AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C6. Order 17 Rule 3 C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C, Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C
  • Rule 2Therefore Order 17 Rule 3 C.P.C
  • Rule 2 and Rule 3 of Order 17 C.P.C
  • Appeal.5. Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C
  • Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C also.11.
  • Rule 10 of Order 8 of C.P.C
  • Order 20, Rule 4(1) of C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 10 (amended),
  • Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C15.
  • Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C7.
  • Order 11 Rule 21 C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 5(1) C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 1 or Rule
  • Order 17 Rule 2 C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C
  • Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 10 V.P.V
  • Order 8 Rule 10 and 5
  • Amendment Act of 1976,
  • Order 8 Rule 1 C.P.C
  • Order 43 Rule 1(b)
  • Section 2(2) C.P.C
  • Order 17 Rule 3(b)
  • Rule 2 and Rule 3
  • 8 Rule 5(2) C.P.C
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9,
  • Rule 10 of C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 5(2),
  • Order 8 Rule 10,
  • Order 17 Rule 2
  • Order 9 Rule 6.
  • Order 9 Rule
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C6. Order 17 Rule 3 C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C, Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C
  • Rule 2Therefore Order 17 Rule 3 C.P.C
  • Rule 2 and Rule 3 of Order 17 C.P.C
  • Appeal.5. Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C
  • Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C also.11.
  • Rule 10 of Order 8 of C.P.C
  • Order 20, Rule 4(1) of C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 10 (amended),
  • Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C15.
  • Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C7.
  • Order 11 Rule 21 C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 5(1) C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 1 or Rule
  • Order 17 Rule 2 C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C
  • Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 10 V.P.V
  • Order 8 Rule 10 and 5
  • Amendment Act of 1976,
  • Order 8 Rule 1 C.P.C
  • Order 43 Rule 1(b)
  • Section 2(2) C.P.C
  • Order 17 Rule 3(b)
  • Rule 2 and Rule 3
  • 8 Rule 5(2) C.P.C
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9,
  • Rule 10 of C.P.C
  • Order 8 Rule 5(2),
  • Order 8 Rule 10,
  • Order 17 Rule 2
  • Order 9 Rule 6.
  • Order 9 Rule
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent Bank filed a suit (O.S No. 96/1977) for recovery against the defendants. The defendants appeared and engaged counsel but took eight adjournments to file their written statement, ultimately failing to file it by the final date fixed (10-1-1978). Consequently, the Court proceeded under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C and passed judgment and decree against the defendants. The defendants filed a petition under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C alleging that their lawyer intended to file an application for better particulars, which the Court did not permit, and that they were absent at the adjourned time when judgment was pronounced. The Court below dismissed this petition, leading the defendants to file this Miscellaneous First Appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the judgment and decree passed under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C attract the operation of Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C.
  2. Whether parties suffering such a judgment and decree have only the right of regular appeal or also a remedy under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C.
  3. Whether the defendants satisfied the requirements of Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C to set aside the ex parte judgment and decree.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendants' Arguments

  • The defendants contended that their lawyer wanted to file an application for better particulars, which the Court did not permit.
  • They were under the bona fide impression that the Court might grant time to enable filing such an application and were therefore absent at the adjourned hearing when judgment was passed.
  • They argued that this absence was justified and constituted sufficient grounds under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C to set aside the ex parte judgment and decree.

Respondent Bank's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent Bank's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Abdul Aziz v. A. Raj Chhabra, A.I.R 1968 Allahabad 119 Rule 13 of Order 9 C.P.C covering all cases of ex parte decrees, including those where defence is struck off under Order 11 Rule 21 C.P.C Supported the view that judgment and decree under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C are ex parte and attract Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C remedy.
Sangram Singh v. 1. Election Tribunal, Kotah, A.I.R 1955 S.C 425 Interpretation of the word ‘hearing’ and the procedural rights to proceed ex parte at adjourned hearings under Order 9 Rule 6 C.P.C Confirmed that the right to proceed ex parte accrues day to day at each adjourned hearing, validating the Court’s power to pass ex parte judgment after multiple adjournments.
Eswara Devaru, S. v. Nagarajaiah, A.R., 1983 2 K.L.J 89 Requirement that ex parte judgment under Order 8 Rule 10 must contain points for determination and decision, and that Court must apply mind to plaint’s allegations before pronouncing judgment Reinforced the obligation on the Court to examine plaint facts and satisfy itself of plaintiff’s case even in ex parte proceedings; criticized the lower Court’s judgment as not meeting these standards.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the amended provisions of Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C, noting that the amendment made it mandatory for the Court to pronounce judgment and draw up a decree when a party fails to file a written statement within the permitted time. The repeal of Order 43 Rule 1(b), which previously allowed a miscellaneous appeal against such orders, indicated legislative intent to provide a better remedy under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C for ex parte decrees passed under Order 8 Rule 10.

