AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order XII Rule 6, Order V Rule 8 and Order VIII Rule 10 of CPC,
  • provisions of Order VIII Rule 5 of CPC
  • Order VIII Rule 5 CPC.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order XII Rule 6, Order V Rule 8 and Order VIII Rule 10 of CPC,
  • provisions of Order VIII Rule 5 of CPC
  • Order VIII Rule 5 CPC.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a decree dated 14-7-2006 passed in O.S No. 1421/2003, wherein the Trial Court decreed a suit filed by the respondent/plaintiff for recovery of Rs. 4,39,583/- along with interest. The suit was decreed on the ground that the defendant did not file a written statement, relying on Order VIII Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC). The defendants have challenged this decree by way of appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Trial Court was justified in decreeing the suit solely on the basis of the defendant’s failure to file a written statement under Order VIII Rule 5 CPC without exercising subjective satisfaction as required by law.
  2. Whether the provisions of Order VIII Rule 5 CPC are mandatory or directory in nature.
  3. Whether the defendant can be permitted to file a belated written statement upon remand, subject to the Trial Court’s satisfaction regarding the reasons for delay.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Salem Advocate Bar Association, Tamilnadu v. Union of India, ILR 2005 KAR 4555 Clarification that Order VIII Rule 5 CPC is directory and not mandatory; Courts must exercise subjective satisfaction before passing judgment even if written statement is not filed. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the Trial Court erred in blindly decreeing the suit without subjective satisfaction, necessitating remand for fresh disposal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court emphasized that Order VIII Rule 5 of CPC is a directory provision and not mandatory, meaning the Trial Court cannot automatically decree a suit merely because the defendant failed to file a written statement. Instead, the Court must exercise subjective satisfaction, assessing whether the facts in the plaint, even if deemed admitted, justify a decree in favor of the plaintiff.

In the present case, the Trial Court failed to apply this principle and decreed the suit without satisfying itself, as evidenced by the brief statement accepting plaint averments without deeper scrutiny. This failure to exercise subjective satisfaction was held to be erroneous.

The Court further noted that the defendant had not filed a written statement at trial or on appeal but allowed the defendant the opportunity to file a belated written statement upon remand, subject to the Trial Court’s discretion regarding the reasons for delay.

Considering that some amount was practically admitted by the defendant, the Court directed the defendant to deposit Rs. 2,00,000/- with the Trial Court as interim security, to be held in a nationalized bank until the suit’s disposal.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is partly allowed; the impugned decree dated 14-7-2006 is set aside, and the matter is remitted to the Trial Court for fresh disposal in accordance with the principles laid down.

The defendant is permitted to file a written statement subject to the Trial Court’s satisfaction concerning the delay. The defendant must deposit Rs. 2,00,000/- as interim security. The Trial Court is directed to proceed with the suit afresh, fixing its own dates for further trial.

No order as to costs was made. This decision does not set any new precedent but reinforces the requirement for courts to exercise subjective satisfaction under Order VIII Rule 5 CPC before decreeing a suit in absence of a written statement.

    Karnataka Small Industries Marketing Corporation Ltd. v. Padma Textiles By Its Proprietor

    Bannurmath, J.:—

    Though the matter is posted for admission, since the scope of enquiry is very limited, with the consent of both the Learned Counsel, the same is taken up for disposal.

    2. This is a defendants's appeal challenging the decree dated 14-7-2006 passed in O.S No. 1421/2003 decreeing the suit of the respondent/plaintiff.

    3. The respondent/plaintiff has filed a suit for recovery of a sum of Rs. 4,39,583/- along with interest. The Trial Court has decreed the suit only on the ground that the defendant has not filed his written statement in view of Order VIII Rule 5 CPC. It is to be noted that having regard to the provisions of Order XII Rule 6, Order V Rule 8 and Order VIII Rule 10 of CPC, the Court cannot act blindly even if written statement is not filed as observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the Case of Salem Advocate Bar Association, Tamilnadu v. Union of India . ILR 2005 KAR 4555.. The provisions of Order VIII Rule 5 of CPC is a directory provision and not mandatory. In a Case where written statement is not filed, the Court should be cautions in proceeding under Order VIII of CPC before passing the judgment against the defendant and it must see that even if the facts set out in the plaint are treated as having been admitted, whether it is possible to pass the judgment in favour of the plaintiff. It is subjective satisfaction of the Court and not blind discretion. The Trial Court in the present Case without satisfying itself has simply decreed the suit holding as follows:

    “I have gone through the plaint averments and the documents and the affidavit evidence of the plaintiff by accepting the plaint advertments and the documents, the suit deserves to he decreed against the defendant.”

    4. In our view, this is not ‘subjective satisfaction’ which is required to be exercised by the Court below. Hence on this ground, the appeal deserves to be allowed and the matter has to be remanded to the Court below.

    5. However, it is to be noted that the defendant has not filed the written statement in time in the Trial Court and even it has not been produced before this Court in this appeal. As such in the light of the observations made by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Salim Advocate Bar Association, Tamilnadu's Case, while remanding the matter to the Court below, we hold that it is open to the appellant/defendant to file written statement at the earliest subject to the satisfaction of the Trial Court as to the reasons assigned for the belated approach.

    6. Taking note of the fact that the plaintiff has filed suit for recovery and some amount is practically admitted by the defendant, we direct the appellant/defendant to deposit a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- within four weeks from today in the Court below. The Trial Court is directed to keep the amount in deposit in a nationalised Bank till the disposal of the suit.

    7. For the reasons statedf above, this appeal is partly allowed and the impugned order is set aside and the matter stands remitted to the Trial Court for fresh disposal. For the convenience of the parties, it is directed that both the parties shall appear before the Court on 12-6-2007 on which day the Trial Court shall fix its own dates for further Trial. There shall be no order for costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Karnataka Small Industries Marketing Corporation Ltd. v. Padma Textiles By Its Proprietor
    (May 31, 2007)