AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — S. Chatterji, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The Rule was issued on 17.5.1985 at the instance of the writ petitioner seeking, inter alia, a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to settle claims arising from loss and damage caused by a flood in 1978. The petitioner is a registered partnership firm operating a cold storage facility at Chilleydanga, P.S. Pursura, District Hooghly. The petitioner insured potatoes stored in the cold storage and also insured buildings, plant, machinery and installations with several insurance companies (respondents). The petition records specific insurance proposals, premiums paid (including a cheque of Rs. 9,800/- dated 7/3/1978), and a policy document (Policy No. 320/124811 (M) dated 7/2/1979) issued by National Insurance Company covering stock to an extent of Rs. 10 lacs with a clause referring to cover for damage caused by change of temperature in certain circumstances.

Following an unprecedented flood that inundated the cold storage, the petitioner alleged heavy damage to potatoes, plant and machinery and claimed about Rs. 20 lacs. The petitioner sent telegrams, letters, and a detailed claim letter dated 13.11.1978 to the appointed surveyor Messrs. Ascon & Avins. The claim was not resolved to the petitioner's satisfaction and the petitioner moved the writ court alleging violation of law and principles of natural justice.

The respondents filed affidavits-in-opposition, denying the maintainability of the writ petition and asserting that contractual/commercial remedies (suit for damages) were the appropriate remedy. They also relied on policy terms, surveyor reports and alleged that certain clauses had been deleted or that the policy was issued by mutual mistake.