The Court interpreted the term "hearing" consistently across Order 8 and Order 17, concluding that judgment and decree under Order 8 Rule 10 are ex parte in nature and thus attract the operation of Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C, which applies exclusively to ex parte decrees.

The Court relied on precedents to affirm that the right to proceed ex parte accrues daily at adjourned hearings and that the Court must apply its mind to the plaintiff’s pleadings even when the defendant defaults. It found the lower Court erred in passing a decree without examining the plaint’s material and improperly denied the defendants’ petition under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C.

Finally, the Court held that the defendants had sufficient grounds for their absence, given their bona fide belief that an application for better particulars was to be filed, and therefore the dismissal of their petition was incorrect.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed, the order of the Court below dismissing the petition under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C is set aside, and the suit is restored to file.

The City Civil Court, Bangalore, is directed to take back the suit and proceed with it, granting the defendants one more opportunity to file their written statement. This decision affirms that an ex parte judgment and decree passed under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C attract the remedy under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C, providing an alternate and less onerous remedy than a regular appeal. No new precedent beyond the direct effect on the parties is established.

    M/S. Kuvarp Industries And Another v. State Bank Of Mysore .

    Kulkarni, J.:— This is a Miscellaneous First Appeal by the defendants against the order dated 16-10-1981 passed by the 13th Additional City Civil Judge, Bangalore City, in Misc No. 407/81 dismissing the Petition filed under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C by the defendants.

    2. The respondent Bank filed a suit in O.S No. 96/1977 on the file of the Principal Civil Judge, Bangalore, for recovery of the amount from the defendants. The defendants appeared before the Court below on 8-8-1977 and also had engaged a Counsel. The defendants took as many as 8 adjournments to file the written statement. The case was posted to 10-1-1978 for filing the written statement. Even on that day, the defendants did not file the written statement. Thus the Court proceeded under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C and passed the judgment and decree. The defendants filed an application under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C alleging that their lawyer wanted to file an application calling for better particulars and the Court did not permit them to file and so the case was posted later on the same day for filing the written statement. At the adjourned time, the defendants were absent and thus the Court proceeded to pass the judgment in the absence of the defendants.

    3. The Court below dismissed the petition. Hence the Miscellaneous First Appeal by the defendants.

    4. The question that would arise for consideration is whether the judgment and decree passed under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C would attract the operation of Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C or whether the parties suffering such a judgment and decree would have only a right of Regular Appeal.

    5. Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C as it stands amended by the Amendment Act of 1976, reads as:—

    “Procedure when party fails to present written statement called for by Court:—

    Where any party from whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9, fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the Court as the case may be, the Court shall pronounce judgment against him, or make such order in, relation to the suit as it thinks fit and on the pronouncement of such judgment, a decree shall be drawn up.”

    Rule 10 before it was amended reads as:—

    “Where any party from whom a written statement is so required fails to present the same within the time fixed by the Court the Court may pronounce judgment against him, or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit.”

