Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The case is a mandamus appeal by the Union of India against a Single Judge's order dated 23 April 2003. An employee of the CISF (No. 801390021 HC/GD R.K. Jha) was charged with two articles of misconduct: (1) a physical scuffle on 5 October 2000 which allegedly resulted in damage to his issued rifle while on duty (Article of Charge No.1); and (2) being a habitual offender by reference to several prior incidents of indiscipline and punishments recorded in service documents (Article of Charge No.2). The disciplinary authority, after investigation and a hearing, found the employee guilty and imposed the penalty of compulsory retirement. The appellate forum upheld that punishment.

The employee filed a writ petition before a Single Judge who, while affirming the finding of guilt, set aside the compulsory retirement penalty, directed the employer to reconsider punishment, ordered reinstatement, and directed payment of 50% of arrear salary from the date of compulsory retirement until reinstatement. The Union of India appealed that order.

While the appeal was pending and without a stay of the Single Judge's order, the employer reconsidered and modified the penalty: instead of compulsory retirement, it imposed reduction of pay to the lowest stage in the Rs. 3200-85-4900 scale for five years with immediate effect, withholding increments during that period and postponing future increments after the period.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Single Judge correctly set aside the disciplinary penalty of compulsory retirement and directed reconsideration despite affirming the finding of guilt.
  2. Whether the employer may lawfully take past misconduct and prior punishments into account when framing charges and imposing punishment for a fresh misconduct.
  3. Whether the employee was entitled to payment of 50% of arrear salary from the date of compulsory retirement until reinstatement, or whether the proper relief was subsistence allowance under Service Rules during the period of deemed suspension.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Union of India) Arguments

  • The appellant supported the original punishment of compulsory retirement and submitted that it was appropriate.
  • The appellant criticized the Single Judge's direction that the employee should receive 50% of arrear salary from the date of compulsory retirement until reinstatement.
  • The appellant contended that the Single Judge's view — that past misconduct could not be taken into consideration in imposing punishment for a fresh misconduct — was inconsistent with Supreme Court authority.
  • The appellant prayed for setting aside the Single Judge's order.

Respondent's (Employee) Arguments

  • The employee's counsel submitted that Service Rules do not permit initiation of disciplinary proceedings based on past misconduct for which punishment has already been imposed, and thus Charge No.2 should not have been taken into account.
  • The employee relied on the Single Judge's finding that past misconduct and consequent punishments could not be considered while imposing punishment for the fresh offence.
  • The employee argued that the employer's subsequent decision to reduce punishment demonstrated the initial compulsory retirement order was wrong and caused unnecessary harassment.
  • The employee supported the Single Judge's direction for payment of 50% of salary from the date of compulsory retirement until reinstatement and urged that this relief not be disturbed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Mysore v. K. Manche Gowda, AIR 1964 SC 506 It is permissible for an employer to take into consideration earlier punishments and earlier misconduct when imposing punishment for a fresh misconduct, provided principles of natural justice and equity are observed by making those facts known to the delinquent employee. The court relied on this principle to hold that framing Charge No.2 (incorporating past misconduct and punishments) was not illegal; the employer could legitimately take past misconduct into account so long as the employee had notice and an opportunity to respond, and therefore the Single Judge's contrary conclusion was rejected.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a step-by-step manner, closely following the record and the intervening actions of the employer:

  1. The disciplinary process: The disciplinary authority investigated, found guilt on the charges (including Charge No.1), and imposed compulsory retirement; the appellate authority upheld that punishment.
  2. Single Judge's order: The Single Judge affirmed the finding of guilt but set aside the compulsory retirement penalty, directed reconsideration of punishment, ordered reinstatement, and awarded 50% of arrear salary from the date of compulsory retirement until reinstatement. The Single Judge's primary rationale (as recorded) was that the employer should not have taken past misconduct and punishments into account in framing charges and determining punishment, because those matters had already been punished and their inclusion prejudged the issue.
  3. Employer's action during the appeal: While the appeal was pending (and without a stay), the employer itself reconsidered the matter in light of the Single Judge's order and reduced the penalty from compulsory retirement to reduction of pay to the lowest stage (Rs. 3200-85-4900) for five years, with denial/postponement of increments as specified.
  4. On reimposition of punishment: The court held that once the employer, on reconsideration of the same materials, has itself reduced the punishment, the earlier penalty of compulsory retirement became unenforceable and the employer should not be permitted to contend that the original compulsory retirement was appropriate. In other words, the employer's reconsideration and modification precluded reimposition of the original penalty in these proceedings.
  5. On the relief of monetary payment: The court reasoned that because the finding of guilt on Charge No.1 stands (affirmed), but the consequential punishment was set aside by the Single Judge, the period from the date of compulsory retirement until the date a fresh order of punishment is passed should be treated as a period of suspension. During that time, the employee is entitled to subsistence allowance as permitted under the Service Rules. Therefore, the court modified the Single Judge's order: instead of directing payment of 50% of arrears, the court awarded subsistence allowance under Service Rules for the suspension period until the fresh order of punishment.
  6. On considering past misconduct: Relying on State of Mysore v. K. Manche Gowda (AIR 1964 SC 506), the court rejected the Single Judge's blanket prohibition on considering past misconduct and prior punishments. The court explained that it is permissible to take past misconduct into account when determining punishment for a fresh offence provided those facts are disclosed to the employee so that he can respond. Given that Charge No.2 was framed to put the employee on notice that past misconduct would be considered for punishment, and that the employee was not thereby prejudiced, framing Charge No.2 was justified.
  7. Limits of the court's adjudication: The court expressly stated it did not examine the propriety of the subsequent punishment (the reduction of pay) imposed by the employer, as that issue lay beyond the writ petition's scope; the employee remains free to challenge that subsequent order before the appropriate forum.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: The appeal is disposed of.

Direct consequences for the parties (as derived from the opinion):

  • The earlier penalty of compulsory retirement is no longer enforceable because the employer itself reconsidered and reduced the punishment; the employer will not be permitted in this appeal to contend that compulsory retirement is the appropriate punishment in the face of its own modification.
  • The Single Judge's direction to pay 50% of arrear salary from the date of compulsory retirement until reinstatement is modified: the employee is entitled to subsistence allowance under the Service Rules for the period of deemed suspension from the date of compulsory retirement until the date of the fresh order of punishment (the employer's subsequent order).
  • Framing Charge No.2 (which recorded past misconducts and prior punishments) and taking those matters into account for consideration of punishment was lawful in the circumstances because those facts were made part of the charge so the employee could respond; the Single Judge's contrary finding is rejected.
  • The court did not rule on the propriety of the employer's subsequent punishment (reduction in pay); the employee may challenge that order before the appropriate forum as provided by law.
  • There will be no order as to costs in the appeal.

The opinion does not purport to lay down any new precedent; it applies existing authority (State of Mysore v. K. Manche Gowda) to the facts and confines its relief to the parties before the court.

    Union Of India & Ors. v. Raj Kumar Jha

    Bhaskar Bhattacharya, J.:— This mandamus appeal is at the instance of Union of India and is directed against the order passed by a learned Single Judge of this Court dated 23rd April, 2003 in a writ application thereby setting aside the order of compulsory retirement imposed upon an employee and directing the employer to reconsider the question of punishment, although, the finding of guilt on the charge levelled against the employee was affirmed.

    2. The employer framed the following charges against the employee:

    Article of Charge No. 1

    “That No. 801390021HC/GD R.K Jha was detailed for ‘B’ shift on 5.10.2000 from 13.00 hrs. to 21.00 hrs. at HBP (L) for security duties with Arms. The said HC/GD scuffled with HC/GD S.N Raju at about 21.05 hrs while handing over the charge of the duty as a result Rifle 7.62 mm (BA) Mark No. 2A Registered No. 42780 issued to him got damaged which tantamount to gross misconduct, most indiscipline and dereliction of duty and thus unbecoming of a good member of the disciplined force like CISF. Hence the charge”.

