Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 16 COURT FEES ACT 1870
  • provisions of Section 89 of C.P.C
  • provisions of Section 89, C.P C.
  • provision of Section 89, C.P.C,
  • Section 89 of C.P.C
  • Section 89, C.P.C,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 16 COURT FEES ACT 1870
  • provisions of Section 89 of C.P.C
  • provisions of Section 89, C.P C.
  • provision of Section 89, C.P.C,
  • Section 89 of C.P.C
  • Section 89, C.P.C,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent No. 1, Honnali Taluk Agricultural Produce Co-operative Marketing Society Ltd., filed a suit (O.S No. 197/1985) against the appellants and other respondents seeking recovery of Rs. 50,053 along with interest. The Trial Court decreed the suit on 20-9-1995. The appellants filed R.A No. 54/2000 and respondent No. 4 filed R.A No. 56/2000 against the decree, both of which were dismissed by the Appellate Court on 24-3-2005, confirming the Trial Court's judgment. The appellants then filed RSA No. 1374/2005. During the pendency of this appeal, the parties settled the dispute out of court, and the appellants requested dismissal of the appeal as settled and refund of the full Court-fees paid. The Court accepted the compromise, dismissed the appeal accordingly, but kept open the question of refunding the Court-fees due to potential financial implications for the State Government. The appellants subsequently filed the present miscellaneous application seeking refund of the full Court-fees paid in RSA No. 1374/2005.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether appellants are entitled to a refund of the full Court-fees paid in RSA No. 1374/2005 after the appeal was dismissed as settled out of court without invoking Section 89 of the Civil Procedure Code (C.P.C)?
  2. Whether the decision in A. Sreeramaiah v. The South Indian Bank Ltd., which involved settlement under Section 89 of C.P.C, applies to cases where settlement occurs without invoking Section 89?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellants contended that since the dispute was settled amicably without any intervention by the Court or any arbitrator/conciliator/mediator, and the appeal was dismissed as settled out of court, they are entitled to a refund of the full Court-fees under Section 16 of the Court Fees Act, 1870.
  • They relied on the Division Bench decision in A. Sreeramaiah v. The South Indian Bank Ltd., where refund of full Court-fees was granted after settlement of the appeal.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The learned Government Pleader argued that the Division Bench decision in A. Sreeramaiah was based on a settlement made by invoking Section 89 of the C.P.C., which involves court-referred settlement mechanisms.
  • He contended that since the present case did not involve invocation of Section 89, that precedent is inapplicable, and therefore, refund of Court-fees should not be granted.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A. Sreeramaiah v. The South Indian Bank Ltd., ILR 2006 KAR 4032 Entitlement to refund of full Court-fees upon amicable settlement of appeal invoking Section 89 of C.P.C. The Court considered this precedent and distinguished the present case on the basis that no Section 89 invocation occurred, but ultimately extended the principle of refund to settlements without court intervention.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the nature of settlement in the present case, noting that the dispute was resolved amicably between the parties without intervention by the Court or any arbitrator/mediator, and without invoking Section 89 of the C.P.C. The Court acknowledged the respondent's argument that the cited precedent involved settlements under Section 89, which may cause State expenditure, whereas settlements without court intervention do not. However, the Court reasoned that since the dispute was settled without Court intervention, the party paying Court-fees should be entitled to a refund under Section 16 of the Court Fees Act, 1870, irrespective of invocation of Section 89. The Court rejected the Government Pleader's contention that the precedent was inapplicable, holding that the principle of refund applies equally to settlements both with and without invoking Section 89.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the miscellaneous application and directed the refund of the entire amount of Court-fees paid by the appellants in RSA No. 1374/2005.

The direct effect is that the appellants receive a full refund of the Court-fees paid for the appeal dismissed as settled out of court. The Court did not set any new precedent beyond applying the existing principle of refund under Section 16 of the Court Fees Act, 1870 to settlements without court intervention.

    Kamalamma And Others v. Honnali Taluk Agricultural Produce Co-Operative Marketing Society Ltd., Honnali And Others

    Arali Nagaraj, J.:— This Miscellaneous application is filed under Section 16 of the Court Fees Act, 1870 seeking direction to the office of this Court to return to the appellants, the full Court-Fee paid by them in RSA No. 1374/2005.

