Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Case Summary: Criminal Revision Petitions Nos. 101–106 of 2002

Factual and Procedural Background

These six criminal revision petitions were filed by the Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle, Bangalore, challenging orders dated 20 October 2001 of the Special Court for Economic Offences, Bangalore (in C.C. Nos. 71, 73, 205, 208, 206 and 207 of 1999). The trial court had allowed applications by the respondents (accused) under section 245(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure and discharged them, principally on the ground that notices issued by the prosecution under section 158BC of the Income-tax Act, 1961, were not validly served on the respondents.

The prosecutorial case, as recited by the High Court, is that searches were conducted at the respondents' business premises in February 1997, during which cash, books of account and other records were seized. Thereafter notices under section 158BC of the Income-tax Act were issued, asking the respondents to furnish returns for assessment years 1986–87 to 1996–97 within 45 days of receipt. The respondents did not furnish returns within 45 days, and following sanction, complaints were filed under section 276CCC of the Income-tax Act. The trial court discharged the accused on the ground that the section 158BC notices were not validly served; the revision petitioner contended that service on the respondents' chartered accountants (who represented them before the income-tax authorities) was valid and that the trial court erred in ignoring admissions by the respondents (in letters dated 22 January 1998) seeking additional time to file returns.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether notice issued under section 158BC of the Income-tax Act and served on the respondents' chartered accountants (agents) constitutes valid service on the respondents for initiating penal proceedings under section 276CCC.
  2. Whether the trial court erred in allowing applications under section 245(2) CrPC and discharging the accused on the ground of non-service of the statutory notice when there was evidence of acknowledgement or ratification (letters seeking extension dated 22 January 1998).
  3. Whether principles or authorities cited by the respondents (relating to strictness of service on an assessee, power of attorney and mandatory jurisdictional provisions) were applicable to the facts of these cases.

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioner (Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax)

  • The notices under section 158BC were served on the respondents through their chartered accountants who represented them before the income-tax authorities.
  • The respondents subsequently wrote letters (dated 22 January 1998) requesting more time to file returns, which the petitioner says amounts to an acknowledgement of receipt of the notices and knowledge of the proceedings.
  • Once the party acknowledges receipt of a notice served on him or his agent, such acknowledgement constitutes valid service; ratification of the agent's receipt estops the party from contending non-service.
  • Reliance was placed on Maharana Mills (P.) Ltd. v. ITO ([1959] 36 ITR 350 (SC)) for the proposition that actual knowledge and discussion with the assessee can validate proceedings even where formal notice requirements were not rigidly complied with.
  • The trial court ignored these facts and admitted a perverse finding; interference is warranted under section 379 CrPC.

Respondents (Accused)

  • Section 158BC imposes a mandatory duty to serve notice on the respondents; compliance with that mandatory provision is a precondition for initiating penal proceedings under section 276CCC.
  • Service on the chartered accountants was not valid because the accountants were not authorised agents on the date of alleged service; Order 5, rule 12 CPC (mode of service) was invoked to emphasise proper service requirements.
  • Authorities were cited to support the proposition that service on an agent (including a chartered accountant) is not necessarily service on the assessee and that mandatory jurisdictional conditions cannot be waived.
  • On this basis, the respondents argued that the trial court correctly allowed applications under section 245(2) CrPC and discharged them.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Maharana Mills (P.) Ltd. v. ITO, [1959] 36 ITR 350 (SC) The proposition that where the assessee actually knows of the proceedings and the matter has been discussed with him, an adverse order will not be invalid merely because a formal notice under the provision was not given. The court relied on this authority to support the view that acknowledgement/knowledge of the notice (through letters seeking time) could validate service effected through an agent, i.e., ratification/knowledge may cure formal defects.
ITO v. Mukesh Kumar, [2002] 254 ITR 409 (Punjab & Haryana High Court) Held that penal consequences under section 276CC/276CCC require proof of service of notice on the assessee; service on a chartered accountant could not be deemed service on the assessee. The High Court distinguished this precedent: in Mukesh Kumar a return was filed after service on an agent and the notice-on-agent principle led to dismissal; here, by contrast, respondents admitted receipt (via letters dated 22 January 1998) and sought time, showing knowledge, so Mukesh Kumar did not apply.
CIT v. K. Adinarayana Murty, [1967] 65 ITR 607 (SC) Where a notice is issued in the wrong status (e.g., individual vs HUF), such a notice is illegal and proceedings under it are ultra vires. The court observed that this ratio is inapplicable to the present cases because the issue here was service on an agent and not the correctness of the addressee's status.
Commissioner of Income-Tax, Jaipur v. Girdharilal, [1984] 147 ITR 379 (Rajasthan High Court) Held that service on an agent was not proper service on the assessee for purposes of affording an opportunity to be heard; power of attorney must be construed strictly. The court found the authority distinguishable: though the chartered accountants were not shown to have been formally authorised, the respondents ratified receipt of the notices, and thus were estopped from denying service.
P.V. Doshi v. CIT, [1978] 113 ITR 22 (Gujarat High Court) Mandatory jurisdictional provisions cannot be waived; where mandatory conditions are not fulfilled reassessment/orders are not valid. The court held this authority inapplicable on facts: it concluded that mandatory notices were in fact served on the respondents' agents and admitted by the respondents, so the respondents could not rely on non-compliance as in P.V. Doshi.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a fact-driven manner. It accepted as undisputed that raids/searches occurred in February 1997, that books and records were seized, and that notices under section 158BC were issued thereafter. These notices were, in fact, served on the respondents' respective chartered accountants. The respondents failed to file returns within the 45-day period prescribed by section 158BC, and complaints under section 276CCC were filed after sanction.

