Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • West Bengal Service (Determination of Seniority) Rules, 1981. According to Rule 6(2) of West Bengal Service (Determination of Seniority) Rules, 1981,
  • 31.7.1982 West Bengal Forest Service (Condition of Service) Rules, 1982,
  • ARTICLE 226 A CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • West Bengal Service (Determination of Seniority) Rules, 1981. According to Rule 6(2) of West Bengal Service (Determination of Seniority) Rules, 1981,
  • 31.7.1982 West Bengal Forest Service (Condition of Service) Rules, 1982,
  • ARTICLE 226 A CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ application (under Article 226 of the Constitution of India) challenges the judgment dated 21 April 1997 of the West Bengal State Administrative Tribunal in Case No. TA 1293 of 1996. Eleven petitioners were directly recruited to the State Forest Service in March 1990. Respondents 4 to 19 (private respondents) were promoted to the State Forest Service by notification No. 940 dated 1 February 1991 and were given retrospective seniority with effect from 31 December 1990.

The West Bengal Forest Service (Condition of Service) Rules, 1982 (brought into force on 31 July 1982) provide (by Rule 3) that determination of seniority in the service is governed by the West Bengal Service (Determination of Seniority) Rules, 1981; Rule 6(2) of the 1981 Rules states that "the promotee shall be enbloc senior to the direct recruits of the same year."

The petitioners challenged the grant of retrospective seniority as arbitrary and contrary to service rules and sought quashing of the impugned notification and direction to re-fix seniority in accordance with law. The Tribunal upheld the grant of retrospective seniority and dismissed the petitioners' application. Aggrieved, the petitioners approached the High Court under Article 226. The judgment below is delivered by Surya Kumar Tiwari, J., with Tarun Chatterjee, J. concurring.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the grant of retrospective seniority (with effect from 31.12.1990) to promotees (respondents 4–19) over directly recruited officers (petitioners) was arbitrary or contrary to applicable service rules.
  2. Whether the State Government and the Public Service Commission acted lawfully in recommending and granting retrospective seniority to the promotees in the circumstances described (including the effect of an earlier interim order that had delayed promotion processes).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The grant of retrospective seniority to respondents 4 to 19 is arbitrary and contrary to service rules governing seniority.
  • Reliance was placed on State of Bihar v. Akhouri Sachindra Nath (A.I.R. 1991 S.C. 1244) to support the proposition that retrospective promotion which adversely affects others is impermissible and that seniority is to be reckoned from date of initial entry into service.
  • Cited authorities concerning statutory requirement for action to be taken in a particular manner and principles of reasonable classification (State of Mizoram v. Biakchhawna and Gursharan Singh v. NDMC) to contend that the State had to adhere strictly to rules and that any classification between petitioners and respondents must be reasonable and not arbitrary.

Private Respondents' Arguments

  • Promotees have a 50% quota in the State Forest Service; the Public Service Commission (PSC) had been approached as early as 1.1.1989 to clear promotion of 22 Forest Rangers, but interim orders of this Court restrained promotions, delaying processing.
  • The stay (in C.O. No. 9700(W) of 1998) was vacated on 11.12.1990; only thereafter could selections proceed, and because the promotees' cases had remained pending before the PSC due to the interim court order, the PSC rightly recommended retrospective seniority with effect from 31.12.1990.
  • Relied on Ram Pal Malik v. State of Haryana (A.I.R. 1994 S.C. 2481), D.D. Sury v. Union of India [1979 (3) S.C.C. 553], and U.D. Lama v. State of Sikkim [1997 (1) S.C.C. 111] to support the proposition that retrospective seniority can be lawfully granted in appropriate circumstances (including where State/PSC delay or failure deprived in-service employees of promotion opportunities).

