AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • provision of Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  • Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.6)
  • Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 378(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Section of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • ARTICLE 136 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 32 A CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 372 Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Sections 420 of the Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code
  • provisions i.e Section 372 and 378(4),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • provision of Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  • Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.6)
  • Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 378(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Section of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • ARTICLE 136 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 32 A CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 372 Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Sections 420 of the Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code
  • provisions i.e Section 372 and 378(4),
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (D.N. Patel, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner (complainant) filed a complaint before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Latehar alleging an offence under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code. According to the complaint, the opposite party No. 2 requested the petitioner to stand as guarantor for a loan applied for by opposite party No. 2 from the Jharkhand State Adivasi Co-Operative Development Corporation Ltd., Daltonganj, for Rs. 2,96,548/-. The petitioner signed as guarantor in good faith. Later, the corporation issued a notice making the petitioner liable for repayment and the petitioner alleged breach of trust by opposite party No. 2.

The trial Court (Chief Judicial Magistrate, Latehar) dismissed the complaint by judgment and order dated 17 July 2012 in Complaint Case No. 212 of 2008 (Trial No. 222 of 2012). The petitioner then applied to the High Court under Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure seeking Special Leave to Appeal from the order of dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a complainant who is also the victim may be granted Special Leave to Appeal by the High Court under Section 378(4) CrPC in respect of a complaint dismissed by a Magistrate, or whether such a complainant-victim must first avail the statutory right of appeal conferred by the proviso to Section 372 CrPC (inserted with effect from 31 December 2009).
  2. Whether, in the circumstances where statutory appeal remedy exists, the High Court should refuse special leave and require exhaustion of the statutory remedy before entertaining an application under Section 378(4) CrPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner applied under Section 378(4) CrPC for Special Leave to Appeal against the trial Court's dismissal of the complaint.
  • Counsel for the petitioner contended that there were several errors of fact and law in the trial Court's judgment and submitted that Special Leave to Appeal should be granted so the High Court could correct those errors.
  • Counsel relied upon various reported decisions (citations provided in the opinion) to support the contention for grant of leave.

State's Arguments

  • The learned A.P.P. raised a preliminary objection that a statutory provision for appeal exists under the proviso to Section 372 CrPC and that the petitioner must first exhaust that statutory remedy instead of seeking Special Leave under Section 378(4) CrPC.
  • It was pointed out that Section 372 was amended with effect from 31 December 2009 (based on the Law Commission's Report No. 154) to provide victims a statutory right of appeal in specified circumstances.
  • The State relied on analogy to other constitutional remedies (Article 32/226/136) and to authority (including a Full Bench decision of the Patna High Court) to argue that, where a concurrent or statutory remedy exists before a lower court, the litigant should approach that forum first and not directly seek special leave in the higher forum.
  • The State further argued that when the complainant is also the victim, Section 372's proviso is the correct route, whereas when the complainant is not the victim (for example an official like an Income Tax Officer), an application under Section 378 may be tenable because the complainant lacks the statutory right under Section 372.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Syed Zafrul Hassan v. State (Full Bench), reported in 1986 PLJR, 274 Principle that where concurrent jurisdiction exists, litigants should ordinarily prefer the remedy before the lower forum (analogy used for preferring lower forum remedies first). The Court noted the State relied on this Full Bench decision by analogy to support the proposition that where statutory or concurrent remedies exist, the applicant should approach the lower forum first rather than seeking direct relief in the higher forum.
2011 Maharastra Cr. L.J. 3473 This decision was relied upon by the petitioner (citation provided in the opinion). The Court observed the petitioner relied upon this decision, but considered the facts of the present case to be different because the petitioner here is both victim and complainant and therefore has the statutory remedy under Section 372 CrPC.
2011 (1) Crimes 647, M.P. Decision cited by the petitioner (citation provided in the opinion). The Court noted the citation but treated the facts as distinguishable for the reasons stated (petitioner here being the victim with an available statutory appeal).
2011 (6) Maharastra Cr. L.J. 165 Decision cited by the petitioner (citation provided in the opinion). The Court considered the citation but found it not controlling because the statutory position and facts (victim = complainant) governed the present case.
(2010) 5 SCC 613 Decision cited by the petitioner (citation provided in the opinion). The Court perused this authority as relied upon by the petitioner but held that the statutory right under Section 372 CrPC (proviso) made the present facts different and required exhaustion of statutory appeal remedy.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded stepwise and relied on the statutory text and the facts as established in the record:

  1. The petitioner is both the complainant and the victim in the criminal complaint under Section 420 IPC as filed in Chief Judicial Magistrate, Latehar.
  2. The learned trial Court dismissed the complaint by judgment dated 17 July 2012 (Complaint Case No. 212 of 2008).
  3. The proviso to Section 372 CrPC (inserted by amendment effective 31 December 2009 pursuant to the Law Commission's Report No. 154) grants the victim a statutory right to prefer an appeal against certain orders (acquittal, conviction for a lesser offence, or imposition of inadequate compensation), and such appeal lies to the court to which an appeal ordinarily lies against the order of conviction of that court.
  4. Section 378(4) CrPC permits, in cases instituted upon complaint, that if the High Court grants Special Leave to Appeal from an order of acquittal on an application by the complainant, the complainant may present such an appeal to the High Court. The petitioner invoked this provision to seek special leave.
  5. The Court emphasized that when the complainant is also the victim, the statutory right under the proviso to Section 372 CrPC is available and must be availed; consequently Special Leave under Section 378(4) should not be granted in such circumstances.
  6. The Court distinguished circumstances where the complainant is not the victim (for instance, enforcement officers like Income-tax, Labour, or Food Adulteration officials): in those cases, the complainant does not have the statutory right of appeal under Section 372 and applications under Section 378 may be tenable.
  7. The Court reinforced the principle of judicial hierarchy and forum discipline: if a remedy or appeal is tenable before a lower forum, the litigant should approach that forum first and exhaust the statutory remedy before approaching the higher forum; this allows the higher forum the advantage of an additional decision on facts and law to review if necessary.
  8. Applying these principles to the present facts, because the petitioner is both victim and complainant and has the statutory remedy under Section 372 CrPC, the Court concluded that Special Leave under Section 378(4) should be refused and the statutory appeal remedy exhausted first.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court refused to grant Special Leave to Appeal under Section 378(4) CrPC and dismissed the Criminal Misc. Petition.

Direct Implications for the Parties:

  • The petitioner is required to exhaust the statutory remedy by preferring an appeal under the proviso to Section 372 CrPC before the Sessions Judge, Latehar, against the judgment and order dated 17 July 2012.
  • The petition for Special Leave to Appeal to the High Court under Section 378(4) CrPC is refused; consequently the High Court will not entertain the petitioner's appeal under that provision at this stage.

Broader implications: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new principle of law beyond applying the existing statutory provisions and established forum-discipline principles; the decision requires victim-complainants to first avail themselves of the statutory appeal under the proviso to Section 372 CrPC where applicable.

    Bidya Lakhan Bhagat Petitioner v. The State Of Jharkhand

    D.N Patel, J.

    1) The present application has been preferred under 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for getting Special Leave to Appeal against the judgment and order dated 17th July 2012 passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Latehar in Complaint Case No. 212 of 2008.Trial No. 222 of 2012 whereby the complaint case filed by the petitioner has been dismissed.

    2) The complaint case was filed by the complainant-petitioner before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Latehar for allegedly committing an offence under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code against the Opposite Party No. 2. The case of the complainant-petitioner, as per the complaint petition, is that opposite party No. 2 requested the complainant-petitioner to offer himself as a guarantor for the loan for which he had applied to the Jharkhand State Adivasi Co-Operative Development Corporation Ltd., Daltonganj to the tune of Rs. 2,96,548/- and the complainant-petitioner in good faith signed the agreement paper as the guarantor for the loan amount. Subsequently, the corporation issued a notice to the complainant-petitioner shifting the liability of payment of loan amount of the opposite party no. 2 upon him. Further case of the complainant-petitioner is that opposite party no. 2 has committed breach of trust of agreement.

