.SP 2
........L.......T.......T.......T.......T.......T.......T.......J.......T....
K.A.ABDUL GAFOOR & K.HEMA, JJ.
@@ jAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
-----------------------------------
@@ jEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
W.A.No.2268 of 2004,
@@ jEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
W.A.No.2271 of 2004
@@ jAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
&
@@ jA
W.A.No.1299 of 2005
@@ jAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Whether temporary employees regularised or
regularly appointed in service on or after 1.10.1994, in
continuation of the temporary service or not, are
entitled to get increments reckoning their temporary
service prior to such regularisation or regular
appointment is the point arising in these Writ Appeals at
the instance of the State.
2. In the impugned judgment the learned Single
Judge found that "there is no justification in denying
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
the benefit of such provisional service for the only
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
reason that it is not followed by regular appointment
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
prior to 1.10.1994" and directed Government to consider
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
the case of the respondents-writ petitioners in the light
of the decision reported in Sobhana K. & Others v. State Of Kerala & Otheres
(2004(3) KLT 131). It is clear from Annexure-C
Government decision deleting Government decision No.2,
which enabled reckoning provisional service for the
purpose of increment, that "those persons whose services
were regularised with effect from 1.10.1994 or thereafter
will not be entitled for increment reckoning their
provisional service". Therefore, the observation made in
the impugned judgment to reckon the provisional service
for the purpose of granting increment is unjustified, the
Government Pleader submits.
3. It is contended by the respondents/writ
petitioners that their case cannot be considered like any
other temporary appointees under Rule 9(a)(i) in of Part
II KS & SSR. All of them were appointed as Junior Health
Inspectors based on a centrally sponsored multi purpose
workers scheme in the year 1986. There were no
sufficient qualified hands for that job. Applications
were invited by the Government. All the writ petitioners
and others applied. The Writ petitioners were selected
and trained by the Government and they were appointed and
continued for years together on temporary basis. In the
appointment the Government had followed the regular mode
of selection and even the reservation on the basis of
communal rotation as is applicable to regular appointees.
It is submitted that the Government themselves were
willing to regularise their services as revealed from
Exhibit R2. The Government took up the issue in 1993
with the P.S.C. But the P.S.C. did not grant
concurrence. The second consultation from the Government
with the P.S.C for the purpose of over ruling the advice
of the P.S.C. was delayed. It is seen from Exhibit R2
that in an Original Petition filed by the candidates who
have registered their names for appointment as Junior
Health Inspectors in Employment Exchanges challenging
regularisation, this Court directed that the
regularisation, if any, to be effected would be subject
to the result of the Original Petition. This also caused
delay. It was in the above circumstances that Exhibit R2
regularisation order was delayed until 31.3.1995.
Otherwise all of them would have been regularised in the
year 1993 and would have got the benefit of Government
Decision No.2 which existed until 30.9.1994.
4. True, the increment is granted considering
"all duty in a post or a time scale", under Rule 33 Part
I K.S.R. The first increment is granted on completion of
one year of regular service subject to other conditions
in the said Rule. The Rule as obtainable on the date of
such grant of increment is to govern the eligibility.
The writ petitioners completed that period of one year in
March, 1996. In the impugned judgment, it is directed to
consider the case of the writ petitioners to reckon their
temporary service for the purpose of granting increment
in the light of Sobhana's case (supra). It is found
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAA
therein that "on a close reading of the government
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
decision it is fairly clear that what the Government
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
actually intended is to confer the benefit of provisional
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
service rendered prior to 1.10.1994". But Government
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
decision No.2 introduced in Rule 33 Part I KSR did not
mention about any date, or period of such provisional
service. So there arises no question whether Government
intended to confer the benefit of provisional service
with reference to any date, in that Government decision.
In spite of that it is declared in Sobhana's case (supra)
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAA
that:
.SP 1
...in the case of employees governed by the KSR,
@@ i
provisional service on regularisation with or
without break in the same category of posts or
provisional service followed by regular
appointment with or without break in the same
category of posts shall be granted the benefit of
increment ignoring the fact that the
regularisation or regular appointment is only
after 1.10.1994.
