Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 137 and 138 of the Evidence Act. Section 137
  • witness.8. Section 137 and 138 of the Evidence Act
  • SECTION 138 EVIDENCE ACT
  • Section 115 C.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 137 and 138 of the Evidence Act. Section 137
  • witness.8. Section 137 and 138 of the Evidence Act
  • SECTION 138 EVIDENCE ACT
  • Section 115 C.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit for specific performance of an agreement of sale, alleging that the defendants, who are siblings, executed the agreement. Defendant-2 claimed to be the general power of attorney holder of defendant-1, a fact disputed by defendant-1. Defendant-1 denied joining hands with defendant-2 in executing the agreement. After the plaintiff closed evidence, defendant-1 sought permission to examine herself after defendant-2's evidence, which the trial court allowed. Defendant-2 was examined as DW-1 and cross-examined by the plaintiff. Subsequently, defendant-1 applied for permission to cross-examine DW-1, alleging a conflict of interest and collusion between defendant-2 and the plaintiff. The trial court permitted this cross-examination with safeguards, including sealing the questions and imposing costs. The legality of this order is challenged in this revision under Section 115 of the Civil Procedure Code.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a co-defendant has the right to cross-examine another co-defendant who has been examined as a witness.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The co-defendant (defendant-1) has no right to cross-examine the other defendant (defendant-2).
  • The trial court's order permitting such cross-examination is erroneous.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lord v. Colvin, 3 Drew 222 (1920) Right of one defendant to cross-examine another defendant's witness when interests are hostile. The court relied on this precedent to affirm that where there is a conflict of interest between co-defendants, one is entitled to cross-examine the other's witnesses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined Sections 137 and 138 of the Evidence Act, which provide for cross-examination by an adverse party, but do not explicitly address cross-examination between co-defendants. The court explained that the purpose of cross-examination is to test evidence and that an "adverse party" is one whose interests are hostile to the witness. Legal dictionaries were cited to clarify the meaning of "adverse" and "adversary."

The court adopted the principle that no evidence should be admitted against a co-defendant without an opportunity to cross-examine, as it would be unjust and unsafe. It noted that if there is no conflict of interest between co-defendants, there is no right to cross-examination. However, where conflicting interests exist, the co-defendant is treated as an adversary.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court found a clear conflict of interest between the defendants, including disputes about execution of the agreement, power of attorney, and allegations of collusion. Given these hostile interests, the court held that defendant-1 was entitled to cross-examine defendant-2, and therefore the trial court's order permitting such cross-examination was neither erroneous nor without jurisdiction.

Holding and Implications

The court dismissed the revision petition, upholding the trial court's order allowing defendant-1 to cross-examine defendant-2 (DW-1).

The direct effect is that co-defendants with conflicting interests may cross-examine each other's witnesses to test evidence. No new precedent was established beyond affirming existing principles regarding cross-examination rights among co-defendants.

    Sri Mohamed Ziaulla v. Mrs. Sorgra Begum And Another

    H.N Narayan, J.:—

    This Civil Revision under Section 115 C.P.C is directed against the order of the Additional City Civil Judge, Bangalore allowing I.A 20 filed by the first defendant for permission to cross examine defendant-2 who is examined as DW-1.

    2. Plaintiff has filed a suit for specific performance of agreement of sale alleging that the defendants who are sister and brother have executed the same. In the defence filed by defendant-2, it is contended that he is the general power of attorney holder of defendant-1 which fact is disputed by the first defendant. Defendant-1 has denied the claim of the plaintiff that she has also joined hands with defendant-2 in execution of agreement of sale consideration.

    3. After the evidence of the plaintiff was closed, defendant-1 filed an application praying permission to examine herself after the evidence of defendant-2. The Trial Court has permitted her to do so. Thereafter, defendant-2 was examined as DW-1 and cross examined by the plaintiff. At that stage, defendant-1 prayed permission to cross examine DW-1 on the ground that there is conflict of interest in the defence of the defendants and that defendant-2 has colluded with the plaintiff in order to snatch a decree. The Trial Court having regard to these facts has permitted the first defendant to cross-examine defendant-2 i.e DW-1. But, to safeguard the interest of the plaintiff, Court has secured the questions from the first defendant's advocate in a sealed cover and allowed the application with costs of Rs. 100/-. The legality of the order is questioned in this revision.

