Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Section 5(3) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, in the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules
  • rule 15(1) of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1955.7.
  • 1956.14. Rule 3 of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules
  • Section 5(3) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947
  • 15(1) of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules
  • Central Civil Service (Conduct) Rules, 1955,
  • Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Section 5(3) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, in the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules
  • rule 15(1) of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1955.7.
  • 1956.14. Rule 3 of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules
  • Section 5(3) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947
  • 15(1) of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules
  • Central Civil Service (Conduct) Rules, 1955,
  • Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules
Smart Summary

Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The Central Government, exercising powers under the proviso to Article 309 and clause (5) of Article 148 of the Constitution and after consultation with the Controller and Auditor-General concerning the Indian Audit and Accounts Department, promulgated the Central Civil Service (Conduct) Rules, 1955. The rules were made on 7 March 1955 and published in the Gazette of India on 12 March 1955. They were circulated by the Central Board of Revenue and later by the Customs Office in Calcutta to officers in 1955.

The petitioner, Shri Sripati Ranjan Biswas (S.R. Biswas), was appointed a Preventive Officer on 18 September 1950, later promoted to Appraiser and confirmed on 22 October 1956. He purchased a plot of land on 15 March 1955 and, according to his account, first informed the Collector of Customs of the purchase by letter dated 27 August 1956. He subsequently began submitting annual asset statements and applied for permission before construction commenced in January 1958. Construction was begun in April 1959 and completed at an asserted cost of Rs. 21,000.

The petitioner was suspended on 4 December 1961 and charged on 22 January 1962 with three charges: (I) accepting illegal gratification on specified dates in 1959–1960; (II) possessing assets disproportionate to known sources of income during 1950–1960; and (III) acquiring immovable property on 15 March 1955 without previous knowledge/sanction or in contravention of Rule 15(1) of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1955.

An Enquiry Officer was appointed, witnesses were examined and the petitioner heard. The Enquiry Officer found the petitioner guilty of Charges II and III, but not guilty of Charge I. The Collector of Customs accepted the findings, called upon the petitioner to show cause, and ultimately dismissed the petitioner from service. The petitioner petitioned the court under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking certiorari to quash the dismissal and mandamus restraining its implementation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Rule 3 of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1955 is vague or indefinite and therefore violative of Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution.
  2. Whether the Enquiry Officer relied upon impermissible presumptions and speculation, rather than legal evidence, in finding the petitioner guilty of possessing assets disproportionate to known sources of income (Charge II).
  3. Whether the petitioner could be held to have contravened Rule 15(1) for acquiring immovable property on 15 March 1955 when the rules were promulgated on 7 March 1955 and circulated to local offices later in 1955, and whether lack of prior knowledge of the rules absolves him from charge III.
  4. What is the appropriate standard of proof and allocation of burden where a public servant claims that excess assets were received from a private source (e.g., gifts from family) rather than acquired by corrupt means?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Mr. S. Roy)

  • Rule 3 of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules is vague and indefinite and therefore contravenes Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution.
  • The finding of guilt on Charge II was based on presumptions and hypothesis, not on admissible legal evidence.
  • The petitioner could not have been expected to comply with Rule 15(1) in relation to the purchase on 15 March 1955 because he only came to know of the promulgation and circulation of the rules on or about 27 August 1956 (per his account), and therefore should not be held guilty of Charge III.

Respondents' Position (as reflected in the Enquiry and record)

  • The rules were promulgated on 7 March 1955, published 12 March 1955, circulated by central offices in April–June 1955, and thus the petitioner had ample opportunity to know of them after June 11, 1955.
  • Evidence produced at the enquiry established the petitioner's total income for the relevant period and the value of assets acquired. The Enquiry Officer computed income and expenditure and found substantial unexplained surplus assets, concluding they were disproportionate to known income.
  • The petitioner failed to satisfactorily prove his special defence (that excess assets derived from gifts or family funds), leaving the respondents' evidence of disproportionation intact and supporting conviction on Charge II.
  • Regarding Charge III, the Enquiry Officer treated the rules as in operation before the purchase date and found the petitioner did not inform authorities promptly after becoming aware of the rules, treating that delayed disclosure as evidence against bona fides.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a focused examination of the legal and evidentiary contentions raised.

