Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 5A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963
  • clauses (a), (b) and (c) of section 7-A(1).9.
  • Sales Tax Amendment Act, 19 of 1974.
  • clauses (a), (b) or (c) of section 5A (1)
  • section 7-A of the Madras Act.
  • clause (c) of sub-section (1)
  • Act in section 7-A(1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 5A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963
  • clauses (a), (b) and (c) of section 7-A(1).9.
  • Sales Tax Amendment Act, 19 of 1974.
  • clauses (a), (b) or (c) of section 5A (1)
  • section 7-A of the Madras Act.
  • clause (c) of sub-section (1)
  • Act in section 7-A(1)
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — P.C. Balakrishna Menon, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

These revisions were filed by the assessee against a common order of the Sales' Tax Appellate Tribunal, Trivandrum, which had confirmed the orders of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner of Sales Tax for the assessment periods 1972-73 and 1973-74. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner had, with certain modifications, confirmed the orders of assessment made by the Sales Tax Officer for those periods.

The assessee is a dealer in rose wood, hard wood and goods made of ivory. The business involved local sales, inter-State sales and exports of rose wood and ivory articles. The revision raises questions about the validity of assessments under section 5A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963 in respect of three categories:

  • Ivory purchased from the Travancore Devaswom Board;
  • Purchase value of packing materials;
  • Purchase value of finished/manufactured articles locally purchased and exported outside India.

The assessments relate to periods prior to the commencement of the Sales Tax Amendment Act, 19 of 1974. The statutory authorities had concluded that the purchase turnover in regard to these items was exigible to tax under section 5A.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the purchase turnover in respect of ivory purchased from the Travancore Devaswom Board is exigible to tax under section 5A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963, given that the Devaswom Board was not a dealer and the sale was not part of its business.
  2. Whether the purchase value of packing materials used in connection with the assessee's sales (local, inter‑State and export/consignment) is exigible to tax under section 5A, and to what extent packing materials used for export or consignment are taxable.
  3. Whether the purchase value of finished or manufactured articles that are purchased locally from persons who are not dealers and then exported outside India is exigible to tax under section 5A.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manager, Pulpally Devaswom v. The State of Kerala, [1977] 40 STC 350; 1977 KLT 549 The Devaswom was neither a dealer nor carrying on business in timber; sale of timber by a Devaswom was held exempt from sales tax under section 5 because it was not a sale by a dealer or in the course of business. The court applied this principle to the Travancore Devaswom Board's sale of ivory and held that the ivory purchase was not exigible to sales tax under section 5 at the point of sale by the Devaswom; consequently the question of taxability falls to be considered under section 5A at the point of the assessee's purchase if any clause of section 5A(1) is satisfied.
Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax v. Raja Oil Mills, [1979] 43 STC 78 (Full Bench) On whether purchase turnover of gunny bags (packing materials) used for packing copra is exigible to tax under section 5A: the Full Bench observed that the physical or commercial identity of containers is not necessarily decisive and that how an ordinary customer would view the transaction is significant; where containers are of substantial value an implied agreement to pay extra may be inferred. The court relied on the Full Bench's observations to analyse whether packing materials used by the assessee were exigible to tax under section 5A; it treated packing for export/consignment differently from packing for local sale and remanded the question of extent to the assessing authority for reconsideration.
Malabar Fruit Products Co. v. Sales Tax Officer, [1972] 30 STC 537 (Ker.) Subramonian Poti, J. explained that section 5A applies where goods are sold by persons who are not dealers and the sale escapes taxation at that point, yet subsequent dealing by a dealer in one of the modes in clauses (a), (b) or (c) may attract tax on the purchaser's turnover; this is the scheme of section 5A. The court relied on this exposition to hold that purchase turnover of manufactured/finished articles locally purchased from non-dealers and later exported is exigible to tax under section 5A.
State of Tamil Nadu v. Kanda-swami, [1975] 36 STC 191 (SC) The Supreme Court accepted the Kerala High Court's construction of section 5A (in pari materia with Madras section 7-A) and emphasised that the provision is a charging section creating liability on a dealer's purchase turnover where goods, though generally taxable, have not suffered tax due to the character of particular sales and are later dealt with as in the specified clauses. The court cited this Supreme Court authority to reinforce that section 5A is a charging provision and to support the conclusion that affected purchases by the assessee are exigible to tax under section 5A when dealt with in the specified modes.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by applying the legal principles set out in the cited precedents to the assessed facts for each contested category:

  1. Ivory purchased from the Travancore Devaswom Board:
    • Relying on Manager, Pulpally Devaswom, the court accepted that the Devaswom was not a dealer and that its sale of ivory was not exigible to tax under section 5 at the point of sale.
    • Because the sale to the assessee did not suffer tax under section 5, the question of taxability arises under section 5A — but only if one of clauses (a), (b) or (c) of section 5A(1) is satisfied.
    • The assessments showed that part of the raw ivory purchased was sold locally (and so had already suffered tax at the point of sale) and the balance was used in manufacture of ivory articles for sale or export. The court held that raw ivory consumed in manufacture is liable to tax under section 5A at the point of purchase by the assessee. Even if raw ivory was despatched outside the State in raw form, the purchase value would be exigible unless the assessee established it was sold in the course of inter-State trade or commerce (the assessee did not make such a case).
    • Conclusion: purchase turnover of ivory, except the quantity already sold within the State, is exigible to tax under section 5A.
  2. Packing materials:
    • The statutory authorities had found packing materials exigible to tax under section 5A.
    • Relying on the Full Bench decision in Raja Oil Mills, the court observed that whether packing materials are taxed under section 5A depends on factors such as how an ordinary purchaser would view the transaction and whether containers have substantial value; physical retention of identity is not decisive.
    • The court reasoned that for manufactured ivory and rose wood articles sold within the State the price would likely have carried the cost of packing materials and so those packing materials would have suffered tax at the point of sale. That reasoning does not apply to packing materials used for export or for consignment sales outside the State, which have not suffered tax at any point.
    • Therefore, packing materials used for export and consignment sales fall under clause (c) of sub-section (1) of section 5A to the extent the sale is not the direct result of inter-State trade or commerce, and are exigible to tax under section 5A.
    • Because the statutory authorities below did not consider to what extent packing materials were exigible to tax in the light of these principles, the court required reconsideration by the assessing authority.
  3. Manufactured or finished articles locally purchased and exported:
    • The court observed that these articles were purchased from persons who were not dealers and had not suffered sales tax under section 5.
    • Applying the exposition in Malabar Fruit Products and the Supreme Court's acceptance in State of Tamil Nadu v. Kanda-swami, the court held that where goods have escaped taxation at the point of sale because the seller was not a dealer, section 5A may impose tax on the purchaser's turnover if the goods are subsequently dealt with in the modes specified by the statute.
    • Therefore, purchase turnover of such manufactured/finished articles is exigible to tax under section 5A.
  4. Quantum and estimation:
    • The Appellate Assistant Commissioner found that the entire purchase amount of raw ivory was not assessable because there were local and inter-State sales recorded. In the absence of separate accounts, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner adjusted the purchase turnover exigible to tax under section 5A by estimating on the basis of transfers and exports after deducting the margin earned.
    • The assessing authority was directed to adopt the figure so arrived at by best judgment estimation. Although the assessee challenged taxability under section 5A before the Appellate Tribunal, the assessee did not challenge the quantum estimated by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The court's operative decision is summarized as follows:

  • The orders of the statutory authorities below are set aside to the extent they relate to the levy of purchase tax under section 5A on the packing materials, and the matter is remitted to the assessing authority for reconsideration in the light of the directions and observations contained in the judgment.
  • In all other respects the order of the Tribunal is confirmed.
  • There will be no order as to costs.

Implications (direct effects based on the opinion):

  • The court held that purchase turnover of ivory purchased from the Travancore Devaswom Board and consumed in manufacture or exported outside India is exigible to tax under section 5A, except to the extent of quantities that had already suffered tax by being sold within the State.
  • Packing materials used for export and for consignment sales outside the State have not suffered tax at any earlier point and are exigible to tax under section 5A (falling under clause (c) of sub-section (1)), but the exact extent of taxability is to be reconsidered by the assessing authority.
  • Purchase turnover of manufactured or finished articles locally purchased from persons who are not dealers and which had not suffered tax under section 5 is exigible to tax under section 5A.
  • No broader new legal principle was announced by this court beyond the application of existing authorities; the decision applies established precedents to the facts and remits one issue (packing materials quantum) for factual reconsideration by the assessing authority.