The central factual point relied upon by the revision petitioner was that the respondents themselves, by letters dated 22 January 1998, sought additional time to file returns — a circumstance which, the petitioner argued, amounted to an acknowledgement of receipt of the notices and indicated actual knowledge of the proceedings. The petitioner framed this acknowledged receipt as a ratification of the agent's reception of notice and invoked estoppel against the respondents' later denial of service.

The court examined the authorities relied upon by both sides. It invoked Maharana Mills to support the proposition that actual knowledge and discussion may render proceedings valid despite technical non-compliance with formal notice requirements. The court distinguished ITO v. Mukesh Kumar because, unlike that case, the respondents here had expressly sought additional time after the notices were said to have been served, which demonstrated knowledge and made Mukesh Kumar inapplicable on the facts.

The court also considered authorities concerning improper addressee or narrow construction of powers of attorney (CIT v. K. Adinarayana Murty; Commissioner of Income-Tax, Jaipur v. Girdharilal) and the proposition that mandatory jurisdictional provisions cannot be waived (P.V. Doshi). It rejected their applicability on the facts: the present dispute turned on admission/ratification of receipt by the respondents (via their letters) rather than on a fundamental defect in the identity of the addressee or an unwaivable jurisdictional precondition.

The court concluded that the trial court had not considered the respondents' letters requesting extension of time and had therefore recorded a perverse finding. The court held that service on the chartered accountants, followed by the respondents' subsequent acknowledgment/ratification, amounted to valid service and estopped the respondents from asserting non-service. The High Court therefore found it appropriate to interfere under section 379 CrPC.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petitions are allowed and the orders of the trial court discharging the accused are set aside.

Consequences: The High Court set aside the trial court's orders dated 20 October 2001 and remitted the matters to the trial court for fresh disposal in accordance with law. The immediate practical effect is that the criminal complaints under section 276CCC filed by the revision petitioner are to be reconsidered by the trial court (i.e., the accused are no longer discharged by virtue of the trial court's earlier orders).

The opinion does not articulate any broader rule-changing pronouncement; its disposition is fact-specific and rests on the court's finding of acknowledgement/ratification by the respondents and the consequent estoppel. The judgment distinguishes adverse precedents on their facts rather than laying down a general new precedent on service by agents.

Delivered by K. Ramanna, J. — Decided 17 February 2004.

    Y. Rajendra, Deputy Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Khoday Eshwarsa And Sons And Others (And Connected Petitions)

    Criminal Revision Petitions Nos. 101 to 106 of 2002

    Decided on February 17, 2004

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    K. Ramanna, J.:— All these criminal revision petitions are filed by the Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle, Bangalore, against the orders dated October 20, 2001, passed by the Special Court for Econo-mic Offences, Bangalore, in C.C Nos. 71, 73, 205, 208, 206 and 207 of 1999, respectively, whereby the trial court allowed the applications filed by the respondents-accused under section 245(2) of the Code of Criminal Pro-cedure and discharged them mainly on the ground that the notice issued by the revision petitioner under section 158BC of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (for short “the Act”), is not a valid service.

