Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petitioners were Managers employed by respondent-1 (Syndicate Bank). By an order dated April 25, 1990 they were placed under suspension pending enquiry for alleged misconduct: unauthorized absence on April 25, 1990 and failure to hand over branch keys, an act said to have caused financial loss and disruption. The suspension orders (extracted in the opinion) imposed conditions during suspension including restrictions on leaving headquarters and requirements to furnish postal address.

Following agitations by Officers of the Bank beginning March 5, 1990, and disciplinary action by the Bank, the suspension orders were revoked by proceedings dated July 19, 1990. The revocation expressly stated that the suspension was revoked without prejudice to departmental proceedings and that the officers were not entitled to any back wages other than subsistence allowances already paid.

On July 19, 1990 the Bank also issued transfer memoranda posting the petitioners to other branches (Mudgal and Tekkalkote), granting seven days joining time and related administrative directions.

The petitioners filed writ petitions seeking: (1) quashing of the order of suspension and the July 19, 1990 order insofar as back wages were denied for the suspension period (stated in the opinion as "between April 25, 1970 and July 19, 1990"), and (2) quashing of the transfer orders.

At the admission stage the learned Judge issued notice and on September 10, 1990 granted a stay of the transfer orders pending examination of whether the transfers were punitive. The Bank filed writ appeals challenging that stay; accordingly, the writ petitions and writ appeals are treated as interconnected in the opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order of suspension dated April 25, 1990 was validly made by a "Competent Authority" under the Syndicate Bank Officer Employees' (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1976.
  2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to back wages for the period of suspension (as sought in the writ petitions) given the revocation order dated July 19, 1990 which denied back wages except subsistence allowance.
  3. Whether the transfer orders issued on July 19, 1990 were punitive/mala fide or otherwise invalid (including whether an internal Circular could prevent or invalidate those transfers).

Arguments of the Parties

Writ Petitioners' Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Subba Rao)

  • The person who signed/issued the April 25, 1990 suspension order was not the "Competent Authority" as defined in the Regulations; therefore the initial suspension was invalid.
  • If the initial suspension was invalid, the subsequent revocation (July 19, 1990) cannot cure that defect, and the petitioners would be entitled to full back wages for the suspension period.
  • As to transfers, the petitioners relied on a Circular (stemming from a joint meeting of Management and Officers' Association) which, according to Annexure-C, imposed limits on transfers (e.g., posting to rural branches for certain scales only for one term, with an option to forego). Because the policy was by mutual agreement, the Bank was bound to follow it; multiple transfers (three transfers in one year) and mid-year transfers indicated mala fides and violated that Circular.

Respondent-Bank's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. S. G. Sundaraswamy)

  • There is no merit in the contention that the suspension was not by a Competent Authority; by delegation the Divisional Manager could pass suspension orders and/or the Managing Director's delegation made such action valid.
  • The suspensions were valid and in any event were validly revoked on July 19, 1990.
  • The petitioners were denied back wages because of the alleged gross misconduct (locking the bank and leaving, causing inconvenience), as shown in Annexure-B, and thus denial of back wages was appropriate.
  • Transfers are an ordinary and necessary part of service; the internal Circular is only for administrative guidance and is not enforceable in a court under Article 226 of the Constitution. Administrative exigency justifies transfers and multiple or mid-year transfers do not, by themselves, indicate mala fides.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a stepwise analysis grounded in the Bank's disciplinary regulations and the documentary record reproduced in the opinion.

First, the court described the alleged misconduct as serious if proved (unauthorised absence and failure to hand over branch keys causing loss and disruption), but explicitly stated that it was not deciding guilt at the writ stage; rather the misconduct's gravity justified careful treatment of the management's actions.

Second, the court examined the Regulations:

  • Regulation 3(f) defines "Competent Authority" as the authority appointed by the Board for the purposes of the regulations; the opinion reproduced that definition.
  • Regulation 5 sets out the authority to institute disciplinary proceedings and permits the Managing Director to empower other authorities, generally or specially, to institute or direct disciplinary proceedings and to be the Competent Authority for imposing penalties.
  • Regulation 12 permits the Competent Authority to impose suspension; suspension is characterised in the opinion as non-punitive (it removes the officer from the sphere of action).

Third, the court examined Annexure-C (an April 16, 1990 order signed by the Managing Director) which, in exercise of powers under Regulation 5, expressly empowered Sri B. V. Bhat, Divisional Manager, to institute disciplinary proceedings against officers of certain grades during the absence of Personnel Managers and declared him to be the Competent Authority under Regulation 12 for those categories of officers. On that basis the court concluded that the orders of suspension (as passed by the empowered authority) could not be successfully impugned on the ground that they were not issued by a Competent Authority.

