Petitioners in Crl.M.C. 1468/2009 are the accused
in C.C.494/2007 on the file of Additional Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram. Third
respondent is the de facto complainant therein. She is
the petitioner in Crl.R.P.2068/2009. Respondents
therein are the petitioners in Crl.M.C.1468/2009.
Crl.M.C.1468/2009 is filed to quash Annexure D First
Information Report No.55/2006 of Medical College
Police Station, registered on receipt of Annexure C
complaint filed by the third respondent before
Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate and forwarded for
investigation under section 156(3) of Code of Criminal
Procedure by the Magistrate. After investigation
Annexure E final report was filed alleging that
petitioners in Crl.M.C.1468/2009 committed the offence
under Section 498A read with section 34 of Indian Penal
Code. It is the admitted case that first petitioner
married third respondent on 18.1.2004 at
Thiruvananthapuram. It is the case of the revision
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 2
petitioner that at the time of marriage, 15 soverigns of
gold was given to first petitioner in the Crl.M.C, when
she was residing with the petitioners in the matrimonial
house at Coimbatore with the knowledge and consent of
petitioners 2 and 3, alleging that the dowry given was
insufficient, Rs.5 lakhs more was demanded and when third
respondent did not yield for the demand, she was treated
with cruelty, mentally and physically during the period
from 18.1.2004 to 7.5.2005, the day on which she was sent
back to her parental home at Thiruvananthapuram and all the
petitioners in the Crl.M.C thereby committed the offence.
Learned Magistrate took cognizance of the offence based on
the final report and issued summons to the petitioners.
Petitioners filed the Criminal M.C under section 482 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure contending that even if the
allegations in Annexure C complaint are accepted, no part
of the cause of action has arisen within the jurisdiction
of Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram
and as the prosecution case is that third respondent after
the marriage was taken to the matrimonial home at
Coimbatore and she was residing there till 7.5.2005 and the
cruelty alleged is during that period, the alleged cruelty
could only be at Coimbatore and Additional Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram has no jurisdiction to take
cognizance of the offence and therefore the cognizance
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 3
taken and all the proceedings taken on Annexure E final
report is to be quashed. Relying on the decisions of the
Apex Court in Y.Abraham Ajith and others v. Inspector of
Police, Chennai (2004) 8 SCC 100), Ramesh and others v.
State of T.N. (2005) 3 SCC 507), Manish Ratan and others v.
State of M.P and another (2007) 1 SCC 262 and Bhuraram and
others v. State of Rajasthan (2009(1) SCC Crl.109) it was
argued that on identical facts the Supreme Court, finding
that no part of cause of action has arisen within the
jurisdiction of the concerned Magistrate, who had taken
cognizance, quashed the complaint with liberty to the wife
to file a complaint before the competent court and
therefore the same procedure is to be followed and the case
is to be quashed. As the Supreme Court in Manish Ratan and
others case (supra) finding that part of the cause of
action has taken place within the jurisdiction of the
Magistrate who had taken cognizance, case was transferred
to the other court which has also jurisdiction to try the
case, as an alternative plea petitioners sought to
transfer the case to a court in Palghat District, which is
nearer to Coimbatore.
2. Third respondent, finding that the complaint and the
final report do not specifically disclose any cruelty meted
out to the third respondent at Thiruvananthapuram, filed
C.M.P 2890/2009 before the trial Magistrate under section
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 4
216 of Code of Criminal Procedure contending that the
mental cruelty inflicted by the first petitioner was not
confined to the period when she was residing at the
matrimonial home but it continued at Thiruvananthapuram
also and therefore the period in the charge framed by the
court is to be altered to that extent. In that application
third respondent also contended that there is material as
against the 6th respondent shown therein, who is not facing
trial as an accused in the case and contended that
charge is to be framed against him also. Under Annexur A4
order in Crl.R.P.2068/2009, learned Magistrate dismissed
the petition. Crl.R.P. 2068/2009 is filed challenging
Annexure A4 order.
3. Learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioners in Crl.M.C.1468/2009 and learned counsel
appearing for the revision petitioner in Crl.R.P.2068/2009
who is the third respondent in Crl.M.C.1468/2009 were heard.
4. As the decision in Crl.R.P.2068/2009 would have a
material bearing in the decision to be taken in
Crl.M.C.1468/2009, both the petitions were heard
together . The question whether the charge framed by the
Magistrate is to be altered as sought for by the revision
petitioner is to be decided first.