    The amendments carried out in Rule 10 are that the written statement required to be filed must be one under Order 8 Rule 1 or Rule 9. Then the next amendment introduced is that the word ‘permitted’ has been used. The unamended Rule 10 only gave discretion to the Court to pronounce a judgment while the amended Section makes it mandatory for the Court to pronounce judgment against him. It further says that on the pronouncement of such judgment, a decree shall be drawn up. These words viz., that “on the pronouncement of such judgment a decree shall be drawn up” are introduced by the amendment. It was not to be found in the old Rule 10. Formerly if a judgment was pronounced under Order 8 Rule 10, it was treated as an appealable order and Order 43 Rule 1(b) provided for an appeal. Order 43 Rule 1(b) is repealed. Therefore on account of the repeal of Order 43 Rule 1(b), the right of filing a Miscellaneous Appeal against the judgment pronounced under Order 8 Rule 10 is taken away. The simple repeal of such a valuable right must have some meaning. Now the amended Rule 10 speaks that “On the pronouncement of such judgment, a decree shall be drawn up” will have to be given some meaning especially in view of the taking away of the right of appeal provided by Order 43 Rule 1(b). The definition of ‘decree’ given in Section 2(2) C.P.C stated that a decree shall not include any adjudication from which an appeal lies as an appeal from an order. So any judgment pronounced under the unamended Rule 10 could not be followed by a decree within the meaning of Section 2(2) because a Miscellaneous Appeal had been provided by Order 43 Rule 1(b). Therefore any judgment that was pronounced under the unamended Rule 10 only amounted to an order and therefore the right of appeal under Order 43 Rule 1(b) had been provided. Therefore in view of the repeal of Order 43 Rule 1(b) and in view of the specific use of the words “a decree shall be drawn up”, it appears to me that the Legislature intended to provide rather better remedies to the party who suffered a decree passed under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C

    6. Order 17 Rule 3 C.P.C reads as:—

    “Where any party to a suit to whom time has been granted fails to produce his evidence, or to cause the attendance of his witnesses, or to perform any other act necessary to the further progress of the suit, for which time has been allowed, the Court may, notwithstanding such default,—

    (a) if the parties are present, proceed to decide the suit forthwith; or,

    (b) if the parties are or any of them is absent, proceed under Rule 2”

    Therefore Order 17 Rule 3 C.P.C contemplates two stages. One is if the parties are present and the other is if the parties are or any of them is absent. If the parties are present, then the Court will have to proceed to decide the suit forthwith. If the parties are or any of them is absent, then the Court will have to proceed only under Order 17 Rule 2 C.P.C It is a case where the defendants were absent when the judgment was pronounced under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C Therefore it is Order 17 Rule 3(b) that would be attracted to the facts of the present case. Order 17 Rule 2 reads as:—

    “Where, on any day to which the hearing of the suit is adjourned, the parties or any of them fail to appear, the Court may proceed to dispose of the suit in one of the modes directed in that behalf by Order 9 or make such other order as it thinks fit.”

    Therefore if the judgment and decree are pronounced under Order 8 Rule 10 (amended), then the party would have a right to proceed under Order 9 also. Then the question would arise whether the word ‘hearing’ used in Rule 2 and Rule 3 has got a separate connotation. Order 8 of the C.P.C relates to the filing of the written statement, set off and counter claim. Rule 1 says that the defendant shall at or before the first hearing or within such time as the Court may permit present a written statement of his defence. Therefore the word ‘hearing’ used in Order 8 Rule 1 C.P.C says that the stage of hearing starts from the moment the defendant puts in his appearance in the Court after being served with summons. Therefore the word ‘hearing’ used in Rule 2 and Rule 3 of Order 17 C.P.C also would have the same meaning. If it is so, then any judgment or decree passed under Order 8 Rule 10 would clearly amount to a judgment and decree popularly called as exparte judgment and exparte decree. The word ‘exparte’ only means that pronounced in the absence of a party. It has not got any other meaning. If it is so, then Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C would be applicable even to a case where a judgment and decree have been passed under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C

    7. The word ‘Decree’ has been specifically used in Order 8 Rule 10 by the amendment Act in order to bring it within the ambit, of Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C If the word ‘decree’ had not been used in Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C, Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C would not have come into play, because Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C applies only to a case of decree being passed exparte. Therefore, the insertion of word ‘decree’ in Rule 10 now, in my opinion, is meant to give an alternate relief to the party under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C, instead of driving him to a Regular Appeal which would involve a lot of expense and energy and the decision of which matter may take unnecessarily longer time.

