AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Judgment (D.M. Dharmadhikari, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a common judgment in three appeals (Misc. Appeal Nos. 142, 143 and 144 of 1989) preferred by the claimants against an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Shivpuri, dated 25.9.1989. The award related to an accident involving truck No. MPW 4832 which overturned on 5.4.1984 at about midnight.

Facts not in dispute: the truck, while carrying labourers in its body, overturned; two labourers (Hotam and Harvilas) died and a third (Deo Pal) sustained fractures. The Claims Tribunal awarded Rs. 28,000 to the claimants of each deceased and Rs. 12,000 to the injured labourer. The Tribunal held the owner and driver jointly and severally liable but completely absolved the insurance company on the ground that the victims were not employed by the owner of the vehicle and were gratuitous passengers. The Tribunal directed refund of the sum paid by the insurer towards 'no fault' liability and directed reimbursement of that amount by the owner and driver.

The appeals challenge, among other things, the absolution of the insurance company and seek enhancement of compensation in the death cases and for injuries.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the evidence, the insurance company could be held liable for compensation when the victims were not directly employed by the owner of the vehicle.
  2. How the terms of the insurance policy must be construed in the context of truck transport business and the statutory purpose of the Motor Vehicles Act — specifically, whether labourers employed by a hirer (not the vehicle owner) are covered by the policy.
  3. Whether an argument regarding breach of statutory provisions (carrying persons in excess of permissible number under the Motor Vehicles Act and Rules) which was not pleaded or proved before the Tribunal can be raised for the first time on appeal to deny insurer's liability.
  4. Whether the compensation awarded by the Claims Tribunal in the two death cases and the injury case requires enhancement, and if so, the correct method and quantum to be applied (including relevance of statutory minimums and Supreme Court guidelines).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Claimants — represented by Mr. N.D. Singhal)

  • The Tribunal erred in completely absolving the insurance company; the finding that the three persons were gratuitous passengers is challenged.
  • Evidence (oral testimony of claimants and vehicle owner) shows the three had boarded the truck as labourers on duty and cannot be treated as gratuitous passengers to absolve the insurer.
  • Alternatively, the insurer cannot deny liability on any ground not available under Section 96 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
  • Relied on earlier decisions (Patharibai Karansingh v. Firm Lalji Shankarlal (1985 ACJ 526 MP), Harishankar Tiwari v. Jagru (1987 ACJ 1 MP), Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan (1987 ACJ 411 SC) and Bhagwan Das v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. (1991 ACJ 1137 MP)) in support of contentions.

Respondent's Arguments (Insurance Company — represented by Mr. B.N. Malhotra)

  • The Tribunal rightly held that the three persons were given a lift while returning after finishing their stone-cutting work at the quarry and were employed by the mine-owner (hirer), not by the vehicle owner.
  • Under the express terms of the insurance policy the risk of persons who are not employed by the insured for work of loading or unloading (i.e., gratuitous passengers or persons not in the employ of the insured) was not covered, so the insurer should be absolved.
  • Heavy reliance placed on specific express terms in the policy (referred to as “Limitations as to use”) as excluding liability in this factual matrix.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Patharibai Karansingh v. Firm Lalji Shankarlal, 1985 ACJ 526 (MP) Cited in support of the proposition that labourers carried in trucks in the course of transport business (even if employed by a hirer) should be covered by insurance. The court relied on this Division Bench decision to support its construction that both labourers employed by the truck-owner and those employed by the hirer are to be deemed covered by insurance.
Harishankar Tiwari v. Jagru, 1987 ACJ 1 (MP) Full Bench decision supporting coverage of labourers carried in truck-transport operations irrespective of direct employment by owner. Used alongside Patharibai to support the view that insurance cover should extend to labourers employed by a hirer when carried in the course of transport business.
Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan, 1987 ACJ 411 (SC) Cited by appellants (specific rule or principle not detailed in the opinion's text). The case was relied upon by appellants; the opinion records the reliance but does not elaborate a discrete rule from it in the reasoning.
Bhagwan Das v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., 1991 ACJ 1137 (MP) Cited by appellants (specific rule or principle not detailed in the opinion's text). Recorded as a reliance by appellants; the judgment does not set out any distinct application beyond noting the reliance.
General Manager, Kerala State Road Transport Corporation v. Susamma Thomas, 1994 ACJ 1 (SC) Supreme Court guidelines for computation of compensation in motor accidents; endorses the multiplier method as appropriate. The court applied these guidelines to re-compute compensation, directing the Claims Tribunal to follow these methods (and directing deposit/disbursal in line with the decision).
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaranlata Das, 1993 ACJ 748 (SC) Supreme Court authority on proper multiplier and related principles for certain age-groups. The court relied on this decision (with others) to adopt a multiplier of 15 for persons aged between 20 and 30 for recomputation.
Urmilla Pandey v. Khalil Ahmad, 1994 ACJ 805 (SC) Supreme Court decision corroborating multiplier guidance and heads of compensation (including/heads for consortium and estate). Used along with Swaranlata and Susamma Thomas to guide recalculation of compensation (multiplier, consortium/estate allowances, and treatment of lump-sum deductions).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through the following analytical steps, strictly as stated in the opinion:

