AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Anna Chandi, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The Food Inspector, Kozhikode Municipality (appellant) filed a complaint under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act (Central Act 37 of 1954) against:

  • The Secretary and Branch Manager of the Calicut Co-operative Society (case CC 332 of 1959).
  • The Indian Medical Practitioners Co-operative Pharmacy and Stores Ltd., Adayar, Madras represented by its Secretary (case CC 333 of 1959).

Both cases were tried together before the District Magistrate, Kozhikode, who acquitted the accused in CC 332 of 1959 and convicted the accused in CC 333 of 1959 under section 16(g) read with section 19 of the Food Adulteration Act, sentencing him to pay a fine of Rs. 300 or, in default, to undergo simple imprisonment for three months. The conviction in CC 333 of 1959 was reversed by the Kozhikode Sessions Judge on the ground that it was not proved beyond reasonable doubt that the honey itself was adulterated or, if adulterated, by whom it was done. The present appeal challenges the Sessions Judge's order of acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sample of honey was proved to be adulterated on the basis of the Food Analyst's tests (Fiehe's test and aniline chloride test) and the evidence available.
  2. Whether non-conformity with the statutory standard (including a positive Fiehe's test where the rule prescribes a negative Fiehe's test) results in the article being deemed adulterated under Section 2(1)(i) of the Act.
  3. Whether a written warranty from a prior seller (successive warranties) absolves the accused-seller of criminal liability under Section 19(2) of the Act.
  4. Whether Section 23(1)(b) of the Act involves an excessive or unconstitutional delegation of legislative power to the Executive in empowering the Central Government to frame rules defining food standards.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Sessions Judge's finding that the honey was not proved to be adulterated is unsustainable.
  • The positive results of the Food Analyst's tests (Exhibit P-3 and Dw.1 evidence) indicate the presence of artificial invert sugar and therefore adulteration.

Accused / Defence Arguments

  • That a positive Fiehe's test is not conclusive of adulteration because pure honey, if previously heated, may give a positive Fiehe's reaction (relying on published analytical authorities).
  • The accused relied on a written warranty (Ext. D-1) from the supplier (Dw.3) to argue that the warranty would absolve him of liability under Section 19(2).
  • There was a submission challenging the rule-making power under Section 23(1)(b) as excessive delegation to the Executive.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Supreme Court in "M.V Jhosi ???s, Shimpri, 1961 2 Ker LR 289" Authority for the proposition that if the quality or purity of an article falls below the standard prescribed by the relevant rule, it shall be deemed to be adulterated within the meaning of Section 2 of the Act (statutory fiction — non-conformity equals adulteration). The court relied on this principle to hold that a positive Fiehe's test (when the rule prescribes a negative result) and non-conformity with the statutory standard renders the honey "adulterated" as a matter of law, and that the accused cannot seek to prove that, despite non-conformity, the article is in fact not adulterated.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in distinct steps, grounded in the statutory standards for honey and the evidentiary record:

  1. Statutory standard: The court cited Clause A.07.08 of Appendix B of the Rules under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act which defines "honey" and prescribes its quality standards, including that Fiehe's test should be negative.
  2. Forensic evidence: The Food Analyst's report (Exhibit P-3) and his evidence as Dw.1 established that he applied two tests to the sample — Fiehe's test and the aniline chloride test — and both showed positive reactions indicating the presence of artificial invert sugar. There was no suggestion in cross-examination that the tests were improperly conducted, nor was such an argument advanced before the appellate court or this court.
  3. Defence contention on tests: The defence relied on authority (textbooks by J.R. Nicholls, Woodman and H.C. Cox) to contend that heated pure honey can give a positive Fiehe's test. The court examined the textual passages quoted from those works and observed that the authors qualify the statement — heated honeys give positive Fiehe's test only when heating is drastic enough to affect flavour or produce near-caramelisation, and that appearance/flavour are thereby impaired.
  4. Use of corroborative testing: The court gave weight to the fact that, besides Fiehe's test (the only test prescribed by the rules), the analyst also applied the aniline chloride test which likewise yielded a positive result. The court noted the textbook observation (Woodman) that the aniline chloride test is less delicate but also less sensitive to the effects of age and temperature and is used to supplement the Fiehe's test, thus reducing the possibility that a positive result was solely due to heating.
  5. Percentage determination not required: Although the analyst admitted he could not state the percentage of artificial invert sugar present, the court observed that neither the rules nor textbooks require that percentage of artificial invert sugar be determined before classifying a test result as positive. The Sessions Judge's suggestion that percentage should have been mentioned was not viewed as fatal to the prosecution's case.
  6. Statutory deeming: The court turned to Section 2(1)(i) of the Act which provides that an article of food shall be deemed adulterated if its quality or purity falls below the prescribed standard. Because the rule prescribes a negative Fiehe's test and the sample produced a positive result, the court held that the honey's quality or purity fell below the statutory standard and it must be deemed adulterated. The court relied on the cited Supreme Court authority to emphasize that once statutory standards are not met, the fiction applies and an accused cannot prove that the article is in fact not adulterated despite non-conformity.
  7. Warranty defence and successive warranties: The court analysed Section 19(2) (conditions for relief by warranty) and noted three required elements in the provision. It observed that successive warranties are not covered by the statutory protection and relied on Halsbury's statement (as cited) that while a buyer (C) prosecuted may rely on a warranty from the seller (B), B (if prosecuted) cannot plead the warranty he received from A as a substantive defence. The court also found no acceptable evidence that the consignment covered by the supplier's warranty was identical to the consignment sold to the Calicut Society, particularly given the nine-month lapse and the admitted heating of the disputed honey; thus the warranty defence failed.
  8. Delegation challenge: The court rejected the submission that Section 23(1)(b) constituted excessive or unconstitutional delegation of power to the Executive to frame rules defining food standards, finding that the Act sufficiently indicates its object and that rules were framed only consistent with that object.
  9. Conclusion of analysis: Taking the test results, the corroborative aniline chloride test, the statutory standard and the deeming provision together, the court concluded it was safe to find that the sample of honey contained artificial invert sugar and was therefore adulterated as a matter of law.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The order of acquittal by the Sessions Judge was set aside. The accused was convicted under Section 16(8) read with Section 19 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act and sentenced to pay a fine of Rs. 300, and in default to undergo simple imprisonment for three months. The fine is to be paid within one month.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The accused's acquittal has been reversed and conviction and sentence restored as described above.
  • On legal principle: The court reaffirmed that non-conformity with a prescribed standard (including a positive Fiehe's test where a negative test is prescribed) results in a statutory deeming of adulteration under Section 2(1)(i), limiting an accused's ability to argue that, despite non-conformity, the article is in fact not adulterated.
  • On warranty defence: The court held that successive warranties do not automatically provide a substantive defence under Section 19(2), and factual proof of identity of consignments (which was absent here) is necessary for such a defence to succeed.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion applied existing authorities and statutory interpretation but did not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond the application of the statute and cited authority; no new, separate precedent was announced beyond the adjudication of the facts on the record.

Acquittal set aside. Conviction and sentence imposed as above.

    Food Inspector Kozhikode v. Indian Medical Practitioners, Co-Operative Pharmacy & Stores Ltd.

    Anna Chandi, J.:— This is an appeal against acquittal. The appellant the Food Inspector, Kozhikode, Municipality had filed a complaint under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act (Central Act 37 of 1954) against the Secretary and Branch Manager of the Calicut Co-operative Society from the Indian Medical Practitioners Co-operative Pharmacy and'Stores Ltd., Adayar, “Madras under a written warranty of purity a separate case was filed”against that company represented by its Secretary. Both the cases were tried together by the District Magistrate, Kozhikode, who while acquitting the accused in the first case (CC 332 of 1959) convicted the accused in the second (CC 333 of 1959) u/s. 16(g) read with section 19 of the Food Adulteration Act and sentenced him to pay a fine of Rs. 300/- or in default to undergo simple imprisonment for three months. The judgment was taken in appeal before the Kozhikode Sessions Judge who reversed the conviction and sentence on the ground that “It was not proved beyond reasonable doubt that the honey itself was adulterated if adulterated by whom it was done”. This appeal is against the above order.