State's Submissions

  • The State (through counsel Shri Balai Chandra Roy) relied on authorities such as Mahmood Hasan v. State of U.P. (A.I.R. 1997 S.C. 800) and P.K. Dikshit v. State of U.P. (A.I.R. 1988 S.C. 260), but the court observed these did not determine the controlling issue in light of U.D. Lama.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Bihar v. Akhouri Sachindra Nath (A.I.R. 1991 S.C. 1244) Principle: retrospective promotion cannot be given with effect from a date when the promoted person was not in the cadre, to the detriment of others; seniority is reckoned from date of initial entry into service. The petitioners relied on this to argue retrospective seniority was impermissible. The court noted the authority but treated it alongside other authorities and factual differences; it did not apply this as controlling precedent to set aside the retrospective seniority in the present facts.
Ram Pal Malik v. State of Haryana (A.I.R. 1994 S.C. 2481) Holds that grant of retrospective seniority to a promotee was not contrary to promotion rules in that case where the ad-hoc promotee's confirmation was delayed. Private respondents relied on this decision to support retrospective seniority. The court considered it supportive of the principle that retrospective seniority can be lawful in appropriate circumstances.
D.D. Sury v. Union of India [1979 (3) S.C.C. 553] Explains "next below rule" and that a competent authority may authorise 'proforma' officiating promotion and grant pay of higher scale; supports ability to grant retrospective effect in proper cases. Cited by private respondents to show competent authority can grant retrospective promotion/seniority; the court treated this as supportive of the proposition that retrospective seniority may be granted by competent authority in proper case.
U.D. Lama v. State of Sikkim [1997 (1) S.C.C. 111] Upheld grant of retrospective seniority to promoted officers over direct recruits where State's failure to constitute a Public Service Commission had deprived in-service employees of promotional consideration; permitted correction to remove injustice. The court regarded Lama as the controlling authority for the present facts, holding that, in light of Lama, the State Government and the PSC acted in accordance with law and the retrospective seniority granted should be upheld.
Chandigarh Administration v. Jagit Singh (A.I.R. 1995 S.C. 705) Statement: bad precedents cannot make good law; each case must be decided on its own merits according to relevant legal principles. Petitioners cited this to rebut respondents' references to past administrative instances of retrospective promotion. The court stated it did not rely on such administrative instances and observed that each case must stand on its own facts.
State of Mizoram v. Biakchhawna (1995 (1) S.C.C. 156) Principle: when a statute requires action to be taken in a particular manner, it must be taken in that manner. Petitioners cited this to argue strict compliance with statutory procedure; the court observed that in the instant case the State Government had not acted in contravention of statutory rules.
Gursharan Singh v. New Delhi Municipal Committee (A.I.R. 1996 S.C. 1175) Deals with reasonable classification (Article 14 principles). Petitioners relied on it to attack the classification between petitioners and respondents; the court found the classification could not be called arbitrary or irrational in the present facts.
Tejkumar Balakrishna Ruia v. A.K. Menon (A.I.R. 1997 S.C. 442) Principle: where two reasonable views are possible, the one preserving constitutionality should be adopted. The court considered this authority but found it not relevant to the circumstances of the present case.
Air India Statutory Corpn. v. United Labour Union (A.I.R. 1997 S.C. 645) Concerned with contract labour: date of engagement is the criterion to determine inter-se seniority of contract labour. The court held that the principle in a contract-labour context was not applicable here because statutory rules under Article 309 specifically deal with inter-se seniority between direct recruits and promotees.
State of Kerala v. T.M. Somarajan (A.I.R. 1984 NOC 219 (Ker.)) Full Bench: mistakes in preparation of seniority lists between promotees and direct recruits can be rectified and subsequent rectification would be valid. Private respondents relied on this to support the validity of rectifying seniority lists; the court noted this supportive authority.
Mahmood Hasan v. State of U.P. (A.I.R. 1997 S.C. 800) Involved quashing of ad-hoc promotions made in terms of High Court orders and direction that further promotions be made according to State level seniority list. The State relied on this case, but the court observed it did not clinch the real issue in light of U.D. Lama.
P.K. Dikshit v. State of U.P. (A.I.R. 1988 S.C. 260) Held that seniority of a promotee has to be reckoned on the date on which vacancy was available for confirmation. The State relied on this decision; the court noted it did not resolve the controlling question given the present facts and the authority of U.D. Lama.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the applicable rules and the factual chronology: the relevant West Bengal rules (1982 and the 1981 Determination of Seniority Rules), the recruitment of petitioners in March 1990, the promotion notification for respondents 4–19 dated 1.2.1991 and retrospective seniority from 31.12.1990, and the procedural delay caused by an earlier interim order that had restrained promotions.