    Article of Charge No. II

    As per service documents of CISF No. 801390021 HC/GD R.K Jha of CISF Unit FBP Farakka it reveals that he is a habitual offender of indulging in various indiscipline following punishments under CISF Rules, 1969.

    i) OSL w.e.f 13.3.85 to 10.4.85 and awarded the penalty of Censure vide Group Commandant New Delhi USO Part-II No. 279/85 dated 22.7.85

    ii) Misappropriation of Govt. money while working as Dry Canteen incharge at ONGC Nazira and awarded the penalty of ‘Five days pay fine’ vide final order No. V-15015.CISF/SDS/Min-97/398 dated 9-2-97.

    iii) Misbehaviour with senior and awarded the punishment of ‘Withholding of one increment for a period of one year without cumulative effect’ vide final order No. V-15015.CISF/IOC(H)/Disc/98/1295 dated 31/1-4-98.

    iv) Absent from duty post on 20.12.98 and awarded the penalty of ‘four days pay fine’ vide IOC(H) final order No. V-15015.IOC(H)/Disc/35.RKJ/ 99/510 dated 11-3-99.

    v) Left the duty post before completion of duty on 19.2.2000 at IOC(H) main gate and awarded the penalty of ‘Two days pay fine’ vide final order No. V-15015.CISF/IOC(H)/Disc/35.RKJ/2000/1582 dated 19.3.2000

    vi) Sent false and baseless allegation against administration and awarded the punishment of ‘withholding of one increment for a period of one year without cumulative effect’ vide IOC(H)/ final order No. V-15014.CISF/IOC(H)/Disc/35.RKJ/2000/1583 dated 18.3.2000”

    3. The disciplinary authority after completing the investigation and after giving opportunity of hearing to the employee found him guilty of the charges and inflicted a punishment of compulsory retirement.

    4. Being dissatisfied, the employee preferred an appeal before the appellate forum but the said punishment was upheld.

    5. Being dissatisfied with such order, the employee filed the aforesaid writ application which ultimately came up for hearing before the learned Single Judge who although affirmed the finding of guilt recorded by the disciplinary authority as well as the appellate authority, yet, set aside the order of punishment and directed the authority to reconsider the question of punishment. The learned Judge further held that the employee should be reinstated in service and the authority should pay him 50 per cent of the arrear salary from the date of compulsory retirement till the date of reinstatement.

    6. It appears from the order passed by the learned Judge that the reason for setting aside the order of punishment was that according to him, the employer while considering punishment could not taken into consideration the past conducts of the employee for which he had already suffered punishment and according to him, the incidents of misconduct and the consequent punishment upon the petitioner in the past, should not have been incorporated in the chargesheet and thereby the entire issues had been “prejudged and premeditated to make the ground of compulsory retirement as punishment”.

    7. Being dissatisfied, the Union of India, the employer, has preferred the present appeal. As during the pendency of this appeal, there was no stay of operation of order impugned, the employer has reconsidered the matter in terms of the judgment given by the learned Single Judge and has passed fresh order of punishment by modifying the penalty of compulsory retirement from service to that of reduction of pay to the lowest stage in the time scale of pay of Rs. 3200-85-4900 for a period of five years with immediate effect. It has further directed that the employee will not earn increment of pay during the period of reduction and that on the expiry of the said period the reduction will have the effect of postponing his future increments of pay.

    8. Mr. Chattopadhyay, the learned Advocate appearing on behalf of appellant, has not only supported the initial order of punishment of compulsory retirement but also criticized that part of the order of the learned Single Judge by which it was directed that the employee should get 50 per cent of the arrear from the date of compulsory retirement till the date of reinstatement. Mr. Chattopadhyay further submits that the findings of the learned Single Judge that the employer cannot take into consideration past misconducts of employee is also not consistent with the decision of the Supreme Court and he, thus, prays for setting aside the order impugned.