On Rule 3 (vagueness and constitutional challenge): The court interpreted Rule 3's language ("Every Government servant shall at all times maintain absolute integrity and devotion to duty.") and explained that "integrity" denotes uprightness and honesty, while "devotion to duty" denotes faithful service. The court rejected the contention that modern administrative complexity renders the rule void for vagueness. It stated that a public officer is not at liberty to amass fortune by taking illegal gratifications and that Rule 3 does not offend Articles 14 or 19 of the Constitution.

On Charge II (disproportionate assets): The Enquiry Officer compiled the petitioner's income for the period 18 September 1950 to 15 September 1960, initially listing documented pay and allowances and additional claimed items. The Enquiry Officer adjusted certain claimed items (notably reducing the overtime claim from Rs. 8,000 to Rs. 5,992.75 as proved and accepting only a small sum for rewards). The Enquiry Officer then assessed expenditure items (food, clothing, education, rent, insurance premium etc.) to arrive at total expenditure, computed a residual surplus, and compared that surplus with the total assets acquired by the petitioner over the period. The Enquiry Officer found a significant excess of assets over the computed available surplus (assets of Rs. 59,242.72 vs. surplus of Rs. 7,519.41 as per his calculations), concluding that the excess must have been acquired by corrupt and illegal means and convicting on Charge II.

The court considered petitioner’s criticisms that the Enquiry Officer relied on presumptions, and carefully reviewed contested items: (a) the cost of construction (disputed witnesses estimated Rs. 21,000 vs. Rs. 43,000), and (b) the petitioner's claim of receiving Rs. 30,000 from his father via his mother. The Enquiry Officer disbelieved certain defence witnesses for credibility reasons and found insufficient positive evidence that second-hand materials materially reduced construction cost. He also accepted at most Rs. 15,000 (if any) from parents toward construction, leaving a large unexplained remainder.

The court recognized that the petitioner argued the burden of disproving the defence was shifted onto him, pointing to Section 5(3) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 (which creates a statutory presumption where disproportionate assets are proved). The court found that, in the administrative inquiry context, the respondents had proved disproportionate assets by evidence and the petitioner failed to prove his special defence (i.e., that excess assets came from family gifts). The court held that while the respondents bear the onus to prove the offence, a specific defence of private source for excess assets must be proved by the petitioner; consequently the handling of burden of proof in this enquiry was acceptable in the factual matrix before the Enquiry Officer.

On Charge III (acquisition of immovable property without prior sanction): The court analyzed the temporal facts: rules promulgated 7 March 1955 and circulated to officers (Calcutta Customs notified officers) by 11 June 1955 according to respondents' affidavit; the petitioner purchased the land on 15 March 1955. The Enquiry Officer considered the rules to be in operation prior to the purchase date and criticized the petitioner for informing the Collector only on 27 August 1956, treating the delay as evidence against bona fides.

The court identified a critical legal error in the Enquiry Officer's approach: once the transaction (the purchase on 15 March 1955) was complete, the petitioner could not have obtained "previous knowledge" or "prior sanction" before that past transaction; and informing the authority after completion cannot retroactively supply the prior sanction required by Rule 15(1). The Enquiry Officer also suggested he might have taken a lenient view had the petitioner informed the authority immediately after the notification, but the court observed that after-completion disclosure cannot cure the absence of "previous" sanction required by the rule. Therefore the court concluded the finding of guilt on Charge III was erroneous on its face.

Standard of review and appellate restraint: The court acknowledged it might have seen the evidence differently on reappraisal (e.g., costs of construction, credibility of witnesses), but in writ jurisdiction it would not substitute its own assessment of credibility for that of the Enquiry Officer where the Enquiry Officer had considered evidence and reached a rational conclusion. Nevertheless, where a legal error was apparent on the face (as in Charge III), the court exercised corrective jurisdiction.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The court quashed the report of inquiry in respect of Charge No. III, upheld the finding on Charge No. II, and issued directions for reconsideration of penalty in light of Charge II alone.

Specific orders and immediate effects:

  • A writ of certiorari issues quashing the Enquiry Officer's report to the extent it finds Charge No. III proved.
  • A writ of mandamus issues directing the Collector of Customs (respondent No. 1) to reconsider the appropriate penalty to be imposed upon the petitioner on the basis of conviction for Charge No. II alone. The Collector may either maintain the penalty already imposed or impose any other appropriate penalty after reconsideration, taking into account the court's observations.
  • In the meantime, the petitioner will continue to remain under the order of dismissal (i.e., no interim reinstatement was directed by the court).
  • There will be no order as to costs.

