and seized by authorities, and that the contract was illegal and barred by limitation. The Trial Court decreed the suit in favor of the plaintiffs. On appeal, the District Judge reversed the decree, holding the contract void ab initio due to statutory control orders and lack of licenses, and dismissed the suit. The plaintiffs then filed this second appeal challenging the reversal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to rely on the equitable provision contained in Section 65 of the Contract Act despite the contract being void ab initio.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The plaintiffs were not aware that the contract was void at the time it was entered into and only discovered its void character later.
  • Section 65 of the Contract Act provides for restoration or compensation when a contract is discovered to be void, and this equitable provision applies to their case.
  • Reliance on the precedent of Kanuri Sivaram Krishnaih v. Vemari Venkata Narahari Rao, where Section 65 was applied to sustain a decree for refund despite the contract being void.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The defendants contended that the contract was illegal and void from the beginning due to statutory licensing requirements.
  • The defendants claimed to have informed the plaintiffs about the absence of the requisite license, making the contract void ab initio.
  • They relied on precedents such as Kearley v. Thomson and Qadir Bukhsh v. Hakam to support the principle that contracts known to be void at inception cannot be enforced.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kanuri Sivaram Krishnaih v. Vemari Venkata Narahari Rao, A.I.R 1960 A.P 186 Application of Section 65 of the Contract Act to allow restitution where a contract is void but not known to be so by the parties at inception. Used to support the plaintiffs' claim for compensation under Section 65, emphasizing restoration to status quo ante despite the contract's void nature.
Kearley v. Thomson, 1890 24 Q.B 742 Principle that contracts known to be void at the time of formation cannot be enforced. Referenced by respondents to argue that the contract was void ab initio and Section 65 does not apply.
Qadir Bukhsh v. Hakam, A.I.R 1932 Lah 503 Similar principle regarding the invalidity of contracts known to be void at inception. Relied upon by respondents to support the position that no restitution is available if the contract was known to be void.
A.I.R 1922 P.C 4031 Section 65 applies only when the party claiming restitution was not aware of the contract's void nature at inception. Used to distinguish cases where the contract is void but not known to be so by the plaintiff at the time of contracting.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court focused on the applicability of Section 65 of the Contract Act, which mandates restitution or compensation where a contract is discovered to be void. The Court explained that this provision is an equitable doctrine of "restitution in integrum" and is intended to achieve justice between parties. It distinguishes between contracts void ab initio with knowledge of the parties and those void but unknown to at least one party at the time of contracting.

The appellate court's conclusion that the contract was illegal with the knowledge of both parties from inception was found to be unsupported by evidence. The defendant's claim of notifying the plaintiffs about the lack of license was not proven. The Court emphasized that Section 65 does not apply if the contract was known to be void at inception, but does apply if the void character was discovered later.

The Court relied on precedents, particularly Kanuri Sivaram Krishnaih v. Vemari Venkata Narahari Rao, to hold that a party can claim restoration without relying on the illegal contract itself, but rather through the equitable remedy provided by Section 65. The Court rejected the respondents' reliance on Kearley v. Thomson and Qadir Bukhsh v. Hakam as those cases do not apply where the void nature was not known at the time of contract.

Accordingly, the Court concluded that the plaintiffs were entitled to compensation for the 93 bags of broken rice and restored the trial court's decree.

Holding and Implications

The second appeal is allowed.

The judgment and decree of the appellate court are set aside, and those of the trial court are restored with costs to the appellants. The plaintiffs are entitled to compensation under Section 65 of the Contract Act because the contract, though void, was not known to be void at the time it was entered into. This decision clarifies that Section 65 applies to contracts discovered to be void after formation and affirms the equitable principle of restitution in such cases. No new precedent beyond the application of Section 65 was established.

    Lakhiram Agarwalla And Others v. Brajalal Agarwalla And Others

    R.N Misra, J.:— The plaintiffs are in appeal against the reversing decree of the learned District Judge. Plaintiffs 1 and 2 are the partners of the Firm, plaintiff no. 3. Similarly defendants 1 to 4 are partners of the Firm, defendant no. 4.

    2. The plaintiffs filed a suit on 17-6-1963 for recovery of Rs. 4068.75 from the defendants on the allegation that pursuant to an agreement they had despatched by train 93 bags of broken rice to the defendants for effecting sale thereof at the rail-head, i.e Shalimar Railway Station. The defendants had quoted the prevailing market rate to be Rs. 17.50 per maund. As the defendants did not pay the price and raised false pleas to avoid the liability, the plaintiffs were obliged to come to the Court.

