Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary: S. Samvatsar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment disposes of an appeal and a number of connected appeals (M.A. Nos. 127, 126, 110, 122, 123, 124, 128, 267, 131, 257, 144, 155 and 132 of 2003) arising from the same motor accident and challenging quantum of compensation awarded by the Third Additional Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Gwalior in Claim Case No. 27 of 2002 and related cases.

On 24.3.2001 there was a head-on collision between a truck (No. HR 55-4375) travelling from Shivpuri to Gwalior and a jeep (No. UP 093-D 9168) travelling from Gwalior to Shivpuri. Seventeen persons were travelling in the jeep; several persons died and some were injured. Separate claim petitions were filed by different claimants and decided by the Claims Tribunal by separate judgments. The Tribunal found composite negligence of both drivers and apportioned liability as 70% to the truck driver and 30% to the jeep driver; the present appeals challenge mainly the quantum awards and the Tribunal's deduction of 30% in many cases on account of contributory negligence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the accident resulted from composite negligence and whether the apportionment of negligence (70% truck, 30% jeep) made by the Tribunal should be disturbed.
  2. Whether the deduction of 30% from compensation (as contributory negligence of claimants/passengers) made by the Tribunal is sustainable, particularly in respect of deceased passengers who were traveling in the jeep.
  3. Determination and reassessment of quantum of compensation for each claimant (including assessment of income, notional income where applicable, applicable multiplier, and other heads such as funeral expenses and loss of consortium).
  4. Whether amounts received as ex gratia by a claimant/deceased must be adjusted/deducted from compensation.
  5. Appropriate rate of interest to be awarded on the enhanced amounts from date of filing of appeal until realization.

Arguments of the Parties

Claimants / Appellants (as evidenced in record)

  • Eyewitness PW 2 (Madhosingh) stated that on 24.3.2001 at about 2:30 p.m. he saw the jeep coming from Satanwada on the right side at slow speed (about 40 kmph); he saw a truck coming from Shivpuri at very high speed and that the truck dashed the jeep from the driver's side. He stated there were about 18 persons in the jeep.
  • Claimants in various matters presented evidence or assertions about the deceased's income (for example, statements that certain deceased earned specific monthly amounts or ran a hotel), or, where no definite evidence existed, the court was asked to adopt notional income figures.

Respondent / Defence (as evidenced in record)

  • Defence witness Om Prakash, driver of the truck, admitted the accident but stated that the jeep coming from the opposite side was carrying 18 to 20 persons, was at high speed, and that the jeep driver lost control and dashed against the truck.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Helen C. Rebelio v. Maharashtra State Road Trans. Corpn., 1999 ACJ 10 (SC) Deduction of ex gratia amounts received by a claimant/deceased from compensation awarded. The court applied the principle to deduct an ex gratia amount of Rs. 23,000 received by the deceased Purushottam Sharma from the enhanced compensation figure for that claimant.
Sushila Bhadoriya v. Madhya Pradesh State Road Trans. Corpn., 2005 ACJ 831 (MP) (Full Bench) In cases of composite negligence, claimants can recover compensation from any of the vehicles involved; where one vehicle's owner/driver/insurer is not joined, claimants can still recover from the insurer of the other vehicle; the insurer who pays may have a right to recover contribution if legally permissible. The court relied on this Full Bench authority to hold that claimants can recover the compensation from the truck's insurance company even though the jeep's owner/driver/insurer were not parties; the truck's insurer would remain free to seek recovery from the jeep's insurer if legally permissible.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded on the basis of the common evidence recorded in the connected appeals. It reviewed eyewitness testimony (PW 2, Madhosingh) and the defence statement of the truck driver (Om Prakash). Both sets of testimony confirm a head-on collision. The court observed:

  • PW 2 described the jeep as being on the right side and moving slowly (approx. 40 kmph), and the truck as moving at very high speed and striking the jeep from the driver side.
  • Om Prakash stated the jeep carried 18–20 persons, was at high speed, and the jeep driver lost control and collided with the truck.