Fourth, having accepted that the suspension was validly imposed and was later revoked on July 19, 1990, the court found that the Bank's decision to deny back wages except for subsistence allowance was within management's discretion given the alleged misconduct. The court considered the seriousness of the misconduct and held the denial of back wages "fully warranted" in the circumstances.

Fifth, on the transfers, the court reiterated the general principle that transfer is an incident of service and that administrative exigencies justify transfers. It held that an internal Circular functions as administrative guidance and is not enforceable before the Court under Article 226; therefore, breach of a Circular does not itself create a cause of action. The court found no evidence of mala fides in the transfers, observing that they were part of general administrative "toning up" rather than punitive measures.

Finally, weighing these conclusions, the court dismissed the petitioners' core contentions: the challenge to the suspension's validity failed because of the valid delegation of authority, the denial of back wages was sustainable given the alleged misconduct, and the challenge to the transfers failed because transfers were administrative and not shown to be mala fide.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Writ petitions dismissed.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The court upheld the validity of the suspension (insofar as it was issued by an authority empowered by the Managing Director under Regulation 5 and declared to be the Competent Authority under Regulation 12).
  • The court sustained the Bank's decision in the revocation order to deny back wages except for the subsistence allowance already paid; the petitioners were not awarded additional back wages.
  • The transfer orders issued on July 19, 1990 were not set aside; the court found no mala fides and treated transfers as administrative decisions not justiciable via the Circular relied upon by the petitioners.
  • The court declined to impose costs against the petitioners despite dismissing their petitions, noting their status as Bank employees.
  • As to the connected writ appeals filed by the Bank against the stay of transfers, the court stated that no order was necessary in those appeals.

The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal precedent; it resolves the instant disputes on the facts and the parties' documentary record under the Bank's Regulations reproduced in the opinion.

    Syndicate Bank v. Sunder K. Paniyadi

    1. These writ appeals and writ petitions are interconnected. As to what exactly the inter-connection, we will deal with it shortly. We will take up the writ petitions first.

    2. The writ petitioners are working as Managers-employees of respondent-1 - Bank (Syndicate Bank) (hereinafter to as the Bank). By order dated April 25, 1990 they were kept under suspension pending enquiry into certain misconduct alleged against them. It is necessary for us to reproduce the relevant portions of the order of suspension :

    "Whereas Sri Sunder K. Paniyadi, Employee No. 076467, Manager, Kemmannu Branch, holding outdoor keys/joint custody keys of Kemmannu Branch, is reported to have absented unauthorised this day, i.e., April 25, 1990 from duties and failed to hand over the said keys to the Bank which caused considerable amount of financial loss to the bank besides disrupting normal functioning of the Branch. Further, the said action on his part has also caused inconvenience to the customers of the Branch and is a breach of contract of service and gross violation of the guidelines laid down by the Bank in this regard.

    And Whereas such acts constitute 'Misconduct' under the Syndicate Bank Officer Employees' (C) Regulations, 1976 and whereas Disciplinary Proceedings in respect of them under the Syndicate Bank Officer Employees' (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1976 are contemplated against Sri Sunder K. Paniyadi and/or a case against him in respect of a criminal offence is also under investigation/enquiry.

    It is also further ordered that during the period of suspension Sri Sunder K. Paniyadi shall not leave the Headquarters without obtaining prior permission of the undersigned. He is further required to furnish his postal address forthwith for the purpose of further communication, if any, with him.

    Whereas Sri. K. R. Kamath, Emp. No. 080925, Manager, Hoode Branch, holding outdoor keys/joint custody keys Hoode Branch, is reported to have absented unauthorisedly this day i.e., April 25, 1990 from duties, and failed to handover the said keys to the Bank which caused considerable amount of financial loss to the bank besides disrupting normal functioning of the Branch. Further, the said action on his part has also caused inconvenience to the customers of the Branch and is a breach of contract of service and gross violation of the guidelines laid down by the Bank in this regard.

    And Whereas such acts constitute 'Misconduct' under the Syndicate Bank Officer Employees' (Conduct) Regulations, 1976 and whereas Disciplinary Proceedings in respect of them under the Syndicate Bank Officer Employees' (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1976 are contemplated against Sri K. R. Kamath and/or a case against him in respect of a criminal offence is also under investigation/enquiry.