  1. Examination of evidence on the manner in which the victims were carried:
    • The vehicle owner (PW 1) denied specific knowledge of the capacity in which the victims were carried but admitted the driver employed labourers to transport stones.
    • The injured claimant Deo Pal (PW 4) admitted he and the deceased were employed by one Baba Thekedar at the mines, stated they were carried by the truck after finishing the day's work, and that no fare was charged (i.e., they were given a lift while employed as labourers).
    • Occupant Daya Ram (PW 5) corroborated that the victims were stone-cutters employed at the quarry and not engaged in loading/unloading activities; he placed the time of the accident between 4 and 5 a.m.
  2. Construction of the insurance policy in light of statutory purpose:
    • The court emphasized that in construing the policy, regard must be had to the nature of truck transport business and the statutory purpose of the Motor Vehicles Act — to give adequate relief to victims of motor accidents.
    • The policy admittedly covered the risk of two drivers, one cleaner and three other persons (maximum six persons). The court rejected a narrow construction that would limit coverage only to labourers employed directly by the insured vehicle-owner.
    • The court preferred a construction that effectuates the intent of the Act and provides relief to victims, holding that labourers employed by the hirer but carried in the course of transport business are covered.
  3. Application of facts to legal construction:
    • The driver chose not to appear (remained ex parte). The owner did not contend that the driver lacked authority to engage labourers or to carry labourers during the transport business.
    • Given the testimony and the accepted realities of truck transport (including that the owner left it to the driver to employ available labourers), the court held that the insurer could not be absolved solely because victims were not directly employed by the insured.
    • Consequently the Tribunal's finding absolving the insurer was set aside insofar as it absolved the insurer; the insurer is held jointly liable with the insured owner and driver.
  4. On the contention of carrying persons in excess of permissible number under the Motor Vehicles Act and Rules:
    • The court observed that no specific plea was raised before the Tribunal and no evidence was led to support an overloading plea. Because it was neither pleaded nor proved and was raised first time on appeal, the court rejected this ground to deny insurer liability.
  5. Recalculation of compensation for the death cases:
    • The court noted legislative change: Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 fixed minimum 'no fault' compensation for death at Rs. 50,000, but the present case arose under the 1939 Act where the minimum was Rs. 15,000. The claimants had only been paid Rs. 15,000 deposited by the insurer.
    • Relying on Supreme Court guidelines (Susamma Thomas; Swaranlata Das; Urmilla Pandey), the court applied the multiplier method. For persons aged between 20 and 30 the proper multiplier is 15; separate amounts are appropriate for loss of consortium/estate; deduction for lump sum payments is disapproved.
    • The court recalculated annual dependency: assuming Rs. 25 per day for 20 days a month = Rs. 500/month = Rs. 6,000/year, with 2/3rds taken as dependency = Rs. 4,000/year. Multiplying by 15 yields Rs. 60,000 as the base compensation for death. Adding a minimum of Rs. 5,000 for loss of consortium/estate gives Rs. 65,000 total for each death case.
  6. On the injured claimant (Deo Pal):
    • The court found no justification to enhance the award of Rs. 12,000. Deo Pal did not prove physical disability or reduction in earning capacity; the Tribunal observed no deformity or physical disability in court and noted the claimant had been almost fully cured after treatment.
    • Consequently the appellate court declined to enhance the award for Deo Pal.
  7. Relief and directions:
    • The court set aside the portion of the Tribunal's award that absolved the insurance company and held that compensation awarded shall be paid jointly and severally by owner, driver and insurer.
    • In the two death appeals compensation in each case was enhanced from Rs. 28,000 to Rs. 65,000. Interest at 12% per annum is payable on unpaid amounts from the date of application to the Tribunal until payment.
    • Distribution directions: 50% of the amount deposited to be paid to the widow in each death case; the remaining amount to be deposited in fixed deposits in a scheduled bank to be made payable to the children, disbursable on proper application/needs of the children in accordance with the directions in Susamma Thomas.
    • The appeal by the injured claimant (M.A. No. 144 of 1989) was dismissed.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeals are partly allowed to the extent of setting aside the Claims Tribunal's absolution of the insurance company and enhancing compensation in the two death appeals; the appeal by the injured claimant is dismissed.

