Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Summary of Judicial Opinion — Gopala Gowda, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are students who studied the MBBS course at various medical colleges affiliated to Bangalore University (Kempegowda Institute of Medical Sciences, Dr. Ambedkar Medical College, M.S. Ramaiah Medical College, Bangalore Medical College, Siddartha Medical College and Sri Devaraj Urs Medical College). Bangalore University conducted examinations up to November 2003, after which no examinations were conducted for students under the scheme applicable to them. The Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences (RGUHS) was thereafter established. By an Official Memorandum at Annexure-A dated 4-11-2004 and related circulars/notifications (including Annexure-B dated 13-12-2004 and Annexure-D dated 20-8-2004), RGUHS called for residual students to appear for examinations under its rules, and fixed fees and dates. Bangalore University issued a circular at Annexure-E dated 8-1-2005 calling upon residual (failed) students to appear for RGUHS examinations.

The petitioners filed writ petitions seeking to quash Annexure-D (dated 20-8-2004) and to declare Annexures A, B and E ultra vires and to restrain Bangalore University from endorsing them. The matter proceeded on affidavits and statements of objections filed by RGUHS, Bangalore University and an affidavit from the State Government (Under Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department (Medical Education)). The court heard counsel for the parties and delivered the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether students who studied under the Bangalore University scheme prior to the establishment of RGUHS can be compelled to appear for examinations conducted by RGUHS under a different scheme/syllabus.
  2. Whether, in view of Section 63 of the Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences Act, 1994, Bangalore University is statutorily obliged to conduct examinations for students who were studying immediately prior to the commencement of the RGUHS Act (i.e., whether Bangalore University must conduct those examinations or whether RGUHS must do so).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners studied subjects prescribed by the syllabus and scheme of Bangalore University and cannot be compelled to appear for examinations conducted by RGUHS under a different scheme which they did not study.
  • Under Section 63 of the RGUHS Act, Bangalore University is statutorily bound to conduct examinations for students who completed or were studying the course before the RGUHS Act came into force, because RGUHS has not chosen to conduct those examinations.

Respondent — Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences (RGUHS)

  • RGUHS contended that its examination scheme is governed by statutes, ordinances and regulations framed under the RGUHS Act, 1994, and the petitioners cannot compel RGUHS to conduct examinations under a different (Bangalore University) scheme.
  • RGUHS' counsel (Mr. N.K. Ramesh) asserted that the syllabus of Bangalore University and RGUHS are "more or less same" and thus the petitioners can appear for RGUHS examinations.
  • RGUHS also submitted that it faced practical difficulties in conducting examinations for repeaters (failed/residual students).

Respondent — Bangalore University

  • Bangalore University filed objections setting out the circumstances and, while referring to Section 63 of the RGUHS Act, pleaded its inability to conduct examinations for the petitioners.

State Government

  • The State's affidavit (Under Secretary) stated that meetings (Registrar of Evaluation, IUB, and a meeting on 5-6-2004 chaired by the Secretary to Government) resulted in decisions and resolutions that RGUHS should hold examinations for students who had not passed and who were admitted prior to the establishment of RGUHS; the State requested RGUHS by letter dated 19-10-2004 to hold such examinations.
  • The State submitted that the resolution of the Inter University Board is binding on all universities under the Karnataka State Universities Act 2000, but also that, since conduct of examinations is an academic matter, the State cannot issue directions to RGUHS as it is an autonomous body.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the matter on merits and proceeded from undisputed facts: the petitioners studied MBBS under the scheme/syllabus that was in force prior to establishment of RGUHS, and RGUHS, after its establishment, had the duty to conduct examinations as provided under Section 63 of the RGUHS Act. The court analyzed Section 63(1)(a), observing that it begins with a non obstante clause ("notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, Statutes, Ordinances or the Rules") and provides that any student who immediately prior to commencement of the Act was studying for a degree in the named universities "may until such examinations is provided by the University, be admitted to the examinations of the Universities of Bangalore, Karnataka and Mysore ... in accordance with the Regulations in force under those Acts."

