AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Delivered by Balakrishnan Nair, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

These writ appeals were heard together because they raised common questions concerning whether Mahatma Gandhi University (the University) could make appointments to vacancies beyond those notified for selection.

W.A. No. 1197/2007 (treated as the main case): The University issued Ext. P3 notification dated 24.12.2005 advertising various teaching posts. Item No. 16 related to two posts of Lecturer in the School of International Relations. A Selection Committee interviewed candidates on 8.3.2006 and published a rank list on 22.5.2006. The appellant (who was the 2nd respondent in the writ petition) was placed at Rank No. 2 (open merit). Rank No. 1 was appointed against an open merit vacancy; the second notified vacancy was filled by an Ezhava reservation candidate. Subsequently, as per Ext. P1 proceedings dated 6.1.2007, Dr. K.N. Harikumar was relieved which created a third vacancy in January 2007. The University proposed to appoint Rank No. 2 to that third vacancy.

The writ petitioners (respondents 2 and 3 in the appeal) challenged the proposed appointment and sought:

  • a declaration that the appointment of the 2nd respondent (appellant in the appeal) was illegal and unconstitutional;
  • a mandamus directing termination of the 2nd respondent;
  • a mandamus directing the University to refrain from appointing candidates without issuing a fresh proper advertisement as per Chapter III clause 3 of the Mahatma Gandhi University Statutes, 1997; and
  • a mandamus directing the University to initiate a fresh selection by issuing a proper advertisement.

During the writ petition's pendency the 2nd respondent was appointed and the writ petition was amended to challenge that appointment. The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition and quashed the appointment of the appellant, directing the University to undertake a fresh selection. The University and the appointee (appellant) appealed to this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Mahatma Gandhi University can make appointments to vacancies other than those notified in the selection notification (i.e., fill vacancies arising after notification without issuing a fresh advertisement).
  2. Whether candidates who participated in the selection (but were not appointed) are estopped or lack locus standi to challenge an appointment made to a vacancy that arose after the notification.
  3. Whether a rank list can be kept alive for a specified period (e.g., one year) and used to fill vacancies arising during that period without a fresh advertisement, and if so, whether such a decision must be communicated at the time of notification.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (the appointed candidate / 2nd respondent)

  • The writ petitioners are defeated candidates and thus have no locus standi to challenge the appointment; their participation in selection estops them from challenging the appointment.
  • The University had a policy (decision of the Syndicate) to keep the rank list alive for one year; appointments during the currency of the rank list are permissible.
  • Selection may validly be made for anticipated vacancies; thus filling a vacancy that arose after the notification was permissible.
  • Relied on decisions of the Apex Court, notably Prem Singh v. Haryana State Electricity Board and Secretary, A.P. Public Service Commission v. B. Swapna, in support of the proposition that appointments for anticipated or subsequent vacancies may be permissible in some circumstances.

University's Position

  • The University filed a counter affidavit supporting its actions and pointed to a Syndicate decision to give one year's validity to the rank list and to fill up vacancies arising in the meantime from that list.

Writ Petitioners' Arguments (respondents 2 & 3)