    It is also further ordered that during the period of suspension, Sri. K. R. Kamath shall not leave the Headquarters without obtaining prior permission of the undersigned. He is further required to furnish his postal address forthwith for the purpose of further communication, if any, with him."

    3. There were certain agitations launched by the Officers of the Association of the Bank from March 5, 1990. Several Officers indulged in illegal activities to interrupt the functioning of the clearing department as also the normal working of the branches' currency chests. The Bank initiated disciplinary proceedings against these officers. Thereafter, the Bank reviewed the orders of suspension and revoked the order of suspension on July 19, 1990 in the following terms :

    "Whereas Sri Sunder K. Paniyadi, Employee No. 076467, Manager, Kemmannu Branch, was placed under suspension by the Competent Authority vide Proceedings No. 69 : PD : IRD : DA : 6 dated April 25, 1990 in exercise of the powers conferred upon him vide Regulation No. 12(1) of Syndicate Bank Officer Employees' (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations 1976.

    And Whereas Regulation No. 12(5)(b) of the Syndicate Bank Officer Employees' (D and A) Regulations 1976 provides for revocation of the suspension order by the Competent Authority.

    And Whereas the undersigned being the Competent Authority at present under the said Regulations, in exercise of the powers conferred upon him thereunder, hereby revokes the suspension order served on Sri Sunder K. Paniyadi and the revocation of suspension of service comes into effect from the date of due service of the proceedings and he shall report for duty within 7 days from the date of due service of the proceedings under reference at the Branch/Office to be indicated by the Deputy General Manager, Zonal Office, Mangalore separately, under intimation to the undersigned as well as to the Deputy General Manager, Zonal Office, Mangalore.

    It is also ordered that the suspension order revoked as above is without prejudice to the rights of the Bank to proceed against him departmentally.

    It is also ordered that Sri Sundar K. Panjyadi is not entitled for any back wages other than what has already been paid to him as subsistence allowance during the period of suspension."

    "Whereas Sri. K. R. Kamath, Employee No. 080925 Manager, Hoode Branch, was placed under suspension by the Competent Authority vide Proceedings No. 68 : PD : IRD : DA : 6 dated April 25, 1990 in exercise of the powers conferred upon him vide Regulation No. 12(1) of Syndicate Bank Officer Employee's (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations 1976.

    And Whereas Regulation No. 12(5)(b) of the Syndicate Bank Officer Employees' (D and A) Regulations 1976 provides for revocation of the suspension order by the Competent Authority.

    Whereas the undersigned being the Competent Authority at present under the said Regulations, in exercise if the powers conferred upon him thereunder, hereby revokes the suspension order served on Sri K. R. Kamath and the revocation of suspension of service comes into effect from the date of due service of this proceedings and shall report for duty within 7 days from the date of due service of the proceedings under reference at the Branch/Office to be indicated by the Deputy General Manager, Zonal Office, Mangalore separately, under intimation to the undersigned as well as to the Deputy General Manager, Zonal Office, Mangalore.

    It is also ordered that the suspension order revoked as above is without prejudice to the rights of the Bank to proceed against him departmentally.

    It is also ordered that Sri K. R. Kamath is not entitled for any back wages other than what has already been paid to him as subsistence allowance during the period of suspension."

    On that very day orders of transfer are issued in terms of the following :

    "MEMORANDUM With reference to the Proceedings of the Personnel Manager dated July 19, 1990 revoking the suspension of Sri S. K. Paniyadi, he is hereby informed that he is posted to our Mudgal Branch to work there as Manager until further orders.

    In terms of this Memorandum and the proceedings of the Personnel Manager mentioned above he shall report for duty at Mudgal Branch under intimation to us. He shall take charge of Mudgal Branch from the officer who is incharge of that branch under intimation to be concerned Zonal Office, DO, Local Banks, HOLDPD : PAS and other concerned Authorities/Offices. Copies of necessary resolution will be sent separately. He shall also take possession of the Manager's quarters fixed for that branch under information to us.

    Seven days joining time is granted. The TA Bill in connection with this posting shall be submitted within 3 days of completing the journey, refunding in cash the sundry advance if any drawn in excess of the T.A. Bill.

    Sd/-

    Deputy General Manager Sri S. K. Paniyadi, Manager, under suspension, Kemmannu Branch."

    "MEMORANDUM With reference to the proceedings of the Personnel Manager dated July 19, 1990 revoking the suspension of Sri K. R. Kamath; he is hereby informed that he is posted to our Tekkalkote branch to work there as Manager until further orders.