    9. Ms. Sengupta, the learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent-employee, however, has opposed the aforesaid contentions of Mr. Chattopadhyay and has submitted that according to the Service Rules there is no provision for starting disciplinary proceeding on the basis of past misconduct for which already punishment has been given. Ms. Sengupta supports the finding of the learned Single Judge that Charge No. 2 framed herein should not have been taken into consideration and even while imposing punishment, those facts could not be taken note of. Ms. Sengupta contends that from the fact that the employer of its own has decided to reduce the punishment, it is apparent that earlier punishment of compulsory retirement was wrong and therefore, her client has unnecessarily been harassed and consequently, the order of the learned Single Judge of awarding 50 per cent of the salary from the date of compulsory retirement to the date of reinstatement should not be interfered with.

    10. After hearing the learned Counsel for the parties and after going through the materials on record we find that the employer itself having reduced the punishment to that of reduction of scale, the order of compulsory punishment earlier passed is no longer enforceable and therefore, the said punishment cannot be reimposed. Once the employer on the basis of materials on record, itself has decided on reconsideration that the compulsory retirement was too harsh although there was no compulsion upon it not to reimpose the self-same punishment we are of the view that we should not permit the employer to contend that the punishment of compulsory retirement is the appropriate punishment.

    11. As regards direction for payment of 50 per cent of salary, we are of the opinion that once the finding of guilt on the Charge No. 1 has established and that has been also affirmed by this Court, but only the consequent punishment was set aside, in such a case, the employee should be deemed to have been under suspension till the final order of punishment is passed and as such, the employee should be entitled to get subsistence allowance permissible under the Service Rules till the date of passing of fresh order of punishment. We accordingly, modify the order of the learned Single Judge to that extent.

    12. As regards the finding of the learned Single Judge that past misconducts and the consequent punishments upon the employee cannot be considered while inflicting punishment on the fresh offence, we are unable to subscribe to the view taken by the learned Single Judge. As pointed out by the Supreme Court in the case of State of Mysore v. K. Manche Gowda, reported in AIR 1964 SC 506, it is permissible for an employer while giving punishment on the basis of fresh misconduct, to take into consideration the earlier punishments and earlier misconducts but the principles of natural justice and equity demand that those facts should be made known to the delinquent employee. Therefore, in our view, the employer in this case did not commit any illegality in framing Charge No. 2 incorporating the incidents of past misconduct and punishment imposed upon him as it proposed to take into consideration those facts while considering the question of punishment. By framing those additional charges, the employee has not been prejudiced in any way; on the other hand, it was for his benefit because if there was any wrong statement as regards earlier alleged punishment or misconduct, he could point out to the employer that those should not be taken into consideration.

    13. We, thus, find that framing of Charge No. 2 along with the present misconduct was quite justified and the same was made for giving adequate opportunity to the employee to make representation against those facts.

    14. We, thus, modify the order impugned to this extent that till the new punishment during the pendency of this appeal has been given by the employer, the employee should be entitled to get subsistence allowance payable under Service Rules during the period of suspension from the earlier date of compulsory retirement till the date of passing of new order of punishment.

    15. We further make it clear that there was no mistake on the part of employer in framing Charge No. 2 and taking into consideration the past misconducts and consequent punishment imposed upon the petitioner while framing Charge No. 1.

    16. As regards the subsequent punishment imposed upon the writ petitioner we make it clear that we have not gone into the propriety of the same as the same is beyond the scope of writ application out of which the present appeal arises and if writ petitioner is dissatisfied with such order, he is free to approach the appropriate forum in accordance with law.

    17. The appeal is, thus, disposed of. In the facts and circumstances, there will be, however, no order as to costs.

    Rajendra Nath Sinha, J.:— I agree.

    Appeal disposed of.
    N.M

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India & Ors. v. Raj Kumar Jha
    (Apr 20, 2005)