The court considered the petitioners' reliance on State of Bihar v. Akhouri Sachindra Nath, which generally prohibits retrospective promotion that adversely affects others, and other authorities relied upon by petitioners to stress strict adherence to statutory procedure and rational classification. The private respondents relied on authorities (including Ram Pal Malik, D.D. Sury and U.D. Lama) that recognize circumstances where retrospective seniority or backdating may be appropriate—notably where administrative or State failures (such as absence of a Public Service Commission or court-ordered delays) deprived in-service candidates of consideration for promotion.

The court identified U.D. Lama as the most pertinent precedent. In Lama, a three-Judge Bench upheld retrospective seniority for promoted in-service employees where the State's failure to constitute a Public Service Commission had created the deprivation; the present court found a parallel factual rationale because the promotees' cases had been kept pending by earlier interim orders and only considered after the restraint was vacated. On that basis the court concluded the State Government and the Public Service Commission acted in accordance with law in recommending and granting retrospective seniority.

The court also invoked the maxim (as stated in the opinion) "actus legis neminee est demnosus" to support the proposition that an act of the court should prejudice no one, and that where a person is harmed by mistake of the court or administrative delay he should be restored to the position he would have normally enjoyed.

The court reviewed other authorities cited by the parties, stating why some were inapplicable or not controlling in the present facts (for example, Air India Statutory Corpn. concerned contract labour and was therefore inapplicable, and some decisions cited by the State did not clinch the issue in light of U.D. Lama). On balance, and applying Lama, the court held that the retrospective seniority granted by the State and recommended by the PSC was lawful and not arbitrary.

Holding and Implications

WRIT APPLICATION DISMISSED

Implications:

  • The High Court upheld the Tribunal's dismissal of the petitioners' application; the impugned order granting retrospective seniority to respondents 4–19 (effective 31.12.1990) stands.
  • The court concluded that the State Government and the Public Service Commission acted in accordance with law in granting retrospective seniority in the factual context of administrative delay and prior interim restraint.
  • No broader or novel legal principle was declared by this judgment; the decision rests on application of existing authorities (in particular U.D. Lama) to the facts. The immediate and direct effect is to leave the parties' seniority as determined by the impugned notification and to dismiss the petitioners' challenge.

Miscellaneous: The court directed that certified xerox copies of the judgment, if applied for, be given to the parties expeditiously. Tarun Chatterjee, J. agreed with the judgment.

    Asis Kumar Samanta & Ors. v. State Of West Bengal & Ors.

    Surya Kumar Tiwari, J.:—This writ application has been filed against the judgment dated 21st April, 1997, delivered by the West Bengal State Administrative Tribunal in Case No. TA 1293 of 1996.

    2. These 11 petitioners were recruited directly to State Forest Service in the month of March, 1990. Respondents 4 to 19 to the original petition were promoted to the State Forest Service vide notification No. 940 dated 1.2.91 They were given retrospective seniority with effect from 31.12.90 It is not disputed that West Bengal Forest Service constituted with effect from 31.7.1982 West Bengal Forest Service (Condition of Service) Rules, 1982, were also brought into force on the same day. According to Rule 3 ibid, determination of seniority in the service is to be governed by West Bengal Service (Determination of Seniority) Rules, 1981. According to Rule 6(2) of West Bengal Service (Determination of Seniority) Rules, 1981, “the promotee shall be enbloc senior to the direct recruits of the same year”.