After hearing arguments, the Court found in favour of the petitioner, made the Rule absolute and issued a writ directing the respondents to consider the petitioners' claim within eight weeks, after giving an opportunity of hearing, and to pass a speaking and reasoned order. No order as to costs was made.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the writ petition seeking a mandamus to compel insurers to consider and decide the petitioner's insurance claim is maintainable in view of available contractual remedies (i.e., whether the respondents are amenable to writ jurisdiction).
  2. Whether valid and subsisting insurance policies covered the petitioner's loss caused by the 1978 flood and, if so, whether the respondents complied with the Insurance Act and the policy terms in considering the claim.
  3. Whether the respondents' conduct (including delay and alleged silence) amounted to a denial of natural justice or an implied rejection of the claim, and whether the claim must be decided by a reasoned, speaking order after an opportunity of hearing.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner asserted that valid contracts of insurance existed covering stock, buildings, plant and machinery and certain deterioration-of-temperature risks, and that premiums were accepted.
  • The petitioner contended that an unprecedented flood in 1978 caused substantial loss (claimed at about Rs. 20 lacs) and that the petitioner promptly informed the insurers by telegrams and letters and lodged a formal claim (letter dated 13.11.1978 to the surveyor).
  • The petitioner argued that the claim was not dealt with in accordance with law, that there was no formal communication repelling or rejecting the claim after giving opportunity of hearing, and that the silence/inaction violated principles of natural justice.
  • Counsel relied on various decisions and provisions of the Insurance Act (including section 14(b)) to support the contention that claim handling and communication requirements must be complied with and that registers should be maintained even if a claim is rejected.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents contended that the dispute arose out of commercial contracts and, if there was any breach, the appropriate remedy was a suit for damages rather than a writ petition; they questioned the maintainability of the writ.
  • It was argued that the respondents are not "authorities" within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution and therefore not amenable to writ jurisdiction.
  • The respondents relied on policy terms and contended that certain clauses had been deleted (for example, a clause limiting liability in relation to refrigeration plant), and that the policy may have been issued by mutual mistake; they also relied on the surveyor's report to ascertain loss and deny liability.
  • Counsel cited case law and provisions (including section 4(b) of the Insurance Act) to support the position that statutory and contractual remedies may bar writ relief and to justify the respondents' course of action in the matter.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
1988 (1) CLJ p. 316 — Umesh Cold Storage v. Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. Ltd. Cited in submissions concerning construction of insurance policy and claim handling by insurers. Noted by the Court as among authorities cited in argument; the judgment was part of submissions concerning policy construction and claim handling. The Court did not record that decision as the sole basis of its final order.
AIR 1986 SC p. 1527 — Shri Barminder Singh Arora v. Union of India Referred to in the parties' arguments (insurance/statutory context cited by counsel). Referenced in argument; the Court recorded its citation among various decisions but did not indicate that this case alone determined the outcome.
AIR 1989 SC p. 1642 — Dwarkadas Marfatia & Sons v. Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay (paras. 21, 25, 27) Referred to in submissions (context: contractual/statutory interplay and procedural aspects in dealing with claims). Cited by counsel and noted by the Court as part of the line of authorities relied upon; the Court did not state that it directly decided the present dispute based solely on this decision.
AIR 1990 SC p. 1031 — Mahabir Auto Stores v. Indian Oil Corporation Cited regarding handling of claims and as authority relevant to whether certain entities are amenable to writ jurisdiction. The Court expressly referred to this decision in support of its conclusion that respondents can be instrumentalities/authorities under Article 12 and therefore amenable to writ jurisdiction.
1990 (2) CLJ p. 137 — Jugal Kanta Pramanik v. State of West Bengal & Ors. Referred to by counsel concerning contract scope and claim procedure. Noted by the Court as part of the authorities cited by the parties; the Court did not identify it as the decisive authority for the final order.
1989 (2) CLJ p. 252 — Nellimarla Jute Mills Co. Ltd. v. Jute Corporation of India Ltd. Referred to regarding scope of contract and arbitration clauses. Cited in submissions; the Court acknowledged the reference in the course of considering arguments about contractual remedies and arbitration but did not base the decision exclusively on it.
1989 (2) Cal. L.T. p. 214 — S.P. Electronics v. State of West Bengal Referred to in submissions on contractual/administrative procedure issues. Noted by the Court among the cited authorities; used for context in considering arguments about procedure and communication of decisions.
91 CWN p. 217 — Hindusthan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. & Ors. v. Shyam Sundar Ganeriwala Referred to in submissions on procedural and claim-handling aspects. Recorded by the Court as part of the body of case law placed before it; the opinion does not indicate exclusive reliance upon this decision.
AIR 1980 SC p. 1037 — Shiv Shankar Dal Mills v. State of Haryana Cited in the context of requirements for communication and procedural fairness. The Court noted the reference in submissions emphasizing communication; it considered the broader principle of fair communication in claim handling.
AIR 1985 All. p. 183 — Bhashir Kumar Agarwal v. Union of India Relied on by respondents' counsel in support of the non-maintainability/Article 12 argument. Noted as part of respondents' submissions; the Court recorded the citation but reached the conclusion that respondents are amenable to writ jurisdiction notwithstanding such arguments.
(1969) 2 SCR 824 — Tilokchand Motichand v. H.B. Munshi Referenced by respondents' counsel among authorities bearing on contractual remedies and procedure. Listed among cases cited by respondents; the Court considered the submissions but did not treat this case as determinative of the maintainability issue in this matter.
AIR 1979 Punj. & Har. p. 183 — M.L. Nohria v. The General Insurance Company of India Cited in argument concerning insurance contract disputes and remedies. Recorded among the authorities referred to by respondents' counsel; the Court noted it but its final ruling did not rest solely on this case.
(1984) 2 SCC 719 — Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Raja Vasiraddy Komalavalli Kamba Referenced regarding insurance law and remedies. Noted by the Court as part of the cited authorities; used in the matrix of cases the Court considered while arriving at its decision.
AIR 1985 SC p. 1265 — Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Smt. Kiren Sinha Referenced in submissions addressing insurance law principles. Recognized among the decisions cited by counsel; the Court considered these authorities in assessing the parties' positions.
(1990) 3 SCC p. 752 — Mahabir Auto Stores v. Indian Oil Corporation (repeat reference) Cited by the Court for the broader position on amenability to writ jurisdiction. Specifically relied upon by the Court in concluding that the respondents are instrumentalities/authorities under Article 12 and thus amenable to writ jurisdiction.
AIR 1991 SC p. 537 — Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi etc. v. State of U.P. Cited regarding the scope of writ remedies and who qualifies as an "authority" under Article 12. Explicitly referenced by the Court to support its conclusion that the respondents fall within the ambit of Article 12 and are amenable to writ jurisdiction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by examining the record and submissions and applied the following analytical steps, based on the materials expressly recorded in the opinion:

  1. The Court accepted the factual position that a flood did occur and that the petitioner sustained loss and damage to stock, plant and machinery; the petitioner had communicated the loss and lodged claims with the respondents and with an appointed surveyor.
  2. The Court found that valid and subsisting insurance policies covered the petitioner's claim and that the claim therefore had to be considered and settled in accordance with the Insurance Act and the contractual clauses of the policies.
  3. The Court addressed the respondents' contention that they were not "authorities" within Article 12 and that the remedy lay in a suit. The Court reviewed relevant Supreme Court authority (specifically Mahabir Auto Stores v. I.O.C. and Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi v. State of U.P.) and concluded that the respondents were instrumentalities of government and constituted authorities under Article 12 and were therefore amenable to writ jurisdiction.
  4. The Court rejected the respondents' submission that the petitioner should be relegated to a suit and held that the writ forum was available; the Court observed that the horizon of writ relief has been broadened and that respondents could not simply direct the petitioner to pursue alternative remedies.
  5. The Court examined procedural conduct and held that there had been a failure to deal with the claim in the manner required by law: no formal communication had been given to the petitioner (after affording opportunity of hearing) in the form of a speaking, reasoned order; prolonged silence without explanation was found to violate principles of natural justice. The Court also disapproved the concept of "implied rejection" in the circumstances described.
  6. On these bases, the Court concluded that there existed a legal duty on the respondents to consider and decide the claim in a lawful fashion and that judicial intervention by way of mandamus was appropriate to secure that statutory and procedural obligations were performed.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Rule made absolute. The Court issued a writ ordering the respondents to consider the petitioners' claim within eight (8) weeks from the date of communication, after giving an opportunity of hearing, and to pass a speaking and reasoned order settling the claim in accordance with law. There was no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The respondents are required to consider the petitioner's insurance claim, provide the petitioner an opportunity to be heard, and issue a reasoned decision within eight weeks. The petitioner's claim must be dealt with in accordance with the Insurance Act and the relevant policy clauses.
  • Jurisdictional implication stated by the Court: The respondents were held to be instrumentalities/authorities under Article 12 and thus amenable to writ jurisdiction; accordingly, writ relief was available rather than being excluded on the basis that an ordinary suit was the only remedy.
  • Procedural implication: The Court emphasised that claim-handling by insurers must include communication and compliance with principles of natural justice — specifically, a speaking reasoned order after affording an opportunity of hearing before rejecting or otherwise disposing of a claim.
  • No novel precedent declared: The opinion grounded its conclusion on extant authority and the facts of the case; the Court referred to Supreme Court decisions to support its position but did not purport to lay down novel law beyond applying those authorities to these facts.

Rule made absolute. A.R.

    M/S. Bholenath Cold Storage v. The National Insurance Company Limited & Ors.

    S. Chatterji, J.:— The present Rule was issued on 17.5.1985 at the instance of the writ petitioner praying inter alia for a Writ of Mandamus commanding the respondents to settle the claims lodged by the petitioners and communicate their decision with regard to the claims in consequences of the loss and damage sustained by the petitioner due to the flood in the year 1978 and for other consequential reliefs as stated in details in the writ petition. It is stated in details that the petitioner is a registered Partnership firm carrying on Cold Storage business. The plant and machinery were installed and these were extremely sensitive requiring stable temperature. The petitioners proposed to insure their stock of potatoes stored in the cold storage premises situated at Chilleydanga, P.S Pursura in the District of Hooghly for a total sum of Rs. 17 lacs against the contingencies stipulated with the respondent Nos. 1 to 5 viz., National Insurance Company, Oriental Fire & General Insurance Company of different divisions and the New India Assurance Company. The petitioner also proposed to insure the buildings, plant and machinery and installation and racks of the cold storage for a total sum of Rs. 28 lacs with the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 respectively. There is also an agreement that the respondent No. 2 Oriental Fire & General Insurance Company towards the deterioration of Stock Policy for a sum of Rs. 22 lacs and machinery break down policy for a sum of Rs. 8.18 lacs. It is alleged that the respondent No. 1 the National Insurance Company Limited gave out in writing on 7th of February, 1979 by issuing Insurance Policy bearing No. 320/124811 (M) in favour of the petitioner against the contingencies and/or perils of fire, riot, M.D Explosion, E.F.S Cyclone and Rood etc., on the conditions stipulated in the said policy to the extent of Rs. 10 lacs on stock of potatoes stored in the cold storage. It is further alleged that a clause was incorporated in the Policy indicating inter alia:

    “It is hereby declared and noted that notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Policy or in any of its conditions this Policy covers destruction of or damage to the property hereby insured caused by change of temperature resulting from total or partial destruction or disablement by fire and other perils covered under this Policy, and the refrigerating plant.”

    2. Various clauses in the policy have been referred in the writ petition for appreciating the rights and obligations of the respective parties. It is placed on record that on March 7, 1978, the petitioner approached the respondent No. 4 in insuring the buildings, plant and machinery as well as stock of potatoes lying with the drawing safe and the petitioner sent a cheque for Rs. 9,800/-. There is a communication from the petitioner to cover the risk of deterioration of temperature clause of stock policy. There is a reference of chain of correspondences between the parties as elaborately disclosed in writ petition. It is specifically claimed that subsequent to the contract entered into by and between the petitioner and the respondents and premium being accepted after approval and/or acceptance of the proposal of the petitioner, there was an unprecedented flood inundating cold storage premises and as a result thereof, there was a huge damage of potatoes in the cold storage as well as there was a building, plant and machinery. Immediately thereafter, the petitioner duly informed about the aforesaid flood by addressing several telegrams and letters to all the respondents. The petitioner allegedly intimated that it sustained a loss to the tune of Rs. 20 lacs and the petitioner lodged a claim for the aforesaid amount. By a letter dated 13th November, 1978 addressed to the Surveyor, Messrs. Ascon & Avins of 14, India Exchange Place, Calcutta detailing the particulars of loss sustained by the petitioners. There is an allegation that the claim has not been settled and the petitioner has been compelled to come to the Writ Court to seek reliefs that the actions taken by the respondent authorities are contrary to law and prejudicial to the interest of the petitioner and is in violation of the principles of natural justice.

    3. The writ petition is contested by the respondents by filing an affidavit-in-opposition. A common defence is taken that the parties entered into commercial contracts and even if there is any breach, the remedies are only available by way of suit for damages against the respondents insurer companies and not by filing a writ petition. It is placed on record that pursuant to the letter of the petitioner to the respondent No. 1 dated 8th of March, 1978 and the proposal for Fire Insurance dated 8th of March, 1978 covered the stocks in this cold storage, there is a stipulation by deleting the clause viz., “it is a condition that the insurance Company, shall not be liable for loss and damages which is resulting from a total partial destruction or disbursement by fire refrigerating plant”. It is further placed on record that after the flood, the respondent No. 1 appointed the independent Surveyor Messrs. Ascon & Avins to survey and assess the damage and/or loss sustained by the petitioner without prejudice to the rights of the insurance. From the surveyor's report, it has to be ascertained and the report with annexures will speak for itself. It is further elaborated that the purported policy was issued by mutual mistake purporting to cover loss or damage, and mainly the respondents have denied the liability by claiming that since the respondent No. 6 Union of India has been expunged from the cause tide, the writ petition is not maintainable and the petition may be dismissed accordingly.