Broader implications: The opinion does not purport to set a new general precedent beyond these findings. It affirms that administrative rules requiring prior sanction cannot be applied retroactively to bar conduct that occurred before a requirement for "previous sanction" could have been complied with, and it confirms that where administrative enquiries establish disproportionate assets, a respondent must satisfactorily prove any special defence as to private-source funds. The court also upheld Rule 3 against vagueness challenges under Articles 14 and 19.

    Sripati Ranjan Biswas v. Collector Of Customs And Others .

    1. In exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 and cl. (5) of Article 148 of-the Constitution and after consultation with the Controller and Auditor-General in relation to persons serving in the Indian Audit and Accounts Department, the President was pleased to make on set of rules known as the Central Civil Service (Conduct) Rules, 1955, providing, inter alia, for a code of conduct for certain classes of civil servants.

    2. It is undisputed that the rules were made on 7th March 1955 and were published in the Gazette of India on 12th March 1955. According to the affidavit to opposition, the rules were circulated by the Central Board of Revenue to different offices subordinate to it on 22nd April 1955, and by the Customs Office in Calcutta to its officers on 11th June 1955. The petitioner alleges that he came to know of the rules on 27th August, 1956 but I would much rather proceed on the basis that the rules were brought to the notice of the petitioner either on 11th June 1955 or shortly thereafter or that the petitioner Shad ample opportunity of knowing of the rules after 11th June 1955.

    3. The circumstances under which the petitioner was said to have come within the mischief of the rules are hereinafter stated in brief. The petitioner was at first appointed as a preventive officer, at the Calcutta Customs House on 18th September 1950. He was, thereafter, promoted as an Appraiser and was confirmed in that post on 22nd October 1956. While serving as a Preventive Officer, the petitioner alleges, he entered into a contract with one Dr. Durgadas Chakravarty for purchase of a plot of land, measuring about 3 cottahs, at No. 32/22 Chandi Ghosh Road, Tollygunge, for Rs. 2700 and did purchase the land on 15th March 1955. The petitioner further alleges that at that time he did not know of the promulgation of the rules and therefore there was no occasion for him to inform the authorities about the transaction. The petitioner also alleges that as soon as he came to know of the rules, he Snformed the Collector of Customs about the purchase of the land by a letter, dated 27th August 1956, and therein stated that the major portion of the purchase price of Rs. 2700 came out of his ancestral funds. The petitioner says that thereafter he began submitting his yearly statement of assets and before starting construction he took the necessary permission of the authorities by an application, dated 28th January 1958. According to the petitioner, he started construction on the above-mentioned land in April, 1959 and completed the construction at a cost or Rs. 21,000/-. About two years thereafter the petitioner was suspended, on December 4, 1961, in view of a contemplated disciplinary action against him and was put on subsistence allowance. Thereafter, on January 22, 1962, the petitioner was charged with three charges of misconduct as stated herein below:

    Charge I.

    4. That Shri Sripati Ranjan Biswas, alias S.R Biswas, while functioning as an Appraiser in the Calcutta Customs, during the period 1959 and 1960 committed gross misconduct in the discharge of his duties as a Public Servant, in that he, by abusing his position as a Public Servant demanded and accepted a sum of Rs. 50/- on 27-5-59, Rs. 500/- on or about 25-11-59 and Rs. 500/- on or about 1-12.59 as illegal gratification from Shri K. Kutty Nair, Managing Director of K. Kutty Nair and Co. (P) Ltd., as consideration for passing his shipping bills on three occasions for the export of lac products.

    Charge II.

    5. That the said Shri Sripati Ranjan Biswas alias S.R Biswas, while functioning as a Preventive Officer Grade II, and an Appraiser, under Calcutta Customs, during the period 18-9-50 to 30-9-60, had failed to maintain absolute integrity and devotion, to duty inasmuch as he was in possession of assets which were found to be disproportionate to the extent of about Rs. 59,661/- for which he could not lender any satisfactory explanation, thereby leading the presumption that he acquired those assets by of Customs (B.N Banerjee J.) A.I.R corrupt and illegal means in the discharge of his duties.

    Charge III.

    6. That Shri Sripati Ranjan Biswas alias S.R Biswas, while functioning as an Appraiser under Calcutta Customs during the years 1955 to 1980, committed gross misconduct as a Public Servant in that he acquired on 15-3-55 a plot of land measuring 3 kattahs at 32/22, Chandi Ghosh Road, in his own name without the previous knowledge and sanction of the prescribed authority and had thereby contravened rule 15(1) of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1955.