    3. The petitioner have challenged the grant of retrospective seniority to respondents 4 to 19 by the State Government as arbitrary and contrary to service rules. The petitioner, therefore, prayed that the impugned notification be quashed and the State Government be directed to re-fix the seniority in accordance with law.

    4. Only private respondents 4, 5, 7 and 9 to 19 contested the application by filing Affidavits-in-Reply. According to them, the promotees have a 50% quota in the State Forest Service and the West Bengal Public Service Commission were approached as back as on 1.1.1989 to clear the promotion of 22 Forest Rangers in the State Forest Services. But their cases could not be processed because of the interim order passed by this court in C.O No. 9700(W) of 1998 restraining the authorities from giving promotion to West Bengal Forest Service. The said stay order was vacated on 11.12.1990 and only thereafter the selection process started and the cases of respondents 4 to 19 were considered by the Public Service Commission. Since their cases for promotion remained pending consideration before the Public Service Commission because of the interim order of this court, the Public Service Commission rightly recommended that respondents 4 to 19 be given retrospective seniority with effect from 31.12.1990

    5. The learned Tribunal up-held the grant of retrospective seniority and dismissed the petitioner's application. Being agrieved by the dismissal of their application, the petitioners have approached this court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

    6. The learned Counsel for the petitioners has placed reliance on the case of State of Bihar v. Akhouri Sachindra Nath (A.I.R 1991 S.C 1244). In this case the petitioners were directly recruited Assistant Engineers. Subsequently, the State Government promoted Overseers as Assistant Engineers and gave them retrospective seniority over them which was challenged. The Apex Court held thus:—

    “It is well settled that no person can be promoted with retrospective effect from date when he was not born in the cadre as to adversely affect others. It is well settled that amongst members of the same grade seniority is reckoned from the date of their initial entry into service”.

    7. The learned Counsel appearing for the private respondents has placed reliance on the case of Ram Pal Malik v. State of Haryana (A.I.R 1994 S.C 2481). In the instant case an ad-hoc promotee was working on the higher post and direct recruits were appointed and were placed higher in the gardation list. The ad-hoc promotee's application for confirmation on higher post remained pending with the State Government for a number of years. Subsequently the State Government considered and allowed the application of the ad-hoc promotee. The Apex Court held that the grant of retrospective seniority to the promotee was not contrary to any rules concerning promotion. The Apex Court in case of D.D Sury v. Union of India [1979 (3) S.C.C 553] while considering the scope of “next below rule” in the service jurisprudence held that an officer in a post (whether within the cadre of his service or not) is for any reason prevented from officiating in his term in a post on higher scale or grade borne on the cadre of the service to which he belongs, he may be authorised by the special order of the appropriate authority, ‘proforma’ officiating promotion into such scale of pay and thereupon may be granted the pay of that scale or grade. It is, therefore, clear that a competent authority can grant retrospective seniority to an employee in proper case. The latest authority on this point is that of U.D Lama v. State of Sikkim [1997 (1) S.C.C 111] wherein a three Judges Bench of the Apex Court up-held of grant of retrospective seniority to subsequently promoted officers over the direct recruits because the State Government of Sikkim had not constituted Public Service Commission for a considerable period of time. As a result of which the cases of in-service employees could not be considered for promotion as against the quota reserved for them. The Apex Court held thus:— “They were deprived of their chances……….. Now that the Public Service Commission has been set-up, the State Government has to undo wrong that was initially done to these employees by subjecting them to tests which was not warranted ….. Therefore they should not be made to suffer in the matter of seniority or promotion in any way by failure of the State Government to implement the rule laid down by it. In these circumstances by directing the new recruits to be treated to have been recruited on the day the appellants were recruited, the State Government has not done anything contrary or wrong but has really removed the injustice done to the respondents by the State Government's failure to recruit them into service in accordance with rule 4(1)(b)”.

