Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging an order dated 31 January 2000 issued by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Nasik (Respondent 1). The order imposed a demand/liability on the petitioner relating to provident fund contributions, as detailed in Annexure A. The petitioner contended that the order was contrary to law. The respondents opposed the writ petition, arguing it was not maintainable due to the availability of an appeal under Section 7C of the Employees' Provident Fund Scheme. The petitioner countered that the order did not fall within the scope of Section 7A and thus the writ petition was the only remedy. The dispute centered on the interpretation of statutory provisions governing provident fund contributions, particularly concerning whether the petitioner was liable to pay 12% contribution on employee salaries exceeding Rs. 5,000 per month.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order dated 31 January 2000 by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner imposing a demand for provident fund contributions at 12% on salaries exceeding Rs. 5,000 per month is legally valid.
  2. Whether the writ petition is maintainable despite the availability of an appeal under Section 7C of the Employees' Provident Fund Scheme.
  3. The correct interpretation of the provisions of the Employees' Provident Fund Scheme, 1952, particularly Sections 2(f), 6, Para. 26, Para. 26A, and Para. 29, in relation to the rate and extent of provident fund contributions payable by the employer.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The order passed by the respondents is contrary to the provisions of law and should be set aside.
  • The writ petition is maintainable because the order does not fall under Section 7A of the Scheme, making writ the only available remedy.
  • The petitioner is not legally obliged to pay provident fund contributions at 12% on salary amounts exceeding Rs. 5,000 per month.
  • The petitioner has been paying 12% contribution up to Rs. 5,000 and 10% on amounts above Rs. 5,000, which is in accordance with law.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The writ petition is not maintainable because an appeal under Section 7C is provided under the Scheme.
  • The petitioner is obliged under the amended provisions of the Employees' Provident Fund Scheme to pay contributions at the statutory rates, which include payment on salary exceeding Rs. 5,000.
  • The amendment to the Scheme mandates employers to calculate contributions including dearness allowance, retaining allowance, and cash value of food consumption, and pay contributions accordingly.
  • The petitioner cannot be exempted from paying contributions at the statutory rate on the entire pay as per the amendments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the relevant provisions of the Employees' Provident Fund Scheme, 1952, focusing on Sections 2(f), 6, Para. 26, Para. 26A, and Para. 29. The court noted that an "excluded employee" is defined as one whose pay exceeds Rs. 5,000 per month at the time of joining. It examined the statutory scheme provisions that limit the employer's contribution to the provident fund to a maximum on Rs. 5,000 of monthly pay, even though the contribution rates were increased from 8⅓% and 10% to 10% and 12% respectively by amendment.

The court observed that the proviso to Section 6 requires the Central Government to notify establishments to which the increased contribution rates apply, and no such notification had been issued for the petitioner’s establishment during the relevant period. Consequently, the increased rate of 12% could not be automatically applied to the entire pay exceeding Rs. 5,000.

By reading the scheme provisions together, the court held that while the contribution rate may be 12%, the employer's liability for contribution is limited to the salary cap of Rs. 5,000 per month. The petitioner’s practice of paying 12% on Rs. 5,000 and 10% on amounts exceeding Rs. 5,000 was in accordance with law. The court rejected the respondent's contention and held that the order directing payment of 12% on the entire salary was contrary to law.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed.

The court quashed the impugned order dated 31 January 2000 and held that the petitioner is not legally obliged to pay provident fund contribution at 12% on the portion of the employee’s salary exceeding Rs. 5,000 per month. The payment of contribution at 12% is required only up to the monthly salary of Rs. 5,000. The respondent is directed not to implement the order demanding 12% contribution on the entire salary and to accept the returns (Form Nos. 3A and 6A) already submitted by the petitioner for the years 1997–1998 and 1998–1999. The respondents are further directed to finalize the members’ accounts accordingly.

No order as to costs was made. The petitioner is to continue contributions as per the returns already submitted.