    Jamnadas Ramakissan Das And Co. v. State Of Kerala

    P.C Balakrishna Menon, J.:— These revisions at the instance of the assessee is against the common order of the Sales' Tax Appellate Tribunal, Trivandrum confirming the orders of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner of Sales Tax relating to the periods 1972-73 and 1973-74. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner had with certain modifications confirmed the orders of assessment by the Sales Tax Officer for these periods.

    2. The assessee is a dealer in rose wood, hard wood and goods made of ivory.

    3. They effect sales locally as well as inter-State and also export rose wood and ivory articles for sale outside India. The questions raised in these revision cases relate to the validity of assessment under section 5A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963 in regard to (1) ivory purchased from the Travancore Devaswom Board (2) the purchase value of packing materials and (3) the purchase value of finished articles locally purchased and exported to countries outside India. The statutory authorities have held that the purchase turnover in regard to these items is exigible to tax under section 5A of the Act.

    4. The assessment relates to periods prior to the commencement of the Sales Tax Amendment Act, 19 of 1974. The Travancore Devaswom Board from whom the assessee had purchased ivory is not a dealer in ivory within the meaning of the Act, nor is the sale by the Board to the assessee part of the business of the Board. Sale of timber by a Devaswom was held to be exempt from sales tax in the decision reported in Manager, Pulpally Devaswom v. The State Of Kerala, [1977] 40 STC 350 (Ker); 1977 KLT 549 on the ground that the Devaswom is neither a dealer, nor is it carrying on any business in timber within the meaning of the Act. On the principle as laid down by this Court in Pulpally Devaswom's case, [1977] 40 STC 350; 1977 KLT 549, we are satisfied that the ivory purchased by the assessee from the Travancore Devaswom Board was not exigible to sales tax under section 5 of the Act at the point of sale by the Devaswom Board. The purchase turnover would, therefore, be exigible to tax under section 5A of the Act if any of the clauses (a), (b) or (c) is satisfied. The orders of assessment relating to these periods show that the raw ivory purchased was partly sold locally and the balance used in the manufacture of ivory articles for sale in the market or for export outside India. The turnover relating to local sales of raw ivory has suffered tax at the point of sale and that quantity of ivory sold locally is not exigible to tax under section 5A of the Act. Raw ivory consumed in the manufacture of ivory articles is liable to tax under section 5A of the Act at the point of purchase by the assessee. Even if it is despatched outside the State in raw form, the purchase value will be exigible to tax under section 5A as the assessee has no case that it was sold in the course of inter-State trade or commerce. We are, therefore, clearly of the view that the purchase turnover of ivory except to the extent of the quantity sold within the State is exigible to tax under section 5A of the Act. The statutory authorities below have found that the packing materials purchased by-the assessee are exigible to tax under section 5A of the Act. A Full Bench of this Court in the decision reported in Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax v. Raja Oil Mills, [1979] 43 STC 78 (FB) in considering the question as to whether purchase turnover of gunny bags used for the purpose of packing copra is exigible to tax under section 5A of the Act stated at page 90:

    “The fact that the packing materials, namely, the gunny bags, retain their physical or commercial identity after the contents are removed may not be decisive of the question. We might add that how an ordinary customer would view the transaction concerned, whether he would consider the transaction as a composite one, purchasing the packing materials besides its contents, would be of considerable significance in the matter. Where the containers are of substantial value, it might be possible to infer more readily an implied agreement to pay an extra price for the containers than when they are insignificant in value”.

    5. The Full Bench after setting aside the orders of assessment challenged in that case remanded the case to the Tribunal to consider the question whether the purchase turnover of gunny bags can be assessed under section 5A of the Act.

    6. In the present case the packing materials purchased were utilised for sale of manufactured goods within the State, for inter-State sales and also for consignment to foreign countries. Considering the nature of the manufactured goods made of ivory and rose wood, we are clearly of the view that the sale of such articles would have taken in also the price of the packing materials and would have suffered tax at that point. But that will not be the case in regard to packing materials used for export of articles to foreign countries and also for consignment sales. The packing materials used for export and for consignment sale outside the State have not suffered tax at any point and the purchase turn-over to that extent is exigible to tax under section 5A as it falls squarely under clause (c) of sub-section (1) to the extent the sale is not as a direct result of inter-State trade or commerce. To what extent the purchase turnover of packing materials is exigible to tax as aforesaid is not considered by the statutory authorities below and that question will have to be considered afresh in the light of the principles stated above.