    3) Counsel for the petitioner has submitted that though there is provision for statutory appeal under the newly inserted proviso to Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, as the petitioner is the complainant, he has preferred this appeal for grant of Special Leave to Appeal under Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Counsel for the petitioner has pointed out several aspects of the matter based upon the evidence recorded by the trial Court and has submitted that Special Leave to Appeal may kindly be granted because there are several errors on the facts and law, committed by the trial Court.

    4) Counsel for the State-A.P.P has taken a preliminary objection as to statutory provision is provided under Section 372 Code of Criminal Procedure, but Special Leave to Appeal may not be granted to the petitioner and let the right of statutory appeal be exhausted and thereafter they may come to this Court. The learned A.P.P also submitted that the provision of Code of Criminal Procedure has been amended with effect from 31st December, 2009 based upon 154 report of the Law Commission of India. It is submitted by the A.P.P that whenever statutory provision of preferring an appeal is given by law, the remedy must be exhausted first and, thereafter, they can approach this Court. The learned A.P.P has also taken analogy from writ petition preferred under Article 32 of the Constitution of India for violation of fundamental rights and in those cases, normally the Hon'ble Supreme Court is sending the petitioner to the concerned High Courts under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Similarly, against the judgment and order of learned Single Judge of the High Court, whenever Letters Patent Appeal is tenable, normally Special Leave to Appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution of India is not granted. Similarly, counsel for the State has relied upon decisions rendered by the Full Bench of Hon'ble Patna High Court in Syed Zafrul Hassan v. State (F.B) reported in 1986 PLJR, 274 that whenever there is a concurrent jurisdiction for grant of anticipatory bail i.e both by the Sessions Court as well as by the High Court, normally the anticipatory bail applications should be preferred before the Sessions Court. In view of this analogy, it is submitted by the counsel for the State that in the facts of the present case, the parties are not remedy-less. They have a right to prefer an statutory appeal against the very judgment of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Latehar before the Sessions Court, Latehar. Thus, the Special Leave to Appeal may not be granted to the petitioner. Counsel for the State has also pointed out that whenever victim is also the complainant himself, then in all such cases statutory provision of Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure should be resorted to and whenever the complainant is not the victim like the cases in which the complainant is Income-tax Officer or the officer of the Labour Department, or the Officer of the Food Adulteration Department, in all those cases, complainant and the victims are different persons, in those cases, instead of preferring an appeal under Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, they can prefer an application under Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure for getting Special Leave to Appeal. But whenever the complainant and the victim are the same person, then statutory right of preferring appeal must be availed first and in those circumstances, without preferring an appeal under Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Special Leave to Appeal under Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure may not be entertained by this Court.

    5) Counsel for the petitioner has also relied upon the decisions reported in 2011 Maharastra Cr. L.J 3473; 2011 (1) Crimes, 647, M.P; 2011 (6) Maharastra Cr. L.J 165; (2010) 5 SCC 613. We have perused the aforesaid decisions. The facts of the present case are absolutely different because the present petitioner is the victim as well as the complainant and, therefore, he has remedy of Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure available to him to file an appeal against the impugned judgment and order passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Latehar, instead of preferring an application for granting Special Leave to Appeal under Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

    6) Having heard learned counsel for both the sides and looking to the preliminary objection raised by the A.P.P it appears that the present appeal preferred under Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure deserves to be dismissed mainly for the following reasons:-

    (I) The present petitioner is the complainant as well as victim. He has preferred a complaint case under under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Latehar.

    (II) The learned trial Court by judgment and order dated 17 July 2012 passed in Complaint Case No. 212 of 2008 dismissed the complaint preferred by the petitioner.

