Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-clause (c) of clause (1A) and item (b) of sub-clause (iii) of clause (14) of S. 2 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1961)
  • provisions of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1961).SI.
  • S. 2(14)(iii)(a) of the Income-tax Act
  • S. 2(14)(iii)(b) of the Income-tax Act.
  • Kerala Land Reforms Act.
  • Section now:14. Capital
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-clause (c) of clause (1A) and item (b) of sub-clause (iii) of clause (14) of S. 2 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1961)
  • provisions of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1961).SI.
  • S. 2(14)(iii)(a) of the Income-tax Act
  • S. 2(14)(iii)(b) of the Income-tax Act.
  • Kerala Land Reforms Act.
  • Section now:14. Capital
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary: Radhakrishna Menon, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The Revenue referred two questions for the court's opinion. The facts, as stated in the opinion, are that the assessee owned a building known as "Murali Sadan" with 24 cents of land and adjacent agricultural land measuring 94 cents. These properties were sold in a court auction during the assessment year 1981-82 for Rs. 15 lakhs to the Guruvayur Devaswom. The assessing authority computed capital gains at Rs. 1,238,100 and rejected the assessee's contention that, because the lands were agricultural, no capital gains tax was chargeable. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) (CIT(A)) confirmed that assessment. The assessee appealed to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (the Tribunal) which accepted the assessee's contention that the agricultural land was not situated within a municipality for the purposes of S.2(14)(iii)(a) of the Income-tax Act. Two specific questions were referred to the court: (1) whether the land situated within Guruvayur township can be treated as a capital asset within S.2(14) and (2) whether the registered firm (the assessee) is entitled to carry forward and set off unabsorbed depreciation. The court noted that, in light of the Supreme Court ruling in Garden Silk Weaving Factory v. CAT (1991 (189) I.T.R. 512), the second question must be answered in favour of the assessee. The court therefore answered the second question affirmatively and proceeded to decide the first question concerning the municipal character of Guruvayur township.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the land in question situated within Guruvayur township can be treated as a capital asset within the definition of S.2(14) of the Income-tax Act?
  2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, and the assessee being a registered firm, the assessee is entitled to have the unabsorbed depreciation carried forward and set off in its hands?

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue's Arguments

  • The Guruvayur township should be treated as a "Municipality" within the meaning of S.2(14)(iii)(a) of the Income-tax Act; consequently the agricultural land situated within it is excluded from the agricultural-land exclusion and capital gains tax is chargeable on the sale.
  • The term "Municipality" should be read expansively in light of the bracketed expressions in the statute (such as "municipal corporation, notified area committee, town area committee, town committee, or by any other name"), and the phrase "by any other name" supports treating a township as a municipality.

Assessee's Arguments

  • The Guruvayur township, though a local authority, is not a "Municipality" as that term is used in S.2(14)(iii)(a); therefore the land sold is agricultural land situated outside a municipality and is not chargeable to tax under the head "capital gains".
  • The word "Municipality" in the statute must be read to include only those local authorities that possess the characteristic features and institutional trappings of a municipality (e.g., elected council/councillors, chairman, standing committees, and an administrative officer such as a commissioner appointed to carry into effect council resolutions).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Garden Silk Weaving Factory v. CAT, 1991 (189) I.T.R. 512 Used to determine the answer to the second referred question regarding the entitlement of a registered firm to carry forward and set off unabsorbed depreciation. The court accepted that precedent and accordingly answered the second question in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis focused primarily on the construction of S.2(14)(iii)(a) of the Income-tax Act, which excludes "agricultural land in India, not being land situate—(a) in any area which is comprised within the jurisdiction of a municipality ... and which has a population of not less than ten thousand..." The court observed that the language of the section is plain and unambiguous: if the agricultural land is situated outside the jurisdiction of a municipality as defined, profits or gains from its transfer will not be chargeable as capital gains.

To resolve whether the Guruvayur township falls within the meaning of "municipality" for this provision, the court examined the competing contentions. The Revenue argued for an expansive reading of "municipality," relying on the bracketed enumerations in the statute and particularly the phrase "by any other name." The assessee argued that "municipality" must be limited to local authorities possessing the institutional features of a municipality (e.g., elected council of prescribed strength, councillors elected by residents, elected chairman and vice-chairman, a commissioner appointed by the government to implement council resolutions, and standing committees).

The court adopted the assessee's approach and gave a purposive reading: the word "Municipality" in the section must be understood to mean a local authority that satisfies those municipal characteristics. The court explained that merely being a local authority or being called a "township" does not automatically make an entity a "Municipality" within the meaning of S.2(14)(iii)(a).

The court then examined the nature of the Guruvayur Township, constituted under the Guruvayur Township Act, and concluded that it is not an autonomous body like a municipality. It is constituted by government notification under the Township Act, its committee members are not elected representatives of area residents, and therefore it lacks the municipal trappings described above.