  • The University could fill only the vacancies specifically notified; the select list could not be used to fill vacancies that were not notified.
  • The notification Ext. P3 contained no stipulation that the rank list would remain alive for a period or that vacancies arising later would be filled from that list.
  • The rules in Chapter III of the University Statutes did not contemplate publication of any rank list to be used in this manner.
  • Relied on earlier decisions (cited in the petition) supporting the position that appointments must be limited to notified vacancies.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kerala Agricultural University v. Gopinathan Unnithan [1996 (1) KLT 344] Support for the proposition that an authority/university can fill only the vacancies notified in the advertisement. Identified by the Court as one of the decisions relied upon by the writ petitioners to support limitation to notified vacancies; used to reinforce the Court's conclusion that only notified vacancies may be filled.
Asok Kumar v. Chairman B.S Recruitment Board [(1996) 1 SCC 283 : AIR 1996 SC 976] Authority for the proposition that appointments should be limited to advertised vacancies. Relied on by the petitioners and recorded by the Court among decisions supporting the position that the University should have filled only the notified vacancies.
Raiamohan v. The State of Kerala [1997 (1) ILR Kerala 199] Support for limiting appointments to notified vacancies. Noted by the Court as one of the decisions relied upon by the petitioners to support their principal contention.
Prem Singh v. Haryana State Electricity Board [(1996) 4 SCC 319] Recognises circumstances where appointments made in excess of advertised posts were saved on special facts and equitable grounds; also addresses locus/estoppel issues of defeated candidates. The Court relied on Prem Singh to reject the estoppel/locus standi objection (paragraph 12 of Prem Singh). The Court also distinguished Prem Singh for the proposition that it favours the appellant—Court observed Prem Singh's survival of some excess appointments was on special facts and equitable grounds and therefore did not support the appellant's general proposition.
Secretary, A.P. Public Service Commission v. B. Swapna [(2005) 4 SCC 154] Instances where the rules expressly provide for a rank list to remain in force for a period (one year) and for appointments from that list. The Court held this decision could not assist the appellant because the rules in that case expressly provided for a rank list for one year; such a rule was not present in the instant case.
Administrator, U.T. of Lakshadweep v. Mushak [2004 (2) KLT 880] Referenced by respondents' counsel in support of submissions (specific rule principle not detailed in the opinion). The Court recorded that counsel relied on this decision; the opinion does not elaborate further application beyond noting reliance.
Balasuhramaniam v. Tamil Nadu Housing Board [ (1987) 4 SCC 738 : AIR 1988 SC 6 ] Principle that a statutory authority authorised to frame subordinate legislation may issue executive orders on subjects concerning which it is authorised to frame rules or regulations. The Court invoked this principle to explain that a competent body of the University could, in principle, decide to keep a rank list alive, but such a decision should be made by the competent body and published along with the notification. Absent such publication, appointments cannot be made to vacancies not notified.
Hoshiar Singh v. State of Haryana [1993 Supp (4) SCC 377] Support for the general proposition that appointments should be limited to advertised vacancies unless lawful provision permits otherwise. Listed among Apex Court decisions relied upon by this Court to support the conclusion that the University should have filled only the notified vacancies.
Gujarat State Deputy Executive Engineers Association v. State of Gujarat [1994 Supp (2) SCC 591] Support for restricting appointments to notified vacancies unless sanctioned by law or rule. Used by the Court as authority reinforcing the rule that only notified vacancies can be filled absent statutory rule permitting otherwise.
State of Bihar v. Madan Mohan Singh [1994 Supp (3) SCC 308] Another authority cited for the principle limiting appointments to notified vacancies. Included among the cases the Court relied on to conclude the University should have filled only vacancies notified in the advertisement.
Madanlal v. State of Jammu and Kashmir [(1995) 3 SCC 486] Supportive precedent concerning limitation on filling vacancies beyond those advertised. Referred to by the Court as part of the body of Apex Court precedent supporting the Court's conclusion.
Mukul Saikia v. State of Assam [(2009) 1 SCC 386] Recent authority cited in the opinion supporting the limitation on filling non-notified vacancies. Listed by the Court among decisions establishing the proposition that appointments should be restricted to vacancies advertised unless a valid rule allows otherwise.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in structured steps closely following issues raised in submissions and the available authorities:

  1. Locus Standi / Estoppel: The Court rejected the preliminary objection that the writ petitioners (defeated candidates) lacked locus standi or were estopped from challenging the appointment. The Court relied on Prem Singh (paragraph 12) to hold that candidates could not have anticipated at the time of interview that the Selection Committee would recommend appointments in excess of advertised posts. Consequently, participation in the selection does not preclude them from challenging appointments to vacancies arising later. The Court emphasized that the writ petitioners have rights under Article 14 and Article 16 of the Constitution to be considered for any fresh vacancy and therefore have standing to maintain the petition.
  2. Whether the University could fill an unnotified vacancy without fresh advertisement: The Court identified the decisive point as whether University statutes or rules provided for (a) the life of a rank list and (b) the use of such a rank list to fill vacancies arising during that period. No statutory provision or rule enabling such a practice was placed before the Court. While the Court acknowledged the general legal principle (from Balasuhramaniam) that an authority empowered to frame rules may also issue executive orders in related subjects, it held that if a rank list is to be kept alive and used for subsequent vacancies, there must be a clear decision by the competent body and publication of that decision along with the notification itself.
  3. Application to facts (Ext. P3): Ext. P3 (the selection notification) was silent regarding the life of the rank list and silent on using the select list to fill vacancies other than those notified. Given this silence and the absence of statutory authority allowing use of the list for subsequent vacancies, the Court held that the University could fill only the vacancies expressly notified in Ext. P3.
  4. Precedents and distinguishing appellant reliance: The Court reviewed the precedents relied upon by both sides. The Court treated a number of Apex Court decisions (Hoshiar Singh, Gujarat Deputy Executive Engineers, State of Bihar v. Madan Mohan Singh, Madanlal, Mukul Saikia, and earlier-cited decisions) as supporting the limitation to notified vacancies. The Court observed that Prem Singh—which the appellant relied upon—actually did not support the appellant's broad proposition because in Prem Singh the excess appointments were saved only on special facts and equitable grounds; hence Prem Singh was not a general authority for making appointments beyond advertised vacancies. Similarly, Secretary, A.P. PSC v. B. Swapna could not help the appellant because that case involved rules that expressly provided for a rank list to remain in force for a year—unlike the present facts.
  5. Conclusion from analysis: For the above reasons, the Court concluded the University should have filled only the two vacancies notified by Ext. P3. The only lawful course for filling an additional vacancy that had arisen was to issue a fresh notification and conduct selection in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The Court dismissed the appeal in W.A. No. 1197/2007, thereby upholding the learned Single Judge's decision quashing the appointment to the unnotified vacancy and directing the University to undertake a fresh selection in accordance with law. The connected appeals W.A. Nos. 1665/2007 and 1715/2007 were also dismissed.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The immediate consequence is that the appointment made to the vacancy that arose after the notification (and which was not notified) is not permissible; the University must notify and conduct a fresh selection to fill that vacancy.
  • The decision affirms that, absent a clear statutory provision, rule, or an explicit published decision by the competent body permitting a rank list to remain in force and be used to fill subsequent vacancies, an authority/university cannot validly appoint candidates to vacancies other than those advertised.
  • The Court emphasized the constitutional dimension: appointments without proper notification affect the rights of prospective applicants guaranteed under Article 14 and Article 16 of the Constitution of India.
  • No broad new precedent altering the existing principles was laid down; rather, the Court applied and reaffirmed existing authorities that limit appointments to notified vacancies unless a lawful rule or explicit published decision permits otherwise.

Note: This summary is strictly confined to the content of the provided opinion and does not introduce facts, inferences, or legal principles beyond those expressly stated in the judgment text.

    Suresh R. (Dr.) v. Mahatma Gandhi University, Kottayam & Others

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Balakrishnan Nair, J.:— Since common questions arose for decision in these Writ Appeals, they are heard and disposed of together by this common judgment. The main point that arises for decision in these cases is whether the Mahatma Gandhi University can make appointments to more vacancies than that are notified for selection.