5. The argument of the learned counsel is that learned
Magistrate did not consider her application to alter the
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 5
charge in the proper perspective and without considering
the application on merit dismissed the petition for the
reason that Crl. M.C is pending before this court and if it
is allowed it would amount to contempt of court, which
cannot be the case and therefore the order is to be
quashed. It was vehemently argued by the learned counsel
that Section 216 of Code of Criminal Procedure enables the
Magistrate to alter or add to any charge, at any stage,
before pronouncing the judgment and when it is pointed out
to the learned Magistrate that the charge framed
restricts the commission of cruelty to the period upto
7.5.2005 and it is prima facie shown that it is not the
prosecution case and cruelty continued even thereafter the
charge should have been altered.
6. Eventhough a petition under section 216 of Code of
Criminal Procedure for alteration of the charge is
maintainable at any stage before pronouncing the judgment,
by such petition revision petitioner is not entitled to
get a third party impleaded as an accused so that a charge
could be framed as against him. After taking cognizance,
a Magistrate could add a person who is not facing trial as
an accused only as provided under section 319 of Code of
Criminal Procedure. The power under section 319 of Code of
Criminal Procedure could be exercised only if it appears
from the evidence collected during trial or inquiry that
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 6
some other person who is not arrayed as an accused in that
case, has committed the offence and that person should
also be tried for the same offence together with the
accused already facing trial (Michael Machado and another
v. C.B.I (AIR 2000 S.C 1127).The evidence contemplated
under section 319 is the evidence adduced before the court
during trial of the case and not the materials produced by
the prosecution based on which the charge was framed
(Ranjith Singh v. State of Punjab (AIR 1998 SC 3148). When
no evidence was let in before the Magistrate, there is no
question of invoking the power under section 319 and
without arraying that person as an accused, no charge can
be framed as against that person. Therefore the prayer to
frame a charge as against the 6th counter petitioner in the
CMP can only be rejected.
7. Though Section 216 of Code of Criminal Procedure
enables the court at any time before pronouncing the
judgment, to alter or add to any charge, that could only be
on the evidence before the Magistrate or on the materials
produced in the case and available before the court. The
charge was framed by the learned Magistrate under section
240 of Code of Criminal Procedure, on the materials made
available to him along with the final report submitted
under section 173(2) of Code of Criminal Procedure.
Thereafter the Magistrate can alter the charge or add to
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 7
the charge, invoking the power under section 216 of Code of
Criminal Procedure only if it is found that the charge so
framed by the Magistrate is not in accordance with the
materials produced before him or on any subsequent
evidence let in, it is found the charge framed is either
to be altered or to be added. When recording of evidence
in the case is yet to begin, learned Magistrate under
section 216 of Cr.P.C can alter the charge, only if the
materials produced along with the final report warrants an
alteration or addition to the charge already framed. No
document produced by the prosecutor or the de facto
complainant before the Magistrate, subsequent to taking
cognizance of the offence, could be looked into to
decide whether the charge framed is to be altered or
additional charge is to be framed. An alteration or
addition to the charge is warranted based on any such
additional material only on recording such evidence.
Therefore based on the document if any produced by the
revision petitioner alone, prosecution is not entitled to
seek alteration of the charge. The only question, in such
circumstance, is whether on the materials which were
available before the Magistrate, framing charge, the
charge so framed warrants alteration or addition. If that
be the case, when evidence was not recorded the charge
cannot be altered as sought for by the revision petitioner
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 8
when the charge framed is proper on the materials
available.
8. The complaint does not show that all the petitioners
or the first petitioner treated revision petitioner with
cruelty subsequent to 7.5.2005, the day on which she left
the matrimonial home. On the other hand, what was alleged
by the prosecution is only the cruelty before she was sent
to her parental home from the matrimonial home on 7.5.2005.
Learned counsel appearing for the revision petitioner
relying on the notice sent at the instance of the
petitioners and produced in the Criminal M.C argued that
the mental cruelty continued even after 7.5.2005 as it was
alleged in the said notice that the revision petitioner is
a sadist. But based on that document even if the
contention is accepted, at this stage, before the
evidence was recorded, the charge cannot be altered.
Therefore though the learned Magistrate did not dismiss
CMP 2890 of 2009 in the proper perspective, I find no
reason to interfere with the dismissal of the petition, for
the reasons stated above.Hence Crl.R.P.2068/2009 is
dismissed.
