AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 14 sub-rule (8) of the said Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules
  • Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules
  • ARTICLE 309 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 14 sub-rule (8) of the said Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules
  • Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules
  • ARTICLE 309 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — G.N. Roy, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This Rule challenges the continuation of a departmental inquiry initiated by memo No. 88.CVC/71 CDE(D) dated 6 July 1973 (Annexure N). The petitioner is a Zoologist employed by the Zoological Survey of India. The charge-sheet against the petitioner was issued on 12 March 1969 by Shri S.P. Josh Joshi, Deputy Secretary, Ministry of Education (Annexure C), and contained four charges with accompanying statement of imputations, a list of documents (Annexure 3) and a list of witnesses (Annexure 4).

Among the documents in Annexure 3 was a letter from the Station Master, Nadbai, which the department proposed to rely on and listed a Station Master of Nadbai as a proposed witness. The petitioner sought inspection of the Annexure 3 documents, including that letter, but the department was unable to provide it because the letter had been misplaced. The petitioner also did not receive copies of statements of three witnesses named in Annexure 4 despite repeated requests.

The petitioner sought inspection of several government records for his defence. He inspected only one such document (serial No. 2); document serial No. 1 was reported missing. Other requested documents (serial Nos. 3–8 and 10–19) were said to be in the Record Room of the Old Court Building of the Sub Judge, Jaipur, and possibly obtainable by requisition. Despite the alleged non-supply and misplacement, the impugned memo directed that the oral inquiry proceed from 6–10 August 1973 and, if necessary, continue day-to-day until concluded.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the departmental inquiry may validly proceed where the petitioner has not been supplied with the statements of three prosecution witnesses and where a document (the Station Master, Nadbai's letter) relied upon in the charge-sheet is missing and was not made available for inspection.
  2. Whether failure to supply witness statements and to permit inspection of relied-upon documents violates the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules (including rule 14(8)) and principles of natural justice and thereby vitiates the departmental inquiry.
  3. Whether the petitioner must participate in the inquiry and exhaust internal avenues before seeking judicial review, or whether he may seek relief at this stage to prevent further prejudice.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Petitioner's) Arguments — Mr. Gupta

  • Under the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules it is incumbent on the Inquiring Officer and/or the Government to supply copies of witness statements and the documents on which the charge-sheet is founded.
  • Supplying those statements and documents (or allowing inspection) is necessary to enable the petitioner to prepare a defence, effectively cross-examine prosecution witnesses and lead evidence in rebuttal.
  • In the present case, three witness statements were not supplied and the Station Master’s letter (Annexure 3) was not made available because it was misplaced; several other relevant government records were not made available for inspection.
  • Proceeding with the inquiry in these circumstances would violate rule 14(8) of the Central Civil Services Rules, Article 309 of the Constitution (by implication through rules framed thereunder), and principles of natural justice, thereby vitiating the departmental proceedings.
  • Relied on Collector of Customs v. Biswanath (1974) C.L.J. 251 as authority that violation of rule 14(8) amounts to denial of reasonable opportunity and vitiates inquiry proceedings.

Respondent's Arguments — Mr. Roy Chowdhury

  • Only one of the ten documents listed in Annexure 3 was not available for inspection (it was misplaced); the remainder are or can be made available, including documents in the Sub Judge’s court records.
  • Although some statements and documents were not supplied, that alone does not vitiate the departmental proceeding; the petitioner should appear, file his written defence and make submissions before the Inquiring Officer, who can adjudicate any prejudice.
  • If the Inquiring Officer rules against the petitioner on such irregularities, the petitioner can then approach the Court; the petitioner is not entitled to a pre-emptive challenge at this stage.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Collector of Customs v. Biswanath, (1974) C.L.J. 251 Principle that violation of rule 14(8) of the Central Civil Services Rules amounts to denial of reasonable opportunity to defend and vitiates the departmental inquiry. The court relied on the principle established in this decision to support the view that non-supply of witness statements and failure to permit inspection of relied-upon documents prejudices the petitioner and vitiates continuation of the inquiry.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a fact-based analysis of the availability of documents and witness statements and the timing of the petitioner's challenge. The key elements of the court's reasoning are:

  1. The court accepted the petitioner's factual assertions that three witness statements relied upon in Annexure 4 had not been supplied and that the Station Master, Nadbai's letter listed in Annexure 3 was not available for inspection because it was misplaced.
  2. The court noted the petitioner had not participated in the inquiry (had not examined or cross-examined witnesses), and therefore there was no question of acquiescence in the alleged procedural defects.
  3. The petitioner had moved the court at an early and appropriate stage—before further continuance of the inquiry—seeking relief against the procedural defects that would cause prejudice to his defence.
  4. The court evaluated the legal effect of non-supply of witness statements and non-provision of relied-upon documents: such non-supply seriously prejudiced the petitioner’s ability to prepare his defence, to cross-examine the prosecution witnesses effectively, and to lead his evidence.
  5. Relying on the principle (as applied in Collector of Customs v. Biswanath) that violation of rule 14(8) and similar procedural requirements amounts to denial of reasonable opportunity and vitiates the inquiry, the court concluded that the departmental proceeding could not properly continue in the absence of the required disclosures and inspection.
  6. The court rejected the respondent’s submission that the petitioner should be compelled to participate in the inquiry and could later litigate the irregularities; the judge reasoned it would be unfair to require the petitioner to undergo the inquiry and then raise the same defects after suffering prejudice.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court made the Rule absolute. In the words of the judgment: Rule made absolute.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The departmental inquiry cannot continue in its present form while the specified omissions persist — specifically, the non-supply of the three witness statements and the failure to give inspection of the Station Master, Nadbai's, letter (and other relevant documents) prejudiced the petitioner and therefore prevented lawful continuation of the inquiry.
  • Practical consequence: The impugned continuation of the inquiry (as fixed by the memo for 6–10 August 1973 and day-to-day thereafter) was restrained by the Court's order until compliance with the procedural requirements is effected.
  • On precedent-setting: The opinion applies established principles (including the authority cited) rather than announcing a novel legal principle; it does not purport to set a new, broader precedent beyond the facts of this case.

No order as to costs was made by the Court in the circumstances of this case.

    Dr. A.K Datta (Petitioner) v. Union Of India And Others (S).

    G.N Roy, J.:— This Rule is directed against a departmental inquiry being conducted against the petitioner in terms of memo No. 88.CVC/71 CDE(D), dated 6th of July 1973 issued by Shri D.N Pande, the Commissioner for departmental enquiries being Annexure ‘N’ to the writ petition. The petitioner in the instant Rule is a Zoologist serving Zoological Survey of India. The said officer was charge sheeted by Shri S.P Josh Joshi, Deputy Secretary, Government of India, Ministry of Education, by his Memo dated 12th of March, 1969 being annexure ‘C’ to the writ petition. It will appear from the statement of article of charges framed against the petitioner that four charges were framed against the petitioner for various lapses alleged in the said statement of articles of charges. Along with the said charge sheet a statement of imputation of misconduct or his behaviour in respect of the Articles of charges made against the petitioner was also forwarded to the petitioner and a list of documents by which the articles of charges framed against the petitioner were proposed to be sustained was also enclosed with the charge sheet. Along with the charge sheet a list of witnesses by whom the articles of charges framed against the petitioner were proposed to be sustained was also forwarded to the petitioner. It appears that out of ten documents referred to in annexure 3 to the charge sheet a letter of Station Master, Nadbai, was also one of the documents proposed to be relied upon by the department. The Station Master, Nadbai, also appears to be one of the witnesses by whom the articles of charges were proposed to be proved.

    2. It appears that the petitioner asked for inspection of the documents referred to in the said annexure 3 including the letter of the Station Master, Nadbai, but the department could not give inspection to the said letter of the Station Master, Nadbai, in view of the fact that the said letter was misplaced and could not be found out. It also appears that despite the petitioner's repeated requests for supply of the copies of the statement of the witnesses referred to in annexure 4 to the charge sheet, statements of three witnesses had not bests supplied to the petitioner. The petitioner also wanted to rely on a number of documents which were in the custody of the Government for the purpose of his defence against the proposed departmental inquiry. But it appears that only one document bearing serial No. 2 had been inspected by the petitioner and the document bearing serial No. 1 could of be inspected by the petitioner and the said document in reported to be missing and efforts were being made to trace the original. So far as the other documents bearing serial Nos. 3 to 8 and 10 to 19 are concerned, the aforesaid documents had been lying in the Record Room of the Old Court Building of the Sub Judge, Jaipur and due to some misconception, the petitioner could not get any inspection of the said documents out from the affidavit in-opposition, it appears that such documents may be available for inspection by requisitioning the said documents from the court of the Sub Judge, Jaipur. It further appears that although the statements of three witnesses relied on by the prosecution for drawing the charge sheet against the petitioner had not been supplied to the petitioner despite demands made therefor and although one of the documents relied on by the prosecution in drawing the charge sheet against the petitioner could not be made available for inspection of the petitioner because of the misplacement of the said document as referred to hereinbefore, by the impugned memo it was direct that the oral inquiry would be held on 6th to 10th of August 1973 and witnesses would be examined on the said dates and if the inquiry would not be concluded within the aforesaid dates the inquiry would continue from day to day until the same was concluded.

    3. Mr. Gupta the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner (submits that under the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules it is incumbent for the Inquiring Officer and/or the Government to supply the copies of the statements of witnesses and the documents on the basis of which the charge sheet had been framed by the Government against the petitioner. Mr. Gupta further submits that the inquiring authority and/or the department was bound to supply such statement of witnesses and/or to give inspection of such documents so as to enable the petitioner to prepare his defence in the said inquiry proceeding and to effectively cross examine the witnesses proposed to be examined by the prosecution and to lead evidence on his behalf.