Consequences and direct effects on the parties (as ordered by the court):

  • The insurance company is held jointly and severally liable with the owner and driver to pay the compensation awarded in the death cases.
  • Compensation in each of the two death appeals is enhanced from Rs. 28,000 to Rs. 65,000.
  • Interest at 12% per annum is payable on unpaid amounts from the date of the application to the Tribunal until payment.
  • Payment directions: 50% of the compensation to be paid to the widow; the balance to be placed in fixed deposit for the children, with disbursements governed by the directions in Susamma Thomas.
  • The injured claimant's appeal is dismissed and he receives no enhancement of the award.
  • No order as to costs was made in all the appeals.

Broader legal implications: The judgment applies and follows existing authorities and statutory principles (as cited) to construe insurance policy terms broadly in favour of victim relief in the truck transport context. The opinion does not purport to announce a novel precedent beyond its application of cited authority and statutory provisions.

    Somti Bai And Others v. Mishri Lal Chhoudhary And Others

    JUDGMENT D.M. Dharmadhikari, J.

    1. A common order is being passed in this appeal, Misc. Appeal No. 142 of 1989, and in appeals, Misc. Appeal Nos. 143 and 144, both of 1989, all preferred by the claimants against the award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Shivpuri, passed on 25.9.1989 in relation to an accident to truck No. MPW 4832.

    2. Facts not in dispute are-that truck No. MPW 4832 while carrying in its body labourers overturned on 5.4.1984 some time in the midnight in which two labourers, by name Hotam and Harvilas, died and the third Deo Pal suffered injuries resulting in fractures of his bones. The Claims Tribunal awarded to the claimants of the deceased in each case a compensation in the sum of Rs. 28,000/- and a sum of Rs. 12,000/- to the injured labourer, Deo Pal. The Claims Tribunal held only owner and driver of the vehicle jointly and severally liable for payment of compensation. The Tribunal totally absolved the insurance company from any liability by holding that the three above-named victims of the accident were not employed on the truck by the owner of the vehicle. They were labourers of the mine-owner and were carried in the truck as gratuitous passengers. The Tribunal directed refund of compensation paid by the insurance company towards 'no fault' liability, and the said amount was directed to be reimbursed to the insurance company by the owner and driver of the vehicle.

    3. The learned counsel, Mr. N.D. Singhal, appearing in all the three cases for the appellants, made strenuous efforts to assail the award of the Tribunal. First, it is urged that the Tribunal erred in completely absolving the insurance company from any liability. The finding recorded by the Tribunal that the three persons were gratuitous passengers has been questioned on several grounds. The oral evidence on record led by the claimants and owner of the vehicle were read in detail to contend that the three persons had boarded the truck as labourers on duty and they could not be termed as gratuitous passengers to absolve the insurance company completely from the liability. Alternatively, it is argued on behalf of the claimants that whatever may be the capacity in which the labourers boarded the truck, involved in the accident, it is not open to the insurance company to deny its liability on any ground not available to it under the provisions of Section 96 of the Motor Vehicles Act. Strong reliance is placed on a Division Bench decision of Indore Bench of this court in Patharibai Karansingh v. Firm Lalji Shankarlal 1985 ACJ 526 (MP), Harishankar Tiwari v. Jagru 1987 ACJ 1 (MP), Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan 1987 ACJ 411 (SC) and Bhagwan Das v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. 1991 ACJ 1137 (MP).

