Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section. Section 80 of the Indian Kailways Act
  • Section 142 of the Indian Railways Act,
  • Section 77 of the Indian Railways Act
  • Section 77 of the Indian Railways Art.
  • Section 74(d) of the Railways Act,
  • SECTION 77 RAILWAYS ACT
  • Section 77 of the Railway Act
  • Order 9 Rule 13 of the CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section. Section 80 of the Indian Kailways Act
  • Section 142 of the Indian Railways Act,
  • Section 77 of the Indian Railways Act
  • Section 77 of the Indian Railways Art.
  • Section 74(d) of the Railways Act,
  • SECTION 77 RAILWAYS ACT
  • Section 77 of the Railway Act
  • Order 9 Rule 13 of the CPC
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Narasimham, C.J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This litigation arose from a suit instituted by the respondent for recovery of damages from the Railway administration for non-delivery of a consignment. The goods were booked from Surareddipalayam on the Southern Railway on 10-12-52 and were not delivered at destination.

The learned Second Additional Subordinate Judge, Cuttack, decreed the suit with costs in favour of the respondent. The Railway administration (defendants / appellants) defended on the ground that the consignment was looted by a riotous mob at Bezwada Railway Station on 16-12-52 during agitation arising from the death by fasting of Andhra leader Poti Sriramulu, and therefore disclaimed liability.

Evidence produced by the Railway included statements that the consignment arrived at Bezwada tranship shed on 14-12-52 in wagon No. NWGG.46452, was re-loaded into wagon BBCG.31100 on 15-12-52 and sealed, and that on inspection on 24-12-52 the consignment was missing. The Railway did not produce evidence directly proving looting by a mob on 16-12-52.

Procedurally, while the trial continued in 1959 the defendants sought time on 4-4-59 to bring witnesses; the court refused and directed attendance on 8-4-59. The defendants again failed to produce witnesses and the case was closed; the suit was disposed of on 15-4-59. The defendants filed an application under Order 9, Rule 13 CPC on 8-5-59 to set aside the order, which was later dismissed for default on 7-8-59, leading to the present appeals (Misc. Appeal No.2 of 1961 and First Appeal No.2 of 1961).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Railway administration could avoid liability by claiming that the consignment was looted by a riotous mob at Bezwada Railway Station on 16-12-52 when there was no direct evidence proving looting on that date.
  2. Whether notice required by Section 77 of the Indian Railways Act (six‑month notice) was served on the correct Railway administration (Southern Railway) within the stipulated period, and whether Section 77 applied where there was complete non-delivery of goods.
  3. Whether the defendants were entitled to relief under Order 9, Rule 13 CPC setting aside the trial court's orders and permitting a fresh hearing, given their failure to produce witnesses and subsequent dismissal for default.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (Railway administration) Arguments

  • The consignment was looted by a riotous mob at Bezwada Railway Station on 16-12-52 during the agitation following Poti Sriramulu's death, and that this excused non-delivery.
  • No notice under Section 77 of the Indian Railways Act was served on the Southern Railway (the railway on which the loss occurred) within the six-month period required by that Section; on this ground the suit should fail.
  • Procedurally, the defendants implied that the trial court's orders had been effectively rendered ex parte and sought relief under Order 9, Rule 13 CPC to set aside such orders and secure a first hearing.

Respondent's (Plaintiff) Position

  • The plaintiff pleaded that registered notices under Section 77 were given to both the Eastern Railway and the Southern Railway and filed copies, registration receipts and acknowledgements with the plaint.
  • Evidence on record showed the consignment was lost at Bezwada between 15-12-52 and 24-12-52, but there was no evidence that it was removed by a mob on 16-12-52; therefore the Railway could not escape liability.
  • The plaintiff relied on the pleadings (paragraph 4 of the plaint) and on Ext. 3 (a copy of the notice to the Eastern Railway bearing an endorsement copying it to "C.C.S Railway, Madras ... for favour of necessary action") to show that notice was also sent to the Southern Railway.
  • The plaintiff argued the defendants had ample opportunity to produce witnesses, failed to do so, and were guilty of laches, making relief under Order 9, Rule 13 inappropriate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Governor General in Council v. Musaddi Lal, AIR 1961 SC 725 Held that Section 77 of the (old) Indian Railways Act applies even where there is complete non-delivery of goods (overruled the earlier Patna view). The court treated this Supreme Court decision as settling the controversy and applied it to hold that notice under Section 77 was required even in cases of complete non-delivery, making service on the Railway where the loss occurred (Southern Railway) necessary.
Jaisram Ramrekh Das v. Great Indian Peninsular Railway, AIR 1929 Pat 109 Represented the Patna view that Section 77 might not apply to complete non-delivery (this view was overruled by Musaddi Lal). The court noted that the Patna view in this case had been overruled by the Supreme Court decision in Musaddi Lal, and therefore it no longer governed the question before the court.
Dunichand Ram Saran Das v. Secy. of State, AIR 1931 Cal 585 Held that where a copy of a S.77 notice is sent 'for information' to another Railway administration, it does not constitute a valid notice under Section 77 as against that administration. The court distinguished this case on its facts: here the copy to the Southern Railway was endorsed "for favour of necessary action" (not merely "for information"), supporting the inference that a claim was intended to be made against the Southern Railway as well.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through a sequence of factual and legal analyses grounded in the record and the authorities cited.