On these facts the court concluded there was composite negligence by both drivers. It accepted the Tribunal's quantitative apportionment of negligence between the truck (70%) and the jeep (30%) and stated it found no reason to interfere with that particular finding. However, the court set aside the Tribunal's separate finding that passengers (victims traveling as passengers in the jeep) were themselves liable to the extent of 30% for the accident. The court reasoned that passengers cannot be held responsible for the overloading or the negligence of the jeep driver and therefore should not suffer a deduction on account of such contributory negligence.

For quantum, the court reviewed each appeal individually and recalculated compensation applying the following approaches explicitly reflected in the opinion:

  • Where credible, direct evidence of income was available (for example, salary certificates or multiple witnesses), the court accepted or adjusted the claimed income accordingly (e.g., Purushottam Sharma's salary certificate, and evidence regarding drivers earning approx. Rs. 3,000 per month).
  • Where no definite evidence of income existed the court consistently adopted a notional income of Rs. 15,000 per year and calculated yearly dependency at Rs. 10,000 per year (used repeatedly across several claims), and applied an age-appropriate multiplier as indicated in the opinion to determine loss of dependency.
  • Where record showed amounts received as ex gratia, the court deducted such amounts from the total compensation as guided by Helen C. Rebelio (see Purushottam Sharma: Rs. 23,000 deducted).
  • For a claimant who was himself the driver of the jeep (M.A. No. 267 of 2003, Claim Case No. 44 of 2002), the court upheld a 30% deduction because the deceased driver contributed to the accident by overloading the jeep and was accordingly found contributorily negligent to that extent.
  • The court adjusted the awards in specified appeals (see Holding and Implications section for per-appeal amounts) and awarded interest on the enhanced amounts at 6% per annum from the date of filing of the appeal until realization, citing the bank rate as the basis for fixing a common rate of interest across all cases.

The court also observed that the truck's insurer, though made liable to pay compensation in the absence of the jeep's parties, would retain the legal right to seek contribution or recovery from the jeep's insurer/owner/driver if legally permissible.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS PARTLY ALLOWED

Direct holdings and their immediate consequences, drawn from the opinion:

  • The Tribunal's finding of composite negligence (70% truck / 30% jeep) is upheld and not interfered with insofar as apportionment between the two vehicles is concerned.
  • The Tribunal's finding that victims/passengers were liable to the extent of 30% is set aside; passengers (other than the jeep driver) are entitled to full compensation without deduction for contributory negligence arising from overloading or the jeep driver's negligence.
  • Exception: In M.A. No. 267 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 44 of 2002), where the deceased was the driver of the jeep, the court held that the deceased contributed to the negligence (overloading) and upheld a 30% deduction in that case.
  • The court enhanced compensation awards in the connected appeals as follows (amounts stated are those awarded by this Court in the opinion):
  • M.A. No. 25 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 27 of 2002) — Ramgopal (driver, aged 34): enhanced to Rs. 4,25,000.
  • M.A. No. 127 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 42 of 2002) — Pooja (aged 9): enhanced to Rs. 1,15,000 (Rs. 1,00,000 + Rs. 15,000).
  • M.A. No. 126 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 43 of 2002) — Purushottam Sharma (aged 42): enhanced to Rs. 5,70,000 after deducting ex gratia of Rs. 23,000 (total compensation Rs. 5,51,000 plus Rs. 19,000 for other heads; aggregate reflected as Rs. 5,70,000 in the opinion).
  • M.A. No. 110 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 41 of 2002) — Susheela Sharma (aged 35): enhanced to Rs. 1,80,000 (Rs. 1,60,000 + Rs. 20,000).
  • M.A. No. 122 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 31 of 2002) — Kalabai: enhanced to Rs. 1,00,000 (Rs. 80,000 + Rs. 20,000) based on likely age between 55–60 years and multiplier of 8.
  • M.A. No. 123 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 34 of 2002) — Usha Sharma (aged 40): enhanced to Rs. 1,75,000 (Rs. 1,50,000 + Rs. 25,000).
  • M.A. No. 124 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 35 of 2002) — Yesodhabai (aged approx. 45–50): enhanced to Rs. 1,50,000 (Rs. 1,30,000 + Rs. 20,000).
  • M.A. No. 128 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 32 of 2003) — Rajabetti: enhanced to Rs. 1,70,000 (Rs. 1,50,000 + Rs. 20,000).
  • M.A. No. 267 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 44 of 2002) — Riyaz Khan (jeep driver, aged 23): after calculating compensation at Rs. 3,32,000 and deducting 30% (Rs. 99,600) for contributory negligence, parents are entitled to Rs. 2,32,400.
  • M.A. No. 131 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 40 of 2002) — Sunil (aged 4): enhanced to Rs. 1,70,000 (Rs. 1,50,000 + Rs. 20,000).
  • M.A. No. 257 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 30 of 2002) — Hariram (aged 42, agriculturist): enhanced to Rs. 1,70,000 (Rs. 1,50,000 + Rs. 20,000).
  • M.A. No. 144 of 2003 — Injury claim (appellant suffered femur fracture): enhanced from Rs. 15,000 to Rs. 50,000 (no permanent disability; hospitalization and prolonged treatment noted).
  • M.A. No. 155 of 2003 (Claim Case No. 28 of 2002) — Ramcharan (aged 40–45, labourer): enhanced to Rs. 1,70,000 (Rs. 1,50,000 + Rs. 20,000).
  • M.A. No. 132 of 2003 — Guddi (aged 5): enhanced to Rs. 1,70,000 (Rs. 1,50,000 + Rs. 20,000).

