Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, Nedungadi Bank Ltd., Kozhikode, issued two cheques (Nos. 355875 and 355896) on the Central Bank of India Ltd., Barabazar Branch, Calcutta. According to the counterfoils, cheque No. 355875 was dated 24-10-1949, payable to the Anglo Swiss Watch Company for Rs. 82-8-0; cheque No. 355896 was dated 10-11-1949, payable to New Standard Watch Company for Rs. 165-0-0.

When presented at the Central Bank of India, Barabazar Branch, cheque No. 355875 (presented 3-11-1949) bore the date 29-10-1949, named Amulya Ratan Saha Ray as payee and was for Rs. 1,765-0-0. Cheque No. 355896 (presented 17-11-1949) bore the date 14-11-1949, named Radheshyam Agarwalla as payee and was for Rs. 3,897-0-0. The Barabazar Branch honoured the cheques and debited the plaintiff’s current account for those amounts.

The plaintiff sued seeking recovery of the total debited amount (Rs. 5,662-0-0), alleging negligence by the Central Bank in failing to detect alleged alterations in the cheques and refusing payment on that account.

The principal procedural question in the appeal (C.M.A.) was whether the suit was properly instituted in the Subordinate Judge of South Malabar, Kozhikode (i.e., whether that court had jurisdiction). The lower court held it did not. The appellate court dismissed the appeal with costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Subordinate Judge of South Malabar, Kozhikode, had jurisdiction to try the suit challenging debits made by the Central Bank of India Ltd., Barabazar Branch, Calcutta.
  2. Whether the presence of a branch of the defendant bank at Kozhikode or the fact that the cheques were drawn within Kozhikode suffices to constitute a cause of action arising, wholly or in part, within the jurisdiction of the Kozhikode court under Section 20(a) and (c) of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908, and Explanation II to Section 20.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • Paragraph 15 of the plaint asserted the cause of action arose on 3-11-1949 and 17-11-1949 when the defendant paid the amounts under the two cheques and debited those sums to the plaintiff’s current account.
  • The plaint further stated that the originals of the forged cheques were drawn in Nagaram amsom in Calicut, within the jurisdiction of the Kozhikode court, and that the defendant bank carried on business through its branch at Calicut, giving that court jurisdiction.

Respondent's (Defendant's) Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's separate, specific legal arguments; the record shows the lower court concluded that the cause of action did not arise at Kozhikode and therefore that court had no jurisdiction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. Ltd. v. Harnam Singh, AIR 1955 SC 590 Principle that a bank's obligation to pay a customer's cheques rests primarily on the branch at which the customer keeps his account; a bank can refuse to cash a cheque at any other branch. The court relied on this principle to support the conclusion that the relevant obligation and cause of action are connected to the Barabazar Branch (where the account was debited), undermining a claim that Kozhikode had jurisdiction.
Mt. Chand Kour v. Partab Singh, ILR 16 Cal 98 (PC) Definition that "cause of action" refers to the grounds set forth in the plaint — i.e., the material facts on which the plaintiff asks the court to grant relief. The court applied this definition to determine that nothing in the plaint showed the cause of action arose wholly or partly at Kozhikode.
Rhokana Corporation Ltd. v. Inland Revenue Commissioners, 1938 AC 380 No specific rule extracted in the opinion. The court stated it could not find anything in this decision that assisted in deciding the present case.
Commr. of Income Tax, Bombay South v. Ogale Glass Works Ltd., AIR 1954 SC 429 Passages cited relate to the principle that, where an addressee requests posting, the post office becomes the addressee's agent and delivery by post may constitute performance of the debtor's obligation. The court observed that the quoted passages concern post-office agency principles and held they were irrelevant to the jurisdictional question before it.
Jagadish Mills Ltd. v. Commr. of Income-tax, Bombay North, Kutch and Saurashtra, Ahmedabad, AIR 1959 SC 1160 No specific rule extracted in the opinion. The court indicated it found nothing in this decision that affected its view on jurisdiction in the present case.
Horsburgh W.P. v. Chandroji Sambajirao, AIR 1957 Madh Bha 90 No specific rule extracted in the opinion. The court stated it did not find this decision helpful for resolving the jurisdictional issue.
Jivatlal Purtapshi v. Lalbhai Fulchand, AIR 1942 Bom 251 No specific rule extracted in the opinion. The court noted this decision but found nothing in it that militated against or assisted the view taken on jurisdiction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis focused on the jurisdictional provisions of Section 20 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (suits where a defendant "carries on business" — Sec. 20(a) — and where the "cause of action, wholly or in part, arises" — Sec. 20(c)) and Explanation II to Section 20, which limits the meaning of "carries on business" for corporations by deeming a corporation to carry on business at its sole or principal office or, in respect of a cause of action arising at any place where it has a subordinate office, at such place.