  1. Procedural conduct and laches: The court emphasized that the defendants were given multiple opportunities to produce witnesses (adjournments on 4-4-59 and an adjournment to 8-4-59) but failed to do so; their subsequent application under Order 9, Rule 13 CPC to set aside the orders for a first hearing was itself dismissed for default. The court concluded that the Railway administration had been guilty of serious laches and that it would not be proper to grant them another opportunity to produce evidence.
  2. Sufficiency of evidence on looting: On the merits, the court observed that the evidence established the temporal window of loss — sometime between 15-12-52 (when the consignment was re-loaded and sealed) and 24-12-52 (when the wagon was checked and the consignment found missing). However, there was no evidence affirmatively showing that a riotous mob looted the wagon on 16-12-52. Because the Railway did not adduce evidence proving removal by a mob, the Railway could not escape liability on that ground.
  3. Applicability of Section 77 to non-delivery: The court relied on the Supreme Court decision in Governor General in Council v. Musaddi Lal, AIR 1961 SC 725, which held that Section 77 of the old Act applied even to complete non-delivery. This resolved the controversy as to applicability in favour of requiring a six-month notice even in non-delivery cases.
  4. Whether notice under Section 77 was properly served on the Southern Railway: The court carefully examined the pleadings and documentary material. Paragraph 4 of the plaint alleged that registered notices under Section 77 were sent to both Eastern and Southern Railways and asserted that copies, registration receipts and acknowledgements were filed. The Eastern Railway (defendant No.1) contested the suit but did not specifically deny the allegation in paragraph 4; the Southern Railway (defendant No.2) did not contest and was treated as ex parte. Ext. 3 (copy of the notice to Eastern Railway) bore an endorsement: "Copy to C.C.S Railway, Madras on 28-3-53 for favour of necessary action."
  5. Legal presumptions and inferences regarding service: The court invoked Section 142 of the Indian Railways Act to note the statutory presumption that where a letter containing notice is properly addressed and registered, it is presumed to have been duly served on the addressee. Coupled with the absence of a specific denial by the contesting defendant and the Southern Railway's ex parte status, the court concluded that the statement in paragraph 4 of the plaint that notice was sent to both Railways must be taken as uncontroverted. The endorsement "for favour of necessary action" on Ext. 3 supported the inference that a claim was also made against the Southern Railway.
  6. Distinguishing precedent: The court distinguished Dunichand Ram Saran Das v. Secretary of State (Cal) on the ground that in that case the copy was sent merely "for information"; here the copy indicated it was for "necessary action," which ordinarily connotes a substantive claim against the Southern Railway.
  7. Conclusion from combined analysis: Given the defendants' failure to prove looting, their procedural laches, the applicability of Section 77 to non-delivery, and the uncontroverted pleading together with Ext. 3 and the presumption under Section 142, the court concluded that service of notice on both Railways had been duly proved and that the Railway administration could not avoid liability.

Holding and Implications

Final Ruling: The court upheld the judgment and decree of the lower court and dismissed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 2 of 1961 and First Appeal No. 2 of 1961 with costs. The decree was slightly modified to award future interest at six per cent per annum from the date of institution of the suit until payment on the total amount of the claim as decreed by the lower court.

Implications:

  • The Railway administration remains liable to the decree-holder for the damages awarded by the trial court, with interest at 6% per annum from the date of institution of the suit until payment.
  • The court declined to reopen the trial or permit additional evidence from the defendants in view of their failure to act and the laches demonstrated on the record.
  • The opinion applied the Supreme Court decision in Governor General in Council v. Musaddi Lal to confirm that Section 77 applied to cases of complete non-delivery — but this judgment itself primarily decides the dispute between the parties and does not purport to announce a novel legal principle beyond the application of existing authorities cited in the opinion.