9. The case of the petitioners in Crl.M.C.1468/2009 is
that AdditionalChief Judicial Magistrate,Thiruvananthapuram
has no territorial jurisdiction to take cognizance of the
offence or try the offence under section 498A as the
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 9
cruelty alleged in Annexure C complaint as well as found on
investigation as is clear from Annexure E final report, is
the alleged cruelty which was meted out to her while the
third respondent was residing along with the petitioners at
Coimbatore during the period prior to 7.5.2005. It is
argued that therefore learned Additional Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram has no jurisdiction to take
cognizance of the offence or try the case. The argument of
the learned counsel appearing for the third respondent is
that if the complaint is read as a whole, it would
establish that the allegations is that the cruelty
continued not only at Coimbatore but at Thiruvananthapuram
also. The relevant pleading in paragraph 7 of the
complaint reads as follows:-
"It is submitted that since the
complainant and her parents did
not heed to the illegal demand
for more dowry the 1st accused
became more angry. Thereafter
the 1st accused started to abuse
the complainant and her family
members by most filthy
language. Lastly he threatened
that 'if your parents are not
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 10
amenable to satisfy the demand
raised by them don't think to
continue the marital
relationship any more' and
further threatened her to face
its dire consequences."
The argument of the learned counsel appearing for the third
respondent is that the allegations in paragraph 7 that
thereafter first accused started to abuse the complainant
and her family members by most filthy language refers to
the period subsequent to 7.5.2005, after the third
respondent was sent to her parental home and therefore the
prosecution case is not that the cruelty was at Coimbatore
alone but at Thiruvananthapuram also.
10. On reading paragraph 7 of the complaint I cannot
accept the submission of the learned counsel. What is
alleged in paragraph 7 is that the complainant and her
parents did not heed to the illegal demand made by first
accused for dowry and it caused first accused to get more
angry and thereafter first accused started abusing the
complainant and her family members. It is not that
first accused started to abuse the complainant and her
family after the third respondent was sent to her parental
home as canvassed by the learned counsel. If that be so,
in the absence of an allegation in Annexure C complaint or
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 11
the materials produced along with the final report filed
under section 173(2) that after 7.5.2005, the day on which
the third respondent returned to her parental home, from
the matrimonial home, first petitioner either approached
her at Thiruvananthapuram and treated her with cruelty or
contacted her over phone and abused her and thereby treated
her with cruelty it cannot be contended that the cruelty
continued at Thiruvananthapuram after 7.5.2005. If so the
cruelty alleged in Annexure C complaint as well as the
final report could only be understood as the cruelty
displayed by the petitioners and experienced by the third
respondent before 7.5.2005, the day on which she returned
to the parental home. If that be so, it can only be found
that the alleged cruelty was only at Coimbatore and did
not take place within the jurisdiction of Additional Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram.
11. Though learned counsel appearing for the third
respondent sought to rely on the notice sent by the first
petitioner subsequent to the filing of the complaint and
produced in the Criminal M.C, that notice was not produced
along with the complaint. In fact it was sent only after
Annexure E final report was filed before the court. Hence
it is not a material which could be looked into to find
out whether the cruelty alleged in Annexure A complaint
was during the period third respondent was staying at
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 12
Coimbatore alone or continued later at Thiruvananthapuram
also. Learned counsel appearing for the third respondent
pointed out that in Annexure A copy of the notice produced
by the petitioners, which was sent to the third
respondent by their lawyer, it is contended that third
respondent left the house in October, 2005 and thereafter
first petitioner contacted her over phone and based on that
fact it was argued that it cannot be said that the cruelty
did not continue at Thiruvananthapuram also, when there is
no allegation in the complaint that first petitioner had
contacted her over phone, after her return to
Thiruvananthapuram and then she was either abused or
scolded or treated with cruelty. Hence based on that
notice also it cannot be said that any part of the cause
of action has arisen within the jurisdiction of
Thiruvananthapuram Court.
12. Section 177 of Code of Criminal Procedure provides
that every offence shall ordinarily be tried by a court
within whose local jurisdiction it was committed. Section
178 provide the place of trial, when it is not certain in
which of several areas an offence was committed or when it
was committed partly in one area and partly in another
area. Section 178 reads:-
" Place of inquiry or trial-)a) When
it is uncertain in which of several
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 13
local areas an offence was
committed, or
(b) where an offence is committed
partly in one local area and partly
in another, or
(c) where an offence is a
continuing one, and continues to be
committed in more local areas than
one, or
(d) where it consists of several
acts done in different local areas,
it may be inquired into or tried by
a Court having jurisdiction over
any of such local areas."
