Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 174 of the Limitation Act (Act IX) of 1908, (hereinafter referred
  • examination.(3) Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC, reads thus:2. Payment
  • Article 125 of the Limitation Act (Act XXXVI of 1963)
  • Section 47 of the CPC. If Article 174
  • Article 174 of the Old Act.6.
  • Order 21 Rule 22 of the CPC
  • Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC,
  • Order 21 Rule 2,
  • Order 21 Rule
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 174 of the Limitation Act (Act IX) of 1908, (hereinafter referred
  • examination.(3) Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC, reads thus:2. Payment
  • Article 125 of the Limitation Act (Act XXXVI of 1963)
  • Section 47 of the CPC. If Article 174
  • Article 174 of the Old Act.6.
  • Order 21 Rule 22 of the CPC
  • Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC,
  • Order 21 Rule 2,
  • Order 21 Rule
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent is the landlord and the appellant the tenant of a house in Cuttack. The landlord obtained an eviction order dated 5-9-1963 directing the tenant to vacate within four months. The tenant did not vacate, prompting the landlord to file an execution case on 6-3-1964. The tenant objected under Section 47 of the CPC, alleging an adjustment of the decree on 6-11-1963, whereby the tenant would pay rent regularly and continue possession, and the landlord would not execute the eviction order without hearing evidence on the objection. The learned Munsif dismissed the objection for lack of documentary proof of settlement. On appeal, the District Judge held that the alleged adjustment was governed by Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC and was barred by limitation under Article 174 of the Limitation Act (Old Act) as the judgment-debtor did not certify the adjustment within 90 days. The District Judge did not remand the case for evidence on the merits of the adjustment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the alleged adjustment of the eviction decree falls within the ambit of Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC, requiring certification within 90 days under Article 174 of the Limitation Act, and is therefore barred by limitation.
  2. If the objection under Section 47 of the CPC does not come under Order 21 Rule 2, whether it is still barred by limitation under Article 174 of the Limitation Act.
  3. The proper interpretation and application of Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC and Article 174 of the Limitation Act in relation to decrees for eviction without monetary relief.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments

  • The alleged adjustment is governed by Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC, which requires certification by the judgment-debtor within 90 days under Article 174 of the Limitation Act, failing which the objection is barred by limitation.
  • Even if the objection falls under Section 47 of the CPC and not Order 21 Rule 2, it is still barred by limitation under Article 174 of the Limitation Act.

Appellant's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the appellant's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1952 All, 814 Provisions of Order 21 Rule 2 of CPC apply to every kind of decree Not followed; Court inclined to the contrary view
AIR 1922 Bom 380 Same as above Not followed; Court inclined to the contrary view
AIR 1928 Cal 715 Same as above Not followed; Court inclined to the contrary view
AIR 1936 Lah 842 Same as above Not followed; Court inclined to the contrary view
AIR 1936 Pat 385 Same as above Not followed; Court inclined to the contrary view
AIR 1948 Nag 374 Same as above Not followed; Court inclined to the contrary view
AIR 1963 Mys 79 Same as above Not followed; Court inclined to the contrary view
AIR 1926 Mad 749 Order 21 Rule 2 applies only to decrees involving payment of money Followed; Court adopted this view
AIR 1958 Andh Pra 705 Order 21 Rule 2 applies only to decrees involving payment of money Followed; Court adopted this view as best exposition of law

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the scope of Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC, which requires certification of payments or adjustments made out of court relating to decrees involving payment of money. The Court noted conflicting High Court authorities but preferred the view that the Rule applies only to decrees where payment of money is one of the reliefs granted. The eviction decree in question did not involve payment of money, so Order 21 Rule 2 did not apply, and certification was not required.

The Court then analyzed Article 174 of the Limitation Act (Old Act), which prescribes a 90-day limitation for certification of payments or adjustments under Order 21 Rule 2. The Court held that this article similarly applies only to decrees involving payment of money. For other adjustments, including those under Section 47 of the CPC, a three-year limitation under the residuary Article 181 applies.

The Court also considered the corresponding provision in the Limitation Act, 1963 (Article 125), which expanded the scope to all kinds of decrees. However, since the case concerned the Old Act, the narrower interpretation applied.

Consequently, the Court found both contentions of the respondent untenable and held that the objection under Section 47 should be examined on merits by the Executing Court with opportunity for evidence. The Court set aside the lower appellate judgment and remanded the case for fresh consideration.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed and the judgment of the lower appellate court is set aside.