    7. The next point urged on behalf of the assessee relates to the purchase turnover of manufactured articles locally purchased by the assessee and exported to foreign countries. These articles are admittedly purchased from persons who are not dealers within the meaning of the Act and had not suffered sales tax under section 5. We are therefore clearly of the view that the purchase turnover of these articles is exigible to tax under section 5A of the Act. Subramonian Poti, J., as he then was stated in the decision reported in Malabar Fruit Products Co. v. Sales Tax Officer, [1972] 30 STC 537 (Ker.) as follows at page 555:

    “29. Yet another possible case is where casual sales are made by persons who are not dealers as the term is defined in the Act. The goods may be such as to attract tax on their sales, but the sales are under circumstances which would not attract the levy on account of the character of the seller. The conditions to attract clauses (a), (b) or (c) of section 5A (1) may be present. The transactions of sales are not taxable in the circumstances in which they were effected because the person who effected the sales was not a dealer liable to tax under the Act and the circumstances indicate that at no subsequent point the goods would suffer taxation in the State. It is then sought to be taxed in the hands of the purchaser under section 5A. This, according to me, is the scheme of section 5A of the Act and bearing this in mind, I am proposing to resolve the questions of tax liability of the various petitioners whose petitions are before me.”

    8. The decision of the learned Judge was accepted as laying down the correct law by the Supreme Court in the decision reported in State of Tamil Nadu v. Kanda-swami, [1975] 36 STC 191 (SC). The Supreme Court stated thus at page 201:

    “In our opinion, the Kerala High Court has correctly construed section 5A of the Kerala Act which is in pari materia with the impugned section 7-A of the Madras Act. ‘Goods, the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under this Act’ in section 7-A(1) means ‘taxable goods’, that is, the kind of goods, the sale of which by a particular person or dealer may not be taxable in the hands of the seller but the purchase of the same by a dealer in the course of his business may subsequently become taxable. We have pointed out and it needs to be emphasised again that section 7-A itself is a charging section. It creates a liability against a dealer on his purchase turnover with regard to goods, the sale or purchase of which though generally liable to tax under the Act have not, due to the circumstances of particular sales, suffered tax under section 3, 4 or 5, and which after the purchase, have been dealt by him in any of the modes indicated in clauses (a), (b) and (c) of section 7-A(1).”

    9. In view of these decisions we are clearly of the view that the turnover of ivory purchased from the Travancore Devaswom Board and consumed in the manufacture of other articles or exported to places outside India is exigible to tax under section 5A of the Act. The purchase turnover of packing materials used for export of articles outside India is also exigible to tax under section 5A. So also the purchase turnover of manufactured or finished articles locally purchased and which had not suffered tax under section 5, is exigible to tax under section 5A of the Act. In the light of our decision as aforesaid it is necessary to reconsider the purchase turnover of packing materials exigible to tax under section 5A of the Act.

    10. In regard to purchase turnover of raw ivory, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner has found that the entire amount is not assessable as there were local sales and inter-State sales as well. In the absence of separate accounts liable to tax under section 5A, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner had modified the purchase turnover of ivory exigible to tax under section 5A, “on the basis of transfer and exports after deducting the margin earned”. The assessing authority was accordingly directed to adopt the figure arrived at by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner on a best of judgment estimation of the purchase turn-over of ivory exigible to tax under section 5A. Even though the taxability under section 5A was challenged before the Appellate Tribunal, the assessee had no challenge against the quantum estimated by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner.

    11. The result of the foregoing discussion is: the orders of the statutory authorities below are set aside to the extent they relate to levy of purchase tax under section 5A on the packing materials and remit the case to the assessing authority for reconsideration in the light of the directions and observations contained in this judgment. In all other respects the order of the Tribunal is confirmed. There will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jamnadas Ramakissan Das And Co. v. State Of Kerala
    (Feb 3, 1986)