    7. The petitioner put his written defence to the charges denying each one of them. The respondent No. 1, Collector of Customs, thereupon appointed respondent No. 2, an Assistant Collector, to conduct the enquiry against the petitioner. Witnesses were examined before the Enquiry Officer, the petitioner was heard in person and ultimately the Enquiring Officer found the petitioner guilty of charges Nos. II and III and not guilty of charge No. I. The reasons that weighed with the Enquiring Officer in finding the petitioner guilty of Charge No. II are hereinafter stated.

    8. According to the statement of allegations, served along with the charge sheet, the petitioner's total income during September 18, 1950 to September 15, 1960 was Rs. 46,618.66 nP. consisting of:

    (i) Pay and allowances … Rs. 41,449.11 nP. (ii) Overtime allowances … Rs. 2,167.55 nP. (ili) Reward … Rs. 30.00 (iv) House rent allowance … Rs. 2,000.00 (v) Insurance policy matured … Rs. 970.00 Total … Rs. 46,616.66 nP.

    According to the petitioner over and above the aforesaid amounts, his income during the same period amounted to Rs. 9,178/-, more as per details herein below:

    (i) Overtime duty income during Sept. 18, 1950 to June, 1954 … Rs. 8,000/- (ii) Other rewards and allowances like uniform allowances and posting allowances … Rs. 450/- (iii) Interest on bank account … Rs. 728/- Total … Rs. 9,178/-

    In the absence of evidence the Enquiring Officer proceeded on the basis of some sort of average and found that in place of Rs. 8000/- the petitioner's overtime allowance, during September 1950 to June 1964, amounted to an additional sum of Rs. 5,992.75 nP. As regards rewards the Enquiring Officer took an Additional sum of Rs. 25/- only as proved. The Esquiring Officer did not accept the theory of increased income on account of uniform allowances and posting allowances, because, according to him, the aforesaid sums must have been pent by the petitioner on uniform and in journeys. The total income of the petitioner during the aforesaid period was ultimately found to be Rs. 52,634.41 nP. consisting of:

    (i) Pay and allowances … Rs. 41,449.11 nP. (ii) Overtime allowances … Rs. 8,160.30 nP. (iii) Rewards … … Rs. 55.00 (iv) House rent allowances … Rs. 2,000.00 (v) Insurance Policy matured… … Rs. 970.00 Total Rs. 52,634.41 nP.

    9. As to expenditure incurred by the petitioner during the period the Enquiring Officer found that the petitioner spent on—

    (i) Food and clothing … Rs. 30,700/- (ii) Education … … Rs. 2,050/- (iii) Electric charges… … Rs. 720/- (iv) House rent… … Rs. 6,880/- (v) Insurance premium … Rs. 4,765/- Total: … Rs. 45,115/-

    10. According to the Enquiring Officer the petitioner was left with a surplus income of Rs. 7,519.41 nP. (Rs. 52,534.41 nP. — Rs. 44,115) only. As against that, the assets acquired by the petitioner during the period amounted to Rs. 59,242.72 nP. as per details given below:

    (i) Land… … Rs. 2,700.00 (ii) Building… … Rs. 43,000.00 (iii) Bank balance … Rs. 11,947.72 nP. (iv) Postal bond… … Rs. 170.00 (v) Radio… … Rs. 300.00 (vi) Gold ornaments … Rs. 700.00 (vii) Sofa Settee… … Rs. 425.00 Total : Rs. 59,242.72 nP.

    Thus according to the Enquiring Officer, the assets of the petitioner exceeded his income by Rs. 51,723.51 nP. The Enquiring Officer, therefore, found that the petitioner must have acquired the excess by illegal means to the detriment of integrity in public service and was guilty of Charge No. II.

    11. So far as Charge No. III was concerned, the Enquiring Officer observed as follows:

    “It is, therefore, clear that the aforesaid Rules were promulgated on 7-3-55 and came into operation from that date i.e prior to the date of purchase of the land by Shu Biswas. As stated earlier the Custom House issued the Notification on 11-8-55. I would have taken a lenient view of the charge if Shri Biswas had informed the Collector of Customs about the transaction already entered into by him just after the date of issue of the Notification by the Customs House. But instead, he brought the matter to the knowledge of the Collector only on 27-9-56 i.e after a lapse of over 1 year. This does not speak of bona fides of the officer. Therefore, it has been abundantly brought out that Shri Biswas purchased the land through a channel other than reputed or regular dealer without previous knowledge and prior permission of the Collector of Customs. I, therefore, hold the charge having been proved against him. The Collector of Customs accepted the finding made by the Enquiring Officer. He, therefore, called upon the petitioner to show cause why he should not be dismissed from service. After considering the cause shown, the respondent Collector of Customs dismissed the petitioner from service.