Interest: The court fixed interest on the enhanced amounts at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of filing of the respective appeals until realization of the amounts, noting differing rates previously awarded by the Tribunal and adopting a uniform rate tied to the bank rate.

No new broader precedent was established beyond the application of cited authorities; the direct effects are the enhanced awards specified above, the setting aside of deductions from passengers (except in the case where the deceased himself was the negligent driver), and the direction regarding interest and the insurer's right of recovery.

Result: All the listed appeals were partly allowed and the awards were enhanced or modified as described. Appeals are partly allowed.

    Uma Rathore And Others v. Om Prakash And Others

    S. Samvatsar, J.:— This judgment shall govern disposal of this appeal as well as connected appeals (M.A Nos. 127, 126, 110, 122, 123, 124, 128, 267, 131, 257, 144, 155 and 132 of 2003) arising out of the same accident, which have been filed challenging the quantum of compensation awarded by the Third Additional Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Gwalior in Claim Case No. 27 of 2002 and other connected cases.

    2. All the claim petitions arise out of the motor accident occurred on 24.3.2001 between a truck bearing No. HR 55-4375 and a jeep No. UP 093-D 9168. The truck was coming from Shivpuri to Gwalior, while the jeep was going from Gwalior to Shivpuri. As many as 17 persons were travelling in the jeep. There was head-on collision between the truck and jeep, in which number of persons died and some were injured. Claimants have filed separate claim applications which were decided by the Claims Tribunal by separate judgments.

    3. In all the claim petitions the Tribunal has held that the accident had taken place due to composite negligence of the driver of the truck and driver of the jeep. Driver, owner and insurance company of the jeep are not joined as parties to the claim petitions and the claim petitions are filed only against the driver, owner and insurance company of the truck. The Claims Tribunal held that accident has taken place due to composite negligence of both the drivers. As per the findings of the Claims Tribunal, the driver of the jeep was liable up to 30 per cent, while the driver of the truck was liable up to the extent of 70 per cent and awarded the compensation. Hence, all these appeals are filed.

    4. These appeals are filed challenging the quantum awarded by Claims Tribunal and its findings whereby it has been held that since the claimants have contributed to the accident to the extent of 30 per cent, therefore, the amount to the extent of 30 per cent is liable to be deducted from the compensation awarded by the Tribunal. In all these appeals common evidence was recorded.