    W.A No. 1197/2007:

    2. This appeal is treated as the main case. The appellant was the 2nd respondent in the writ petition. Respondents 2 and 3 were the writ petitioners. The 1st respondent University issued Ext. P3 notification dated 24.12.2005, inviting applications for various teaching posts under it. Item No. 16 under the said notification was for appointment to two posts of Lecturer in International Relations/Political Sciences/History/Economics in the School of International Relations. The writ petitioners were qualified for appointment to the said post. Pursuant to the said notification, the Selection Committee met on 8.3.2006, held the interview of the candidates and published the rank list on 22.5.2006 The appellant was ranked as Rank No. 2. He was an open merit candidate. Rank No. 1 was appointed in the open merit vacancy. The second vacancy was filled up by an Ezhava reservation candidate. While so, as per Ext. P1 proceedings dated 6.1.2007, one Dr. K.N Harikumar, who was a Senior Lecturer working in the School of International Relations and Politics was relieved from the University, to enable him to join the Centre for Development Studies, Trivandrum. He availed leave without allowance from the University on 22.10.2001 and was working as an Associate Fellow in the said Centre. Since the said institution decided to absorb him, he moved for relieving him from the service of the University and the same was granted as per Ext. P1 proceedings. In the resultant third vacancy, which arose in January, 2007, Rank No. 2 was proposed to be appointed. On coming to know of this, the writ petitioners approached this Court, seeking the following reliefs.

    i) to declare that the appointment of the 2 respondent as Lecturer in the School of International Relations and Politics in Mahatma Gandhi University is unjust, illegal, arbitrary and unconstitutional;

    ia) to issue a writ of mandamus directing the 1 respondent to terminate the service of the 2 respondent as Lecturer, forthwith

    ii) to issue a writ of mandamus directing the 1 respondent to refrain from appointing the 2 respondent or any other candidates as Lecturer in School of International Relations and Politics in M.G University without issuing a proper advertisement on the basis of Chapter III clause 3 of Mahatma Gandhi University Statutes 1997 and without following the procedure stated therein;

    iii) to issue a writ of mandamus directing the 1 respondent to initiate a fresh selection process for appointment of Lecturer in the School of International Relations and Politics in M.G University by issuing a proper advertisement as contemplated by Chapter III of Clause 3 of Mahatma Gandhi University Statutes 1997.

    3. The main contention raised in the writ petition was that the University can fill up only the vacancies notified by it and in support of that submission, the petitioners relied on the Division Bench decision of this Court in Kerala Agricultural University v. Gopinathan Unnithan [1996 (1) KLT 344] and the decision of the Apex Court in Asok Kumar v. Chairman B.S Recruitment Board [(1996) 1 SCC 283 : AIR 1996 SC 976]. They also relied on the decision of this Court in Raiamohan v. The State of Kerala [1997 (1) ILR Kerala 199].

    4. During the pendency of the writ petition, since the 2 respondent was appointed, the writ petition was amended challenging his appointment also. The 2 respondent/appellant resisted the prayers in the writ petition, by filing a detailed counter affidavit. He pointed out that the writ petitioners were defeated candidates and therefore, they have no locus standi to raise the challenge against his appointment. It was also submitted that after having participated in the selection, they are estopped from challenging the appointment. The University has decided to keep the rank list published by it alive for a period of one year and therefore, there is nothing wrong with the appointment made during the currency of the rank list to the vacancy, which arose in the meantime, it is submitted.

    5. The 1 respondent University also filed a counter affidavit, supporting its actions. The University pointed out that the Syndicate has taken a decision to give one year's validity to the rank list published pursuant to the selection and to fill up the vacancies, which arose in the meantime, from the said list

    6. The learned Single Judge, who heard the writ petition, upheld the contention of the writ petitioners, allowed the Writ Petition and quashed the appointment of the appellant/2 respondent. The University was directed to undertake a fresh selection, in accordance with law, for appointment to the post of Lecturer, in which, the appellant was appointed.

    7. The learned senior counsel for the appellant, Mr. O.V Radhakrishnan, attacked the impugned judgment on various grounds. He pointed out that the writ petitioners have not challenged the select list. Having participated in the selection, they are estopped from challenging the appointment of the appellant. The University has taken a policy decision to keep alive the rank list published by it pursuant to Ext. P3 notification, for a period of one year. The University is competent to do that. The learned senior counsel pointed out that selection can be made for making appointment in anticipated vacancies also. The same is permissible, in view of various decisions of the Apex Court. In support of his submissions, the learned senior counsel relied on the decisions of the Apex Court in Prem Sinph v. Haryana State Electricity Board [(1996) 4 SCC 319] and in Secretary, A.P Public Service Commission v. B. Swapna ((2005) 4 SCC 154].