The court interpreted "such examinations" and the phrase "in accordance with the Regulations in force under those Acts" to mean that students should be admitted to the examinations of the subjects notified in the syllabus they had studied and that this admission should continue until the newly established university (RGUHS) provides the corresponding examinations. The court concluded that this provision does not permit RGUHS to compel students to take examinations under RGUHS rules and syllabus which the students had not studied. Compelling students to appear for examinations in subjects/syllabus not studied was characterized by the court as "unscientific and unrealistic."

The court found the second guideline in Annexure-A to be contrary to Section 63 and noted that it was not a decision of RGUHS's Syndicate or Academic Council. The court held that the State's letter of 19-10-2004 and the State's position did not legally absolve RGUHS of its duty to conduct the examinations it had agreed to hold, and that RGUHS's plea of practical difficulties in conducting examinations for repeaters was untenable.

The court reviewed the chronology of missed examinations (noting that though two examinations ought to have been conducted annually, some were not, and last year no examination was conducted) and observed that petitioners could not appear for the September 2004 schedule due to syllabus problems. The court emphasized the serious lapse by the State and RGUHS in not conducting examinations since April 2004, resulting in loss and delay to students.

Holding and Implications

Writ petitions allowed; Annexures A, B, D & E quashed; Bangalore University directed to conduct the examinations for the petitioners within four weeks.

Direct consequences:

  • Annexures A, B, D and E (the notifications/circulars at issue) were quashed.
  • Bangalore University is directed to conduct the examinations for the petitioners expeditiously, and in any event within four weeks from the judgment.
  • The court admonished the State Government and RGUHS, noting the statutory duty of RGUHS to conduct examinations for failed students in subjects notified in the syllabus they studied and the State's failure to exercise executive power appropriately; the court hoped the State would issue suitable directions to RGUHS in such matters.

Broader implications:

  • The decision enforces the court's interpretation of Section 63(1)(a) of the RGUHS Act, emphasizing protection for students who were studying under pre-RGUHS schemes and the requirement that they be admitted to examinations in the syllabi they actually studied until the new university provides equivalent examinations.
  • The opinion does not announce any new binding precedent beyond this interpretation and the directions given; it primarily resolves the parties' dispute and orders remedial action for the affected students.

    G.S Shankar Linge Gowda & Others v. The State Of Karnataka Rep. By Its Secretary Medical Education & Others

    Gopala Gowda, J.:—

    As per the Memos filed by the learned counsel for the petitioners, permitted to delete Respondents 5 to 9 in W.P Nos. 4630-49/2005 and Respondents 5 to 8 in W.P Nos. 5699-5719/2005.

    2. The petitioners have studied MBBS Course in Kempegowda Institute of Medical Sciences, Dr. Ambedkar Medical College, M.S Ramaiah Medical College, Bangalore Medical College, Siddartha Medical College and Sri Devaraj Urs Medical College. The said colleges are affiliated to Bangalore University which is duty bound to conduct examinations under the Regulations framed by it in exercise of its power under the provisions of the Karnataka State Universities Act of 2005. The examinations have been conducted by the University upto November 2003 and thereafter no examinations were conducted by it to the students who have studied under the Scheme applicable for them. As a result of which, the petitioners could not take-up the examinations. When the things stood thus, the State Government has established Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences (hereinafter referred to as RGUHS). Under Official Memorandum at Annexure-A dated 4-11-2004 issued by the Registrar, the RGUHS shall conduct the examination for the students admitted to the course prior to 1996-1997. The Rules, Regulations, Scheme of examination of RGUHS were made applicable to such students. Consequently, the Circular/Notification at Annexure ‘B’ dated 13-12-2004 was issued calling upon the Principals of the Colleges to furnish list of residual students (repeaters) and to collect the examination fee. Thereafter, the Notification at Annexuere-D dated 20-8-2004 was issued fixing the examination fee and the dates for payment of the same. In turn, the Bangalore University issued the Circular at Annexure-E dated 8-1-2005 calling upon the residiual (failed) students to appear for the examinations conducted by RGUHS. The petitioners have filed these writ petitions seeking to quash the Notification at Annexure-D dated 20-8-2004 issued by the fourth respondent and to declare Annexures-A, B and E as ultra vires and to forbear the Bangalore University from endorsing them.