    2. The case of the prosecution is that the search of the respondents' premises was conducted in the month of February, 1997, and seized cash, certain books of account and then issued notice under section 158BC of the Act to the respective respondents calling upon them to furnish the return of the income for the periods 1986-87 to 1996-97 within 45 days from the date of receipt of that notice. But the respondents failed to submit the returns even after a lapse of 45 days therefore the revision petitioner filed a complaint under section 276CCC of the Act, after obtaining necessary sanction from the competent authority. The grounds urged by the revision petitioner are that the trial court erred in discharging the accused on the ground that the notice under sec-tion 158BC of the Act was not served on them. In fact the notice was served on their chartered accountants who represent before the income-tax authorities. Even though the service of notice was valid the trial court has not considered about the service of notice on their agent/chartered accountant. The trial court has not considered about the admission made by the respondents in their letters of request to grant some more time to submit the returns as their chartered accountants are busy in connection with the time barring assessments which are to be completed during March, 1997, and the records for the relevant years have been seized dur-ing the course of the search, being numerous, out of which most of the documents are yet to be scrutinised by them. In spite of that the trial court has ignored the point of admission made by the respondents about the service of notice on their chartered accountant and discharged them which amounts to illegality committed by the trial court.

    3. Heard learned counsel for both parties and perused the records.

    4. It is an undisputed fact that the revision petitioner conducted raids dur-ing the month of February 1997, in respect of the business premises of the respondents in all these cases. At that time books of account, cash and other records were seized from their premises. After seizure, notice under section 158BC of the Act was issued to them. On behalf of the respondents, the said notices were served on the respective chartered accountants of the firm. As per section 158BC the revision petitioner has granted 45 days time to the respondents to submit their income-tax returns for the years 1986-87 to 1996-97. In spite of that the respondents in all these cases have not submitted their returns. Therefore, the revision petitioner herein has filed a complaint under section 276CCC of the Act before the Special Court for Economic Offences, Bangalore. In this behalf learned counsel for the revision petitioner vehemently argued that though notice was served on the respondents through their authorised chartered accountants and subsequently the respondents sought time to submit their returns which amounts to valid service and they had knowledge about the service of the notice on their respective chartered accountants, therefore they sought fur-ther time to file income-tax returns. But the trial court without considering that aspect of the matter straightaway allowed the applications filed by the respondents under section 245(2), Criminal Procedure Code, and dis-charged them, which is highly illegal and incorrect. The trial court has recorded a perverse finding which calls for interference. Learned counsel for the revision petitioner has drawn my attention to the letter dated January 22, 1998, addressed by the respondents with a prayer to grant some more time to submit income-tax returns. Once a party acknowledges about the receipt of the notice served either on him/it or his/its agent, it amounts to valid service. If a party ratifies the action of the agent, then he is estopped from contending that the revision petitioner has not complied with the mandatory provisions of section 158BC of the Act. In support of these contentions learned counsel for the petitioner relied on a decision reported in the case of Maharana Mills (P.) Ltd. v. ITO, [1959] 36 ITR 350 (SC), wherein the apex court has held that (page 355):

    “The object of the provision as to notice in the second sub-section of section 35 is that no order should be passed to the detriment of an assessee without affording him an opportunity but it cannot be said that the rule is so rigid that if, as a matter of fact, the assessee knows of the proceedings and the matter has been discussed with him then an adverse order would be invalid merely because no notice under section 63 was given.”

    5. Per contra learned counsel for the respondents submitted that criminal proceedings have been initiated against the respondents in all these cases and section 158BC is mandatory on the part of the revision petitioner to serve notice on the respondents, since the revision petitioner has not com-plied with the mandatory provisions of section 158BC, therefore the trial court has rightly allowed the applications filed by them under section 245(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code. Therefore, the order of discharge of the respondents passed by the trial court is in accordance with law and there is no perverse or illegal finding recorded by it to interfere with its order. In this regard he has drawn my attention to Order 5, rule 12, Civil Procedure Code, about the mode of service of summons or notice. It is further contended that the chartered accountants on whom the notice was said to have been served by the revision petitioner are not their authorised agents as on the date of alleged service of notice, therefore, the revision petitioner utterly failed to comply with the mandatory provisions of the Act. Hence, initiation of crimi-nal proceedings under section 276CCC of the Act is illegal and incorrect.

