Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision challenges the Order dated 31.3.2003 of the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Thrissur in CMP No. 231/2003, which rejected a complaint filed by the petitioner against the second respondent.

The second respondent was working as Deputy Superintendent of Police in the Vigilance and Anti-corruption Department. The petitioner, Secretary of the Kerala People's Forum, alleged that the second respondent had amassed wealth disproportionate to his known sources of income: construction of a house said to cost Rs. 60 lakhs in violation of the approved plan; ownership of 8 tanker lorries and 4 jeeps plying for hire; and expenditure on two children studying in posh schools at about Rs. 3,000 per month per student. The petitioner sought initiation of proceedings under the Prevention of Corruption Act.

The learned Special Judge rejected the complaint on the ground that the materials produced did not show prima facie the truthfulness of the allegations. The petitioner challenged that rejection by way of the present revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Special Judge erred in rejecting the private complaint at the threshold on the ground that the materials produced did not show prima facie truthfulness of the allegations.
  2. Whether, in respect of allegations against a public servant, the Special Judge should have ordered at least a preliminary enquiry (or forwarded the complaint for investigation) rather than rejecting the complaint outright.
  3. Whether the petitioner had locus standi to file the private complaint.
  4. Whether the Special Judge could, without proper application of mind, direct the Vigilance Department to conduct an enquiry (and conversely, whether a failure to order any preliminary enquiry justified rejection of the complaint).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The learned Special Judge wrongly found that the materials produced did not show prima facie truthfulness; there were sufficient materials on record to make out a prima facie case against the second respondent.
  • The Special Judge ought to have ordered an enquiry into the allegations by the Vigilance Department instead of rejecting the complaint.

Second Respondent's Arguments

  • The learned Special Judge's order rejecting the complaint was correct and there was no ground for interference.
  • The petitioner lacked locus standi and was not a person aggrieved by the alleged offences.
  • Reliance was placed on a Division Bench decision (Satheesh v. Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge (2003 (3) KLT 480)) to contend that the special court cannot, without proper application of mind, issue a direction to the Vigilance Police to conduct enquiry or investigations.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P. Sirajuddin, Etc. v. State Of Madras, Etc.† ((1970) 1 SCC 595 : AIR 1971 SC 520) When the accused is a public servant, there must be some suitable preliminary enquiry into the allegations by a responsible officer before proceeding. The court relied on this authority to hold that a preliminary enquiry by a responsible officer of the Vigilance Department ought to have been ordered in respect of allegations against the second respondent (a public servant).
Satheesh v. Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge (2003 (3) KLT 480) The special court cannot simply act as a 'Post Office' and, without proper application of mind, issue directions to the Vigilance Police to conduct enquiry or investigations. The court noted this principle relied on by the second respondent but distinguished it to the extent that while the special court must apply its mind before issuing directions, it was improper to reject the complaint at the threshold without at least ordering a preliminary enquiry.
A.R Aanthulav v. R.S Naik ((1984) 2 SCC 500 : AIR 1984 SC 718) Locus standi: generally any person can initiate criminal proceedings; locus standi is not a requirement in criminal jurisprudence except where statute indicates otherwise. The court applied this principle to reject the contention that the petitioner lacked locus standi to file the complaint.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court found the impugned order of the Special Judge unsustainable. The Special Judge had issued a brief/cryptic order rejecting the complaint on the sole ground that the materials did not show prima facie truthfulness. On examination of the complaint and supporting materials (photographs, plan, etc.), the revising court concluded that the allegations did disclose the commission of an offence under the Prevention of Corruption Act and that the materials produced could support prima facie truthfulness of the allegations.

The court emphasized that at the threshold stage it is not the court's role to determine whether allegations will ultimately be proved; rather, where prima facie material exists, the Special Judge should have ordered at least a preliminary enquiry. The court observed that a Special Judge exercising original criminal jurisdiction has the power to forward a private complaint to the police for investigation under Section 156(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code before taking cognizance.

Because the second respondent was a public servant, the court relied on P. Sirajuddin to require a suitable preliminary enquiry by a responsible officer of the Vigilance Department. The court also addressed the Satheesh authority relied upon by the second respondent: while agreeing that the special court must apply its mind before directing enquiries, the court held that outright rejection at the threshold without such enquiry was inappropriate in the present circumstances.

Finally, the court rejected the locus standi objection by reference to A.R Aanthulav v. R.S Naik, noting that any person may set the criminal law in motion unless the statute expressly provides otherwise.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The impugned order rejecting the complaint is set aside. The Special Judge is directed to order a preliminary enquiry into the allegations against the second respondent by a responsible officer of the Vigilance Department.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the complaint which had been rejected must now be the subject of a preliminary enquiry by the Vigilance Department (or be forwarded for investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C as appropriate), rather than being dismissed at the threshold.
  • The court applied established principles (as cited) regarding preliminary enquiries against public servants and the permissibility of private complaints; the decision instructs the Special Judge to engage in preliminary fact-finding rather than terminate the matter summarily. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond the application of existing authorities noted in the reasoning.