    3. The two-fold grivevance of the petitioners is that (1) they have studied the subjects prescribed in syallabus of Bangalore Univerisity under the scheme made applicable to them and they cannot appear for the examination that would be conducted by RGUHS as the scheme is quite different and (2) in view of Section 63 of Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences Act, 1994, the Bangalore University is duty bound statutiorily to conduct the examination for them as RGUHS has not choosen to conduct examinations to the petitioners and other students who have studied and completed the course before the Act has come into force and the said University was established.

    4. Statement of objections is filed on behalf of RGUHS inter-alia contending that the scheme of examinations conducted by it are governed by the statutes, ordinances and regulations framed under the Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences Act, 1994 and therefore it is contended by the learned counsel Mr. N.K Ramesh that the petitioners cannot compel RGUHS to conduct the examination under different schemes. The University is conducting examinations to the MBBS students, for the subjects studied by them and the syllabus of the Bangalore University are more or less same and there is no much difference. Therefore these petitioners also can appear for the exams conducted by it. He further submits that Bangalore University was conducting examinations and it is bound to conduct the same in view of Section 63 of the Act of 1994. He further submits that RGUHS has got practical problems to conduct examinations for the repeaters.

    5. The Bangalore University has filed statement of objections narrating the circumstances leading to the situtation. In view of Section 63 of the Act it has pleaded its inability to conduct examination to the petitioners.

    6. On behalf of the State Government, Affidavit of the Under Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department (Medical Education) is filed. In paragraphs 3 to 5 it is stated as under:—

    “3. I humbly submit that, the meeting of the Registrar of Evaluation of all Universities in the State was held on 2-8-2003 and a decision was taken that the Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Science shall hold the examination to such of the students who have not passed the medical course including PG degree in the respective Universities in which they have admitted and decision was taken to bring up the said decision before IUB (Inter University Board) for the resolution. Accordingly, the said subject was included in the Agenda of the meeting of IUB held on 23-8-2003. The resolution emerged under subject number 7, which reads as under:

    SUBJECT No. 7:

    Conduct of Medical and Engineering Examinations to such of the students who were admitted prior to the Establishment of Rajiv Gandhi University for Health Sciences and Vishveswaraiah Tehcnological University.

    As regards conduct of Medical and Engineering Examinations to such of the students who were admitted prior to the establishment of Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences and VTU, the Committee felt that the proceedings of the meeting of the Registrars of Evaluation of all the universities held on 2-8-2003 at Mysore University, Mysore be circulated to all the Universities.

    4. I humbly submit that resolution of IUB is binding on all the Universites in the State as per Karnataka State Universites Act 2000.

    5. I humbly submit that, in a meeting held on 5-6-2004 under the Chairmanship of Secretary to Government, Health and Family Welfare Department (Medical Education) a decision was taken to the effect that Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences shall be responsible for conducting examination in respect of students who have joined Health Science course prior to 1996-1997. Further, on the request made by the large number of students, State Government by its Government letter dated 19-10-2004 requested the Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Science to hold the examination to, those students who have joined the medical course prior to the establishment of Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Science.

    (Underlined Supplied)

    7. Mr. Manohar, learned Additional Government Advocate, submitted that letter was written by the State Government on 19-10-2004 requesting RGUHS to conduct examination to the students in question. He further submitted that since conduct of examination is a academic matter, the State Government cannot issue any directions in the matter to the RGUHS as it is an Autonomus body.

    8. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, this Court proceeds to examine the matter on merits. It is an undisputed fact that the petitioners have studied MBBS course in the subjects under the scheme as per the syllabus that was in force prior to the establishment of RGUHS. After the establishment of RGUHS, it has to conduct the examinations as stated under the provisions of 63 of the Act. The same is spelled-out clearly in Annexure-A. It cannot compel the petitioners or similarly placed students to take the examination according to its syllabus which was not studied by them. Compelling them to appear for examination of the subjects not studied is most unscientific and unrealistic.

