Basheer, J.
This appeal, which is at the instance of the State is
directed against an interim order passed by a learned Single
Judge in W.P.(C) No. 18671 OF 2009.
2. By the impugned order the learned Single Judge has
directed the appellants to release respondent's vehicle on
depositing a sum of Rs.25,000/-, if the said amount had not
already been deposited by him pursuant to the order passed
by the District Collector.
3. Sri.Ranjith Thampan, learned Additional Advocate
General submits that the learned Single Judge ought to have
imposed more stringent conditions while releasing vehicles
involved in illegal transportation of sand, in order to ensure
that such interim orders work as deterrents especially since
degradation of bio-diversity is involved in such offence. He
invites our attention to the judgments of the Apex Court in
this regard.
4. Having heard learned Additional Advocate General
WA No.2578 of 2009
and learned counsel for the respondent we are of the view that,
the interim order passed by the learned Single Judge can be
modified to some extent.
5. It is brought to our notice that the vehicle has been
valued at Rs.1,00,000/- and the respondent has deposited a sum
of Rs.25,000/- before the District Collector way back in March
2009, as a condition for interim custody as directed by the
District Collector. However, the vehicle was not released for
nearly three months. Ultimately, the District Collector, at the
teeth of contempt proceedings, passed a final order ordering
confiscation of the vehicle. It was at that stage the present Writ
Petition was filed by the respondent. The learned Single Judge,
after considering the entire aspects of the matter, has passed the
impugned order indicated above.
6. Having regard to the peculiar facts and circumstances of
the case we are of the view that, the interim order passed by the
learned Single Judge may be modified slightly. Therefore, it is
directed that the respondent's vehicle, bearing registration No.KL
10-C-2689, shall be released to him on his depositing a sum of
Rs.25,000/-(Rupees twenty five thousand only) in addition to the
WA No.2578 of 2009
amount of Rs.25,000/- which is already in deposit and also on
executing a bond for the balance sum of Rs.50,000/- with two
solvent sureties in the like sum undertaking to produce the
vehicle as and when directed. The sureties shall produce current
basic tax receipt or such other document in respect of the
property evidencing non-encumbrance.
7. Having regard to the fact that large number of cases
involving illegal transportation of sand in violation of the
provisions contained in Kerala Protection of River Banks &
Regulation of Removal of Sand Act, 2001, we are of the view that
following guidelines/directions have to be issued with regard to
the release of vehicles that may be involved in such cases.
i. The vehicle shall be released to the registered
owner on his depositing half of the total value of the
vehicle as may be assessed by the Assistant Executive
Engineer(Mechanical), PWD as provided under Rule 4 of
the Kerala Abkari(Disposal of Confiscated Articles) Rules,
1996 or the Assistant Motor Vehicles Inspector.
ii. The registered owner shall execute a bond
furnishing security for the balance amount to the
WA No.2578 of 2009
satisfaction of the District Collector concerned. He shall
further undertake to produce the vehicle as and when
directed and also not to transfer/alienate the vehicle
pending the proceedings. It shall also be undertaken by
the registered owner that he will not cause any damage
to the vehicle so as to reduce its value and utility.
iii. If the vehicle gets involved in a similar offence
after such release, it shall be liable to immediate seizure,
in which event it shall not be released until finalisation of
the proceedings.
8. We make it clear that the above guidelines/directions
are not exhaustive. They are only intended to ensure that
adequate measures are taken to prevent recurrence of such
offences under the Act.
The Writ Appeal is disposed of as above.
S.R. Bannurmath,
Chief Justice.
A.K. Basheer,
Judge.
ttb
WA No.2578 of 2009