Order: Judgment and decree of the lower court are upheld with the stated modification as to interest. R.K. Das, J. concurred. "Order accordingly."

    Union Of India And Another v. Bansidhar Nandy .

    Narasimham, C.J:— These two appeals arise out of the judgment of the learned Second additional Subordinate Judge, Cuttack, decreeing with costs a suit brought by the respondent for recovery of damages from the Railway administration for non-delivery of certain goods that were booked from Surareddipalayam on the Southern Railway on 10-12-52. The defence of the Railway Administration was that the consignment was looted by a riotous mob at Bezwada Radway Station on 16-12-52 when, due to the death, by fasting, of the well known Andhra Leader Poti Sriramulu in Madras, in connection with the formation of a Andhra Province, there was an agitation and commotion in several parts of Andhra territory including Bezwada Railway Station. The Railway administration examined some of the members of its staff at Bezwada Railway Station, to show that the loss of the consignment took place at Bezwada Railway Station on 16-12-52. Thus D.W 1 stated that the consignment in question was kept in wagon No. NWGG. 46452, that it arrived at Bezwada Tranship shed intact on 14-12-52 and that the consignment was re-loaded in another wagon BBCG. 31100 on 15-12-52 and properly sealed for onward despatch. D.W 2 stated that he checked this wagon on 24-12-52 and found the consignment missing altogether. The Railway administration did not lead further evidence to show that this wagon was looted by the mob on 16-12-52.

    2. While the trial was going on in the lower court, the defendants (appellants) on 4-4-59 wanted further time to being their witnesses but the court refused the prayer as the suit was already old, and directed the defendants to produce their witnesses on 8-4-59. But even on that day the defendants did not examine any other witness, and then the case was closed, with the evidence already on record and the suit was disposed of on 15-4-59. Thereupon, the defendants assuming the said orders have been passed ex parte filed an application under Order 9 Rule 13 of the CPC before the same Court on 8-5-59 for setting aside the order and for first hearing. But even that application was allowed to be dismissed for default on 7-8-59. Against the order of dismissal Misc. Appeal No. 2 of 1961 was filed. There is absolutely no ground for setting aside the judgment of the lower court. The defendants were given ample opportunities to adduce at available evidence. The suit was instituted on 15-254. Some of the Railway witnesses were examine on commission at Bezwada and the suit was the taken up for further hearing at Cuttack in 1959. It should not have been difficult for the Railway administration to bring Railway witnesses to Cuttack and complete their evidence. Even when their prayer for time was rejected on 4-4-59 the learned lower court adjourned the case to 8-4-59 and during that interval also no steps were taken to bring their witnesses. Again when the application under Order 9, Rule 13 of the CPC was filed on 8-5-59 no further steps were taken to explain the circumstances under which the witnesses were not available on 8-4-59 in the suit on the other hand that application itself was allowed to be dismissed for default on 7-8-59. Thus the Railway Administration has been guilty of serious laches and it will not be proper to give them again another opportunity to produce evidence.

    3. Thus, on the meagre evidence on record though it is established that the consignment was lost in Bezwada railway station sometime between 15-12-52 and 24-12-52 there is no evidence to show that it was removed by riotous mob which looted Bezwada Railway Station on 16-12-52. The defendant railway administration cannot therefore escape liability on this ground.

    4. The next pa frit urged by Mr. Pal appearing for the Railway administration is that no notice under Section 77 of the Railway Act was served on the Southern Railway (where the goods were lost) within the period of six months as required by that Section. Section 80 of the Indian Kailways Act as it stood prior to the amendment of 1961 (by Act 39 of 1961) required that where there was loss of goods, a suit for compensation may be filed either against the Railway Administration where the consignment was delivered or against the Railway administration on whose railway the loss occurred. Under the aforesaid S. 77, where there is loss of goods during transit the claim must be made before the Railway administration within 6 months from the date of delivery of the goods. There was some controversy as to whether this section was applicable where there was complete non-delivery of the goods (as in the instant case) as distinct from loss of goods during transit.

    5. But the recent decision of the Supreme Court reported in Governor General in Council v. Musaddi Lal, AIR 1961 SC 725 has set the matter at rest. There the Patna view in Jaisram Ramrekh Das v. Great Indian Peninsular Railway*, AIR 1929 Pat 109 was overruled and it was held that even if there was complete non-delivery Section 77 of the old Act was applicable. As Surareddipalayam is admittedly in the Southern Railway and the loss of the consignment is admitted to have taken place at ??? railway station which is also on the Southern Railway, the notice under Section 77 of the Railways Act should have been given to that Railway and not to the Eastern Railway (now South Eastern Railway) where the station of destination, viz., Kapilas Road is situated.