    2. The main point urged by the appellant is that the finding of the learned Sessions Judge that the honey has not been proved to be adulterated is unsustainable.

    3. Clause A. 07.08 in Appendix B of the Rules under Prevention of Food Adulteration Act. (hereinafter referred to as the Act) defines honey and fixes its standard of quality as follows:

    “Honey means the food derived entirely from the work of bees operating upon the nectar of flowers and other sweet exudation of plants. It shall not contain more than (a) 25 percent of moisture (b) 0.9 percent of ash, and (c) 10 percent of surcose. The minimum reducing sugar content shall be 60 percent. Fiehe's test should be negative”.

    4. In Ex. P-3 report of the Food Analyst he has given his opinion that the sample of honey sent for analysis contained artificial inverst sugar and was therefore adulterated. The analyst was examined as Dw. 1 and he gave evidence that applied two test, namely Fiehe's test and aniline Choloride test to the sample of honey sent to him for analysis and both the tests showed positive reaction indicating the presence of artificial invert sugar. There is no suggestion in his cross-examination that the test were not properly conducted. No such argument was also advanced before me nor does it appear to have been advanced before the appellate court. The stand taken before this court as well as before the Sessions Court was that the test itself is no a conclusive one in that even pure honey if it had been heated previously will give positive reaction and as such no inference that the honey is adulterated can be drawn from the mere fact that the Fiehe's test was positive. (The evidence in this case is that the honey was heated by the accused for the removal of was an other foreign bodies so that the honey could be used in medicinal preparations) This contention is based on the observation made by J.R Nicholls in his book on Aids to Analysis of Food and Drugs Seventh Edition-Page 248 that.

    “Heated pure honeys frequently give a positive Fiehe's test”.

    5. However the above observation is only the first part of sentence the latter portion of which goes on to say that:

    “………………;but unless the heating has been so drastic as to affect the flavour of the honey. No hydroxy-methyl furfuraldehyde can be detected by ultra-violed absorption”.

    6. Woodman in his book on food Analysis which is also a standard book on the subject gives expression to the same opinion. On page 335 when dealing with resorcin test (Fiehe's) the learned author observes:

    “Honey that has been boiled or strongly heated for some time, especially if somewhat acid in reaction, will sometimes give a similar reaction, but such high temperature are seldom appearance and flavour are thereby impaired, the colour being much darder. Experimental tests have shown that honey must be heated almost to incipient carame-lization to give a good positive action.

    7. H.C Cox in his book on Chemical Analysis of Foods page 36 has this to say about Fiehe's test.

    “This test is characteristic of artificial honeys and is not given by genuine honeys, even if they have been heated and long stored, although a momentary pink colour sometimes appears if they have been much heated”.

    8. When it was suggested to the Food Analyst that heated pure honey gives a positive Fiehe's test his reply was that it gives “a fairly positive test” but be maintained that he was positive that the sample of honey analysed by him was adulterated. It is seen that besides applying the Fiehe's test which is the only test prescribed by the rules the Food Analyst by way of abundant caution has also applied the aniline Chloride test which also yielded a positive result and thereby minimised the possibility of error. Woodman at page 335 observes:

    “The Aniline Chloride test is less delicate than Fiehe Test, but at the same time less sensitive to effect of age and temperature, hence on supplements the other”.

    9. It was admitted the Analyst that from these two tests he will not be able to give the percentage of artificial invert sugar present in the sample. The learned Sessions Judge seems to counsel that the failure to mention the percentage efficacy of the test. Neither the rules nor the textbooks prescribe that the percentage of artificial invert sugar should be determined before the result of the test could be classed as positive. Taking all the things into consideration I think it is safe sample of honey sent to him contained artificial invert sugar and was therefore adulterated.