    4. Mr. Gupta contended that in the instant case it is quite clear and evident that the statement of three witnesses proposed to be examined by the prosecution against the petitioner in the departmental inquiry have not been supplied to the petitioner. Further, a document referred to in annexure 3 to the charge sheet being a letter of the Station Master, Nadbai, was not made available to the petitioner for inspection on the ground that the said document was misplaced. Mr. Gupta also points out that large number of documents called for by the petitioner from the custody of the Government for the purpose of his defence were also not yet made available to the petitioner for inspection but in spite of such facts, the Inquiring Officer was proceeding to continue the departmental inquiry proceeding and start examination of witnesses to serious loss and prejudice of the petitioner. Mr. Gupta submitted that the statement of the witnesses and the document referred to in annexures 3 and 4 to the charge-sheet form the basis on which the charge-sheet was drawn against the petitioner and until and unless inspection of the documents referred to the said annexures are given to the petitioner and the copies of the statement of all the witnesses referred to in the said annexure 4 are supplied to the petitioner, the departmental proceeding cannot continue and any attempt to continue the departmental proceeding without furnishing such statements of the witnesses and without giving inspection of the documents referred to in annexure 3 will amount to violation of the statutory Rules framed for such departmental inquiry under Article 309 of the Constitution of India and also violation of the principles of natural justice. In support of his contention Mr. Gupta relied on a decision of this court made in the case of Collector of Customs v. Biswanath kfukhegee, reported in (1974) C.L.J 251. In the said decision a large number of decisions of this court and other, Courts, including Supreme Court of India, were considered and it was held that violation of rule 14 sub-rule (8) of the said Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules amounted to denial of reasonable opportunity to defend the delinquent officer and as such, such violation vitiated the departmental inquiry proceeding.

    5. Mr. Roy Chowdhury the learned Advocate appearing for the respondent, however, contends that out of ten documents referred to in Annexure 3 only one document was not made available to the petitioner for inspection because the said document was misplaced. Mr. Roy Chowdhury further stated that although inspection of a large number of documents called for by the petitioner could not be made available because of non-availability of the records at the time of issuing the Rule have now been found out and it will appear from the statement made in the affidavit-in-opposition that a number of documents lying in the court of the Sub Judge learned Sub Judge of Jaipur will be made available to the petitioner for inspection Mr. Roy Choudhurj submits that although the petitioner did not get inspection of one of the documents relied on by the prosecution and the petitioner was also not supplied with the statement of three witnesses relied on by the prosecution for framing the charges and although some of the documents called for by the petitioner were do not made available to the petitioner for inspection the departmental proceeding itself is not vitiated and the petitioner is bound to appear in the said departmental proceeding and to file his written defence. Mr. Roy Chowdhury submits that if there is no inherent lack of jurisdiction in issuing a charge sheet and/or initiating a departmental proceeding then the said departmental proceeding must continue and the petitioner may make submissions about the prejudice suffered by him for non-supply of certain documents and/or for not giving inspection of certain documents and it is for the Inquiring Officer to adjudicate in the facts and circumstances of the case. Mr. Roy Chowdhury submitted that the in start Rule must fail because the petitioner is not entitled to challenge the departmental inquiry proceeding at this stage. M. Roy Chowdhury contends that the Inquiring Officer on noting the submissions made by the petitioner may adjudicate in favour of the petitioner and in that event there may not be any occasion for the petitioner to move this Court in its ??? writ jurisdiction that if, on the other hand, the adjudication is made by the officer concerned against the petitioner he may move this Court and ventilate his grievances by pointing out the irregularities committed in the departmental proceeding and it is only at that stage this Court will interfere in its Constitutional writ jurisdiction.

    6. I am unable to accept this contention of Mr. Roy Chowdury if for violation of statutory rules and/or principles of natural justice, a departmental proceeding is liable 10 be quashed by this Court there is no sense in asking the petitioner to suffer the agony of the departmental proceeding and then come to this Court for ventilating his grievance on me irregularities which obviously vitiate the proceeding. It may be noted in this connection that the petitioner has not taken part in the inquriy proceeding by examining and/or cross-examining the witnesses. Hence there is no question of acquiescence. For breach of statutory rules and violation of principle of natural justice the petitioner has moved this Courts at the earliest opportunity and before further continuance of the inquiry proceeding and in my view the petitioner has moved, this Court at the proper stage. It is quite clear and evident in the facts and circumstances of the case that statement of three witnesses relied on by the prosecution for the purpose of framing the charge-sheet has not been supplied to the petitioner. It also quite clear that the letter of the Station Mastei, Nadbai, on the basis of which one of the charges were framed against the petitioner was not made available to the petitioner for inspection because of the alleged misplacement of the said document. There is no doubt that the petitioner is seriously prejudiced for non-supply of the aforesaid statement of the witnesses and for failure to give inspection of the documents in question. The petitioner is also seriously handicapped in submitting his defences in the said departmental inquiry and/or effectively cross-examining the witnesses proposed to be examined by the department in the departmental proceeding and/or in leading his evidences in the proceeding. Accordingly, in my view, the departmental proceeding cannot continue without supply of the statement of witnesses and/or of the giving inspection of the aforesaid documents to the petitioner.

    7. The Rule is, therefore, made absolute but in the facts and circumstances of the case I make no order as to costs.

    8. Rule made absolute.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dr. A.K Datta (Petitioner) v. Union Of India And Others (S).
    (Jan 16, 1978)