    Motor Industries Company, Ltd., Bangalore (Factory At Nashik) v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Nashik, And Another

    1. The petitioner by this writ petition challenges the order and the interpretation sought to be put by the R 1 in its order No. MH/12053.PF/A/CS/SRO/NSK-1/1273/13352, dated 31 January 2000, whereby fastening it with an unwarranted demand/liability as per Annexure A.

    2. Heard the learned senior counsel Sri Kasturi for Kasturi Associates for the petitioner and Sri V. Padmanabha Kedilaya, learned counsel for the respondents.

    3. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the order passed by the respondents is contrary to the provisions of law and therefore, it is liable to be set aside.

    4. The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that this writ petition is not maintainable in view of the fact that an appeal under S. 7C is provided Therefore, the writ petition is liable to be dismissed summarily.

    5. Controverting this argument, the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the order or direction issued by the respondent does not come within the purview of S. 7A and, therefore, thic is the only remedy available to the petitioner.

    Annexure A is to the order passed by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Office — In charge, SRO, Nasik. The operative portion oi that order, dated 31 January 2000, reads thus:

    “Further, an employee, who is deemed as an excluded employee since his total pay exceeds Rs. 5,000 per month at the time of joining the establishment itself is also entitled to join the fund. In this case I may quote Chap. 3.3.2 of Partha of the Manual of Accounting Procedure which reads as

    Besides even an excluded employee whose pay per month exceeds Rs. 5,000 can become a member of the fund and contribute up to Rs. 5,000 or on the entire pay, subject to his willingness in writing and employer's acceptance to pay his share or contribution and administrative charges.

    Here in this case also the employer has to pay his share or contributions and administrative charges and the contribution will be at the statutory rates only as per Para. 29 of the Employees' Provident Fund Scheme.

    I hope the position is elucidated and I, therefore, request you to carry out the direction contained in this letter and the letters sent earlier and retransmit the Form Nos. 3 A and 6 duly rectifying the defect of recovery and remittance of contributions below the statutory rate of contribution that is 10 per cent instead of 12 per cent on the pay) and making good the short amount paid early.”

    From this it is clear that it is not an order passed as stipulated under S. 71 nor does it come in any other provisions wherein an appeal, is provided. Therefore, as rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the preliminary objection that this petition is not maintainable is unsustainable.

    6. This order came to be passed in view of the admitted correspondence between the petitioner and the respondent as per Annexures A to P which I have gone through carefully.

    7. The respondents also filed objections contending inter alia that the writ petition is not maintainable on facts and on law. The amendment introducing definition of excluded employees in S. 2(f) and amending S. 6, Para. 26(6), Para. 26|fy, Para. 29 of Provident Fund Scheme and Chap. 3.3.1 of Para. 1 of Manual of Accounting Procedure, came into force with effect from 22 September 1997 obliging all the employers including the petitioner to calculate dearness allowance, retaining allowance, if any, and cash value of food consumption and such salaried employee is allowed to contribute 10 per cent or 12 per cent of the amount more than the limit of Rs. 5,000 also. Administrative charges to be paid by employer. The employers cannot be forced to contribute more than the statutory limit of 10 per cent or 12 per cent. Therefore, the contention of the petitioner that there is no compulsion under law to pay contribution as per statutory rate over and above the pay of Rs. 5,000 is not lawful as per the amendment as made by the respondents. Hence, the contention of the petitioner is against, the provisions contained in S. 6, Para. 26(6), Para. 26A, Para. 29 of the Scheme, Para. 2(f) and Chap. 3.3.1 of Paral of Manual of Accounting Procedure, etc. Therefore, the respondents contend that the petition is liable to be dismissed.

    8. In this case the only question that arises for consideration is in regard to the interpretation sought to be put by respondent 1 in the order referred to above. To interpret this order, it is required to refer to certain provisions of the Employees' Provident Fund Scheme, 1952 (hereinafter referred to as the Scheme), more particularly 26A of the Scheme. In that connection, it is necessary to refer to CI. 2(f) which reads:

    “‘excluded employee’ means—

    (i) an employee who, having been a member of the fund, withdrew the full amount of his accumulations in the fund under Cl. (a) or Cl. (c) of] Sub-para.(1) of Para. 69;

    (ii) an employee whose pay at the time he is otherwise entitled to become a member of the fund, exceeds (five thousand rupees) rupees per month;

    Explanation.— ‘Pay,’ includes basic wages with dearness allowance (retaining allowance (if any)] and cash value of food concession admissible thereon.”