    8. The Learned Counsel Shri Visveswara for the revision petitioner referred me to Abdul Aziz v. A. Raj Chhabra . A.I.R 1968 Allahabad 119.. It was a case where the defence of a defendant had been struck off under Order 11 Rule 21 C.P.C and a Judgment was pronounced against him. The Allahabad High Court said as:—

    “It shall thus be seen that Rule 13 is wide enough to cover all cases of exparte decrees no matter for what reason the exparte decree has been passed. A persual of Order 11 Rule 21 C.P.C would show that where a defence is to be struck off in the circumstances mentioned therein, the order would be that the defendant, “be placed in the same position as if he has not defended”. This also indicates that once the defence has been struck off under Order 11 Rule 21 C.P.C, the position would be as if the defendant had not defended and accordingly the suit would proceed exparte”

    Similar would be the situation covered by Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C As the defendant failed to file the written statement as called upon by the Court, the Court has been empowered to pronounce the judgment and pass a decree. Thus it means that the judgment and decree will have to be passed in a case coming under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C as if he had not defended the matter. Therefore the principle laid down in the said Abdul Aziz's case also lends assurance to the view that I have taken.

    9. The Learned Counsel Shri Mani placed before me the decision in Sangram Singh v. 1. Election Tribunal, Kotah . A.I.R 1955 S.C 425.. The most important point that was involved in the said case was as to what is the meaning of the word ‘hearing’ and the first hearing and the adjourned hearing. It does not cover the case under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C at all. The following observation of the Supreme Court in para 16 would be of material help in the present case:—

    “Now a code of procedure must be regarded as such. It is ‘procedure’, something designed to facilitate justice and further its ends: not a penal enactment for punishment and penalties: not a thing designed to trip people up. Too technical a construction of Sections that leaves no room for reasonable elasticity of interpretation should therefore be guarded against (provided always that justice is done ‘both’ sides) lest the very means designed for the furtherance of justice be used to frustrate it.”

    The Supreme Court has further stated in para 17 as:—

    “Next, there must be ever present to the mind the fact that our laws of procedure are grounded on a principle of natural justice which requires that men should not be condemned unheard, that decisions should not be reached behind their backs, that proceedings that affect their lives and property should not continue in their absence and that they should not be precluded from participating in them.”

    The Supreme Court has also stated in para 30 as:—

    “Now Rule 2 only applies when one or both of the parties do not appear ‘on the day fixed for the adjourned hearing’. In that event, the Court is thrown back to Order 9 with the additional power to make “such order as it thinks fit”. When it goes back to Order 9 it finds that it is again empowered to proceed ‘exparte’ on the adjourned hearing in the same way as it did, or could have done, if one or other of the parties had not appeared at the first hearing, that is to say, the right to proceed ‘exparte’ is a right which accrues from day to day because at each adjourned hearing the Court is thrown back to Order 9 Rule 6.”

    This observation of the Supreme Court makes it absolutely clear that the right to proceed exparte is a right which would accrue from day to day because at each adjourned hearing the Court is thrown back to Order 9 Rule 6. Therefore right to proceed exparte does not depend uponstatic circumstances or position. It is a matter which will have to be applied day to day in every matter. Therefore merely because 8 adjournments had been taken by the defendants in this case, it does not mean that the Court could not proceed exparte against them, when the defendants were absent.

    10. Therefore, in the result, I find that the judgment and decree contemplated under Order 8 Rule 10 V.P.V amount to an exparte judgment and exparte decree and thus attract Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C also.

    11. I am fully aware that the remedy under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C is only an alternate remedy. The person who suffers an exparte decree has not only got a right to proceed under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C but also he has got a right to file a regular Appeal. If he wants he can proceed in both ways or resort to any one of the remedies. Therefore, the present application filed under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C by the defendants against the exparte judgment and decree passed by the Court below under Order 8 Rule 10, is competent and maintainable.