The case is remanded to the Executing Court to decide on the merits of the alleged adjustment under Section 47 of the CPC, allowing both parties to present evidence. The Executing Court is directed to dispose of the case within four months and inform this Court. The parties are to bear their own costs up to this stage. This decision clarifies that eviction decrees without monetary relief do not fall under Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC or the 90-day limitation under Article 174 of the Old Limitation Act, and objections under Section 47 must be adjudicated on merits rather than dismissed on limitation grounds.

    Dhani Bahera v. Sushil Chandra Palit .

    1. Respondent is the landlord and the appellant is the tenant under him in respect of a house situate in the city of Cuttack. In House Rent Control Appeal No. 9 of 1963 the landlord obtained an order of eviction on 5-9-1963 wherein the tenant was directed to vacate the house within four months. As the tenant did not vacate the house, the landlord filed the execution case on 6-3-1964. On receipt of notice under Order 21 Rule 22 of the CPC the appellant filed an objection under Section 47 of the CPC alleging that there was an adjustment of the decree on 6-11-1963. The story of settlement, as stated in the objection petition, was that the parties agreed that the tenant would henceforward pay rent regularly and continue in possession of the house as a tenant as before and the landlord would not execute the eviction order dated 5-9-1963 without going into the merits of the objection by taking evidence, the learned Munsif dismissed the petition stating that no document showing settlement having been filed, the objection could not be accepted. Against that order an appeal was carried to the learned District Judge, who held that the alleged adjustment dated 6-11-63 was one under Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC, and as the judgment-debtor did not certify the adjustment within 90 days, as required under Article 174 of the Limitation Act (Act IX) of 1908, (hereinafter referred to as the Old Act), it was barred by limitation. In this view of the matter he did not remand the case for going into evidence on merits whether in fact there was any adjustment as pleaded by the judgment-debtor.

    2. In support of the judgment of the learned lower appellate court. Mr. Sinha advanced two contentions:

    (1) The alleged adjustment, even if true, comes within the ambit of Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC and the certification not having been done by the judgment-debtor within 90 days under Article 174 the objection is barred by time; and

    (2) Even if the objection of the judgment-debtor pleading adjustment does not come within the ambit of Order 21, Rule 2 and is on application under Section 47 of the CPC, it would be hit by Article 174 as being barred by limitation.

    Both the contentions require careful examination.

    (3) Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC, reads thus:

    2. Payment out of Court to decree holder:

    (1) Where any money payable under a decree of any kind is paid out of Court, or the decree is otherwise adjusted in whole or in part to the satisfaction of the decree-holder, the decree-holder shall certify such payment or adjustment to the Court whose duty it is to execute decree, and the Court shall record the same accordingly.

    (2) The judgment-debtor also may inform the Court of such payment or adjustment, and apply to the Court to issue a notice to the decree-holder to show cause, on a day to be fixed by the Court, why such payment or adjustment should not be recorded as certified; and where certification has been made by an endorsement of such payment or adjustment by the decree-holder or by any person authorised by him in that behalf upon the process issued by the Court, the Court shall issue such notice of its own motion. If after service of the notice, the decree-holder fails to show cause why the payment or adjustment should not be recorded as certified, the Court shall record the same accordingly.

    3. A payment or adjustment, which has not been certified or recorded as aforesaid, shall not be recognised by any court executing the decree.

    4. There is conflict of authority on the question whether this Rule has application only to decree under which payment of money is one of the reliefs granted under them, or to all decrees without any distinction. Allahabad. Bombay, Calcutta, Lahore, Patna, Nagpur and Mysore High Courts have taken the view that the provisions of the rule apply to every kind of decree: See AIR 1952 All, 814, AIR 1922 Bom 380 (2), AIR 1928 Cal 715, AIR 1936 Lah 842, AIR 1936 Pat 385. AIR 1948 Nag 374 and AIR 1963 Mys 79. The High Courts of Madras and Andhra Pradesh have on the other hand taken the view that the Rule applied to cases where money is payable under the decree, whether there are other reliefs or not (See AIR 1926 Mad. 749 and AIR 1958 Andh Pra 705).