    Sreekumar S. Menon v. State Of Kerala & Another

    1. This revision is directed against the Order dated 31.3.2003 of the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Thrissur in CMP No. 231/2003, rejecting a complaint filed by the petitioner against the send respondent.

    2. The facts necessary for the disposal of this petition may be stated as follows: The second respondent herein was working as Deputy Superintendent of Police in the Vigilance and Anti-corruption Department. The petitioner who is the Secretary of the Kerala People's Forum filed a complaint against the second respondent alleging that he had amassed huge wealth disproportionate to his known sources of income. It is alleged that he has constucted a house, which will cost Rs. 60 lakhs in violation of the approved plan.

    3. It is also alleged that the owns 8 tanker lorries and 4 jeeps which are plying for hire. The further allegation is that two of his children are studying in posh schools where a sum of Rs. 3,000/- per month for a student will have to be spent. On these allegations, the petitioner wanted to initiate proceedings against the second respondent under the prevention of Corruption Act. The learned Special Judge by the impugned order rejected the complaint on the ground that the materials produced do not show prima facie the truthfulness of the allegations. The order is seriously challenged in this revision.

    4. The learned counsel for the petitioner strongly contended that the learned Special Judge seriously erred in finding that the materials produced do not show prima facie truthfulness of the allegations. According to him, the learned Judge ought to have ordered an enquiry into the allegations leveled against the second respondent by the vigilance Department. He further content that there are sufficient materials on record to make out a prime facie case against the second respondent. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the second respondent supported the order and urged that there is no ground for interference.

    5. At the outset, I must say that the order of the court below rejecting the complaint is clearly unsustainable. It is seen that the learned Special Judge rejected the complaint by a cryptic order holding the view that the materials produced do not show prima facie truthfulness of the allegations. On going through the complaint, it cannot be said that the allegations do not disclose the commission of any offence under the prevention of Compitition Act. It is specifically alleged in the complaint; the second respondent has amassed wealth disproportionate to his known source of income. I cannot agree with the court below that the photographs, the plan etc. Produced along with the complaint cannot bring home prima facie truthfulness of the allegations leveled against the second respondent. At this stage, the court is not expected to see whether the allegations are likely to be proved by the materials produced before the court. According to me the learned Special Judge should have at least ordered a preliminary enquiry into the allegations by the Vigilance Department. It is settled positions that the court of Specials Judge being the court of original criminal jurisdiction, the special Judge can forward a private complaint to the police for investigation under Section 156(3) of the Cr. P.C before taking cognisance of the offences. No doubt, since the second respondent is a public servant, there must be some suitable preliminary enquiry into the allegations by a responsible officer in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in P. Sirajuddin, Etc. v. State Of Madras, Etc.† ((1970) 1 SCC 595 : AIR 1971 SC 520). I am of the view that the learned Special Judge ought to have ordered at least a preliminary enquiry, into the allegations leveled against the second respondent. The learned counsel for the second respondent reliving on a Division Bench decision of this court in Satheesh v. Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge (2003 (3) KLT 480) contended that without proper application of mind, the special court cannot issue a direction to the Vigilance Department to conduct an enquiry into the allegations. No doubt, in the decision relied on by the learned counsel, it has been held by this court that “the special court cannot simply act as a Post Office and issue without proper application of mind, a direction tot the vigilance Police to conduct enquiry or investigations into the allegation”. But a special court cannot reject the complaint at the threshold itself without proper application of mind.

    6. The learned counsel for the second respondent further contended that the lower court was fully justified in rejecting the complaint since the petitioner has no locus standi to file the complaint. According to the learned counsel, the petitioner is not a person aggrieved by the alleged offences. I cannot agree. Any person whether aggrieved or not by a particular offence can file a complaint. In this connection, it is relevant to note the following observations of the Supreme Court in A.R Aanthulav v. R.S Naik ((1984) 2 SCC 500 : AIR 1984 SC 718) “It is a well recognized principal of criminal jurisprudence that any one can set or put the criminal law into motion except where the statute enacting or creating an offence indicates to the contrary. The scheme of the Criminal P.C envisages two parallel and independent agencies for taking criminal offences to court. Even if the most serious offence of murder, It was not disputed that a private complaint can, not only be filed, but can be entertained and proceeded with according to law. Locus standi of the complainant is a concept foreign to criminal jurisprudence save and except that where the statute creating ah offence provides for the eligibility of the complainant by necessary implication, the general principal gets excluded by such statutory provision”, in view of the decision of the Supreme Court referred to above, the contention of the learned counsel for the second respondent in this regard cannot be accepted.

    7. For the reasons stated above, I am unable to sustain the impugned order of the lower court rejecting the complaint filed by the petitioner. I set aside the impugned order and direct the Special Judge to order a preliminary enquiry into the allegation leveled against the second respondent by a responsible officer of the Vigilance Department.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sreekumar S. Menon v. State Of Kerala & Another
    (Feb 19, 2004)