    4. Mr. B.N. Malhotra, learned counsel who appeared for the insurance company, reread the oral evidence on record and argued emphatically that the Tribunal was right in holding that the three persons were given a lift on the truck as they were returning after completing their job of stone-cutting from the stone-quarry where they were employed by the owner of the mine. It is argued on behalf of the insurance company that under the express terms of the policy the three labourers having not been employed by the owner of the vehicle, i.e., the insured, for any work of loading or unloading, their risk was not at all covered. On behalf of the insurance company heavy reliance is placed on the following express terms contained in the policy of insurance, which are reproduced hereinunder:

    Limitations as to use:

    6. On the controversial issue of the capacity and the manner in which the three victims of the accident boarded the truck, the best evidence available is of the owner of the vehicle, Mishri Lal Chhoudhary and one of the injured claimants, Deo Pal. The owner of the vehicle examined as PW 1 denies any knowledge of the capacity and the manner in which the three victims were carried in the truck. In the cross-examination, however, he admits that the driver of the truck used to transport stones in the truck and for that purpose the labourers were employed by the driver. The injured victim Deo Pal has been examined as PW 4. In para 5 of his statement in cross-examination he admits that he and the deceased Hotam and Harvilas were employed by one Baba Thekedar at the mines. In his statement-in-chief he states that the driver of truck had carried them to the mine as labourers. They were returning after the day's work from the mines in the truck in which the stones were also loaded. In para 7 in his cross-examination he states that they were given lift in the truck being employed as labourers and no fare was charged from them. The other witness, who was also the occupant of the truck, is Daya Ram, PW 5. He also corroborates in material part the version of Deo Pal, PW 4. In para 4 he admits that the three victims of the accident were stone-cutters and they were not doing the work of loading or unloading of stones. In para 5 in his cross-examination he states that on the date of the incident they were brought to the mines of quarry owners for discharging duties as labourers. In para 5 of his statement in cross-examination he states that on the fateful day after loading the truck with stones they had proceeded sometime in the midnight and the accident took place somewhere in the early hours of morning between 4 and 5 a.m.

    7. The question before us is whether in the state of above evidence the insurance company could be made liable for the death of the two labourers and for the injuries to the third when none of them was directly employed by the owner of the vehicle. We have also to consider and construe the terms of the policy of the insurance quoted above, to determine whether the insurance company can be held jointly liable with the insured and the driver of the vehicle. In construing the policy of the insurance due regard has to be given to the nature of the transport business by trucks and the purpose for which the insurance cover is statutorily provided in the Motor Vehicles Act. As has come in the evidence on record of the case that truck was employed in transporting cut-stones from the quarry or mines of different contractors. The truck owner had left it to the discretion and authority of the driver to employ the available labourers for the purpose. The three victims of the accident were labourers and were employed at the mines. On the fateful day they boarded the truck with stones and were returning from the mines after their day's work. The insurance policy admittedly covers the risk of two drivers, one cleaner and three other persons, maximum six persons. Can it be held from the terms of the policy and the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act that only the risk of the labourers employed by the insured was covered by the terms of the policy? The terms of insurance policy have to be reasonably construed keeping in view the provisions of insurance in Motor Vehicles Act and the nature of transport business. A construction on the terms of the policy which effectuates the intention of law of giving adequate relief to the victims of motor accidents has to be preferred to any other construction which would defeat the purposes of the Act. In transport business by truck it is many times necessary to carry labourers with the goods. The labourers are sometimes employed directly by the truck-owners and sometimes they were employed by the hirer of the truck. Both categories of labourers should be deemed to be covered by the insurance cover. Any other interpretation would not fulfil the aim and intent of the Act. We are supported in our view by the Division Bench decision of Indore Bench of this court in the case of Patharibai Karansingh v. Firm Lalji Shankarlal 1985 ACJ 526 (MP) and a Full Bench decision of this court in Harishanker Tiwari v. Jagru 1987 ACJ 1 (MP). The contentions advanced on behalf of the insurance company cannot be accepted that the terms of the policy cover risk of the labourers employed directly by the owner of the vehicle on the truck and not of labourers employed by the hirer of the truck. The driver in this case has chosen to remain ex pane and has not entered the witness-box. The owner of the vehicle has not taken a stand that the driver was not authorised to engage labourers or carry labourers in the course of the transport business of the owner. The labourers although engaged by hirer of the vehicle, but having been carried in the truck in the course of the transport business can claim reimbursement of the compensation awarded against the insured from the insurer under the terms of the policy. The award of the Claims Tribunal to the extent that it completely absolved the insurance company from the liability towards compensation, therefore, deserves to be set aside. We accordingly set it aside partly and hold that the insurance company would be jointly liable to pay compensation with the insured and the driver of the vehicle for the accident.