    Paragraph 26 of the scheme reads:

    “Classes of employees entitled and required to join the fund.— (1) (a) Every employee employed in or in connection with the work of a factory or other establishment to which this scheme applies, other than and excluded employee, shall be entitled and required to become a member of the fund from the day this paragraph comes into force in such factory or other establishment.”

    Sub-paragraph (6) of Para. 26 of reads:

    “(6) Notwithstanding anything contained in this paragraph (an officer not below the rank of an Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner) may, on the joint request in writing of any employee of a factory or other establishment to which this scheme applies and his employer, enrol such employee as a member or allow him to contribute on more than rupees (five thousand) of his pay per month if he is already a member of the fund and mere upon as such employee shall be entitled to the benefits and shall be subject to the conditions of the fund, provided that the employer gives an undertaking in writing that he shall pay the administrative charges payable and shall comply with all statutory provisions in respect of such employee.).”

    Paragraph 26A reads:

    “Retention of membership.—(1) A member of the fund shall continue to be a member until he withdraws under Para. 69 the amount standing to his credit in the fund or is covered by a notification of exemption under S. 17 of the Act or an order of exemption under Para 27 or Para. 27A.

    Explanation: In the case of claim for refund by a member under Sub-para. (2) of Para. 69 the membership of the fund shall be deemed to have been terminated from the date the payment is authorised to by the authority specified in this behalf by the Commissioner irrespective of the date of claim.

    (2) Every member employed as an employee other than an excluded employee, in a factory or other establishment to which the scheme applies, shall contribute to the fund, and the contribution shall also be payable to the fund in respect of him by the employer. Such contribution shall be in accordance with the rate specified in Para. 29:

    Provided that subject to the provisions contained in Sub-para. (6) of Para. 26 and (in Para. 27), or Sub-para.(1) of Para. 27A, where the monthly pay of such a member exceeds (five thousand rupees) rupees, the contribution payable by him, and in respect of him by the employer, shall be limited to the amounts payable on a monthly pay of (five thousand rupees) rupees including (dearness allowance, retaining allowance (if any) and] cash value of food concession.”

    Further it is also necessary to refer to Para. 29 which reads:

    “The contributions payable by the employer under the scheme shall be at the rate of [8-⅓ per cent] of the [basic wages, dearness allowance (including the cash value of any food concessions) and retaining allowance (if any) payable to each employee to whom the scheme applies:

    [Provided that the above rate of contribution shall be (ten) per cent in respect of any establishment or class of establishments which the Central Government may specify in the Official Gazette from time to time under the first proviso to Sub-sec. (1) of S. 6 of the Act.”

    The rate of contribution has been now changed to 10 per cent. Subsequently it was amended to 12 per cent. Therefore, with this reference, it is now necessary to find out as to whether the petitioner is liable to pay 12 per cent over and above the pay drawn by the employees or the employer is liable to pay only 12 per cent up to Rs. 5,000 and above with only 10 per cent. It is not in dispute that the petitioner has voluntarily paid the provident fund contribution of 12 per cent up to Rs. 5,000 and for the remaining above Rs. 5,000 the petitioner has been paying 10 per cent but the respondent directed him to pay even above Rs. 5,000 the contribution at 12 per cent This is all the question that has to be considered.

    9. From the reading of amendment to S. 6 which came into force by notification, dated 27 October 1997, amending Para. 20 of the scheme, the earlier words and figures 8-⅓ per cent and 10 per cent respectively have also been amended to read as 10 per cent and 12 per cent. The procedure contemplated in the proviso to S. 6 of the main Act is that in this application to any establishment or class of establishments which the Central Government, after making such inquiry as it deems fit, by notification in the Official Gazette specify, the section shall be subject to the modification in that for the words “eight and one-third per cent” and “ten percent” at both the cases where they occur, the words “ten” and twelve per cent” shall be substituted. According to proviso to S. 6, the procedure contemplated, i.e, issuing of notification after making such enquiry is necessary, till then contribution 12 per cent cannot be automatic for any establishment.