    5. As regards question of negligence is concerned, the claimants have examined themselves and some eyewitnesses. PW 2, Madhosingh is one of the eyewitnesses, who has stated that the accident has occurred on 24.3.2001 at about 2.30 p.m This witness was standing in front of the hotel owned by one Nawab. He has seen the jeep coming from Satanwada. According to this witness, the jeep was on the right side and was in a slow speed. When this jeep reached near the bridge he saw a truck coming from Shivpuri. According to this witness, speed of the truck was very fast and truck dashed the jeep from driver side. This witness says that 18 persons were sitting in the jeep. He further says that speed of the jeep was around 40 kmph.

    6. The defence has examined one Om Prakash, who is driver of the truck. He has admitted the accident. He says that the jeep which was coming from the opposite side was carrying 18 to 20 persons and the jeep was in high speed. The jeep driver lost the control of the jeep and dashed against the truck. Thus, there is statement of Om Prakash, driver of the truck and one eyewitness, who had seen the incident. From the statement of these witnesses, it appears that there was head-on collision between the two vehicles and both the driver of the truck as well as the driver of the jeep were responsible for the accident. Driver of the jeep was carrying nearly 18 to 20 persons in the jeep, whereas the seating capacity of the jeep is about 8 to 10 persons. This itself shows that the driver of the jeep was also responsible for the accident. Hence, it is held that the accident has occurred due to composite negligence of the driver of the truck as well as the driver of the jeep. The Tribunal has held that negligence of the truck was 70 per cent while that of the jeep driver was 30 per cent. We do not find any reason to interfere in the said finding. However, we set aside the finding of the Tribunal that the victims who were travelling as passengers were also liable to the extent of 30 per cent.

    7. Now, the question is about quantum and this question will have to be decided by this court separately in respect of each of the claimant.

    M.A No. 25 of 2003:

    8. This appeal arises out of Claim Case No. 27 of 2002. Deceased Ramgopal died in the said accident. He was the truck driver. He was aged 34 years at the time of accident. The Claims Tribunal assessed the compensation at Rs. 2,04,000 (rupees two lakh four thousand) and deducted an amount of 30 per cent holding the deceased liable for negligence. Deceased was aged 24 years. His yearly income is assessed by the Claims Tribunal at Rs. 18,000 per year. PW 1, Uma has deposed that her husband was getting Rs. 3,000 per month as salary and Rs. 50 per day towards allowances and his income was Rs. 4,000 per month. PW 3, Laxman says that he was owner of the truck in which the deceased was a driver and he was paying him salary at the rate of Rs. 3,000 per month and he was getting allowance of Rs. 50 per day. PW 4, Om Prakash has stated that the deceased was getting salary of Rs. 3,000 per month and Rs. 50 towards travelling allowance. There is no evidence in rebuttal. It is a thing of common knowledge that the truck drivers are normally earning Rs. 3,000 per month. Hence, the Claims Tribunal has erred in assessing his income at Rs. 18,000 per year. The yearly income of the deceased, who was driver can be safely assessed at Rs. 36,000 per year and his yearly dependency conies to Rs. 24,000. As he was aged 34 years, the multiplier of 17 is applicable. Thus compensation comes to Rs. 4,08,000. The claimants are further entitled to a sum of Rs. 17,000 over and above this amount and thus, the claimants are entitled to compensation of Rs. 4,25,000 (rupees four lakh twenty-five thousand).

    M.A No. 127 of 2003:

    9. M.A No. 127 of 2003 arises out of Claim Case No. 42 of 2002. The claim petition is filed by the brothers of deceased Pooja, who was 9 years of age. Her parents also died in the same accident. The claimants are elder brothers of the deceased. She was not an earning member and, therefore, her income is taken on the basis of notional income at Rs. 15,000 per year and dependency comes to Rs. 10,000 per year. Considering the fact that claimants are her elder brothers, hence multiplier of 10 can safely be adopted in her case and compensation is enhanced from Rs. 70,000 as awarded by Tribunal to Rs. 1,00,000 + Rs. 15,000 for funeral expenses and other heads. Thus total compensation comes to Rs. 1,15,000 (rupees one lakh fifteen thousand).