As declared by the Apex Court in Purushottamdas Dalmia v.
State of W.B (AIR 1961 SC 1589), L. N. Mukherjee v. State Of Madras. (AIR 1961 SC 1601), Mohan Baitha v. State of Bihar
(2001) 4 SCC 350)the word 'ordinarily' used in Section 177
need not be limited to those specially provided for by the
law and exceptions may be provided by law on consideration
or may be implied from the law permitting joint trial of
offences by the same court. Ingredients constituting an
offence under section 498A of Indian Penal Code are
subjecting woman to cruelty by the husband or relatives of
the husband. Cruelty under Explanation (a) is wilful
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 14
conduct which is of such nature as is likely to drive her
to commit suicide or cause grave danger to life, limb or
physical or mental health of the woman. Under Explanation
(b) cruelty is harassment of the woman with a view to
coerce her or any person related to her to meet unlawful
demand for dowry.
13. Hence if any part of the cruelty provided under
section 498A has take place within the jurisdiction of that
court, the concerned Magistrate has jurisdiction to try the
offence. So also if parts of the cruelty has taken place
within the jurisdiction of several courts Magistrate having
jurisdiction of any of those local areas have jurisdiction
to try the offence as provided under Section 178. The
concept of cause of action is not alien to criminal cases.
Apex Court in Abraham Ajith's case (supra) held:-
"13.While in civil cases, normally
the expression 'cause of action'
is used, in criminal cases as
stated in Section 177 of the Code,
reference is to the local
jurisdiction where the offence is
committed. These variations in
etymological expression do not
really make the position
different. The expression 'cause
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 15
of action' is, therefore, not a
stranger to criminal cases.
14. It is settled law that cause
of action consists of a bundle of
facts which give cause to enforce
the legal inquiry for redress in a
court of law. In other words, it
is a bundle of facts, which taken
with the law applicable to them,
gives the allegedly affected party
a right to claim relief against
the opponent. It must include
some act done by the latter since
in the absence of such an act no
cause of action would possibly
accrue or would arise.
15. The expression 'cause of
action' has acquired a judicially
settled meaning. In the
restricted sense cause of action
means the circumstances forming
the infraction of the right or the
immediate occasion for the action.
In the wider sense, it means the
necessary conditions for the
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 16
maintenance of the proceeding
including not only the alleged
infraction, but also the
infraction coupled with the right
itself. Compendiously, the
expression means every fact, which
it would be necessary for the
complainant to prove, if
traversed, in order to support his
right or grievance to the judgment
of the court. Every fact, which
is necessary to be proved, as
distinguished from every piece of
evidence, which is necessary to
prove such fact, comprises in
cause of action."
If that be so from Annexure C complaint, and Annexure E
final report it is absolutely clear that the alleged acts
constituting cruelty was committed during the period
18.1.2004 to 7.5.2005. It was the period third respondent
wife was living with first petitioner husband in the
matrimonial house at Coimbatore. The inescapable
conclusion could therefore be that the cause of action has
arisen at Coimbatore and not within the territorial
jurisdiction of Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate at
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 17
Thiruvananthapuram. When no part of the cause of action
has arisen within the jurisdiction of the Magistrate who
has taken cognizance what is its effect? This is the
question to be answered in this case.
14. In Abraham Ajith's case (supra) an identical
question was considered by the Apex Court. That was a case
where the complaint alleging commission of offences under
section 498A and 406 IPC and Section 41 of Dowry
Prohibition Act, was sought to be quashed by invoking the
powers under section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure
which was rejected by the High Court and challenged before
the Apex Court. As in this case complaint filed before the
Magistrate was forwarded for investigation under section
156(3) of Code of Criminal procedure. After investigation
final report alleging commission of offences under Section
498A and 406 IPC was submitted before Magistrate Saidapet
Chennai. On the allegations in the complaint it was found
that the cause of action which consist of bundle of facts
per se took place at Nagarcoil and not within the
jurisdiction of Chennai Court and therefore the Magistrate
had no jurisdiction to deal with the matter. The
proceedings was therefore quashed as follows:-
"When the aforesaid legal
principles are applied, to the facts
scenario disclosed by the complainant
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 18
in the complaint petition, the
inevitable conclusion is that no part
of cause of action arose in Chennai
and therefore, the Magistrate
concerned had no jurisdiction to deal
with the matter. The proceedings are
quashed. The complaint be returned.