    10. Moreover even if one were to recognise the possibility that the positive result was due to the honey having been heated as claimed by the defence I do not think that so long as the honey does not cnoform to the standard prescribed by the Act, it is open to the accused to contend that the honey is not in fact adulterated. Section 2(I)(i) of the Act provides that an article of food shall be deemed to be adulterated if the quality or purity of the article falls below the prescribed standard or its constituents are present in quantities which are in excess of the prescribed limits of variability. As mentioned earlier one of the standard prescribed for honey is that Fiehe test should be negative. When that test yielded a positive result as in this case, the quality or purity of the article has fallen below the standard prescribed by the said rule and it shall be deemed to Act. As observed by the Supreme Court in M.V Jhosi ???s, Shimpri, 1961 2 Ker LR 289.

    “…………if the quality or purity of the article falls below the stan dard prescribed by the said rule, it shall be deemed to be adulterated within the meaning of Section 2 of the Act. If the prescribed standard is not attained, the statute treats such article by fiction, as an adultera ted article though in fact it is not adulterated. To put it in other words by reason of the fiction it is not permissible for an accused to prove that though the standard prescribed is not attained the confirmity the article of food is in fact not adulterated. The non confirmity with the standard prescribed makes the article an adulterated Food”.

    11. The honey was sold as honey and whether it was heated or not it must conform to the standard prescribed in the Act or it must be deemed to be adulterated. It is not open to the accused to contend that the honey he sold though it did not conform to the standard prescribed by the Act was not in fact adulterated. The order of acquittal cannot be sustained on the basis.

    12. The learned counsel for the accused attempted to support the order of acquittal on other grounds as well. The defence case is that the honey in question sold by them to the Calicut Co-operative Society came from the consignment purchased by them from Dw. 3 and under Ext, D-1 warranty. The learned defence counsel argues that this warranty would absolve the accused of all liability. Section 19(2) provide that:

    (i) that the article of food purchased by him was the same in nature, substance and quality as that demanded by the purchaser and with a written warranty in the prescribed form, if any, to the effect that it was of such nature, substance and quality.

    (ii) that he had no reason to believe at the time when he sold it that the food was not of such nature, substance and quality; and.

    (iii) That he sold it in the same state as he purchased it”.

    13. The section does not appear to be applicable in the case of successive warranties; Halsbury in his Laws of England in dealing with “Successive warranties” (their edition Vol. 17, page 601) observed that:

    “The case of successive warranties, however, does not fall within the statutory provisions; thus if A sells to B with warranty, though C on being prosecuted for adulteration, may rely successfully on the warranty from B, B on being prosecuted for giving a false warranty cannot plead as a substantive defence, the warranty he received from A”.

    14. Moreover in the case there is no acceptable evidence that the consignment covered by Ext. D-3 warranty is identical with that covered by Ext. D-1 and considering the lapse of about nine months between the supply of the honey covered by the warranty and the sale of the disputed honey to the Calicut Society, it is not possible to find that they are identical. Fu. ther the honey that is covered by the warranty was not supplied to the Calicut Society in the same condition as it was received; it was admittedly heated.

    15. Another ground urged was that there is excessive and arbitrary delegation of powers to the executive under Section 23 sub-section (1)(b) which empowers, the Central Government to frame rules under the Act defining the standards of quality of articles of food. No question of any unconstitutional delegation of powers arises in the case. There is ample indication in the Act as to the object for which it was made and it is only the power to frame rules consistent with the said object that was delegated to the Executive.

    16. The order of acquittal is therefore set aside and the accused is convicted under Section 16(8) read with Section 19 of the Prevention of food Adulteration Act and sentenced to pay a fine of Rs. 300/- and in default to undergo simple imprisonment for three months. The fine will be paid within a month.

    17. Acquittal set aside.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Food Inspector Kozhikode v. Indian Medical Practitioners, Co-Operative Pharmacy & Stores Ltd.
    (Oct 23, 1961)