    9. RGUHS Act was enacted by the State Legislature under the Concurrent List with the avowed object of establishing an in the State of Karnataka to look into the problem faced by the students and take remedial steps to solve them early so that the hardship an inconvenience faced by the student community are avoided. The problems of the petitioners was required to be looked into by RGUHS. For that purpose, remedy is provided under the Act itself. Section 63(1)(a) of the Act reads as under:—

    “63. SAVING AS TO CERTAIN EXAMINATIONS-

    (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, the Statutes, Ordinances or the Rules:—

    (a) any student who immediately prior to the commencement of this Act was studying for a degree in health science, of the Bangalore University, the Karnataka University or the Mysore University or Kuvempu University, Gulbarga University, Mangalore University eastiblished under the Bangalore University Act, 1964, the Karnataka University Act, 1949, the Mysore University Act, 1956 and the Karnataka State Universities Act, 1976, in accordance with the Regulations in force under those Acts, may until such examinations is provided by the University, be admitted to the examinations of the Universities of Bangalore, Karnataka and Mysore and Kuvempu University, Gulbarga University Mangalore University and be conferred the degree in Health science of the Inter Universities for which he qualifies on the result of such examination.”

    (Emphasis supplied)

    The Section begins with the non-abstance clause “notwithstanding anything; contained in this Act, Statutes, Ordinances or the Rules”. The underlined words in accordance with the Regulations in force under those Acts, until such examinations is provided by the University, be admitted to the examinations of the Universities of… can note that the students studied in various colleges affiliated to the Universites referred to in Section 63 of the Act, immediately prior to the Act came into foce, should be admitted to the examinations of the subjects notified in the syllabus studied by them. The further words, “until such examinations is provided by the University” means, so long as the syllabus studied by the student prior to the RGUHS was established is provided by it the students shall be admitted to such examinations that is required to be conducted either by the fourth respondent University or third respondent University. Again the words “such examinations” means the examinations that were being conducted by the various Universities referred to be in Section 63 of the Act and not applying the rules, regulations, scheme of examinations of RGUHS which are framed by it under Section 62 of the Act, after the university was established.

    10. In the light of the clear wordings of Section 63 of the Act, the 2nd guidelines contained in Annexure-A is contrary to the said provision and it is not the decision of either Syndicate or Academic Coucil of the RGUHS and therefore it is not the decision of the University on the basis of the letter dated 19-10-2004 written to it by the State Government. Therefore the stand taken by the RGUHS as also the State Government that Bangalore University is duty bound to conduct the examinations to the petitioners, is wholly untenable in law. In paragraph 3 of the Affidavit filed by the Under Secretary, which is extracted above, it is clear that decision was taken that RGUHS shall conduct the examination of such students who have not passed the course. There is no dispute about it. Such being the case, the submission made by the learned counsel for the RGUHS that it has got practical difficulties to conduct examination for the petitioners, is wholly untenable and cannot be accepted.

    11. The details of the examinations to be conducted and actually conducted are mentioned in paragraph 5 of first batch of writ petitions. A perusal of the same indicates that though two examinations ought to have been conducted in a year, some of the examinations have not at all been conducted. Last year no examination was conducted. For the examinations scheduled to be held during September 2004 as per Annexure-D, the petitioners could not appear on account of syllabus problem. The matter was not placed either before the Academic Council or the Syndicate. The petitioners and similarly placed students, though studied the course, cannot take-up the examination on account of the lapse on the part of the State Government and RGUHS. It is a serious lapse which has defeated the very object and purpose for which the Act was enacted and RGUHS is established. Petitioners suffered great loss due to non-conduct of examinations since April 2004. The precious time wasted by the petitioners by spending their time in litigating the matter on account of lapse on the part of the RGUHS as also the State Government for not giving suitable directions to the University in the matter, cannot be compensated in any manner. This kind of students problems should be given top priority both by the State and Universities and solve them immediately. Holding examinations for the petitioners and similarly placed students was not a Herculian task for the RGUHS. By conducting examinations, they could have avoided the petitioners approaching this Court as litigants and they are made litigants for no fault of them. It is a serious dereliction of statutory duty by the University and the State has failed to exercise its Executive power.

    12. For the aforesaid reasons, these writ petitions are allowed. Annexures-A, B, D & E are quashed. The Bangalore University is directed to conduct examinations to the petitioners expeditously but not later than four weeks.

    13. In the light of the observations made above, it is hoped that the State Government will take up the matter and issue suitable directions to the RGUHS in such students matters without any delay. The RGUHS shall note that it has a statutory duty to conduct examinations to the failed students in the subjects notified in the syllabus which were studied by them under the scheme which were in force to them.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    G.S Shankar Linge Go... v. The State Of Karnata...
    (Feb 18, 2005)