AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Non-Clinical Courses) in Medical College of M.P. Rules, 1984."(hereinafter referred to as 1984 Rules'). Under Rule 9.5.(b),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Non-Clinical Courses) in Medical College of M.P. Rules, 1984."(hereinafter referred to as 1984 Rules'). Under Rule 9.5.(b),
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Two petitioners, both employed as Assistant Surgeons in the service of the State Government, sought admission to postgraduate (M.D./M.S.) courses in the State's medical colleges under the "M. P. Selection to Post-Graduation Courses (Clinical, Para-Clinical and Non-Clinical Courses) in Medical College of M.P. Rules, 1984" (the "1984 Rules"). Rule 9.5(b) of those rules provided for weightages of marks for certain extra-curricular activities, including rural service in scheduled areas and conducting sterilization operations, which would be added to the candidates' MBBS examination marks for seats reserved under the Assistant Surgeon's quota.

The petitioners contended that, if those weightages were applied to their MBBS marks, they would have a fair chance of selection. Their grievance was that the respondent authorities amended the 1984 Rules by a notification dated 14-2-1990 deleting Rules 8.5 and 9.5, thereby withdrawing the weightages and, according to the petitioners, depriving them of a chance at admission.

The order in the present petition also addresses Misc. Petition No. 531 of 1991 (Dr. Sunil Kumar Gupta v. State of Madhya Pradesh) because common questions of fact and law arise.

Relevant procedural context in prior litigation: A Division Bench at the principal seat (Dr. Asha Pratibha Khalkho) had earlier upheld the validity of weightages; an Indore Bench Division (Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar Doshi) later declared the weightages invalid and directed amendment within three years while permitting interim operation; a Special Leave Petition to the Supreme Court against the Indore Bench's direction was dismissed after the State conceded it would not operate the weightages even during the three-year period, and the State thereafter issued the 14-2-1990 notification deleting the weightage provisions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners can claim the benefit of the weightages of marks provided by the 1984 Rules after those provisions were struck down and deleted by the State following judicial rulings and a Supreme Court order dismissing a Special Leave Petition by way of the State's concession.
  2. Whether the ostensibly conflicting Division Bench decisions of this Court (one upholding the weightages and another declaring them invalid) require reference to a larger Bench for resolution.
  3. Whether the doctrine of estoppel can be invoked against the State to retain the benefit of weightages where petitioners say they acted to their detriment relying on the 1984 Rules.
  4. Whether the Division Bench's direction allowing weightages to operate for a period of three years was a judgment in rem that binds persons not parties to that case (i.e., whether the benefit of three years' continued operation of the old rules must be given to all similarly placed doctors).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • If the weightages under the 1984 Rules are applied to their MBBS marks, the petitioners have a fair chance of selection to postgraduate courses.
  • There is an alleged conflict between two Division Bench decisions of this Court — the principal seat's decision (Dr. Asha Pratibha Khalkho) upholding weightages and the Indore Bench's decision (Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar Doshi) invalidating them — and this conflict should be resolved by a larger Bench.
  • The Indore Bench decision did not receive the "seal of approval" of the Supreme Court because the S.L.P. was dismissed on a concession by the State rather than on the merits; therefore the Indore Bench decision should not be treated as finally authoritative.
  • The doctrine of estoppel applies: petitioners undertook rural service and sterilization operations in reliance on the 1984 Rules to obtain weightages and thereby altered their position to their detriment; the State should be estopped from withdrawing those weightages.
  • The three-year period permitted by the Division Bench (I) was a benefit intended for all doctors in that category (a judgment in rem), and the State could not, by conceding before the Supreme Court, withdraw that benefit to similarly placed doctors.