    8. The other argument advanced on behalf of the insurance company is that the truck was carrying persons more in number than permissible under the Motor Vehicles Act and the Rules framed thereunder. No specific plea was raised in that behalf before the Tribunal and no evidence was led in support of the said plea. It was neither pleaded nor proved that due to the breach of the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act and the Rules, the insurance company could deny its liability. The above ground urged for the first time in this appeal, therefore, could not be accepted.

    9. The learned counsel for the claimants seeks enhancement of the amount of compensation awarded in the two cases concerning deaths and in the third case for the injuries caused. We have perused the relevant part of the award of the Claims Tribunal on the question of determination of quantum of compensation payable to the dependants of the deceased. In the case of deceased Hotam, the learned Member of Claims Tribunal determined the total amount of compensation at Rs. 28,000/-. Deceased Hotam was aged 28 years and found to be earning about Rs. 25/- to Rs. 30/- per day. On the above basis his annual income (Sic. dependency) was determined at Rs. 2,000/- and taking a multiplier of 15, a sum of Rs. 30,000/- was arrived at being the total compensation payable. From the above sum Rs. 5,000/- were deducted for lump sum payment. Thus, only Rs. 25,000/- were held payable for the death. In addition to the above, Rs. 2,000/- were awarded for loss of consortium to the widow and a total sum of Rs. 1,000/- awarded to the children. Thus, in all a sum of Rs. 28,000/- was awarded. In the similar manner the same amount of compensation was determined for the death of Harvilas. The injured claimant, Deo Pal, was awarded a total sum of Rs. 12,000/- for the injuries sustained by him. In doing so, it was held that he was earning Rs. 25/- per day and thus he was able to save about Rs. 2,000/- per annum. Because of the injuries caused to him his loss of earning capacity was held to have been reduced approximately to 25 per cent. Thus, determining loss of his income at Rs. 500/- per annum and taking a multiplier of 20 a sum of Rs. 10,000 was determined as compensation for future loss of earnings. For pain and suffering he was awarded a sum of Rs. 1,000/- and Rs. 1,000/- were awarded for medical expenses. Thus, in all a sum of Rs. 12,000 was awarded to the claimants who had suffered injuries in that accident.

    10. In our opinion, the amount of compensation determined for death in the two cases has to be re-computed in view of the legislative changes and the latest decisions of the Supreme Court. In Motor Vehicles Act of 1988 a minimum compensation fixed for death, irrespective of no fault of the driver of the vehicle, is Rs. 50,000/-. It is true that the present case is covered by the Act of 1939 and at that time the minimum no fault compensation for death was Rs. 15,000/-. Against the awarded amount by the Claims Tribunal the claimants have not been paid anything more than Rs. 15,000/- deposited by the insurance company towards 'no fault' liability. The present claimants are thus suffering because they have not been fully paid the amount of compensation awarded by the Tribunal. The provision contained in the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 fixing Rs. 50,000 as the minimum amount of 'no fault' compensation for death can, therefore, be taken aid of for computation of compensation based on fault liability.