    8. We heard the learned counsel, Mr. Kalseeswaram Raj, for respondents 2 and 3. The learned counsel relied on the decisions, which the said respondents/writ petitioners cited before the learned Single Judge. Further, it is submitted that respondents 2 and 3 have no grievance against the selection and therefore, they are not challenging the select list Their claim is that the select list could be used only to fill up the notified vacancies. While participating in the selection, they never had an inkling that the select list is going to be used for filling up vacancies, which are not notified. The notification, Ext. P3, does not contain any such stipulation. Further, the rules contained in Chapter III of the 1 Statutes of the Mahatma Gandhi University, providing for selection for filling up of teaching posts, do not contemplate publication of any rank list

    9. We also had the benefit of hearing learned counsel, Mr. N. Sugathan, who appeared for the appellants in the connected cases and also learned counsel, Smt. Bhadrakumari, who appeared for the contesting respondents in the connected appeals. She also relied on the decision of this Court in Administrator, U.T of Laksfaa Dweep v. Mushak [2004 (2) KLT 880], in support of her submissions.

    10. The preliminary objection raised by the learned senior counsel for the appellant regarding the locus standi of the writ petitioners or the question of estoppal, raised against them, is plainly untenable. Similar contentions raised in Prem Singh v. Haryana State Electricity Board [(1996) 4 SCC 319] were rejected by the Apex Court in the following words:

    “12. In our opinion, there is no substance in the objection raised with respect to locus standi of the original writ petitioners. The candidates could not have anticipated when they appeared for the interview that the Selection Committee would recommend candidates and the Board would make appointments far in excess of the advertised posts. The petitioner, who was not eligible, had a just grievance that due to appointments of candidates in excess of the posts advertised he was deprived of the right of consideration for appointment against the posts which would have become vacant after he acquired eligibility.”

    11. So, we hold that the participation of the writ petitioners in the selection process will not in any way, bar them from contending that the 2 vacancy, which arose in the open merit quota, should be filled up only after issuing a fresh notification and conducting selection. They are candidates, who could have tried their chance to get appointment, if a fresh notification is issued. At any rate, they have a right to be considered for selection to the new vacancy, flowing from Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Their rights in this regard were infringed by the action of the University. So, they have every right to maintain the writ petition.

    12. It is more or less fairly settled that if the rules, governing selection, provide a life for the rank list and also permit appointments from that list to vacancies reported till the expiry of the list, there is nothing wrong with filling up more vacancies than the notified vacancies. So, for resolving the controversy in this case, the 1 point to be ascertained is whether there is any such provision in the statutes of the M.G University, governing selection and appointment of teachers. No statutory provision has been brought to our notice on this point. Of course, it is a settled principle in law that a statutory authority, which is authorised to frame subordinate legislation, may issue executive orders on subjects, concerning which it is authorised to frame rules or regulations. This position is settled by the decision of the Apex Court in Balasuhramaniam v. Tamil Nadu Housing Board ((1987) 4 SCC 738 : AIR 1988 SC 6). If, in relation to a particular selection, it is proposed to have a rank list alive for a particular period and it is proposed to fill up the vacancies that may arise during the currency of the rank list from it, there should be a decision to that effect by the competent body of the University and it should be published along with the notification itself. In this case, Ext. P3 notification is totally silent, regarding the life of the rank list or appointment to vacancies other than those notified. In view of the above position, the University can fill up only the vacancies notified by it. The said position is settled by the decisions of the Apex Court in Hoshiar Singh v. State of Haryana [1993 Supp (4) SCC 377], Gujarat State Deputy Executive Engineers Association v. State of Gujarat [1994 Supp (2) SCC 591], State of Bihar v. Madan Mohan Singh [1994 Supp (3) SCC 308) Madanlal v. State of Tammu and Kashmir [(1995) 3 SCC 486], Mukul Saikia v. State of Assam [(2009) 1 SCC 386] and also the decisions relied on by the writ petitioners, which we have already mentioned earlier.