Respondent / State and Medical Authorities' Arguments

  • The State and medical authorities supported the deletion of the weightage provisions, asserting that effect was given to the Supreme Court's decision in Dr. Dinesh Kumar and the Division Bench (I) decision in Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar Doshi, thereby admitting only on academic merit.
  • The State argued that no exception can be taken to denial of weightages because the rules had been declared invalid and the State implemented that outcome by amending the rules.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dr. Asha Pratibha Khalkho v. State of M.P., 1989 MPU 140 (Division Bench) Upheld validity of rules providing weightages for extra-curricular activities (including rural service and sterilization) where the proportion of such weightages was small (noted as 1.7%). The opinion notes this decision but distinguishes it from the present matter on the basis that the Supreme Court authority (Dr. Dinesh Kumar) governs the issue; the Court did not adopt this decision as dispositive in the present petitions.
Dr. Dinesh Kumar v. Motilal Nehru Medical College, Allahabad, AIR 1986 SC 1877 : 1987 All LJ 189 (cited also as (1987) 4 SCR 459) Held that selection for admission (especially on an All India basis) should be based solely on merit; weightage for rural service (and similar factors) is not appropriate for admission to postgraduate courses. The Court treated this Supreme Court decision as controlling: it adopted the principle that weightages for rural service and sterilization are irrelevant to judging merit for postgraduate admissions and applied that reasoning to seats available to the State or institution.
Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar Doshi v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1990 MP 171 (Indore Bench, Division Bench) Declared provisions granting weightages for extra-curricular activities invalid as irrelevant to selecting meritorious candidates for postgraduate courses; directed amendment and allowed existing rules to operate for up to three years. The opinion treats this decision as having declared the weightages invalid and as the basis for the State's eventual concession and deletion of the weightage provisions; the Court relied on this decision and its compatibility with the Supreme Court's reasoning.
Order of the Supreme Court in S.L.P. No. 1050/90 dated 22-2-1990 (dismissal) The S.L.P. was dismissed after the State's counsel conceded that the State would not operate the weightages during the three-year period and that admissions during that period would be on academic merit and institution-wise. The Court relied on the contents of this order to demonstrate that the State voluntarily conceded non-operation of weightages, and that the S.L.P.'s dismissal was based on that concession rather than a ruling on merits; this supported the State's deletion of weightage provisions by notification dated 14-2-1990.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by examining relevant precedent and the factual sequence of events, and then applied legal principles to the petitioners' claims:

  1. Precedent analysis: The Court held that the Supreme Court decision in Dr. Dinesh Kumar is determinative. The Supreme Court's observations disapproved grant of weightage for rural service and held that selection to postgraduate medical education must be based on merit. The Court read those observations as applying to State and institutional seats as well, not only to All India seats.
  2. Rejection of the distinction asserted by petitioners: Petitioners attempted to distinguish Dinesh Kumar on the ground that its observations were limited to All India seats and not to State quotas (e.g., Assistant Surgeons' quota). The Court rejected that argument, stating the same parity of reasoning applies and that an incentive for rural service or sterilization has no obvious connection to assessing a candidate's academic merit for higher medical education.
  3. Regarding the conflict between Division Bench decisions: The Court found no need to refer the matter to a larger Bench. It concluded that the matter was concluded against the petitioners by the Supreme Court decision in Dr. Dinesh Kumar and that the earlier Division Bench (Asha Pratibha Khalkho) decision did not control the outcome in light of higher authority.
  4. On estoppel: The Court held that estoppel — an equitable doctrine — could not be invoked against the State in these circumstances. The admission rules were not statutory and could be amended; the deletion of weightages resulted from the judicial decision and the State's voluntary concession before the Supreme Court. Accordingly, the State committed no error by volunteering to delete the weightage provisions, and the petitioners could not claim estoppel against the State.
  5. On the claim that the three-year direction was a judgment in rem: The Court read the Division Bench (Penil Doshi) directions as fixing an outer limit (three years) for amendment, not as prohibiting the State from withdrawing weightages earlier. It held that the direction benefited the parties to that case and did not bind non-parties; when the State made a concession in the Supreme Court, non-parties could not insist on continued operation of the old rules for three years.
  6. Conclusion of the analysis: Applying the foregoing legal principles and precedents, the Court concluded that the petitioners could not be granted the benefit of weightages after the rules were struck down and deleted, and that none of the petitioners' contentions had sufficient force to require relief.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The petitions are dismissed. The Court emphasized that the petitioners cannot be granted the benefit of weightages of marks after those provisions were declared invalid and deleted; accordingly, the challenge fails.