    6. Mr. Pal urged that the plaintiff failed to establish affirmatively that notice under Section 77 of the Indian Railways Act was served on the Southern Railway within the stipulated period and that consequently the entire suit must fail on this ground alone.

    7. To appreciate this argument it is necessary, to refer to certain facts. In paragraph 4 of the plaint the plaintiff alleged that he gave registered notices under Section 77 of the Indian Railways Art. to the Railway administration, namely the Eastern Railway and the Southern Railway, and further stated that copies of the said notices, registration receipt and acknowledgement were filed along with the plaint. Both the Eastern Railway and the Southern Railway were impleaded as defendants, the Eastern Railway being defendant No. 1 and the Southern Railway being defendant No. 2—the Union of India representing both the Railway administrations. But the Eastern Railway alone entered appearance and contested the suit. The Southern Railway (defendant No. 2) did not contest and the order of the learned trial Court dated 12-3-1954 shows that defendant No. 2 was treated as ex parte. Defendant No. 1 also in his written statement did not expressly deny the allegation in paragraph 4 of the plaint that registered notices under Section 77 of the Indian Railways Act were sent to both the Railways. Defendant No. 1's contention in para. 2 of his written statement was that no valid notice under Section 77 of that Act was served. In other words it was the validity of the notice under S. 77 that was challenged and not the fact that such notice was issued by registered post by the plaintiff. Thus, when the facts averred in paragraph 4 of the plaint were not specifically denied by the contesting defendant No. 1 and when the Southern Railway (defendant 2) allowed the suit to proceed ex parte it was not necessary for the plaintiff further to establish by evidence that notice under Section 77 of the Indian Railways Act was in fact issued to the Southern Railways. Hence the statement in paragraph 4 of the plaint must be taken to be uncontroverted. Some corroboration of this statement is found in Ext. 3 which is a copy of the notice under S. 77, issued to the Eastern Railway by the plaintiff on 26-5-53. At the bottom of this document it is written:

    “Copy to C.C.S Railway, Madras on 28-3-53 for favour of necessary action.”

    8. This endorsement, coupled with the assertion in paragraph 4 of the plaint must lead to the necessary inference that due notice by registered post was also given to the Southern Railway (defendant No. 2). Under Section 142 of the Indian Railways Act, if it be proved that the letter containing the notice was properly addressed and registered there was a presumption that it was duly served on the addressee. Here apart from presumption, the absence of any specific denial by the two Railways concerned must lead to the inference that the notice under S. 77 was duly served by registered post and duly received. Hence, in my opinion, Mr. Pal is not correct in saying that the plaintiff has failed to prove that the notice was served on the Southern Railway.

    9. Some reliance was placed on Dunichand Ram Saran Das v. Secy. of State, AIR 1931 Cal 585 where it was held that if notice of claim is given under Section 77 of the Indian Railways Act to one Railway administration while a copy of that notice is sent to the agent of another Railway Administration ‘for information’ and compensation is demanded from the latter, there is no valid notice under S. 77.

    10. There the copy was sent to the Railway Administration ‘for information’ whereas here, as already pointed out Ext. 3 shows that the copy was sent to C.C.S Southern Railway, Madras “tor favour of necessary action”. The instant case is therefore distinguishable from the aforesaid Calcutta case. The words “for favour of necessary action would ordinarily mean that a claim was made against the Southern Railway also. At that time the plaintiff could not obviously be certain as to where the loss of consignment actually took place. In fact under Section 74(d) of the Railways Act, it was the responsibility of the Railway to disclose to the plaintiff where the loss occurred. Hence the plaintiff took the precaution of sending the notice under Section 77 to the Eastern Railway with a copy to the Southern Railway also, for necessary action. If in fact, the notice was not received by the Southern Railway that Railway would have entered appearance and contested the suit and then the plaintiff would have proved the postal receipt of notice and also the acknowledgement receipt to show that the notice was served on the Southern Railway also. I must accordingly hold, in the circumstances of this case that the service of notice on both the Railways has been duly proved.

    11. For these reasons the judgment and decree of the lower court are upheld and Miscellaneous Appeal No. 2 of 1961 and First Appeal No. 2 of 1961 are both dismissed with costs. But the decree of the lower Court is slightly modified and it is further directed that the decree-holder (respondent) should get future interest at six per cent per annum, from the date of institution of the suit till the date of payment, on the total amount of claim as decreed by the lower Court.

    12. R.K Das, J.:— I agree.

    HF/H/V.B.B

    13. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Another v. Bansidhar Nandy .
    (May 3, 1962)