    M.A No. 126 of 2003:

    10. This appeal arises out of Claim Case No. 43 of 2002. Claims Tribunal awarded Rs. 3,85,000 for the death of Purushottam Sharma, who was 42 years of age. The Claims Tribunal assessed his yearly income at Rs. 54,000. Exh. P12 is the salary certificate which shows that his monthly income was Rs. 5,241, out of which an amount of Rs. 450 was deducted towards G.P.F and Rs. 100 towards G.I.S Thus there was deduction of Rs. 550 from his salary. The Claims Tribunal also found that the salary of the deceased was Rs. 5,241 per month and assessed the yearly income at Rs. 54,000 on the ground that he must be paying income tax. This approach of the Tribunal does not appear to be correct because in 2001 as per slab of income tax, the amount up to Rs. 60,000 was not taxable. Considering this fact, the income of the deceased should be taken at Rs. 62,890 per year and his yearly dependency can be assessed at Rs. 41,000. As the deceased was 42 years of age, a multiplier of 14 will be applicable and the total compensation comes to Rs. 5,74,000. It has also come on record that he has received an amount of Rs. 23,000 as ex gratia amount. Hence, as per the judgment of Apex Court in the case of Helen C. Rebelio v. Maharashtra State Road Trans. Corpn., 1999 ACJ 10 (SC). this amount will have to be deducted from the amount of compensation. Thus, the total amount of compensation comes to Rs. 5,51,000. Claimants are also entitled to further sum of Rs. 19,000 towards funeral expenses, loss to estate, loss of love and affection, etc. Thus, the claimants are entitled to a sum of Rs. 5,70,000 (rupees five lakh seventy thousand).

    M.A No. 110 of 2003:

    11. This appeal arises out of the Claim Case No. 41 of 2002. This claim petition was filed for the death of Susheela Sharma, who was 35 years of age. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 1,10,000 as compensation for her death. She was not an earning member. However, her income can be assessed on notional basis at Rs. 15,000 per year. Her dependency comes to Rs. 10,000 per year. As she was 35 years of age, multiplier of 16 is applicable and it is held that her heirs are entitled to compensation to the tune of Rs. 1,60,000 + Rs. 20,000 towards other heads like funeral expenses, loss of love and affection, etc. and thus the amount of compensation is hereby enhanced from Rs. 1,10,000 to Rs. 1,80,000 (rupees one lakh eighty thousand).

    M.A No. 122 of 2003:

    12. This appeal is filed against the judg ment passed in Claim Case No. 31 of 2002 for the death of Kalabai. Claims Tribunal awarded compensation of Rs. 50,000 for her death. As per the claimant Kalabai was his mother and aged about 50 to 55 years. The Claims Tribunal found that the age of the deceased was 85 years. This finding is arrived at on the basis of the post-mortem report in which her age is described as 85 years. While as per the statement of the claimant, her age was about 55 years. The naksha panchnama also mentions her age as 55 years. The claimant is son of the deceased, who is aged about 30 years. Considering this fact, the finding of the Tribunal appears to be not probable that his mother was aged 85 years at the time of accident. If this age is accepted, then at the time of birth of the claimant, her age comes to 55 years. It, therefore, appears that there must be some error in recording the age of the deceased in the post-mortem report. The probability in this appeal is that her age must be between 55 and 60 years. Therefore, multiplier of 8 will be applicable. The deceased is not an earning member. Hence, considering the notional income of Rs. 15,000 per year her dependency is assessed at Rs. 10,000 per year and on applying multiplier of 8, the compensation comes to Rs. 80,000. The claimant is entitled to further sum of Rs. 20,000 over and above this amount for funeral expenses, loss to estate, loss of love and affection, etc. Thus, the total compensation comes to Rs. 1,00,000 (rupees one lakh).

    M.A No. 123 of 2003:

    13. This appeal arises out of the Claim Case No. 34 of 2002. This appeal is filed claiming compensation for the death of Usha Sharma. She was aged 40 years. The Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs. 1,20,000 for her death. As per the claimants she was earning Rs. 6,000 from running a hotel. This fact is disbelieved by the Claims Tribunal on the ground that there is no definite evidence about her income. Claimants have not produced any document to support the evidence adduced by them. Therefore, in the absence of any evidence the court has rightly assessed her income on notional basis at Rs. 15,000 per year and dependency at Rs. 10,000 per year. Considering the fact that she was aged 40 years, multiplier of 15 is applicable and the total compensation comes to Rs. 1,50,000 + Rs. 25,000 for loss of consortium, funeral expenses, loss of love and affection, etc. Thus, the total compensation comes to Rs. 1,75,000 (rupees one lakh seventy-five thousand).