DISPOSED OF

Implications and consequences:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioners receive no relief; the deletion of weightages stands and they will not be given the weightage marks for admission. The petitions were dismissed as devoid of merit.
  • Costs and ancillary orders: The Court made no order as to costs. Any security amount deposited by the petitioners is to be refunded.
  • Broader legal implication: The opinion relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Dr. Dinesh Kumar to treat weightages for rural service and sterilization as irrelevant to merit-based selection for postgraduate medical education. The Court did not purport to create a new precedent beyond applying existing higher-court authority; the decision's direct effect is the denial of weightages in the particular admissions context at issue.

    Rajesh Kumar Singhai (Dr.) v. State Of Madhya Pradesh And Others

    1. The order passed in this petition shall also decide Misc. Petition No. 531 of 1991 (Dr. Sunil Kumar Gupta v. State of Madhya Pradesh), in which common questions of fact and law arise.

    2. The two petitioners, in the petitions before us are employed as Assistant Surgeons in the services of the State Government. They seek admission to post-graduate (M.D./ M.S.) courses in the Medical Colleges of the State in accordance with the terms and conditions contained in the admission rules called

    "M. P. Selection to Post-Graduation Courses (Clinical, Para-Clinical and Non-Clinical Courses) in Medical College of M.P. Rules, 1984."
    (hereinafter referred to as 1984 Rules'). Under Rule 9.5.(b), in addition to the total marks obtained by the candidates in the University examination of M.B.B.S., for seats available for admission against Assistant Surgeon's quota, weightages of marks are provided, amongst other extra curricular activities, for doing rural service in the scheduled areas and for conducting sterilization operations.

    3. According to the petitioners, if these weightages of marks are added in accordance with 1984 Rules to the marks obtained by them in M.B.B.S. examinations, they have a fair chance of selection for admission to the post-graduate courses.

    4. The grievance of the petitioners is that the respondent authorities by making amendment to the 1984 Rules, vide notification dated 14-2-1990 (Annexure P-6) deleted Rules 8.5 and 9.5 which provided weightages of marks for extra curricular activities, rural service as also for sterilization operations. According to the petitioners, since under the amended rules the weightages of marks on various extra curricular activities, rural services and sterilization operations are being withdrawn, the petitioners have lost chance of their selection to the post-graduate-courses.

    5. Before discussing the contentions raised by the learned counsel appearing for the two petitioners, it is necessary to consider a few decisions of this Court on the question of validity of the admission rules containing the provisions for weightages of marks for extra curricular activities. A Division Bench of this Court in the case of Dr. Asha Pratibha Khalkho v. State of M.P., 1989 MPU 140, upheld that validity of the rules providing for weightages of marks for extra curricular activities when the same were challenged by the doctors working in hospitals set up in urban areas under the E.S.I. Act. The contention of these doctors working in E.S.I. hospitals was that giving of such weightages for rural service and sterilization operations deprives them a fair chance of admission visa-vis Assistant Surgeon in the State services because the doctors working in E.S.I, hospitals, by virtue of their peculiar conditions of servjce, have no chance or occasion either to work in rural areas or to undertake sterilization operations. The Division Bench in the case of Dr. Asha Pratibha Khalho (supra) upheld the weightages of marks on the above factors holding that proportion of such marks for weightages to the total marks works out only to 1.7%, that is much below 15% as was the matter before the Supreme Court in the case of Dr. Dinesh Kumar v. Motilal Nehru Medical College, Allahabad, AIR 1986 SC 1877 : 1987 All LJ 189. The Division Bench distinguished the case of Dr. Dinesh Kumar (supra) holding that weightages of marks up to 1.7% do not vitiate the selections for admission.