    12. Aggrieved by the order of dismissal, the petitioner moved this Court, under Article 226 of the Constitution, praying for a writ of certiorari for the quashing of the order and for a writ of Mandamus restraining the respondents from giving effect thereto and obtained this rule.

    13. Mr. S. Roy, learned advocate for the petitioner, argued two points in support of this view. He criticised R. 3 of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules as vague and indefinite and as such, violative of Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution. He further contended that the petitioner was found guilty of Charge No. II on presumption and hypothesis and not on legal evidence. He also contended that the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules could not be brought to the notice of the petitioner prior to 27th August, 1956 and he should not have been found guilty of violation of R. 15 of the rules in respect of purchase of the land made on 15th March, 1956.

    14. Rule 3 of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules is set out below:

    “3. General Every Government servant shall at all times maintain absolute integrity and devotion to duty.”

    Integrity is uprightness, honesty or purity. Devotion to duty is faithful service. Modern approaches to life have changed many ideals, which used to be held sacred. Such approaches have also worked a change in our sense of the sublime. But even then the idea of right and wrong has not been forgotten and the difference between honesty and dishonesty, fidelity and faithfulness wholly lost. It is sometimes argued with sophistry that it is difficult to prescribe the outside limits of integrity in a complex system of modern administration, in which considerations of expediency occasionally outweigh other considerations. Considerations of expediency may be irresistible at times but their evils are merely to be put up with and not to be extolled or prescribed as standards of life and work. If a public officer is required to maintain integrity and to be devoted to duty, he is merely asked to keep within the bounds of that administrative decency, which goes by the name of civilized administration. In my opinion, no vagueness or indefiniteness attaches to the language used in R. 3 above quoted. A public officer is not at liberty to amass fortune by taking illegal gratifications, even though willingly given. In the view taken by me, R. 3 does not offend against Article 14 or 19 of the Constitution.

    15. There is, however, an edge in the other branch of the argument of Mr. Roy that the Enquiring Officer proceeded against the petitioner on the basis-of presumptions and speculations. In finding out how much the construction of the house had cost, the Enquiring Officer was confronted with two contrary sets of evidence. The petitioner alleged that some old and second-hand materials were used in the construction and that considerably reduced the cost. According to the witnesses examined by the petitioner, one of them an Engineer, the costs amounted to Rs. 21,000 only. According to the witnesses examined by the respondents, the costs amounted to Rs. 43,000. The Enquiring Officer disbelieved the Engineer examined by the petitioner merely because he was interested in the petitioner, being a friend of his son. So far as the use of old materials in construction was concerned, the Enquiring Officer observed as follows:

    A. ‘It has also been urged in defence that certain smaller size of Jhama, old brick, old brick bats had also been used. No positive evidence had been adduced. However, these materials could not be used other than for foundation and plinth of the building. Even if certain quantities of them had at all been used I do not think the price structure would be affected to any appreciable extent.”

    B. “Incidentally I would mention that at the time of inspection Shri Biswas drew my attention to 2 or 3 windows in a bed room and urged that they were of second-hand C.P Teak wood. He also told me that the door and window frames are of Sal wood. Although the colour of these windows were slightly faded I could not make out whether they were second-hand C.P teak wood. I have carefully seen the doors and windows of 1st floor. All of them are coloured with green paint and as such I could not determine as to whether the frames were of C.P or Sal wood. The veracity or otherwise of the defence contention could have been verified if certain portion of some doors and windows would have been clipped off before or at the time of my inspection. If Shri Biswas were certain of his contention he would have done so. In view of the above and in the absence of positive evidence I am not prepared to accent his story of use of old and second-hand materials.”

    This is not a very satisfactory way of bringing home a charge. The Enquiring Officer was not himself very positive in his views. If I had appellate powers. I might not have agreed with the conclusion of the Enquiring Officer. But the Enquiring Officer discussed evidence and based his conclusion on his view of credibility of witnesses. I cannot, sitting in writ jurisdiction, substitute my own appraisement of evidence, in place of the appraisement made by the Enquiring Officer.