The court further noted supporting indicia in government practice and legislative materials: (1) a Central Government draft notification (referenced in the opinion) specified areas "falling within Guruvayur Township upto a distance of 8 Kms. from the municipal limits" as falling outside the local limits of a Municipality or Cantonment Board for the purposes of the Income-tax Act; and (2) an explanation in S.2(25) of the Kerala Land Reforms Act which equates municipal and township land in a manner that reflects a legislative distinction between municipalities and townships. The court treated these materials as consistent with the view that Guruvayur Township is not a "Municipality" under S.2(14)(iii)(a).

On this basis, the court concluded that the Tribunal's finding — that the land situated within Guruvayur township is not land situate within the jurisdiction of a municipality for the purposes of S.2(14)(iii)(a) — was correct and unassailable.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • The court answered the first question in the negative and in favour of the assessee: the land situated within Guruvayur township is not situated within the jurisdiction of a "Municipality" as contemplated by S.2(14)(iii)(a) of the Income-tax Act; accordingly the profit on sale of such agricultural land is not chargeable under the head "capital gains" on that basis.
  • The court answered the second question in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee, following the Supreme Court's decision in Garden Silk Weaving Factory v. CAT: the registered firm (the assessee) is entitled to carry forward and set off unabsorbed depreciation.

Implications: As a direct effect of the decision, the Tribunal's finding that the disputed land did not come within the statutory definition of a municipality was upheld and the Revenue's contention that capital gains tax was chargeable on the sale was rejected. The second issue (carry forward and set off of unabsorbed depreciation) was resolved for the assessee in accordance with the cited Supreme Court authority. The court directed that a copy of the judgment be forwarded to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench. The opinion does not elaborate broader legal or policy implications beyond these direct effects on the parties.

Disposition: The appeal was dismissed (i.e., the Revenue's appeal was dismissed), and formal directions were given for communication of the judgment to the Tribunal.

    Commissioner Of I.T v. Murali Lodge

    Radhakrishna Menon, J.:— The Revenue is before us. The questions referred for our opinion are:

    “1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the land in question situated within Guruvayur township can be treated as a capital asset within the definition of S. 2(14) of the Income tax Act?

    2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, and the assessee being a registered firm, the assessee is entitled to have the unabsorbed depreciation carried forward and set off in its hands?”.

    2. It is the common case of the parties that the second question, in the light of the recent ruling of the Supreme Court in Garden Silk Weaving Factory v. CAT. (1991 (189) I.T.R 512) requires to be answered in favour of the assessee. We accordingly answer the question in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee.

    3. Coming to the first question: The case of the assessee briefly stated is:. The assessee was the owner of the building known as ‘Murali Sadan’ with 24 cents of land and also the land lying contiguous to the said land and measuring 94 cents in extent These properties were sold in court auction which was conducted during the assessment year 1981-82.

    4. They were sold for a sum of Rs. 15 lakhs to the Guruvayur Devaswom. The assessing authority computed the capital gains arising from the transfer of these properties at Rs. 1238,100/- and while doing so rejected the contention of the assessee that, inasmuch as the lands which were sold in court auction were agricultural lands, the question as to whether the assessee is liable to pay tax on capital gains does not arise at all. On appeal, the C.I.T (A) confirmed the order of assessment. The assessee thereupon filed a second appeal before the Tribunal and reiterated the aforesaid contention. Elaborating this contention he submitted that, since this agricultural land cannot besaid to be situated within a municipal area, the transaction will not attract the tax under S. 45.-The Tribunal accepted the above contention (See Annexure-C).

    5. The answer to the question depends upon the construction of S. 2(14)(iii)(a) of the Income-tax Act We shall read the Section now:

    “14. “Capital asset” means property of any kind held by an assessee, whether or not connected with his business or profession, but does not include—

    ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

    (iii) agricultural land in India, not being land situate—

    (a) in any area which is comprised within the jurisdiction of a municipality (whether known as a municipality, municipal corporation, notified area committee, town area committee, town committee, or by any other name) or a cantonment board and which has a population of not less than ten thousand according to the last precedingcensus of which the relevant figures have been published before the first day of the previous year,”