    6. The 1984 Rules containing weightages of marks for second time, came for consideration when their validity was attacked in the case of Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar Doshi v. State of MadhyaPradesh, AIR 1990 MP 171, Indore Bench. The Division Bench in the above case, placing reliance on the decision in the case of Dr. Dinesh Kumar (supra) declared the provisions granting weightages of marks for extra curricular activities as invalid being an irrelevant consideration for selecting best meritorious candidates for postgraduate courses. The Division Bench (I) held that all factors, other than the academic attainments as reflected from the marks obtained in M.B.B.S. examination are irrelevant factors for judging the merit of the candidates. While disposing of the petition, the Division Bench (I), however made the following directions:--

    "81. The State would do well to suitably amend the rules so as to restore merit rather than preference, be it institutional or any other in the light of the various decisions of the Supreme Court, as discussed above. The Supreme Court by its order dated 25-9-1987, in Dr. Dinesh Kumar v. Motilal Nehru Medical College, (1987) 4 SCR 459, has pronounced the necessity of having uniform practice to be evolved in the matter of admissions to P. G. Courses. The respondents have also relied upon this judgment in their return. There is no reason as to why at the State level a uniform policy as suggested by the Medical Council of India, be not evolved so as to discourage preference and restore the merit and merit alone in the matter of admissions. period of three years from now would, to our mind, be more than enough for switching over to such a practice. It would also not cause any inconvenience to the students aspiring for admission to P.G. Courses. It is, however, made clear that while following the existing pattern for selection of students from various channels, the State shall see to it that merit is not sacrificed while giving preference and weightages on considerations held to be untenable and illegal by the Supreme Court.

    82. It is made clear that candidates already found eligible for admission to P. G. Courses for the current sessions and those candidates who may be found eligible for admission to P.G. Courses for the period of further three years, shall not be affected in any way by this order and the delay if any, caused due to the stay order passed by this Court shall not come in the way of admission or attendance of such successful candidates in the current session of P. G. Courses."

    (Underlined by us)

    7. The decision containing the above directions given by the Division Bench (I) of this Court in the case of Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar Doshi was challenged by the petitioner in that case, in the Supreme Court by Special Leave Petition. The full details of the grounds taken in the S.L.P. are not before us. Learned counsel appearing for the State pointed out that the challenge was to the directions made by the Division Bench (II) for continuing the operation of the weightages in 1984 Rules for a further period of three years, or till the amendment of Rules. The S.L.P. in the Supreme Court was dismissed on the short ground that the counsel appearing for the State of M. P. made a statement before the Supreme Court that although the High Court had permitted operation of the old Rules for a period of three years, the State Government had taken a decision not to operate the rules of weightages even during the above period. The concession made was that even for the future admissions, the Rule of weightages will not be given effect to and the admissions would be given strictly on merits. It is better to reproduce the contents of the order passed by the Supreme Court in S.L.P. No. 1050/90 dated 22-2-1990 as under, because there is borne controversy between the parties regarding the real effect of the order of the Supreme Court:--

    "The Special Leave Petition is dismissed. Mr. Datar appearing for the State of M. P. very fairly states that although the old rules have been permitted to operate by the High Court for a period of three years, the State Government shall not extend weightage to any of the categories during this period and separate reservation/quota to the children of the IAS/Government Officers, shall also be not operated during this period. He further states that the admissions will continue to be made during this period of three years under the old rules on the basis of academic merit and institutionwise."

    8. The stand taken before us on behalf of the State, by Shri P.G. Naik, learned Dy. Advocate General is that since the Division Bench (I) of this Court had declared the Rules of weightages invalid, the State in all fairness immediately conceded to exclude the factor of weightages from the Rules, even for the interim period of three years, which was given as an outer limit for removing the invalid part of weightages from the Rules. As a result of the Division Bench (I) decision as approved by the Supreme Court in the aforesaid S.L.P. the State Government issued an order on 14-2-1990 (Annexure P-6), deleting from the Rules the provisions granting weightages of marks for extra curricular activities, for rural services and sterilization operations.