Respondent 2 who, if she so chooses,
may file the same in the appropriate
court to be dealt with in accordance
with law. The appeal is accordingly
allowed."
15.In Ramesh and others's case(supra) after
registration of the F.I.R and investigation charge sheet
for the offence under section 498 A and 406 of Indian
Penal Code and Section 3 and 4 of Dowry Prohibition Act
was laid before Judicial Magistrate III, Trichy which was
taken cognizance by the Magistrate. Petition was filed
before the High Court of Madras to quash the proceedings or
in the alternative to transfer the F.I.R to Mumbai. A Writ
Petition was earlier filed before the Bombay High Court,
which was later withdrawn with liberty to approach the High
Court of Madras for appropriate relief and it is
thereafter the petition was filed under section 482 of
Code of Criminal Procedure for quashing the proceedings
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 19
before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Trichy. The
Madras High Court dismissed the petition. It was
challenged before the Apex Court. Their Lordships on facts
found that on looking at the complaint at its face value,
though most of the alleged acts were done at Mumbai, part
of the acts were done in Chennai and therefore it is not
necessary to delve in the question of territorial
jurisdiction. Their Lordships held:-
"10. The next controversy arising
in the case is about the
territorial jurisdiction of the
Magistrate's Court at
Tiruchirapalli to try the cases.
As already noted, the High Court
was of the view that the
questions raised in the petition
cannot be decided before trial.
It is contended by the learned
counsel for the appellants that
the issue relating to the place
of trial can be decided even at
this stage without going beyond
the averments in the complaint
filed by the respondents and the
High Court should have,
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 20
therefore, decided this points
of jurisdiction, when it is
raised before the trial has
commenced. Our attention has
been drawn to a recent decision
of this Court in Y.Abraham Ajith
v. Inspector of Police. In that
case,the Madras High Court
refused to interfere under
section 482 Cr.PC when the issue
of territorial jurisdiction of
the Magistrate concerned to take
cognizance of the offence was
raised. This Court did not
endorse the approach of the High
Court for not recording the
finding on the question of
jurisdiction. On reading the
allegations in the complaint,
the Court came to the conclusion
that no part of the cause of
action arose in Chennai and
therefore the Metropolitan
Magistrate at Chennai could not
have taken cognizance and issued
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 21
summons. On this ground, the
criminal proceedings were
quashed and the complaint was
directed to be returned to the
respondent who was given liberty
to file the same in an
appropriate court. That was
also a case of complaint for an
offence under Sections 498A and
406 Cr.PC filed by the wife
against the appellants therein."
"11.In the view we are
taking, it is not necessary for
us to delve into the question of
territorial jurisdiction of the
Court at Trichy in detail.
Suffice it to say that on looking
at the complaint at its face
value, the offences alleged
cannot be said to have been
committed wholly or partly within
the local jurisdiction of the
Magistrate's court at Trichy.
Prima facie, none of the
ingredients constituting the
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 22
offence can be said to have
occurred within the local
jurisdiction of the court.
Almost all the allegations
pertain to acts of cruelty for
the purpose of extracting
additional property as dowry
while she was in the matrimonial
home at Mumbai and the alleged
acts of misappropriation of her
movable property at Mumbai.
However, there is one allegation
relevant to Section 498A from
which it could be inferred that
one of the acts giving rise to
the offence under the said
section had taken place in
Chennai. It is alleged that when
the relations of the informant
met her in-laws in a hotel in
Chennai where they were staying
on 13.10.1998, there was again a
demand for dowry and a threat to
torture her in case she was sent
back to Mumbai without the money
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 23
and articles demanded.
12.Thus the alleged acts which
according to the petitioner
constitute the offences under
sections 498A and 406 were done
by the accused mostly in Mumbai
and partly in Chennai. Prima
facie, there is nothing in the
entire complaint which goes to
show that any acts constituting
the alleged offences were at all
committed at Trichy."
Finding that the proceedings between the parties are
pending before Family Court, Mumbai, Apex Court
transferred the case to Mumbai. So as distinct from the
present case, in that case the complaint itself discloses
that part of the cause of action has arisen within the
jurisdiction of the Magistrate which has taken cognizance
of the offences.