    3. The defendants in a joint written statement denied that the despatch of the consignment was not in the manner as pleaded by the plaintiffs; the defendant no. 2 had informed the second plaintiff that the defendants were not licensed dealers under the West Bengal Food Grains Licensing Order and thus it would be difficult for them to dispose of the consignment of broken rice at Calcutta; it was ultimately agreed that the plaintiffs would despatch the consignment to Shalimar with their man and attempt would be made for disposal with the assistance of defendant no. 3; the plaintiffs' representative accompanying the consignment got the stock transported to the premises of one Mohanlal & Co. with the help of defendant no. 3 the stock of broken rice was unfit for human consumption and the authorities of the Calcutta Corporation seized and destroyed the same and even started a prosecution against Mohanlal & Co.; the claim was not tenable as the contract was illegal; the Bargarh Court had no jurisdiction; the suit suffered from defect of non-joinder of parties-Corporation of Calcutta and Mohanlal & Co. were necessary parties; the claim was barred by limitation, etc.

    4. The learned Trial Judge found that the suit as laid was maintainable; the defendants failed to establish that the stock of broken rice was unfit for human consumption or that it had been seized and destroyed by the Corporation of Calcutta. He further found that the contract was valid and the plaintiffs were entitled to recover the price of the 93 bags of broken rice. Accordingly he decreed the suit with pendentelite and future interest.

    5. Upon appeal by the defendants, the learned District Judge sustained all the findings of the trial Court except the one relating to the legality of the deal forming the basis of the claim. He found that in 1960 when the rice was consigned, there were in vogue statutory control orders both in Orissa and West Bengal and neither the plaintiffs nor the defendants had the requisite license to possess and deal in rice. He assumed that the parties were aware of the position and, therefore, the contract was void ab initio and the provisions of section 65 of the Contract Act was not applicable. He accordingly reversed the decree of the trial Court and dismissed the suit. In this second appeal the plaintiffs assail the reversing decree.

    6. The only question that has to be considered is whether the plaintiffs are entitled to rely upon the equitable provision in section 65 of the Contract Act. That section provides:

    “When an agreement is discovered to be void, or when a contract becomes void, any person who has received any advantage under such agreement or contract is bound to restore it, or to make compensation for it to the person from whom he received it.”

    7. The doctrine of “restitution in integrum” is of general application and section 65 incorporates that equitable provision. Both at Common Law in England and in this country Courts have taken the view that the rule should be liberally construed in order to do equity and justice between parties.

    8. section 65 of the Contract Act does not apply to contracts which were ab initio void to the knowledge of the contracting parties but is applicable to cases where at least the plaintiffs were not aware of the void character of the contract (though from the inception the contract was invalid) and discovered it to be so A.I.R 1922 P.C 4031.

    9. The defence plea in paragraph 7 of the written statement that the defendant no. 2 had notified the plaintiff no. 2 of absence of the requisite license at Calcutta and, therefore, the deal would not be possible has not been established at the trial. The defendant no. 2 as D.W 3 has only casually said that he had mentioned about there being no license at Calcutta. The finding of the appellate Court that the deal was illegal to the knowledge of the parties from the very beginning is a conclusion based upon no evidence. Mr. Mohanty for the respondents tried to put it as an inference of fact from the proved facts. I am not able to accept that contention particularly in the background of several untenable pleas of the defendants. Those pleas having been negatived by both the Courts below, the defendants were to compensate the plaintiffs unless section 65 of the Contract Act was not to be applied.

    10. Reliance has rightly been placed by the learned counsel for the appellants on the case of Kanuri Sivaram Krishnaih v. Vemari Venkata Narahari Rao . A.I.R 1960 A.P 186., where in a case of this type, section 65 of the Contract Act was relied upon to sustain the decree for refund of the value. The learned Chief Justice said:

    “The effect of section 65 is that, in such a situation, it enables a person in paridelicto to claim restoration since it is not based on an illegal contract but dissociated from it. That is permissible by reason of the section because the action is not founded on dealings which are contaminated by illegality. The party is only seeking to be restored to the status quo ante.”

    11. Mr. Mohanty relied upon the case of Kearley v. Thomson . 1890 24 Q.B 742., and Qadir Bukhsh v. Hakam . A.I.R 1932 Lah. 503.. The principle indicated in the aforesaid cases is beyond dispute. But the question that pertinently has arisen for determination in this case is as to whether at the time the contract was entered into and the despatch of the consignments of broken rice was made, whether both the parties or at least the plaintiff knew that the contract was void. If the finding to be reached is that the plaintiff was not aware of that position, the only conclusion that can be reached is that the contract was discovered to be void. The application of section 65 of the Contract Act is kept out only in those cases where the contract was known to be void at the time it was entered into. A distinction has been made between the cases where the contract is void from the inception and is known to the parties to be so at the time it is entered into and a contract which is void from the inception but parties or at least one of the parties enters into it bona fide and later is discovered to be void. In the first case section 65 is not applicable while in the second case benefit is available of that statutory provision.

    12. I, therefore, hold that the plaintiffs were entitled to the compensation for the 93 bags of broken rice. The second appeal succeeds. The judgment and decree of the appellate Court are set aside and those of the trial Court are restored with costs to the appellants throughout.

    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lakhiram Agarwalla And Others v. Brajalal Agarwalla And Others
    (Aug 28, 1973)