    12. If it is so, then the question arises whether the defendants have satisfied the requirements of Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C The evidence adduced by the defendants shows that their lawyer told them on that day that he would file an application seeking better particulars. According to them, the lawyer filed such an application, but the Court was rather not inclined to accept it. Thus they were under the bona fide impression that the Court may grant such an application when it adjourned the matter to a latter part of the day. They say that they were absent at the adjourned time on that day. Therefore their impression that the Court might grant time to them in order to enable them to seek further particulars, cannot be said to be unfounded. Therefore they had sufficient grounds to remain absent at that time when the judgment and decree were passed against them under Order 8 Rule 10 C.P.C Therefore, the Court below was wrong in holding that sufficient grounds had not been made out by the defendants for their absence at the time when the judgment and decree were passed against them exparte.

    13. Before, I close the matter, I would like to reproduce the exparte judgment and decree passed by the Court in the suit. It reads as:—

    “Not filed. Smt. - For Smt. S.P prays for time 8th time is granted Advocate prays for time till 3 P.M Kept by.

    Called at 3 P.M Advocate and party absent - Waited till 4-50 P.M Advocate has not turned up. Plaint averments make out suit claim. As no written statement is filed, the suit is decree as prayed for under Order 8 Rule 10 and 5 of the C.P.C with three months time for payment. Draw up preliminary decree.”

    This is not the way in which a Court is expected to pronounce the judgment and decree when the rights of the parties are involved. Merely because the defendants are absent, it does not mean that the plaintiff is entitled to a decree. The Court will have to scan the material available on record in order to find out whether the plaintiff has really made out a case or not. It is no doubt true that Order 8 Rule 5(1) C.P.C says as:

    “Every allegation of fact in the plaint, if not denied specifically or by necessary implication, or stated to be not admitted in the pleading of the defendant, shall be taken to be admitted except as against a person under disability.”

    Order 8 Rule 5(2) C.P.C says as:—

    “Where the defendant has not filed a pleading, it shall be lawful for the Court to pronunce judgment on the basis of the facts contained in the plaint, except as against a person under a disability, but the Court may in its discretion, require any such fact to be proved.”

    If the defendant does not file the written statement it may be lawful for the Court to pronounce the judgment on the basis of the facts contained in the plaint. Merely because it is lawful, it does not mean that the Court should abdicate its function of finding out as to whether the plaintiff has already made out a case or not. Otherwise the results would be rather disastrous. If in a suit by the plaintiff seeking a declaration that he is the adopted son of one B and also for possession, the defendant does not file the written statement, should the Court proceed to conclude that the allegation of adoption mentioned in the plaint is proved? It may be lawful for it to take that spect into consideration. In Eswara Devaru, S.… v. Nagarajaiah, A.R…. . 1983 2 K.L.J 89., it is held as:—

    “Under Rule 10 of Order 8 of C.P.C as it stands after amendment by Act 104 of 1976, where a defendant from whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9, fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed, as the case may be, Rule 10 comes into play and the Court has to pronounce judgment against the defendant or make such other order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit.

    The minimum that is required of a judgment of a Court of Small Causes is that it should contain the points for determination and the decision thereon.

    Where the order amounts to a judgment within Rule 10 of C.P.C if it does not contain the points for determination and the decision thereon as required under Order 20, Rule 4(1) of C.P.C it is liable to be set aside.

    Even under Order 8 Rule 5(2), it is obligatory for the Court to examine the plea and the facts set out in the plaint to find out whether the plaintiff has made out a case for a decree.”

    Therefore, the principles laid down by this Court in the said case require that even in exparte cases the Court should apply its mind to the allegations made in the plaint and should convince its conscience to find out as to whether the allegations made by the plaintiff are really sufficient and proved to the extent as to enable him to get a decree in the Batter. The judgment and decree passed in this case, in my opinion, are not in consonance with law and rules at all. Therefore the said judgment cannot be allowed to stand.

    14. Even apart from it, I have already dealt with the matter holding that it falls under Order 9 Rule 13 C.P.C

    15. In the result, the order passed by the Court below is set aside. The appeal is allowed. The suit is restored to file. The City Civil Court, Bangalore City, should take it back to file and proceed with the suit. The Court below should, however, give one more opportunity to the defendants to file the written statement.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S. Kuvarp Industries And Another v. State Bank Of Mysore .
    (Aug 1, 1984)