    8. In the light of Lama's case (supra), it is clear that the State Government and the Public Service Commission acted in accordance with law and their action cannot be called arbitrary or illegal. It would also be partinent to keep in mind the legal maxim “actus legis neminee est demnosus” meaning thereby that an act of court shall prejudice no one. There is no higher principle for the guidance of the courts then the one that no act of court should harm a litigant and it is the duty of the courts to see that if a person is harmed by mistake of the court he should be restored to the position he would have normally enjoyed. It is, therefore, pre-eminently just and proper that the impugned order is up-held.

    9. The learned Counsel for the petitioners has cited A.I.R 1995 S.C 705 (Chandigarh Administrative v. Jagit Singh) wherein it has been laid down that bad precedents cannot make good law. Each case must be decided on it's own merits in accordance with law or relevant legal principles and not on the basis of wrong decisions taken by the State Government. This case was cited to rebut the case set-up by respondents 4 to 19 where they have cited certain instances where some officers were given retrospective promotion in the past. We have not placed any reliance on any such precedent.

    10. The next case cited by the learned Counsel for the petitioners is reported in 1995 (1) S.C.C 156 (State Of Mizoram v. Biakchhawna.) wherein it has been laid down that when statute requires an action to be taken in a particular manner, the same has to be taken in the same manner. Suffice it to say that the instant case the State Government has not acted in contravention of any statutory rules.

    11. The learned Counsel for the petitioners has also cited A.I.R 1996 S.C 1175 (Gursharan Singh v. New Delhi Municipal Committee) which deals with reasonable classification. In the present case the classification between petitioners and respondents cannot be called arbitrary or irrational.

    12. The next case relied upon was A.I.R 1997 S.C 442 (Tejkumar Balakrishna Ruia v. A.K Menon) which lays down that if two views are possible, the one is preserved the constitutionality of the provision must be adopted. This case also has no relevance to the circumstances of the present case. Then the learned Counsel placed reliance on the case of Air India Statutory Corpn. v. United Labour Union (AIR 1997 S.C 645) which was a case relating to contract labour. The Apex Court laid down that the date of engagement of labourer shall be the criteria to determine the inter-se seniority. In the present case, the statutory rules framed by the State Government under proviso to Article 309 of Constitution specifically deals with the inter-se seniority between the direct recruits and promotees. Hence the principle which was made applicable to the absorption of contract labour does not apply to the parties to this case.

    13. The learned Counsel appearing for the private respondents have placed reliance on a Full Bench decision of Kerala High Court reported in A.I.R 1984 NOC 219 (Ker.) (State of Kerala v. T.M Somarajan) wherein it has been laid down that mistake committed in preparation of seniority list between the promotees and direct recruits can be rectified and subsequent rectification would be valid.

    14. The learned Counsel Shri Balai Chandra Roy appearing for the State of West Bengal has placed reliance on A.I.R 1997 S.C 800 (Mahmood Hasan v. State of U.P) wherein the Apex Court had quashed the ad-hoc promotion granted in terms of various orders of the High Court and directed further promotion to be made according to State level seniority list.

    15. The next case relied by Shri Balai Chandra Roy is A.I.R 1988 S.C 260 (P.K Dikshit v. State of U.P) wherein the Apex Court laid down that the seniority of the promotee has to be reckoned on the date on which vacancy was available for confirmation. These cases do not clinch the real issue. However, in the light of U.D Lama's case (supra), the State Government's order giving retrospective seniority must be up-held and the learned Tribunal committed no error in dismissing the petitioners' application.

    16. We find no substance in this writ application and the same is dismissed.

    17. Certified xerox copy of the judgment, if applied for, be given to the parties as expeditiously as possible.

    Tarun Chatterjee, J.:—I agree.

    Writ application dismissed.
    M.M

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Asis Kumar Samanta & Ors. v. State Of West Bengal & Ors.
    (Mar 24, 1999)