.SP 2
5. Of course Government decision No.2 under Rule
33 Part-I KSR was deleted with effect from 1.10.1994 as
per Annexure-C G.O(P) 540/94/Fin. dated 30.9.1994. That
means from 1.10.1994 onwards there is no provision in the
Statute Book to treat provisional service as officiating
service for the purpose of granting increment.
6. Grant of increment is not based on whether
one has to his credit temporary or provisional service,
but as to what are the conditions to be satisfied as on
the date on which the increment is to be granted. If one
among the conditions permits reckoning of provisional or
temporary service, necessarily it will enable the
incumbent to count it; otherwise not. As already
mentioned, the first increment is usually granted on
completion of one year of duty of regular substantive
service in a post on a time scale. If the Rule as on the
date of grant of increment permits, for that purpose, to
reckon temporary or provisional service, necessarily it
shall be reckoned. If it does not permit, on such date
it cannot be. Merely because one does have such
temporary/provisional service put in by him prior to
deletion of that Government decision, he cannot claim to
reckon that service for the purpose of grant of
increment, when it falls after the date of deletion of
Government decision No.2 on 1.10.1994. In otherwords, it
is not the time factor of the provisional or temporary
service which is relevant, but the condition in the rules
which govern the grant of increment. From 1.10.1994
onwards there is no provision to treat provisional or
temporary service as officiating one for the purpose of
grant of increment. If the first increment falls on that
date or any subsequent date, one cannot claim such
increment reckoning his provisional service, immaterial
whether it was rendered before the said date.
7. As on the date for grant of increment to the
petitioners there was no Rule, as rightly pointed out by
the learned Government Pleader, to reckon their
provisional service for the purpose of granting
increment. Therefore, there cannot have any doubt with
regard to the provision of law applicable in this case.
8. But at the same time, going by the facts and
circumstances of this case, the case of the petitioners
is to be dealt with on a different footing. As already
mentioned above, they underwent a different form of
selection process. There was training imparted for the
writ petitioners at the instance of the Government and
they spent a major part of their life in service under a
centrally sponsored scheme for the betterment of the
health of the people of the State. They were not
appointed for a fixed term of 179 days as is applicable
in the case of an appointee under Rule 9(a)(i) of Part II
KS & SSR. Principles of communal rotation to be followed
for a regular appointment through the P.S.C. had been
followed. Thus, in every respect except styling their
appointment as on temporary basis, the entire process for
a regular appointment had been followed. The Government
also was willing to regularise them at the latest in
1993. They have decided also for that purpose. But the
P.S.C. turned down that request of the Government and
did not grant concurrence. Second consultation had been
taken up with the P.S.C. But there was delay on the part
of the Government in taking up the second consultation
and in overruling the advice of the P.S.C. In the
meantime, the entire process was interdicted by an
Original Petition which was filed challenging the attempt
of regularisation of the persons like petitioners. In
these uncertain circumstances, their regularisation was
delayed. Otherwise the Government was willing to
regularise the petitioners at the latest in 1993, in
which case, they could have availed the benefit of
Government decision No.2. In such circumstances, it is a
fit case for the Government to consider their temporary
service for the purpose of grant of increment invoking
Rule 39 of the General Rules in KSS & SS Rules.
Accordingly, the direction issued by the learned
Single Judge is modified to the effect that the question
of grant of increment to the writ petitioners shall be
considered in the aforesaid facts and circumstances
invoking Rule 39 of the General Rules. This exercise
shall be done within three months from the date of
receipt of a copy of this judgment. Such treatment shall
always be just and equitable as envisaged under Rule 39
itself. Appeal is disposed of accordingly.
K.A.ABDUL GAFOOR, JUDGE
@@ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
K.HEMA, JUDGE
@@ EEEEEEEEEEEEE
vgs.
@@ EEEE