    M.A No. 124 of 2003:

    14. This appeal arises out of the Claim Case No. 35 of 2002. The claim petition is filed for the death of deceased Yesodha-bai, who died on the spot. The Claims Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs. 90,000 for her death. The deceased was 40 years of age. As per the naksha panchnama, her age is 45 years and as per the post-mortem report, her age is 50 years. Considering this fact, this court can safely infer that her age must be between 45 and 50 years. The court has assessed her income at Rs. 700 to Rs. 800 per month. In view of Schedule under section 163-A, her income can be assessed on notional basis at Rs. 15,000 per year and dependency can be assessed at Rs. 10,000 per year. As she was between 45 and 50 years, multiplier of 13 will be applicable and the compensation comes to Rs. 1,30,000 plus Rs. 20,000 for funeral expenses, loss to estate, loss of love and affection, etc. Thus, the total compensation comes to Rs. 1,50,000 (rupees one lakh fifty thousand).

    M.A No. 128 of 2003:

    15. This appeal arises out of Claim Case No. 32 of 2003. This appeal is filed for the death of deceased Rajabetti. The Claims Tribunal awarded compensation for her death at Rs. 1,20,000. It is alleged that she was a labourer as well as a housewife. The Claims Tribunal has assessed her income on notional basis at Rs. 15,000 per year and applied multiplier of 15 and assessed yearly dependency at Rs. 10,000. Thus, the compensation in her case comes to Rs. 1,50,000 + Rs. 20,000 towards other heads like funeral expenses, loss to estate, loss of love and affection, etc. Thus, the total compensation comes to Rs. 1,70,000.

    M.A No. 267 of 2003:

    16. This appeal arises out of Claim Case No. 44 of 2002. This appeal is filed for the death of Riyaz Khan, who was driver of the jeep. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 1,31,000 for his death. As per the findings arrived at by the Claims Tribunal, he was earning Rs. 18,000 per year. He was aged 23 years. As he was a driver of jeep and the claimants have deposed that he was earning Rs. 3,000 per month, in the absence of any evidence in rebuttal, we do not find any reason to disbelieve their statement. Hence, compensation is decided on the basis of his income at Rs. 3,000 per month. The total income comes to Rs. 36,000 per year and yearly dependency comes to Rs. 24,000. As he was 23 years of age, on applying multiplier of 15 the compensation comes to Rs. 3,60,000, but since the claimants are parents, therefore, multiplier will be applicable on the age of the mother, who is 45 years. Hence, the multiplier of 13 will be applicable and compensation will come to Rs. 3,12,000. Apart from this amount, the claimants are entitled to Rs. 20,000 for funeral expenses, loss to the estate, loss of love and affection, etc. Thus, compensation comes to Rs. 3,32,000. As regards deduction of 30 per cent is concerned, the deceased in this case was driver of the jeep. He was carrying 18 to 20 persons in the jeep, which shows that he was also negligent in driving to the extent of 30 per cent as held by Claims Tribunal and, therefore, 30 per cent of the said amount deserves to be deducted, which comes to Rs. 99,600. After deducting this amount the parents of the deceased are entitled to get compensation at Rs. 2,32,400 (rupees two lakh thirty-two thousand four hundred).

    M.A No. 131 of 2003:

    17. This appeal arises out of Claim Case No. 40 of 2002 which was filed for the death of Sunil, who was aged 4 years. The Claims Tribunal awarded the compensation at Rs. 60,000. He was not an earning member, hence, his income is assessed on notional basis at Rs. 15,000 per year. The dependency comes to Rs. 10,000 per year. After applying the multiplier of 15 for the age of parents, total compensation comes to Rs. 1,50,000. Apart from this amount the claimants are entitled to Rs. 20,000 towards other heads such as loss to estate, funeral expenses, loss of love and affection, etc. Thus, total compensation comes to Rs. 1,70,000 (rupees one lakh seventy thousand).