    (III) Against the said judgment and order, there is a remedy of appeal as provided under the proviso of Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure reads as under:-

    “372. No appeal to lie unless otherwise provided. - No appeal shall lie from any judgment or order of a Criminal Court except as provided for by this Code or by any other law for the time being in force.”

    Provided that the victim shall have to prefer an appeal against any order passed by the Court acquitting the accused or convicting for a lesser offence or imposing inadequate compensation, and such appeal shall lie to the Court to which an appeal ordinarily lies against the order of conviction of such Court. (Emphasis supplied)

    (IV) The aforesaid proviso has been inserted by way of amendment in the Code of Criminal Procedure with effect from 31 December, 2009 based upon the 154 report given by the Law Commission of India.

    (V) Thus, the petitioner, who is also the victim, he has statutory right to prefer an appeal against the impugned judgment and order passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Latehar.

    (VI) The present application has been preferred by the petitioners under Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure for getting leave to appeal. Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure reads as under:-

    378. Appeal in case of acquittal.-

    (1) … … …

    (2) … … …

    (3) … … …

    (4) If such an order of’ acquittal is passed in any case instituted upon Complaint and the High Court, on an application made to it by the complainant in this behalf, grants, Special Leave to Appeal from the order of acquittal, the complainant may present such an appeal to the High Court.

    (5) … … …

    (6) … … … (Emphasis supplied)

    (VII) In view of the aforesaid sub-section, the present application has been preferred for getting Special Leave to Appeal. We are not in agreement with the counsel for the petitioners mainly for the reason that in the facts of the present case, when the victim and the complainant are the same person(s), then the complainant has a right to prefer statutory appeal under Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and, therefore, the Special Leave to Appeal cannot be granted in the facts and circumstances of the present case. Whenever the statutory appeal is provided, the parties have to avail the statutory right to prefer an appeal.

    (VIII) It further appears that in the facts of the present case and also looking to both the aforesaid provisions i.e Section 372 and 378(4), when the complainant is not the victim like in the case, an officer of the Income-tax Department, or the Labour Department or the Food Adulteration Department, etc, though they have preferred the complaint case, but, the victims are somebody else, in those cases, application under Section 378(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure is tenable at law, because they have no right to prefer the statutory appeal under the provision of Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Whereas, the cases in which the complainant and the victim are the same person, then they have to avail the statutory remedy by way of appeal instead of preferring an application for getting Special Leave to Appeal directly to the High Court.

    (IX) Moreover, in a judicial hierarchy, whenever any appeal or application is tenable at law before the lower Court, then always the applicant should approach the lower forum first so that after exhausting the said remedy, still if the petitioner is aggrieved, he can approach the higher forum. Thus, the petitioner is not remedy-less. Moreover, the higher forum will have an advantage of one more judgment over and above, the judgment of lower Court on the point of facts and law. In a judicial hierarchy, instead of approaching directly higher forum, if law permits, always matter should be filed in lower forum. Against the judgment and order of learned Single Judge of the High Court, whenever Letters Patent Appeal or any appeal, is tenable, normally Special Leave to Appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution of India is not granted.

    7) Thus, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the victim and the complainant being the same person and the complaint petition, registered by the complainant-petitioner for the offence under Sections 420 of the Indian Penal Code, having been dismissed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, he should first exhaust the remedy available to him under the provision of Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, by preferring an appeal before the learned Sessions Judge, Latehar.

    8) As a cumulative effect of the aforesaid facts and reasons and judicial pronouncements, we hereby refuse to grant leave to Appeal to the present petitioner under Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure Ubi jus ibi remedum. Petitioner not being remedy-less under proviso to Section of the Code of Criminal Procedure, let the remedy by way of statutory appeal be exhausted by him first.

    Thus, this Criminal Misc. Petition is hereby dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bidya Lakhan Bhagat Petitioner v. The State Of Jharkhand
    (Dec 19, 2012)