The court relied on commentary (Chitaley) to explain that the effect of Explanation II is to restrict the meaning of "carries on business" for corporations and that the presence of a subordinate office alone does not dispense with the requirement that some part of the cause of action must arise at that place. The court summarized this as: if no part of the cause of action arises where the branch is located, the mere existence of a branch will not give that court jurisdiction.

Turning to the plaint, the court quoted paragraph 15, in which the plaintiff asserted the cause of action arose when the defendant paid the cheques and debited the account (dates given) and that the originals were drawn within Kozhikode jurisdiction. The court analyzed these assertions and held:

  • The debits were effected at the Barabazar Branch in Calcutta and cannot reasonably be said to give rise to a cause of action within Kozhikode.
  • The fact that the cheques were drawn within the Kozhikode court's territorial jurisdiction does not suffice to establish that any part of the cause of action arose there for purposes of Section 20(c).
  • Applying the Delhi Cloth principle, the primary obligation to pay rests with the branch where the customer keeps his account — here, Barabazar — reinforcing that the cause of action is connected to Calcutta, not Kozhikode.
  • Applying the Mt. Chand Kour definition of "cause of action," the court found nothing in the plaint that established a cause of action arising wholly or partly at Kozhikode.
  • Other authorities cited by counsel (including Rhokana, Ogale Glass Works, Jagadish Mills, Horsburgh, and Jivatlal Purtapshi) were considered and found not to assist the plaintiff; the Ogale Glass Works passages relied upon concerned post-office agency and were not relevant to the present jurisdictional issue.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appellate court affirmed that the cause of action in respect of the Rs. 5,662-0-0 debited to the plaintiff’s account at the Central Bank of India Ltd., Barabazar Branch, Calcutta, did not arise wholly or in part within the jurisdiction of the Court of the Subordinate Judge of South Malabar, Kozhikode. The appeal is dismissed with costs.

Implications: The direct effect is that the suit, as instituted in Kozhikode, cannot be maintained for lack of jurisdiction; the proper forum is connected to the Barabazar Branch in Calcutta where the account was debited. The opinion does not indicate that any broader legal principle or new precedent was established beyond the application of existing jurisdictional principles; the court expressly found earlier authorities cited did not alter its conclusion.

    Nedungadi Bank Ltd. v. Central Bank Of India Ltd.

    M.S Menon, J.:— The plaintiff, the Nedungadi Bank Ltd., Kozhikode, issued two cheques, Nos. 355875 and 355896, on the Central Bank of India Ltd., Barabazar Branch, Calcutta. According to the counterfoil of cheque No. 355875 (Ext. A-3) the date of that cheque should be 24-10-1949, the payee, the Anglo Swiss Watch Company, and the amount covered Rs. 82-8-0. According to the counterfoil of cheque No. 355896 (Ext. A-4) the date of that cheque should be 10-11-1949, the payee, New Standard Watch Company, and the amount covered, Rs. 165-0-0.

    2. Cheque No. 355875 when presented at the office of the Central Bank of India Ltd., Barabazar Branch, Calcutta on 3-11-1949 bore the date 29-10-1949. The payee mentioned in the cheque was Amulya Ratan Saha Ray, and the amount, Rs. 1,765-0-0. Cheque No. 355896 when presented at the office of the Central Bank of India Ltd., Barabazar Branch, Calcutta, on 17-11-1949 bore the date 14-11-1949. The payee mentioned in the cheque was Radheshyam Agarwalla, and the amount, Rs. 3,897-0-0. The cheques were duly honoured and the Central Bank of India Ltd., Barabazar Branch, Calcutta, debited the amounts in the current account of the plaintiff with that branch. The plaint questions the validity of the two debits and seeks recovery of the total of those debits, namely, Rs. 5,662-0-0, on the ground that the Central Bank of India Limited was negligent in the discharge of its duty as a banker of the plaintiff in not discovering the alterations in the cheques and refusing payment on that account.

    3. The only question that arises for determination in this C.M.A is whether the suit can be instituted as has been done by the plaintiff in the Court of the Subordinate Judge of South Malabar, Kozhikode. Issue No. 1 — “Whether this court has jurisdiction to try this suit?” — relates to this question. The lower court considered the arguments advanced before it and said:

    “Both under the general law of banker and customer and on the narrower aspect of the claim made for repayment of two sums of money wrongly debited in the current account of the plaintiff at Calcutta the cause of action cannot be said to have arisen in Kozhikode. I hold that this court has no jurisdiction to try this suit”.

    4. It is common ground that the head office of the Central Bank of India Limited is in Bombay, and that it has a branch at Kozhikode. Under section 20(a) of the CPC, 1908, it is possible to institute a suit where the defendant “carries on business”, and under Sec. 20(c) where the “cause of action, wholly or in part, arises”. Explanation II to Sec. 20 provides:

    “A corporation shall be deemed to carry on business at its sole or principal office in India or, in respect of any cause of action arising at any place where it has also a subordinate office, at such place”.