    9. Shri P.P. Naolekar, learned counsel appearing for Dr. Rajesh Kumar Singhai in this petition mainly raised two contentions. Firstly, it was contended that the Division Bench (I) in the case of Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar Doshi (supra) did not notice the decision of the Division Bench of this Court at the principal seat, in the case of Dr. Asha Pratibha Khalikho (supra), in which rules of weightages were upheld. There is thus conflict in the two Division Bench decisions of this Court which needs to be resolved by a larger Bench of this Court. In this respect it is submitted that the Indore Bench decision in the case of Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar Doshi (supra) cannot be hold to have received the seal of approval of the Supreme Court because the S.L.P. was dismissed not on merits, but on the basis of a concession made by the State of Madhya Pradesh volunteering to amend the rules by deleting the provisions of weightages even without waiting for a grace period of three years, allowed by the High Court.

    10. The second contention on behalf 6f the petitioners is that principle of estoppel can appropriately be applied against the State and its authorities in denying the benefit of weightages of marks. The argument is that an Assistant Surgeon acquires eligibility for post-graduate admission only on completion of five years of service. At the time, the petitioners commenced service, 1984 Rules containing weightages were in force. Acting on that representation contained in the Rules, the petitioners agreed to go for rural service and devoted their time for sterilization operations only to get the benefit of weightages of marks for seeking admission to post-graduate courses. The petitioners thus have acted to their detriment on the representation contained in the Rules. The authorities giving admission are, therefore, estopped from changing the rules so as to take away the weightages and deny admission.

    11. Shri H. B. Agarwal, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner Dr. Sunil Kumar Gupta in M.P. No. 531/91 raised an additional ground in support of his petition. His argument is that the Division Bench (I) had granted three years period as a limit for giving benefit of 1984 Rules containing the weight-ages. This was a benefit, granted not only to the respondents in that petition, but to all doctors falling in that category. It was according to him a judgment in rem and, therefore, the State of M.P. before the Supreme Court could not withdraw that benefit to all such categories of doctors by making a concession adverse to their interest. The argument, therefore, is that effect should be given to the directions of the Division Bench (I) by continuing the benefit of the Rule of weightages for a further period of three years from the date of that judgment.

    12. Learned counsel appearing for the State and the Medical authorities supported the action of authorities in amending the rules by deleting the provisions of weightages. Submission is that effect has been given to the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Dr. Dinesh Kumar (supra) and of the Division Bench (I) of this Court in the case of Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar Doshi (supra). No exception can, therefore, be taken to the denial of the weightages of marks to the petitioners.

    13. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submission made by the learned counsel appearing for the parties and have also carefully gone through the decisions of this Court and of the Supreme Court quoted above. We are of the opinion that the petitioners cannot be granted benefit of weightages of marks after the rules of weightages were struck down as invalid by the Division Bench (I) of this Court.

    14. So far as the first contention raised by Shri P. P. Naolekar is concerned, we do not find that the so-called conflict pointed out by him in the Division Bench decision at the principal seat in the case of Dr. Asha Pratibha Khalkho and of Indore Bench in the case of Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar Doshi, needs to be resolved, because in our opinion, the matter stands concluded against the petitioners by the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Dr. Dinesh Kumar (supra). The following observations of the Supreme Court in the case of Dr. Dinesh Kumar (supra) may be seen which are as under:--

    "We are of the view that when selection of candidates is being made for admission on an All India basis, no factor other than merit should be allowed to tilt the balance in favour of a candidate. We must remember that what we are regulating are admissions to Postgraduate Courses and if we want to produce doctors who are M.D. or M.S. particularly Surgeons who are going to operate upon human beings, it is of the utmost importance that the selection should be based on merit. Moreover we are extremely doubtful if a candidate who has rendered three years rural service for the purpose of getting a weightage of 15% would go back to the rural area after he has got M.D. or M.S. degree. We are, therefore, of the view that no weightage should be given to a candidate for rural service rendered by him so far as admission to Post-graduate Courses are concerned. Even if an undetaking is taken from such a candidate that after obtaining M.D. or M.S. Degree he will settle down in a rural area and serve the rural masses, it would in all probabilities serve no useful purpose because in the absence of requisite facilities such as hospital, medical and surgical equipment, nursing etc., it would not be possible for him to give the advantage of his higher medical education to the rural masses and the higher medical education received by him would not be of service to the community."