    10. Paragraph 26A of the scheme speaks about retention of membership. Sub-paragraph (2) of Para. 26 A provides that every member employed as an employee other than excluded employee in a factory or other establishment to which the scheme applies, shall contribute to the fund and the contribution shall also be payable to the fund in respect of him by the employer. Such contribution shall be in accordance with the rate specified in Para. 29. The proviso to Sub-para.(2 of Para. 26A further clarifies that where the monthly pay of a member exceeds Rs. 5,000 the contribution payable by him and in respect of him by the employer, shall be limited to the amounts payable on a monthly pay of Rs. 5,000 including dearness allowance, retaining allowance (if any) and cash value of food concession.

    11. In Para. 29 the rate of contribution prescribed is 8⅓ per cent and 10 per cent in respect of establishment notified for that purposes. The proviso to Sub-para. (2) of Para. 29 also provides that the contribution payable by the employee if he so desires, be an amount exceeding 8.⅓ per cent or 10 per cent as the case may be of the basic wages, etc., subject to the condition that the employer shall not be under an obligation to pay any contribution over and above his contribution payable under the Act. The wording in Sub-para. (2) of Paras. 26A and 29 read together would show that such contribution shall be in accordance with the rate specified in Para. 29. But as to what extent of the salary such contribution shall be paid by the employer, Sub-para.) of Para. 26A alone can be resorted to. Therefore, the rate of contribution could be 12 per cent now as specified by the Act, but, however that rate of contribution on a reading of proviso to Para. 26A could be limited to monthly of Rs. 5,000 only and there is no compulsion under the Act, that the rate of contribution shall be at 12 per cent even on salary over and above Rs. 5,000 per month. Just because the rate of contribution is increased to 10 per cent and 12 per cent respectively. Under S. 6 such an increase first of all can apply only to establishment which the Central Government after making such enquiry as it deems fit, specify in the Official Gazette. No such notification was issued so far by the Central Government for the relevant period specifying the establishment to which the increased rate of contribution shall apply. The rate of interest is only subject to Para. 26A of the Scheme. Therefore, the remittance even otherwise is in accordance with law. The petitioner however has stated that the rate of contribution mentioned in Para. 26 of the scheme is subject to other provisions of the scheme viz., Para. 26A of the scheme. As the contribution is limited to a monthly pay of Rs. 5,000 only, over and above which amount the employe would be an excluded employee. Therefore, the question of there being any compulsion under law to pay contribution at 12 per cent over and above the monthly salary of Rs. 5,000 cannot arise. The contribution made by the petitioner company is perfectly in acordance with law and therefore, the argument of the learned counsel for the respondent before me in this regard is liable to Be rejected. It is clear that the provident fund scheme has not suffered any short payment due to the alleged short amount paid. For the foregoing reasons, I have no hesitation to hold that this petition deserves to be allowed.

    12. Accordingly, the petition is allowed. The direction of the respondent, dated 30 January 2000, is held to be contrary to law and Annexure A stands quashed holding that, the petitioner is not obliged in law to make the employee's contribution at 12 per cent of the total monthly salary and that the payment of contribution at 12 per cent is liable to be paid up to the monthly salary of Rs. 5,000 only. Consequently, the respondent is directed not to implement its directions in the impugned order, dated 3 January 2000, and I also direct respondent 1 to accept the returns 3A and 6A submitted by the petitioner-company for the year 1997–1998 and 1998–1999 and issue balance confirmation slips to the individual members of the provident fund scheme and also direct the second respondent to accordingly finalise the members accounts.

    13. However, there is no order as to costs.

    14. Further, it is also made clear that the petitioner shall contribute the amount as it as been contributing as per the returns (3A and 6A) already submitted.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Motor Industries Com... v. Regional Provident F...
    (Sep 13, 2000)