    16. The other criticism made by Mr. Roy that the Enquiring Officer was wrong in disbelieving that the petitioner had received Rs. 30,000 from his father, through his mother, for construction of the house must also fail on similar grounds. The Enquiring Officer considered the evidence on the point and came to the conclusion that the petitioner had received no more than Rs. 15,000, if he did receive any amount at all from his father or mother, for the construction of the house. Even with that money received a sum of Rs. 36,723 worth of assets remained unaccounted.

    17. Faced with this difficulty, Mr. Roy argued that the onus of disproving the charge was wrongly placed on the petitioner. He invited my attention to Section 5(3) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 which reads as follows:

    “Section 5(3): in any trial of an offence punishable under sub-sec. (2) the fact that the accused person or any other person on his behalf is in possession, for which the accused person cannot satisfactorily account, of pecuniary resources or property disproportionate to his known sources of income may be proved, and on such proof the Court shall presume unless the contrary is proved, that the accused person is guilty of criminal misconduct in the discharge of his official duty and his conviction therefor shall not be invalid by reason only that it is based solely on such presumption.”

    He contended that there was no provision, similar to the provision of Section 5(3) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, in the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules and the respondents must prove the charges themselves and must not be allowed to depend upon presumptions. This criticism is not very well conceived in the facts and circumstances of this case. The respondents proved by evidence that the assets I acquired by the petitioner were disproportionate to his income. The petitioner wanted to explain away the disproportionateness by leading evidence to the effect that the excess had been received as gift from his father or mother. This he failed to prove in a way acceptable to the Enquiring Officer. The onus is not on the respondents to disprove the defence. The special defence set up by the petitioner must be proved by the petitioner himself. Therefore, although the onus is on the respondents to prove the charge, they succeeded in doing so, in the instant case, in a way satisfactory to the Enquiring Officer.

    18. Regarding the third charge, Mr. Roy contended that the purchase had been effected on March 15, 1955. The Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules were published in the Gazette of India of March 7, 1955, were circulated by the Central Board of Revenue on April 22, 1955 and were circulated by the Customs Office in Calcutta to its officers on Judo 11, 1955. But, he contended, the petitioner came to know of the same on August 27, 1956 and immediately thereafter informed the Collector about the purchase. I have already held that if the rules were circulated on June 11, 1955, the petitioner should have come to know of the same on that day or shortly thereafter. Now, R. 15(1) of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules is in the following language:

    “15(1). No Government servant shall, except: with the previous knowledge of the prescribed authority, acquire or dispose of any immovable property by lease, mortgage, purchase, sale, gift or otherwise, either in his own name or in the name of any member of his family:

    Provided that any such transaction conducted otherwise than through a regular or reputed dealer shall require the previous sanction of the prescribed authority.”

    If the petitioner had come to know of the rules on, June 11, 1955, it was not possible for him to apply for previous sanction of the prescribed authority before he purchased the land on March 15, 1955. The Enquiring Officer observed that he would have taken a lenient view of the matter, if the petitioner had in formed the prescribed authority of the transaction immediately after he came to know of the rules. The Enquiring Officer forgets that after completion of the transaction, no previous sanction of the prescribed authority could be taken and no occasion arose for the petitioner to apply for sanction after the event. In my opinion the finding of the Enquiring Officer of Charge No. HI is erroneous on the face of it and should not be sustained.

    19. The petitioner was penalised on being found; guilty of two charges, namely, Charge No. II and Charge No. III. I do not know what penalty would have been imposed upon him by the respondent No. 1, if he had been found guilty of charge No. II only.

    20. In the circumstances of this case I quash the-report of Enquiry so far as Charge III is concerned and direct the respondent No. 1 to consider the-appropriate penalty which should be imposed upon, the petitioner, on Charge No. II only.

    21. Let a writ of certiorari accordingly issue quashing the report of inquiry on Charge No. III. Let a writ of Mandamus also issue on the respondent No. 1 directing him to re-consider the penalty to be imposed upon the petitioner in the light of the observations contained in the judgment. If he does not find any reason to change his views on the penalty already imposed, he may maintain the same otherwise he may impose any other appropriate penalty on the petitioner.

    22. In the meantime, the petitioner shall continue to remain under order of dismissal.

    23. There will be no order as to costs.

    FH/H.G.P/R.G.D

    24. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sripati Ranjan Biswas v. Collector Of Customs And Others .
    (Jul 15, 1963)