    11. The leading case of the Supreme Court in General Manager, Kerala State Road Transport Corporation v. Susamma Thomas 1994 ACJ 1 (SC), contains the guidelines to be followed by all Claims Tribunals in the matter of computation of compensation in motor accidents. The multiplier method is upheld as the appropriate method for calculating just compensation. In the subsequent decisions of the Supreme Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaranlata Das 1993 ACJ 748 (SC) and Urmilla Pandey v. Khalil Ahmad 1994 ACJ 805 (SC), for the age between 20 and 30 the proper multiplier indicated is of 15. A separate amount is to be awarded under the head of loss of consortium and loss of estate between Rs. 5,000/- and Rs. 10,000/-. Deduction for lump sum payment has been disapproved by the Supreme Court. In cases, where a proper multiplier is taken and the amount awarded remains unpaid for a long period of time deduction for lump sum payment cannot be upheld.

    12. Taking aid of the decisions of the Supreme Court (supra) we proceed to recalculate the amount of compensation payable in the present two cases of deaths. Admittedly, both were labourers and daily wage-earners. The minimum wage fixed under the Minimum Wages Act is above Rs. 30/-. Considering the uncertainty that they might not have got work every day it can be safely assumed that in a month they would have definitely worked at least for 20 days. At the rate of Rs. 25/- per day for 20 days in a month they would earn Rs. 500/- per month, i.e., Rs. 6,000/- per year. It can be assumed that about 2/3rd of the income would have been spent on the dependants. The annual dependency would, therefore, come to Rs. 4,000/-. Multiplying the same by 15, the amount of compensation payable to each of the claimants for death would come to Rs. 60,000/-. A sum of Rs. 5,000/- minimum is payable towards the loss of consortium and estate, all inclusive. Thus, a total amount of Rs. 65,000/- as compensation should have been awarded by the Claims Tribunal to the claimants in each case of death in the accident in the two cases.

    13. So far as the injured claimant, Deo Pal, is concerned, we do not find any justification to grant any enhancement. The claimant has not proved that he has been physically disabled from working as a labourer. The Tribunal had seen the claimant in the witness-box and has also recorded that no deformity or physical disability was seen by the learned Member of the Tribunal while he was walking in the court. It has also not been proved by him that his earning capacity has been reduced as a result of the accident. It appears that for the injuries suffered by him he took medical treatment and was almost fully cured. The learned counsel on his behalf cited a few unreported decisions of this court to claim a sum of Rs. 25,000 in all towards general damages and special damages. In the instant case, the injured claimant has failed to prove the extent of his physical disability and loss of earnings to him. We do not consider that any case is made out for enhancing the amount of compensation awarded to him.

    14. In view of the discussion aforesaid in consequence we partly allow the appeal, M.A. No. 142 of 1989 (Somti Bai v. Mishri Lal Chhoudhary) and M.A. No. 143 of 1989 (Kashumal v. Mishri Lal Chhoudhary) to the extent of enhancing the amount of compensation and setting aside the avvord of the Claims Tribunal absolving the insurance company from the liability to pay compensation. Instead, we direct that the compensation awarded by us shall be paid jointly and severally by all the respondents, i.e., the owner, driver and the insurance company. In the above-mentioned two appeals filed by the claimants for death, the amount of compensation in each appeal is enhanced from Rs. 28,000/- to Rs. 65,000/-. On the unpaid amount of compensation the claimants shall be paid interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum from the date of application to the Tribunal till payment. Out of the compensation so deposited 50 per cent of the amount be paid to the widow in each of the two cases of death and the remaining amount of compensation is directed to be deposited through Claims Tribunal in the fixed deposits in a scheduled bank, to be made payable to the children of the deceased in each of the cases. On demand made by them or on their behalf for their requirements the amount in deposit shall be disbursed on a proper application and for proper needs of the claimants themselves or through their guardians and in disbursing of that fixed deposit amount the Tribunal shall be guided by the penultimate directions given by the Supreme Court in Susamma Thomas' case 1994 ACJ 1 (SC).

    15. The appeal filed by the injured claimant, Deo Pal, M.A. No. 144 of 1989 is dismissed.

    16. In the circumstances, in all the appeals there shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Somti Bai And Others v. Mishri Lal Chhoudhary And Others
    (Mar 7, 1995)