    5. As pointed out by Chitaley:

    “The result of this explanation is to restrict the meaning of the expression “carries on business” in cl. (a) in relation to corporations. But in the presence of cl. (c) the purpose of the second part of the explanation is obscure. However that may be where the suit is instituted at a place where a corporation maintains a subordinate office, the Court cannot dispense with the requirement that the cause of action must arise at such a place”. Civil Procedure Code, Vol. I, page 558; see also the cases cited in the commentary in support of the proposition.

    6. In other words, if no part of the cause of action arises at the place where the branch office is situate, the mere fact of the corporation having a branch office will not give the court of that place jurisdiction to entertain a suit.

    7. Paragraph 15 of the plaint reads as follows:

    “The cause of action for this suit arose on 3-11-1949 and 17-11-1949 when the defendant paid the amounts respectively under the two cheques and debited the said amounts against the plaintiff in its current account and thereafter in Nagaram amsom in Calicut in South Malabar where the originals of the forged cheques were drawn within the jurisdiction of this Court. This court has also jurisdiction to entertain this suit as the defendant bank is carrying on its business through its branch at Calicut within the jurisdiction of this court”.

    8. The debiting of the amounts covered by the cheques on 3-11-1949 and 17-11-1949 in the current account of the plaintiff at the Barabazar Branch cannot possibly the said to give rise to a cause of action, within the jurisdiction of the Subordinate Judge of South Malabar, Kozhikode. Nor can the fact that the cheques were drawn within the jurisdiction of that court suffice. It is equally clear that the existence of a branch of the Central Bank of India Limited at Kozhikode will not also sustain a suit at Kozhikode if no part of the cause of action arose within the jurisdiction of the Court at Kozhikode. It has also to be borne in mind that, as pointed out by the Supreme Court in Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. Ltd. v. Harnam Singh, (S) AIR 1955 SC 590, “the obligation of a bank to pay the cheques of a customer rests primarily on the branch at which, fee keeps his account and the bank can rightly refuse to cash a cheque at any other branch”.

    9. The expression cause of action “refers entirely to the grounds set forth in the plaint as the cause of action, or, in other words, to the media upon which the plaintiff asks the Court to arrive at a conclusion in his favour”, Mt. Chand Kour v. Partab Singh, ILR. 16 Cal 98 (PC). There is nothing in the plaint which can lead us to the conclusion that the cause of action arose either wholly or in part at Kozhikode.

    10. Counsel for the appellant drew our attention to Rhokana Corporation Ltd. v. Inland Revenue Commissioners, 1938 AC 380; Commr. of Income Tax, Bombay South, Bombay v. Ogale Glass Works Ltd. Ogalewadi, AIR 1954 SC 429; Jagadish Mills Ltd. v. Commr. of Income-tax, Bombay North, Kutch and Saurashtra, Ahmedabad, AIR 1959 SC 1160; Horsburgh, W.P v. Chandroji Sambajirao, AIR 1957 Madh Bha 90 and Jivatlal Purtapshi v. Lalbhai Fulchand, AIR 1942 Bom 251. We are unable to find anything in these decisions which is of assistance for the decision of this case or which militates against the view we have taken. In AIR 1954 SC 429, for example, the question decided in the passages to which our attention was drawn with be clear from the following extract:

    “There can be no doubt that as between the sender and the addressee it is the request of the addressee that the cheque be sent by post that makes the post office the agent of the addressee. After such request the addressee cannot be heard to say that the post office was not his agent and, therefore, the loss of the cheque in transit must fall on the sender on the specious plea that the sends? having the very limited right to reclaim the cheque under the Post Office Act, 1898, the Post Office was his agent when in fact there was no such reclamation. Of course if there be no such request, express or implied, then the delivery of the letter or the cheque to the Post Office is delivery to the agent of the tender himself. Apart from this principle of agency there is another principle which makes the delivery of the cheque to the post office at the request of the addressee a delivery to him and that is that by posting the cheque in pursuance of the request of the creditor the debtor performs his obligation in the manner prescribed and sanctioned by the creditor and thereby discharges the contract by such performance”.

    11. This certainly has nothing to do with the case before us. In the light of what is stated above we must bold that the plaintiffs cause of action, if any, in respect of the sum of Rs. 5,662-0-0 debited in its account with the Central Bank of India Ltd., Barabazar Branch, Calcutta, did not arise wholly or in part within the jurisdiction of the Court of the Subordinate Judge of South Malabar, Kozhikode, and that this appeal must fail. The appeal is dismissed with costs.

    KD/D.H.Z

    12. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nedungadi Bank Ltd. v. Central Bank Of India Ltd.
    (Apr 6, 1960)