    6. From the plain and unambiguous language employed in this Section it is clear that, if the agricultural land is situated outside the jurisdiction of a municipality, then no tax on any profits or gains arising from the transfer of such land will bechargeable under the head ‘capital gains’. The question therefore is: Whether the agricultural land of the assessee sold in public auction can be said to situate, in an area which is comprised within the jurisdiction of a Municipality. The case of the Revenue is that it is; because, the Guruvayur township is a Municipality within the meaning of that word in the Section. On the other hand the counsel for the assessee submits that the Guruvayur township though alocal authority cannot be said to be a Municipality and therefore the agricultural land in dispute cannot be said to be situated in an area which is comprised within the jurisdiction of a Municipality. The word Municipality used in the section, considered in the light of the various expressions used in the brackets namely “whether known as a municipality, municipal corporation, notified area committee, town area committee, town committee, or by any other name” must be held to take in its fold a township also, the counsel for the Revenue submits. Of the various words included in the brackets, the learned counsel for the Revenue laid emphasis on the words “by any other name”. These words, the counsel argues, take colour from the preceding words and if that be the position the Guruvayur Township also can be called a Municipality. May be that the Guruvayur Township can be called a local authority. But all local authorities cannot be called Municipalities. Only those local authorities which have all the trappings of a Municipality can be treated as a Municipality within the meaning of the Section. Therefore to find a solution for the problematic dispute we have to give a meaning to the word ‘Municipality’ which stands undefined in the Act. Generally understood Municipality means a legally incorporated or duly authorised association of inhabitants of limited area for local governmental or other public purposes. (Blacks Law Dictionary). The above definition more or less is reflected in the provisions contained in Chapter III of. The Kerala Municipalities Act. The Council constituted under S. 7 with the assistance of the standing committee of the Council, Chairman, Commissioner etc. will administer the provisions of the Act. The Council consists of such number of members as are prescribed. They are called Councillors. They are elected by the residents of the area within the jurisdiction of the Municipality. The Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Municipality are elected by the members of the Council. The Commissioner is appointed by the Government in consultation with the Council It is the duty of the Commissioner to carry into effect the resolutions of the Council unless it be that the said resolution is suspended or cancelled by the Government. The Municipality contemplated under S. 2(14)(iii)(a) must be one which satisfies the above requirements. All the local authorities included in the brackets must satisfy the above requirements to be known as Municipality. The position however, would have been different had the Section contained a definition which takes in its fold the local authorities included in the brackets, namely ‘municipal corporation’ notified area committee, town area committee, town committee or such other similar local authority. In that event the Guruvayur Township can be said to be a municipality. The plain language employed in the section however, makes it clear that the intention of the legislature is not to treat every local authority as a Municipality; but on the other hand only those local authorities which have all the trappings of the Municipality as stated above, can be said to be a Municipality within the meaning of the Section.

    7. The Guruvayur Township, constituted under the Guruvayur Township Act, considered in this backdrop, cannot be said to be a Municipality. The Guruvayur Township is not an autonomous body like a municipality. It is constituted by the Government by a notification issued under the Guruvayur Township Act. To put it differently the members of the township committee are not elected representatives of the residents of the area. The Central Government also has understood the position thus is obvious from the draft notification dt. 8-2-1991 published in the Gazette issued under S. 2(14)(iii)(b) of the Income-tax Act. We shall now read that part of this notification which is relevant here:

    “In pursuance of item (B) of clause (ii) of the proviso to sub-clause (c) of clause (1A) and item (b) of sub-clause (iii) of clause (14) of S. 2 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1961) and in supersession the notification of the Government of India in the erstwhile Ministry of Finance (Department of Revenue and Insurance) No. S. 0.77(E) dated the 6th February, 1973, the Central Government having regard to the extent of, and scope for urbanisation of the areas concerned and other relevant considerations, hereby specifies the areas shown in column (4) of the Schedule hereto annexed and falling outside the local limits of Municipality or Cantonment Board, as the case may be, shown in the corresponding entry in column (3) thereof and against the State or Union Territory shown in column (2) thereof for the purposes of the abovementioned provisions of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1961).

    SI. No. Name of the State or Un-ion Territory Name of the Munici-pality or Cantonment Board falling in the State/Union Territory mentioned under Col. (2) Details of areas falling outside the local limits of Municipality or Canton-ment Board etc, mentioned under Col. (3). XII KERALA 2. Chowghat Areas falling with Guruvayur Town-ship upto a distance of 8 Kms. from the municipal limits”.

    8. It is therefore clear that the areas falling within the jurisdiction of the Guruvayur Township cannot be said to be areas within the jurisdiction of a Municipality mentioned in S. 2(14)(jii)(a). The Kerala State legislature which enacted the Guruvayur Township Act also has understood the meaning of the word ‘Municipality’ in the same way in which the Central legislature has understood and that it is so can be seen from S. 2(25) Explanation I of the Kerala Land Reforms Act. The explanation aforesaid provides that in calculating the total extent of the land of akudikidappukaran for the purposes of this clause, three cents inacity or major municipality, shall be deemed to be equivalent to five cents in any other municipality, and three cents in a city or major municipality or five cents in any other municipality shall be deemed to be equivalent to ten cents in a panchayat area or township.

    9. From the discussion above it is clear that the areas lying within the jurisdiction of the Guruvayur township cannot be said to be areas lying within the jurisdiction of a municipality. In other words, the land situated within the jurisdiction of the Guruvayur township must be said to be land not situated within the jurisdiction of a municipality. If that be the position the contention of the Revenue that the land in dispute is situated within the jurisdiction of a municipality and hence the profits, the assessee got by the sale of the sanie in court auction is chargeable to income tax under the head capital gains is liable to be rejected. The findings of the Tribunal are unassailable.

    10. The question therefore is answered in the negative and in favour of the assessee.

    11. A copy of this judgment under the signature of the Registrar and the seal of this court will be forwarded to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench.

    12. Dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of I.T v. Murali Lodge
    (Jun 18, 1991)