    4. Sri S.A Mujeeb, Learned Counsel for the petitioner, contended that the co-defendant has no right of cross examining the other defendant and that the trial Court's order is therefore erroneous.

    5. The short but important question that arises for consideration is whether a co-defendant has right to cross examine the other defendant.

    6. It is undisputed that no special provision is made in the Evidence Act for cross examination of the co-accused or co-defendant's witnesses, the only relevant provision of law is Section 137 and 138 of the Evidence Act. Section 137 refers to examination-in-chief and cross examination of a witness by the adverse party. The examination of an adverse party is the cross examination. The question is who is an adverse party so far as the witness is concerned. The very object of cross-examination is to test the evidence.

    Dictionary of law by Curzon 4th Edition defines ‘adversary’ as witness who disappoints the party calling them i.e they are unfavourable and hostile witnesses. The new Webster Dictionary of English Language has explained the word ‘adverse’ as going in contrary direction; counter action; opposing, calamitous, unprosperious etc.

    7. Section 137 specifically explains that the examination of a witness by the adverse party is cross examination. Section 138 of the Evidence Act refers to cross examination if the adverse party so desires after the witness is first examined in chief. These two sections of the Evidence Act make it abundantly clear that a party has a right of cross examining his adversary or his witness.

    8. Section 137 and 138 of the Evidence Act do not specifically refer to cross examination of co-defendant's witnesses. But, the courts have to adopt a golden rule that no evidence shall be received against any co-defendant or co-accused who had no opportunity of testing it by cross examination; as it would be unjust and unsafe not to allow a co-accused or co-defendant to cross-examine witness called by one whose case was adverse to his, or who has given evidence against him. If there is no dash of interest or if nothing has been said against the other party, there cannot be any right of cross-examination. A short but, interesting discussion is found in Sarkar's Evidence at Page 1342 13th Edition. Similar opinion is found in Principles and Digest of the Law of Evidence by M. Monir, Third Edition Page 1114.

    9. This very question was debated in the English Courts as far back as in 1920 vide a decision in Lord v. Colvin,1 3 Drew 222. The learned Judge in the said case after consulting all the equity judges held that an examiner in Chancery, one defendant might cross examine another defendant's witness. The same right exists between respondent and co-respondent in divorce cases provided either is hostile to the other, for if friendly, e.g where both deny the adultery, each can only be examined as the other's witness and not cross-examined. A defendant may cross-examine his co-defendant who gives evidence or any of his co-defendant's witnesses if his co-defendant's interest is hostile to his own. Therefore, the procedure that has been followed by the Courts in England and in India has not left this question in doubt. Where it is shown that the interest between the defendants' inter-se conflict each other, the other defendant has necessarily to be treated as an adversary and he is certainly entitled to cross examine the other defendant or his witnesses.

    10. Here is a case where one defendant disputes execution of agreement in favour of the plaintiff and reserves her right of examination perhaps to know the nature of evidence of her adversary viz. defendant-2. Learned Counsel for the petitioner is quick to point out that defendants are none other than the sister and brother. Unfortunately, the relationship is strained. There appears to be a conflict of interest between the two. Defendant-2 i.e DW-1's evidence discloses that he has borrowed money along with defendant-1 from the plaintiff and she put her signature on a blank paper viz. the suit document. In fact, this has been emphatically denied by defendant-1. The other conflicting interest between them is in regard to the execution of power of attorney by defendant-1 in favour of defendant-2. Therefore, it is obvious that defendants 1 and 2 did not see eye to eye in all these matters. The allegation made by defendant-1 against defendant-2 is that he has joined hands with the plaintiff and they both want to knock of the property of defendant-1. The only mode of testing this evidence is by way of cross-examination of the witnesses. The Court has rightly granted permission for cross-examination of DW-1. Under the circumstances, it cannot be stated that the impugned order is erroneous or passed without jurisdiction. There is no material irregularity at all in the order.

    11. Therefore, this revision falls and accordingly disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sri Mohamed Ziaulla v. Mrs. Sorgra Begum And Another
    (Jan 31, 1997)