    4. A lengthy argument was advanced on behalf of the petitioner and the respondents. The attention of the Court has been drawn to the averments made in the writ petition and the affidavit-in-opposition and the affidavit-in-reply. The learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner has specifically drawn the attention of the Court to various provisions of law of insurance and to consider the construction of the policy. Several reported decisions have been cited viz. 1988 (1) CLJ page 316 (Umesh Cold Storage v. Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. Ltd.), AIR 1986 SC page 1527 (Shri Barminder Singh Arora v. Union of India) and paragraphs 21, 25 and 27 of AIR 1989 SC page 1642 (Dwarkadas Marfatia & Sons v. Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay). It is highlighted that the claim of the Policy-holder should be understood in the proper perspective and there should be maintenance of register even if the claim is rejected. The attention of the Court has been drawn to section 14(b) of Insurance Act. There is also reference of paragraphs 12 and 13 of AIR 1990 SC page 1031 (Mahabir Auto Stores v. Indian Oil Corporation), and 1990 (2) CLJ page 137 (Jugal Kanta Pramanik… v. State Of West Bengal & Ors.…). The scope of contract and arbitration clause have also been referred and the attention of the Court has been drawn to 1989 (2) CLJ page 252 (Nellimarla Jute Mills Co. Ltd. v. Jute Corporation of India Ltd.) and 1989 (2) Calcutta Law Times page 214 (S.P Electronics v. State of West Bengal). There is a reference of 91 CWN page 217 (Hindusthan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. & Ors. v. Shyam Sundar Ganeriwala). It is emphasized that there must be communication and there is no question of giving provision by referring AIR 1980 SC page 1037 (Shiv Shankar Dal Mills etc. v. State of Haryana) The main thrust of the argument is that claim of the petitioner has not been considered in the proper perspective and there is no communication to repudiate the claim lodged by the petitioner.

    5. The learned counsel appearing for the respondents has mainly argued that the respondents are not the authorities within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India and the writ petition is not maintainable. He has drawn the attention of the Court to AIR 1985 All. page 183 (Bhashir Kumar Agarwal v. Union of India) and to section 4(b) of the Insurance Act. It is argued that first part is directed and not the second part if the Insurance Company does not repudiate the claim. There is a reference of (1969) 2 SCR page 824 (Tilokchand Motichand v. H.B Munshi, AIR 1979 Punj. & Har. page 183 (M.L Nohria v. The General Insurance Company of India, Bombay; (1984) 2 SCC page 719 (Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Raja Vasiraddy Komalavalli Kamba) and AIR 1985 SC page 1265 (Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Smt. Kiren Sinha).

    6. Having considered the materials on record in depth and the submissions made on behalf of the respective parties at length, this Court finds that there are valid and subsisting policies covering the claim of the petitioner. Admittedly, there was a flood. Undisputedly, the petitioner has sustained loss and damage. The petitioner has duly communicated their loss and damages. The claims have got to be settled in accordance with law as provided in the Insurance Act and in the manner as covered by several clauses of the policy. The respondents are certainly instrumentalities of the Government and they are certainly the authorities as envisaged under Article 12 of the Constitution of India and they are amenable to writ jurisdiction. Reference may be made to the latest decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court as reported in (1990) 3 SCC page 752 (Mahabir Auto Stores v. I.O.C) and AIR 1991 SC page 537 (Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi etc. v. State of U.P). There cannot be any doubt that the remedies available for breach of contract by the statutory authorities, the door of the Writ Court is closed. The horizon has been broadened and the respondents cannot be permitted to ask the petitioner to go for alternative remedies by filing a suit. The concept of implied rejection is wholly unwarranted and uncalled for. Upon perusal of the materials on record, this Court is convinced that the claim of the petitioner has not been dealt with in the manner as required under law. No formal communication has been sent to the petitioner after giving an opportunity of hearing and/or by passing any speaking order. There is also violation of the principles of natural justice in keeping silence over the claim of the petitioner for a long time without ascertaining any reason.

    7. For the foregoing reasons, this Court does not find any bar and/or impediment to grant reliefs to the petitioner in the manner as indicated below. The Rule is made absolute by issuing an appropriate writ commanding the respondents to consider the claim of the petitioners within 8 (eight) weeks from the date of communication by giving an opportunity of hearing: and by passing a speaking and reasoned order to settle the claim of the petitioner in accordance with law. There will be no order as to costs.

    Rule made absolute.
    A.R

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S. Bholenath Cold Storage v. The National Insurance Company Limited & Ors.
    (Jul 15, 1991)