    In terms of this Memorandum and the proceedings of the Personnel Manager mentioned above he shall report for duty at Tekkalkote branch under intimation to us. He shall take charge of Tekkalkote branch from the officer who is in charge of that branch under intimation to the concerned Zonal Office, DO, Local Banks, HOLD : PAS and other concerned Authorities/Officers. Copies of necessary resolution will be sent separately. He shall also take possession of the Manager's quarters fixed for that branch under information to us.

    Seven days joining time is granted. The TA bill in connection with the this posting shall be submitted within three days of completing the journey, refunding in cash the sundry advance if any drawn in excess of the T. A. Bill.

    Sd/-

    Deputy General Manager, Sri K. R. Kamath, Manager, under suspension, Hoode Branch.

    It is under these circumstances, the writ petitions were filed with the following prayer :

    1) To quash the order of suspension as also the order dated July 19, 1990 in so far as the back wages had been denied for the period of suspension between April 25, 1970 and July 19, 1990.

    2) To quash the orders of transfer.

    4. When the writ petitions came up for admission, the learned Judge ordered notice and the matter came up for hearing on September 10, 1990. He was of the view that it requires to be examined whether the transfer was punitive in character and therefore he granted stay of the orders of transfer. Aggrieved by that order of stay dated September 10, 1990, the present writ appeals have been preferred by the Bank. Thus it is obvious that the writ petitions and the writ appeals are interconnected.

    5. In support of the writ petitions. Mr. Subba Rao, learned Counsel for the writ petitioners, would urge the following points our consideration :

    As to who is the disciplinary authority is specified under Regulation 3(g) of the Syndicate Bank Officer Employees' (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1976. The authorities to institute disciplinary proceedings are catalogued under Regulations 5. Of course, as per the regulation, an Officer could be placed under suspension, but that order could be passed by the Competent Authority. The authority who passed the order of suspension on April 25, 1990 is not the Competent Authority within the meaning of the Regulations. Therefore, if the initial suspension itself is bad, the revocation orders on July 19, 1990 is of no consequence even assuming that the orders had been passed by the proper authority. In such an event, the writ petitioners will be entitled to all the back wages. To deny the back wages to the petitioners is improper and illegal.

    6. As regards transfer, there is a Circular which had emanated by reason of a joint meeting between the representatives of the Management-Bank and the Officers' Association. Under the terms of that Circular, the petitioners are not liable to be transferred because Annexure-C states that the Officers in the Scale of I and II will necessarily be posted to rural Branches for one term in the entire service but should that Officer be not desirous of promotion, he could always forego and avoid posting in the rural Branches. In so far as the policy had been entered into by reason of mutual agreement, the Management is bound to follow that policy. In any event, having regard to the fact that there had been three transfers of the writ petitioners. Within a period of one year and that too the orders of transfer had come to be passed in the middle of the year, they are actuated by mala fides, more so, looked at from the point of view of the Circular dated June 25, 1990.

    7. In countering these submissions, Mr. S. G. Sundaraswamy, Senior Advocate for the respondent-Bank, would urge that with regard to imposition of suspension, there is no question of that being done by a Competent Authority. Even otherwise, by reason of delegation, it is open to the Divisional Manager to pass an order of suspension. Therefore no exception could be taken to the orders of suspension. Whatever it may be, the suspension order have been validity revoked on July 19, 1990. The reason why the petitioners had been denied back wages was because of the gross misconduct of locking the Bank and going away and thereby putting the clients of the Bank of great inconvenience. As a matter of fact, it is clear from Annexure-B that the petitioners did indulge in that misconduct. Therefore, the Bank thought that they did not deserve back wages. Hence, the argument addressed in this regard has to be rejected.

    8. Transfer is a necessary concomitant of every service. No person or Officer could say that he would serve in the same station at all times. The policy that is relied on by the other side is only for internal guidance. That is not enforceable in the Court of Law, much more so under Article 226 of the Constitution. If the administrative exigencies warrant transfer, be it thrice in a year or more, that cannot be complained of in this Court. There cannot be any mala fides as contended by the other side in this transfer which was fully warranted. After all the transfer is not punitive in character nor again would that be bad merely because it had been passed in the middle of the year. These arguments are extraneous to the points in issue.