    2. The facts leading to the present petition are as under:

    (a) The respondent No. 1 herein namely Honnali Taluk Agricultural Produce Co-operative Marketting Society Ltd., filed O.S No. 197/1985 on the file of the learned Addl. (Civil Judge (Senior Division), Shimoga against the appellants and also the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 in this second appeal for recovery of a sum of Rs. 50.053/- together with interest thereon. The said suit came to be decreed by the said Trial Court by its judgment and decree dated 20-9-1995. Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree, the appellants filed R.A No. 54/2000 in the Court of the learned District Judge, Davanagere. Aggrieved by the same judgment and decree, the respondent No. 4 herein filed R.A No. 56/2000 before the same Appellate Court. By its common judgment 24-3-2005, the Appellate Court dismissed both the said appeals and thereby confirmed the judgment and decree dated 20-9-1995 passed in the said O.S No. 197/1985. Aggrieved by the said common judgment of the Appellate Court, the appellants herein (the defendants in the original suit) filed RSA No. 1374/2005.

    (b) During the pendency of the said RSA. on 30.1.2009 the learned Counsel for the appellants filed a memo stating that the matter involved the said suit came to be ‘settled out of Court’ between the appellants and the first respondent and therefore the appeal be ‘dismissed as settled out of Court’ and full Court-fees paid by the appellants in the said RSA be refunded to them. This Court, accepted the said compromise and dismissed the said RSA appeal ‘as settled out of Court. While dismissing the appeal, the question “whether full Court-fees shall have to be refunded to the appellants”? was kept open on the ground that the answer to the said question will have implication on the finance of the State Government. Further, liberty was given to the appellants to file separate application seeking refund of full Court-fees with a direction to them to serve copy of the said application on the learned Government Advocate. Therefore, the appellants in the said RSA have filed the present Misc. application.

    3. Today, I have heard the arguments of Sri R.A Kulkarni, the learned Counsel for the appellant-applicants and also Sri H. Hanumantharayappa, the learned Government Pleader on this Misc. Civil No. 2716/2009.

    4. Placing reliance on the decision of Division Bench of this Court in the case of A. Sreeramaiah v. The South Indian Bank Ltd., Bangalore reported in ILR 2006 KAR 4032, the learned Counsel for the appellant-applicants strongly contended that since the appellants got their dispute in the said RSA settled amicably with the first respondent therein namely Honnali Taluk Agricultural Produce Co-operative Marketing Society Ltd., without any intervention by this Court or any Arbitrator/conciliator/mediator and got their said appeal dismissed ‘as settled out of Court’, they are entitled to refund of full Court-fees paid by them in the said RSA, as provided under Section 16 of the Court-Fees Act, 1870. As against this, Sri H. Hanumantharayappa, the learned Government Pleader, strongly contended that the said decision of the Division Bench of this Court came to be rendered in respect of the appeal which was settled between the parties invoking the provisions of Section 89 of C.P.C and therefore, the Division Bench held in the said case that the appellants therein were entitled to refund of full Court-fees but in the present RSA there was no reference under Section 89 of C.P.C for settlement and therefore, the decision in the said case cannot be applied to the facts of the present appeal.

    5. In the said case before the Division Bench of this Court, the plaintiff had filed suit against the defendants for recovery of Rs. 8,11,582/-, the said suit was decreed and the defendants in the said suit had filed RFA No. 258/2005 and during the pendeney of the said RFA, the matter was settled between the parties invoking Section 89 of C.P.C On these facts, the Division Bench held that the appellants therein were entitled to refund of full Court fees.

    6. Whether the parties to a suit or appeal or any other proceeding get their dispute settled amicably through Arbitration, or meditation or conciliation in the Lok Adalath, by invoking provisions of Section 89, C.P C. or they get the same settled between themselves without the intervention of any Arbitrator/Mediator/Conciliators in Lokadalath etc., and without invoking the provision of Section 89, C.P.C, the fact remains that they get their dispute settled without the intervention of the Court. If they get their dispute settled by invoking Section 89, C.P.C, in that event the State may have to incur some expenditure but, if they get their dispute settled between themselves without the intervention of the Court or any one else, such as arbitrator/mediator etc., the State would not be incurring any expenditure. This being so, I am of the considered opinion that whether the parties to a litigation get their dispute settled by invoking Section 89, C.P.C or they get the same settled between themselves without invoking Section 89, C.P.C, the party paying Court-Fees in respect thereof should be entitled to the refund of full Court-Fees as provided under Section 16 of the Court-Fees Act, 1870. Therefore, the contention of the learned Government Pleader that the principles laid down by the Division Bench of this Court in the said case cannot be made applicable to the facts of the present case does not deserve acceptance.

    7. For the reasons aforesaid, the present Misc. Cvl. 2716/2009 is hereby allowed. The appellants in RSA No. 1374/2005 shall be entitled to the refund of the entire amount of Court-fees paid by them in the said RSA which has been dismissed by order of this Court dated 30-1-2009 ‘as settled out of Court’. Accordingly, the office is directed to refund the full Court Fees to the appellants therein.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kamalamma And Others v. Honnali Taluk Agricu...
    (Jul 15, 2009)