    15. From careful reading of the above judgment it appears to us that the Supreme Court disapproved in very clear language, the grant of weightages of marks for rural service as a relevant factor for judging merit of the candidates for admission. Learned counsel for the petitioner made an attempt to distinguish the above case of Dr. Dinesh Kumar (supra), stating that the observations should be read as restricted to All India seats. It was argued that for Assistant Surgeons' quota, rendering service in rural areas and conducting sterilization operations, is a relevant factor showing additional experience of the candidate concerned. The above argument is not acceptable. A factor which is found to be irrelevant by the Supreme Court for admission to All India seats on the same parity of reasoning, is also an irrelevant factor for admission to the seats available to the State or the institution concerned. The aim and object of giving such weightages of marks for rural service and sterilization operations is to take services of the incoming doctors in the State service as an incentive for participation in the National Health Programme. Such an incentive, however, has no obvious connection with the merit of the candidate. It is not correct to say that for Assistant Surgeons, experience of rural service is a relevant factor for judging their merits. Under the scheme of the admission Rules, it may be seen that those candidates who are unable to get admission on the basis of their marks in M.B.B.S. immediately after passing their M.B.B.S. examination, have to wait for a period of five years to seek admission in Assistant Surgeons' quota. After five years, their merit for admission is judged not on the basis of their performance in service, but on the basis of their academic attainments. The trend of the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Dr, Dinesh Kumar (supra) is that for super specialities in medical education the only relevant criteria to select the best is to see their academic attainments and nothing else. It is with that view that a certain percentage of seats were directed to be filled on All India basis. That, however, did not mean that institutional seats or seats available to concerned States can be allowed to be filled on various other irrelevant factors such a rural service and conducting of sterilization operations. Incentive in any other form as suggested in the case of Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar Doshi, to lure the candidates for rural services and sterilization operations may be granted by the State, but that cannot be a ground for giving weightage of marks while admitting them to higher medical education.

    16. We are also not impressed by the argument raised on behalf of the petitioners on the ground of estoppel. In our opinion, the principle of estoppel which is an equitable principle cannot be taken aid of by the petitioners. The rules of admission are not statutory in nature and are subject to change and amendment from time to time. The Rules containing weightages of marks came to be deleted as a result oft the decision of the Court and the State committed no error in volunteering before the Supreme Court to delete the Rule of weightage so as to bring the admissions in conformity with the directions of the High Court. The authorities under the State have thus acted on the basis of the directions of the Court and principle of estoppel cannot operate against them in such a situation.

    17. So far as the contention raised by the learned counsel Shri H. B. Agarwal, on behalf of his petitioner is concerned, that also does not appeal to us. Bare perusal of the directions quoted in the case of Dr. Penil Sharad Kumar of the Division Bench (I) would show that three years was fixed the outer limit to amend the rules for removing the weightages. That direction did not prohibit the State from withdrawing the weightages earlier than three years. It was open to the State Government, therefore, to give effect to the directions of the High Court forthwith, when that part containing direction of three years limit was challenged by the petitioner in that case in the Supreme Court. The argument is fallacious that the judgment of the Division Bench (I) was a judgment in rem. The directions and orders made by the Division Bench (I) in that case could benefit only the parties before it and the petitioners who were not the parties to that case can derive no benefit out of it, may be that some of the directions were general in nature. When the matter went up to the Supreme Court, none of the parties present in that case objected to the concession made by the State. The petitioners, therefore, who were not the parties to that petition, even as interveners, cannot be allowed to contend that the rules which were declared invalid should have been allowed to operate for a period of three years, for the candidates waiting for admission in accordance with unamended 1984 Rules.

    18. None of the contentions of the petitioners thus has any force. The petitions are devoid of merit and are hereby dismissed. In the circumstances of the case, however, we make no order as to costs. Amount of security, if deposited, be refunded to the petitioners.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajesh Kumar Singhai (Dr.) v. State Of Madhya Pradesh And Others
    (Jan 18, 1992)