16. In Manish Ratan's case (supra) father of Meena
the wife, lodged a complaint in Jabalpur Police Station
alleging cruelty and demand for dowry against the son -in-
law and in-laws. Later Meena herself lodged a complaint
against the husband and in-laws at Datia Police Station
based on which case was registered. The allegation in
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 24
the complaint was that during the time of Dussehra Manish
her husband, Ratan the father-in-law, and Kiran the
mother-in-law and Maneka the sister-in-law ill-treated
her so much that she left her house and saved her life by
some means and reached her mama's house at Bhopal and from
there she reached her house and since then she has been
staying with her father. A criminal revision was filed
questioning the jurisdiction of court of Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Datia. It was dismissed holding that the
offence being a continuing one, Datia Court had
jurisdiction to take cognizance of the offence,following
the decision of the Apex Court in Sujatha Mukherjee v.
Prashant Kumar Mukherjee (1997) 5 SCC 30). The order was
challenged before the Apex Court. Apex Court found that
High Court did not consider the question on the touchstone
of Section 177 and 178 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
After analysing the earlier decisions it was found that in
Sujatha Mukherjee's case specific allegations were made
against the husband that he had also gone to Raipur where
the complaint was filed and had assaulted the wife therein
and it is in such situation it was held that though cruelty
alleged was mainly at Raigarh cruelty alleged as against
the husband continued at Raipur and therefore the case as
against the husband was maintainable at Raipur, though it
is not maintainable as against others at Raipur. On facts
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 25
it was found that the alleged acts which according to
complainant constitute the offences have not taken place
within the jurisdiction of Court of Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Datia and therefore that court has no
jurisdiction to take cognizance. It was found that in the
criminal case lodged by the father at Jabalpur
investigation is completed. Their Lordships therefore
held:-
"17. Our attention was drawn to
the fact that no criminal case
was lodged at Jabalpur. Our
attention was further drawn to
the fact that the investigation
of the case is complete.
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 26
Datia to the Court of Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Jabalpur.
We accordingly do so."
In Bhuraram's case (supra) a complaint was lodged before
Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ganganagar. It was
sent for investigation under section 156(3) of code of
Criminal Procedure. After investigation a final report
was filed before the same Magistrate showing that offence
under section 498A and 406 of Indian Penal Code was
committed. The Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Ganganagar took cognizance of the offence and later framed
the charge also. Thereafter the accused raised a
contention before the Magistrate that the said court has no
jurisdiction to try the case as cause of action accrued
within the jurisdiction of another court. When it was
rejected it was challenged before the Sessions Court in
revision and when it was rejected Crl.M.C was preferred
before the High Court under section 482 of Code of Criminal
Procedure. The High Court dismissed the petition holding
that although the marriage was solemnised at Village
Ramsara of Ferozpur District right from the marriage the
complainant and her husband were living in Punjab with her
in-laws and her husband died and she was then residing
in Ganganagar District in Rajasthan along with her maternal
relations but still offence under section 498A being a
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 27
continuing one the complaint cannot be dismissed on that
ground as the offence of cruelty being a continuing offence
is still continuing within the local area of Rajasthan
where at present the complainant was living and therefore
Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ganganagr had
jurisdiction to try the case. It was challenged before the
Apex Court. Their Lordships held:-
"3. It is contended by the learned
counsel for the appellants that the
question involved is squarely covered
by the decision of this court in
Y.Abraham Ajith and others v.
Inspector of Police, Chennai and
Another, (2004) 8 SCC 100, wherein
this court has held that cause of
action having arisen within the
jurisdiction of the court where the
offence was committed, could not be
tried by the court where no part of
offence was committed.
4. The facts stated in the complaint
disclose that the complainant left the
place where she was residing with her
husband and in-laws and came to the
city of Sri Ganganagar, State of
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 28
Rajasthan and that all the alleged
acts as per the complaint had taken
place in the State of Punjab. The
Court at Rajasthan does not have the
jurisdiction to deal with the matter.
On the basis of the factual scenario
disclosed by the complainant in the
complaint, the inevitable conclusion
is that no part of the cause of action
arose in Rajasthan and, therefore, the
Magistrate concerned has no
jurisdiction to deal with the matter.
be returned to the complainant and if
she so wishes she may file the same in
the appropriate court to be dealt with
in accordance with law."