    6. In support of his contention learned counsel for the respondents relied on a decision reported in the case of ITO v. Mukesh Kumar, [2002] 254 ITR 409 wherein the High Court of Punjab and Haryana held that (see [2002] 123 Taxman 55):

    “…Failure to furnish return of income—Assessment year 1976-77 —Whether penal consequences of punishment under section 276CC can enure only when it is proved as a fact that assessee has wilfully failed to furnish return in due time after service of notice under section 148 and, thus, service of notice is a condition precedent before proceeding to punish assessee under aforesaid provision—Held, yes —Whether notice accepted by Chartered Accountant working for assessee or service of notice on accountant of assessee could be deemed to be service of notice on assessee—Held, no—Whether, therefore, trial court was justified in rejecting criminal complaint filed under section 276CC—Held, yes.”

    7. In the aforesaid case notice was served on the agent of the assessee and subsequently submitted a return showing a net loss of Rs. 20,930 and then a criminal proceeding has been initiated. Whereas, in the instant case though the notice was served on the respective chartered accountants, subsequently, the respondents acknowledged the receipt of the notice by letter dated January 22, 1998, in their respective letters, the respondents sought further time to submit the returns, that means that they had the knowledge about the service of notices on their chartered accountants. Therefore, the ratio laid down in the aforesaid decision will not be appli-cable to the present cases.

    8. Further, learned counsel for the respondents relied on another decision reported in the case of CIT v. K. Adinarayana Murty, [1967] 65 ITR 607, wherein the Supreme Court held that (page 611):

    “Under the scheme of the Income-tax Act the ‘individual’ and the ‘Hindu undivided family’ are treated as separate units of assessment and if a notice under section 34 of the Act is wrongly issued to the assessee in the status of an ‘individual’ and not in the correct status of ‘Hindu undivided family’ the notice is illegal and all proceedings taken under that notice are ultra vires and without jurisdiction.”

    9. In the aforesaid case the notice was issued by the income-tax authorities to the karta of the Hindu undivided family but not in the individual names of the members of the undivided family and the proceedings initiated against the members of the Hindu undivided family were held to be ultra vires and without jurisdiction. Therefore, the ratio laid down in the afore-said decision relied upon by learned counsel for the respondents is not applicable to the present cases.

    10. Further learned counsel for the respondents relied on another decision reported in the case of Commissionerof Income-Tax, Jaipur v. Girdharilal., [1984] 147 ITR 379, wherein the Rajasthan High Court held that notice on the agent was not proper service on the assessee so as to hold that the assessee had an opportunity of being heard for the purpose of passing an order under section 263 of the Act. Further it was held (headnote) : “it is well settled that the power of attorney given to an agent should be construed strictly and from that power of attor-ney only such authority which has been conferred expressly or by implica-tion, should be taken into consideration”.

    11. In the aforesaid case the respondents herein have not executed any power of attorney on behalf of them to their respective chartered account-ants to receive notice issued by the income-tax authorities or on behalf of the respondents. Since the chartered accountants who represented the res-pondents in the present case, though not authorised, received notice issued to the respondents by the authorities, and subsequently they ratified the act of the chartered accountants about the receipt of the notice, the respon-dents are estopped from contending that they have not received manda-tory notice issued under section 158BC of the Act. Therefore, the ratio laid down in the aforesaid decision also is not applicable to the facts of the pre-sent cases. Further, learned counsel for the respondents also relied on a decision reported in the case of P.V Doshi v. CIT, [1978] 113 ITR 22 wherein the Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court held that (headnote):

    “As a jurisdictional provision which was mandatory and enacted in public interest could never be waived and the want of jurisdiction was discovered by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner, there was no question of waiver by the assessee. No question of finality of the remand order of the Tribunal could arise because the mandatory con-ditions for founding jurisdiction for initiating reassessment proceed-ings had not been fulfilled. The order of reassessment was, therefore, not valid.”

    12. But in the instant case the mandatory notices were duly served by the revision petitioner on their chartered accountants (i.e, agents) and which has been admitted by the respondents, therefore, the provisions of Order 5, rule 12, of the Civil Procedure Code, will not at all come to the aid of the respondents to hold that service of notice on chartered accountants is not a valid service. Therefore, it could be said that the trial court lost sight of the provisions of Order 5, rule 12 of the Civil Procedure Code and the letters of request made by the respondents in all these cases to grant time or extend the time to submit the return is perverse and incorrect which calls for inter-ference under section 379 of the Criminal Procedure Code.

    13. In view of the above, the order under revision passed by the trial court is liable to be set aside. Accordingly, the revision petitions are allowed and the orders under challenge passed by the trial court are set aside. The matter is remitted back to the trial court for fresh disposal in accordance with law.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Y. Rajendra, Deputy ... v. Khoday Eshwarsa And ...
    (Feb 17, 2004)