    13. To get over the decisions, the learned senior counsel for the appellant, mainly, relied on the decision of the Apex Court in Prem Singh v. Haryana State Electricity Board [(1996) 4 SCC 319]. But, we notice that the said decision is against the proposition canvassed by the appellant. In fact, the excess appointments made were saved on the special facts of the case and on equitable ground. The operative portion of the judgment, which is contained in paragraph 26, will show the same. The said portion of the judgment reads as follows:

    “26. In the present case, as against the 62 advertised posts the Board made appointments on 138 posts. The selection process was started for 62 clear vacancies and at that time anticipated vacancies were not taken into account. Therefore, strictly speaking, the Board was not justified in making more than 62 appointments pursuant to the advertisement published on 2.11.1991 and the selection process which followed thereafter. But, as the Board could have taken into account not only the actual vacancies but also vacancies which were likely to arise because of retirement etc. by the time the selection process was completed it would not be just and equitable to invalidate all the appointments made on posts in excess of 62. However, the appointments which were made against future vacancies - in this case on posts which were newly created - must be regarded as invalid. As stated earlier, after the selection process had started 13 posts had become vacant because of retirement end 12 because of deaths. The vacancies which were likely to arise as a result of retirement could have been reasonably anticipated by the Board. The Board through oversight had not taken them into consideration while a requisition was made for filling up 62 posts. Even with respect to the appointments made against vacancies which arose because of deaths, a lenient view can be taken and on consideration of expediency and equity they need not be quashed. Therefore, in view of the special facts and circumstances of this case we do not think it proper to invalidate the appointments made on those 25 additional posts. But the appointments made by the Board on posts beyond 87 are held invalid. Though the High Court was right in the view it has taken, we modify its order to the aforesaid extent. These appeals are allowed accordingly. No order as to costs.”

    (emphasis supplied)

    14. The learned senior counsel for the appellant also relied on the decision of the Apex Court in Secretary. A.P Public Service Commission v. B. Swapna [(2005) 4 SCC 154]. Selection involved in this case was a selection made by the Andra Pradesh Public Service Commission. The Rules of the Commission itself provide for a rank list, which will remain in force for a period of one year. So, the observations in that case can, in no way, support the case of the appellant.

    15. Going by the various decisions of the Apex Court mentioned, we have nc doubt in our mind that the University should have filled up only the two vacancies notified by it. If an additional vacancy was available, the only course open to the 1 respondent University, was to notify the same and fill up the same, after making the selection in accordance with law. So, we find no merit in the appeal and it is accordingly dismissed

    W.A Nos. 1665/2007 & 1715/2007:

    16. These appeals are filed by the same person, Whose selection was unsettled by the common judgment of this Court in W.P(C) No. 26454/2006 and 27024/2006. The case of the appellant is squarely covered by our judgment in W.A No. 1197/2007. But, learned counsel, Mr. N. Sugathan, appearing for the appellant tried to draw a distinction, by contending that the 2 open merit vacancy, in which the appellant was appointed, was available even at the time of initial notification. We think, the said fact will not make any difference. If that vacancy was available, that should also have been notified. If three vacancies were available, more candidates would have applied. Many may not have applied, thinking that there were only two vacancies available. If appointment is made to a vacancy without notification, the same will affect the rights of many candidates, guaranteed under Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. So, the principle which persuaded us to dismiss W.A No. 1197/2007, will govern these appeals also. Accordingly, they are also dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Suresh R. (Dr.) v. Mahatma Gandhi University, Kottayam & Others
    (Feb 17, 2009)