17. Learned counsel appearing for the third
respondent relying on the decision of the Apex Court in
Sohanlal and others v. State of Rajasthan (1990) SCC (Crl)
650) argued that the charge could be altered at any stage
before pronouncing the judgment and eventhough the
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 29
complaint as now stands does not contain a specific
allegation that the cruelty continued at Thiruvananthapuram
in fact it continued even after third respondent returned
to her parental home and Annexure A notice sent by
petitioner to Thiruvananthapuram shows the cruelty and at
the time of recording the evidence prosecution is entitled
to get the charge altered, invoking the power under section
216 of Code of Criminal Procedure and meanwhile if the
complaint is to be quashed it will prejudice her and so it
cannot be allowed to be quashed for the reason that
cruelty was only at Coimbatore. Relying on the decision
of the Apex Court in Mushtaq Ahmad v. Mohd.Habibur Rehman
Faizi(1996 SCC (Crl.)443) it was argued that the court is
not justified in quashing the complaint by considering the
rival versions and entering into debatable area of deciding
which of the versions was true in a petition under section
482 of Code of Criminal Procedure and the question whether
the allegations in paragraph 7 of the complaint relates to
the cruelty meted out to the third respondent at Coimbatore
alone or continued at Thiruvananthapuram cannot be decided
at this stage and therefore based on that fact,the
complaint cannot be quashed. Learned counsel also argued
that the court is competent to direct further investigation
under section 173(8) of the Code of Criminal Procedure even
after taking cognizance and in the light of allegations, a
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 30
further investigation could be ordered and whether there
was cruelty after third respondent returned to her parental
home at Thiruvananthapuram is to be investigated and based
on want of specific allegations in the complaint alone,
the complaint cannot be quashed. Learned counsel
vehemently argued that the social purpose of enactment of
section 498A of Indian Penal Code will be defeated, if a
restricted meaning is given to the pleadings in the
complaint and interest of justice warrants that the case
is not to be quashed invoking the inherent jurisdiction
of the court under section 482 of Code of Criminal
Procedure. Though learned counsel relied on the decision
of the Bombay High Court in Madhuri Mukund Chitnis v.
Mukund Martand Chitnis (1992 Crl.L.J.111), Allahabad High
Court in Azad Hussain v. State of U.P.(1993(1) Crimes
1072), Rajasthan High Court in Jagadish v. State of
Rajasthan (1998 Crl.L.J.554), Punjab and Haryana High Court
in Rajesh Kumar v. State of Punjab (II (1990) DMC 404),
facts are different and in the light of the decisions of
the Apex court the decisions cannot be applied.
18. The allegations in the complaint along with
the materials collected at the time of investigation, which
form part of the final report submitted under section 173
(2) of Code of Criminal Procedure, establish that the
cruelty alleged against the petitioners which constitute
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 31
the offence under section 498A, is only with respect to the
specified period 18.4.2004 to 7.5.2005. It was admittedly
the period when third respondent was residing at her
matrimonial home at Coimbatore. If so, it can only be
found that the alleged cruelty took place only at
Coimbatore and not at Thiruvananthapuram. If so the
Court at Thiruvananthapuram has no territorial
jurisdiction to try the case as found by the Apex Court in
Abraham Ajith's case (supra) and Manish Ratan's case
(supra). As is clear from the complaint Annexure C as well
as Annexure E final report the allegation of cruelty is
only prior to 7.5.2005 when the third respondent was
residing at Coimbatore. In the light of the settled legal
position, it can only be found that learned Additional
Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram has no
jurisdiction to try the case. Hence the proceedings before
the learned Magistrate can only be quashed. The complaint
is to be returned to third respondent who is at liberty
to file it before the appropriate court. Dismissal of the
complaint will not affect her right to agitate the case
before the appropriate court.
Criminal Revision Petition is dismissed. Crl.M.C is
allowed. The proceedings before Additional Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram taken on Annexure E final
report based on Annexure C complaint (CMP 394/2006) in
Crl.M.C.1468/09 & Crl.R.P.2068/09 32
C.C.494/2007 is quashed. Return the original complaint
filed by third respondent to her, if she chooses may file
the same before the appropriate court to be dealt with in
accordance with law.
sd/-
M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR
JUDGE
tpl/-
/true copy/
P.S to Judge
M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR, J.
---------------------
W.P.(C).NO. /06
---------------------
JUDGMENT
SEPTEMBER,2006