    M.A No. 257 of 2003:

    18. This appeal is filed against the award in Claim Case No. 30 of 2002 for the death of Hariram, who was 42 years of age. He was an agriculturist. The Claims Tribunal awarded Rs. 1,20,000 for his death. There is no definite evidence about his income, hence the same is assessed on notional basis, i.e, Rs. 15,000 per annum. The dependency comes to Rs. 10,000 per annum and applying multiplier of 15, the compensation comes to Rs. 1,50,000 + Rs. 20,000 towards loss of consortium, fu neral expenses, loss of love and affection, etc. Thus, the award is enhanced from Rs. 1,20,000 to Rs. 1,70,000 (rupees one lakh seventy thousand).

    M.A No. 144 of 2003:

    19. This appeal is filed by the claimants for enhancement of compensation for the injuries caused to the appellant in the said accident. She suffered fracture on femur bone. There is no permanent disability. She was hospitalised for 10 days and has undergone a prolonged treatment. Consid ering this fact the compensation awarded is enhanced from Rs. 15,000 to Rs. 50,000 in the present case.

    M.A No. 155 of 2003:

    20. This appeal arises out of Claim Case No. 28 of 2002. This appeal is filed for compensation for the death of Ramcharan. The Claims Tribunal awarded an amount of Rs. 1,40,000. Ramcharan was aged be tween 40 and 45 years. He was a labourer. There is no definite evidence about his income, hence, compensation is assessed taking his income on notional basis at Rs. 15,000 per year and yearly dependency comes to Rs. 10,000 per year. After apply ing multiplier of 15, the compensation comes to Rs. 1,50,000. Claimants are fur ther entitled to Rs. 20,000 over and above this amount for loss of consortium, funeral expenses, loss of love and affection, etc. The compensation is thus enhanced from Rs. 1,40,000 to Rs. 1,70,000 (rupees one lakh seventy thousand).

    M.A No. 132 of 2003:

    21. This appeal is filed by the claimants for the death of deceased Guddi, who was aged 5 years. The Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs. 52,000 as compensation. She was not an earning member. Her dependency is calculated at Rs. 10,000 per year on the basis of notional income at Rs. 15,000 per year. Her parents are aged 30 years, hence the multiplier of 15 is applicable and the compensation comes to Rs. 1,50,000 + Rs. 20,000 towards funeral expenses, loss to estate, loss of love and affection, etc. Thus, the total compensation comes to Rs. 1,70,000 and the claimants are entitled to an amount of Rs. 1,70,000 (rupees one lakh seventy thousand).

    22. As regards deduction of 30 per cent except M.A No. 267 of 2003 arising out of Claim Case No. 44 of 2002 is concerned, we find that the finding of the Tribunal cannot be sustained. In the present claim cases, the deceased were passengers in the jeep and they cannot be held responsible for the overloading or the negligence of the driver of the jeep. They are, therefore, entitled to get entire compensation without any deduction. The Full Bench of this court in a case of Sushila Bhadoriya v. Madhya Pradesh State Road Trans. Corpn., 2005 ACJ 831 (MP), has laid down that the claimants in case of composite negligence can recover the amount of compensation from any of the vehicles. In such circumstances, merely because owner, driver and insurance company of the jeep is not joined as party, they can recover the said amount from the insurance company of the truck. Of course the insurance company of the truck will be free to recover part of the amount from the insurance company of the jeep, as the jeep was also equally liable for payment of the compensation, if legally permissible.

    23. In the result, all these appeals are partly allowed and the amount of compensation is enhanced as indicated above. As regards interest is concerned, in all the cases different rates of interest are awarded by the court below. Hence, we hold that looking to the bank rate, all the claimants are entitled to interest on the enhanced amount at the rate of 6 per cent per annum from the date of filing of the appeal till realisation of the amount.

    24. Appeals partly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Uma Rathore And Others v. Om Prakash And Others
    (Apr 10, 2006)