"CR"
1.Learned standing counsel appears for the
Municipality.
2.These petitions are filed challenging different
decisions of authorities under the Malappuram
Municipality refusing to grant building permits
applied for under the Kerala Municipality
Building Rules, 1999, hereinafter referred to as
the "KMBR", on the ground that Detailed Town
Planning Scheme, hereinafter, "DTPS", for short,
as available in relation to that municipal area,
namely, the Town Planning Scheme published in
terms of G.O.(Ms.)No.74/90/LAD dated 24.5.1990
published as S.R.O.No.1464/90 in the Kerala
Gazette dated 23.10.1990, does not provide for the
grant of permit as sought for by the petitioners
in the different cases, in as much as if such
permits are granted, they would be in violation of
the classification of municipal area into
different zones which are earmarked for different
purposes. The DTPS also would have green belts
which are exclusively meant for maintaining the
sustained development of the ecological factors.
3.In some of the cases, the competent authority
under the Kerala Land Utilization Order, 1967
issued under the Essential Commodities Act, 1955
has granted permits to convert lands for the
purpose of putting up buildings. Even in those
cases, the Municipality has refused permits on
grounds relatable to the provisions of the DTPS.
4.The respondent Municipality has come on record
with the counter affidavit which is adopted in the
different matters, placing therewith the G.O.(Ms.)
No.338/2008/LSGD dated 22nd December, 2008 whereby
the Government has proposed to issue a
notification varying the 1990 Scheme. The exercise
being undertaken under the 2008 Government Order
is expressed to be under the provisions of the
Madras Town Planning Act, 1920 and on the premise
that the 1990 scheme requires to be varied for the
purpose of making the Zoning Regulations
compatible to the present development scenario.
5.The 2008 Government Order itself evidences the
ground reality that the present development
scenario is not compatible with the terms of the
1990 Scheme. The proposal in the 2008 Government
Order is to issue a notification varying the 1990
Scheme, to the extent required. The issuance of
such a notification essentially has cautioned the
Municipality that the 1990 Scheme is intended to
be modified. Objections have been called for. The
Municipality has placed objections and suggestions
before the Government.
6.In Padmini v. State of Kerala, 1999 KHC 619, the
Division Bench of this Court considered the
question whether the Municipality involved in that
case, namely, the Vadakara Municipality, was
justified in rejecting the application for
building permit on a ground referable to a
proposal to acquire land in satisfaction of the
provisions of the Town Planning Scheme which fell
for consideration in that case and also whether
the provisions of the Municipality Act, 1994
empower the Municipality to acquire and possess
land or whether the acquisition has to be done
under the provisions of the Kerala Land
Acquisition Act, 1894, hereinafter, the "LA Act",
for short. The Bench concluded that the land in
relation to which the building permit was sought
for, was not under any proceedings for acquisition
in terms of the LA Act as on the date of
application for building permit and therefore, the
Municipality was not justified to refuse permit on
a ground relatable to the scheme. The ratio of
that judgment is that (1) without recourse to the
provisions of the LA Act, there cannot be any
acquisition for the purpose of a DTPS under the
Town Planning Act and for an acquisition of land
from a private owner, the very earmarking of a
piece of land cannot result in deprivation of
rights of the owner of that land and that (2) the
Municipality is not justified in refusing permit
under the provisions of the Municipality Act and
the KMBR merely on the ground that the land is
identified and earmarked for public purpose in
terms of zoning done under the DTPS. The said
proposition as enunciated by this Court is in
clear conformity with the conclusions of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Raju S.
Jethmalani v. State of Maharashtra,(2005) 11 SCC
222 wherein, posing a question whether the
Government can prepare a development plan and
deprive the owner of the land from using that
land, it was laid down that while there is no
prohibition of including a private land in a
development plan, no development can be made on
that land unless that private land is acquired for
development and still further, that the Government
cannot deprive the persons from using their
private property. It was categorically stated that
the Municipal Corporation involved in that case
had not taken any effort to acquire the plot which
was the subject matter of the dispute and because
it was not acquired, the owner of the land was
entitled to relief and the Government were well
within jurisdiction to grant the relief that it,
did which generated that litigation.
7.With the aforesaid, it needs to be noticed that
on the facts of the cases in hand, the 1990 Scheme
was never followed by any acquisition of private
lands and the Municipality does not dispute the
fact that the lands in question are part of the
holding of the petitioners. It has no case that
the 1990 Scheme was made operational by effecting
necessary acquisitions, including of the different
parcels in question which belong to the
petitioners. So much so, following the decision in
Padmini (supra), there is no rhyme or reason for
the Municipality to have refused the building
permits sought for.
8.As the law now stands, as laid down in Padmini
(supra), the acquisition of land for the purpose
of a Town Planning Scheme has to be done under the
LA Act. The cardinal date for various matters in
relation to that legislation, including the
fixation of compensation, is the notification of
Section 4(1) of the LA Act, which is the date that
is relevant even for determination of the
compensation. This remains so in spite of the fact
that in terms of the Municipality Act, the
Government could be obliged to act on the request
of the Municipality for the acquisition.
Therefore, while the Government would not have any
choice in the matter of acquisition for a
Municipality and while any proposal of the
Municipality to acquire would not depend upon any
sanction of the Government, in so far as the owner
of the land is concerned, the acquisition affects
his interest only from the issuance of
notifications and declarations under the LA Act
and therefore, any attempt to curb the rights of
the owners of lands, until the publication of
those statutory notifications and declarations,
would result in infraction of the right to
property under Article 300A of the Constitution.
On the face of the law settled by this Court in
Padmini (supra), any infraction of the principle
stated therein would also result in the violation
of the equality principle in the matter of
enforcement of laws as is contained in Article 14
of the Constitution. Any demand to create a rider
over the title of the owner of the property under
the pretext of a Town Planning Scheme which has
not become operational by acquisition would,
essentially, be oppressive and would not be
countenanced on the face of Article 14 of the
Constitution.
9.For the aforesaid reasons, the decisions impugned
in the captioned writ petitions are quashed and
the Municipality is directed to reconsider the
cases of the petitioners afresh without reference
to Detailed Town Planning Scheme and issue orders
granting building permits, if the applications are
otherwise in order. Let this be done within an
outer limit of one month from the date of receipt
of a copy of this judgment. The writ petitions are
ordered accordingly.
This Court places its appreciation for the able
assistance rendered by Adv.Ranjit B.Marar and
Adv.L.Rajesh Narayan as amicus curiae in these
cases.
THOTTATHIL B. RADHAKRISHNAN,
JUDGE.
Sha/150609