    5. I am inclined to follow the Madras view the plain language of the Rule justified the latter view. The expression “where any money payable under a decree of any kind” clearly shows that the decree referred to must be one under which one of the reliefs must be for payment of money. It may be a money decree simpliciter or a composite decree under which a relief for payment of money is granted. A suit for recovery of possession and mesne profits would be of one such decree. A suit for mere recovery of possession or for injunction or for both would not come within the ambit of the Rule. The words “any kind” are not wide enough to take within their sweep, decrees of all kinds. The aforesaid words qualify the decree which itself is restricted by the concept that under it any money is payable. It is to be noted that the word “decree” is qualified by the indefinite article “a” in the first part of R. 2(1) while it is qualified by the definite article “the” in the second part. The words “the decree” in the second portion of the Rule refer to the words “a decree” in the first portion of the Rule. “The decree” in the second portion must there fore be of the same character as “the decree” in the first portion. The words “otherwise adjusted” in the second part of the Rule is in contradistinction to the words “out of Court” in the first part of the Rule. In other words the payment of money under a decree, in which one of the reliefs is for payment of money, is to be made either out of the Court, or such a decree may be otherwise adjusted. For instance, the decree may be adjusted by creation of a fresh agreement between the parties where under the decree becomes satisfied or adjusted. If a decree of such a nature is adjusted or the payment is made thereunder out of Court, the judgment-debtor is bound to certify such a payment or adjustment under Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC, and the period of limitation prescribed for such certification by a judgment-debtor is 90 days under Article 174 of the Old Act.

    6. In this case, the decree under execution was, merely for eviction. It is not a decree under which one of the reliefs is for payment of money to such a decree Order 21 R. 2 of the CPC, has no application. The judgment-debtor was not required to certify the adjustment under Order 21 Rule 2. The best exposition of law as to the meaning of Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC is to be found in AIR 1958 Andh Pra 705.

    7. Mr. Sinha further contended that even assuming that the objection of the judgment debtor does not fall within the ambit of Order 21 Rule 2, still is barred by limitation under Article 174 of the Old Act. All questions relating to discharge and satisfaction of the decree as be tween the parties must be decided by the Executing Court under Section 47 of the CPC. A payment of money or adjustment of the decree relates to satisfaction of the decree. The objection, 111 terms, comes within the purview of Section 47 of the CPC. If Article 174 would apply to a case of such adjustment, the objection would be barred by limitation even though it does not specifically fall within the ambit of Order 21 Rule 2 and comes within the purview of S. 47. This necessitates an examination of Article 174 of the old Act which reads as follows—

    For the issue of a notice under the same Code, to show cause why any payment made out of Court of any money payable under a decree or any adjustment of the decree should not be re corded as certified. Ninety days. When the payment or adjustment is made.

    8. On a plain reading of the article it is clear that the payment or adjustment referred to in the article is almost identical with the language used in Order 21 Rule 2 except for the words “of any kind” qualifying the decree. The decree referred to in this article is one under which one of the reliefs must be for payment of money. The reasons, already given while construing Order 21 Rule 2 apply with full force to it also. Article 174 prescribes the period of limitation for payments and adjustments coming within the ambit of Order 21 Rule 2 of the CPC. This article has no application to cases of adjustment falling outside Order 21 Rule 2. The Imitation for such adjustment is three years under the residuary Article 181 of the old Act.

    9. The position would be clear by reference to Article 125 of the Limitation Act (Act XXXVI of 1963) This corresponds to Article 174 of the Old Act.

    It runs thus. To record an adjustment or satisfaction of a decree. Thirty days. When the payment or adjustment is made.

    10. Thus the new article has enlarged the ope of the old article. The new article would apply to adjustment or satisfaction of all kinds of decrees irrespective of their nature or class.

    11. Both the contentions fail and the judgment under appeal cannot be upheld. The case must go back to Executing Court which should go into the merits and determine whether the judgment-debtor has established the plea of settlement. Parties should be given full opportunity for adducing evidence and the Executing Court would decide whether the alleged settlement is true and enforceable in law. The case should be disposed of within four months from today with intimation to this Court. The records of the lower Court be sent down at once. In the result the affirming judgment of the lower appellate Court is set aside and the appeal is allowed. In the circumstances, parties to bear their own costs upto this stage.

    KJ/RKC/G.G.M

    12. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dhani Bahera v. Sushil Chandra Palit .
    (Aug 11, 1966)