    9. Before we go to deal with the submissions, we would rather express our mind as to the nature of the misconduct alleged against the writ petitioners. We have already extracted the proceedings of the Divisional Manager dated April 25, 1990 in and by which the suspension came to be made. If certainly the misconduct alleged against the petitioners, in that they absented themselves unauthorisedly on April 25, 1990 and failed to hand over the keys of the Bank which caused considerable loss to the Bank besides disrupting the normal working of the Bank, is made out the consequences would be serious. Undoubtedly, if it is proved, it cannot be gainsaid that it has caused immense inconvenience to the customers of the Branch. Therefore, we tend to view this seriously. But at the same time, we hasten to caution we are not deciding the guilt of the writ petitioner. All that we are constrained to point out is no Officer of a public institution, more so, a banking institution which on account of nationalisation is regarded as an instrument in social revolution, could behave in this callous fashion. In other works, the petitioners who are the Managers of the Branches of the respondent-Bank cannot hold people to ransom. With that we stop.

    10. Who is the Competent Authority is mentioned under Regulation 3(f). It reads as follows :

    "3(f). 'Competent Authority' means the authority appointed by the Board for the purposes of these regulations."

    Regulation 5 talks of the Competent officers. It reads as follows :

    "5. Authority to institute disciplinary proceedings and impose penalties :-

    1) The Managing Director or any other authority empowered by him general or special order may institute or direct the Disciplinary Authority to institute disciplinary proceedings against an officer employee of the Bank.

    2) The Disciplinary Authority may himself institute disciplinary proceedings.

    3) The Disciplinary Authority or any authority higher than it may impose any of the penalties specified in Regulation 4 on any officer employee."

    Regulation 12 enables the Competent Authority to impose an order of suspension. As contemplated under Regulation 12, suspension is not punitive in character. After all what has been done by the suspension is removing the officers from the sphere of action, nothing more nothing less. Under these circumstances, the question of Competent Authority may not arise at all. All that we need to do is to extract Annexure-C.

    "April 16, 1990.

    ORDER Whereas Regulation No. 5 of Syndicate Bank officer Employees' (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1976 confers upon the Managing Director of the Bank to empower any other Authority, by a general or special order, to institute or direct the Disciplinary Authority to institute Disciplinary Proceedings against an Officer-Employee of the Bank.

    And Whereas the undersigned being the Managing Direct of the Bank, in exercise of the powers conferred upon him under the above referred regulation, hereby empowers Sri. B. V. Bhat, Division Manager, S. R. D. Head Office, Manipal, to institute Disciplinary Proceedings against any Officer Employees in Junior Management Grade Scale I, Middle Management Grade Scale II and III, working in any of the Branches/Officers, during the absence of the personal Managers, either on Tour or on Leave, until further orders. Further, he is also the Competent Authority under Regulation No. 12 of the Syndicate Bank Officer Employees' (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1976 in respect of the above referred to category of Officers.

    A copy of this Order be sent to the concerned Officer Employee whenever Disciplinary Proceedings are instituted against him under the said Syndicate Bank Officer Employees' (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1976.

    Sd/-

    (P. S. V. MALLYA) Managing Director."

    Therefore, the Competent Authority namely, the Managing Director has come to pass the orders of suspension. No exception could be taken to the same. It has been revoked on July 17, 1990. No doubt at the time of revocation, it was stated that excepting the subsistence allowances, the writ petitioners would not be entitled to any back wages. We think, in the circumstances, that was fully warranted. It is entirely a matter for the Management as to how the period of suspension should be treated depending upon the misconduct alleged. About that misconduct, we have already expressed our opinion as to how serious it is, if it comes ultimately to be established. Therefore, we reject first of the arguments of Mr. Subba Rao.

    11. As rightly contended by Mr. S. G. Sundaraswamy, learned Counsel for the Bank, the transfer is a necessary concomitant of every service. Therefore, if the administrative exigencies warrant a transfer, this Court cannot, as though it is exercising the supervisory jurisdiction over the Bank, say how it should meddle its affairs. It is entirely the look out of the Bank. The mere fact that the writ petitioners were subject to three transfers or it had come to be passed in the middle of the year will be of no consequence whatever in examining the validity of the transfer, nor again, the so-called policy which is adumberated in a Circular could ever be enforced by this Court. The Circulars are intended only for the internal guidance the breach of which will not give rise to any cause of action in favour of the writ petitioners.

    12. We find no scope whatever to conclude that the orders of transfer are actuated by mala fides. This was in pursuance of general toning up of administration. Therefore, we reject that argument as well.

    13. In the result, the writ petitions will stand dismissed. Normally we would have been inclined to award costs, but having regard to the fact that the petitioners are employees of the Bank, we do not propose to mulct them with costs.

    14. In view of the above, no order is necessary in the writ appeals.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Syndicate Bank v. Sunder K. Paniyadi
    (Nov 13, 1990)