Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • S. 56, Jammu and Kashmir Tenancy Act, Samvat 1980;b) Proceedings under sub-s. (2) of S. 68-A Jammu and Kashmir Tenancy Act, Samvat 1980;c) Proceedings under S. 24, Jammu and Kashmir Big Landed Estates Abolition Act, Samvat 2007;d) Application
  • S. 19 sub-sec. (3), Cl. (e) by the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms (Amendment) Act, 1981 (Act No. VIII of 1981) and amendment in Cl. (b) of S. 25 of the principal Act (sic).
  • provisions of the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976 (hereinafter called the Act).
  • Act of 1981 (Act No. VIII of 1981) in place of Cl. (e) of sub-s. (3) of S. 19,
  • provision of the Agrarian Reforms Act either S. 19(3), Cl. (e) or S. 25
  • K Agrarian Reforms Act, 1972 (26 of 1972); and (2) 1979 Srinagar
  • provision of S. 19, sub-s. (3), Cl. (e) by amending Act of 1981,
  • Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976,
  • Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act,
  • Act of 1981.Section 19, sub-s. (3),
  • Amendment Act of 1981
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • S. 56, Jammu and Kashmir Tenancy Act, Samvat 1980;b) Proceedings under sub-s. (2) of S. 68-A Jammu and Kashmir Tenancy Act, Samvat 1980;c) Proceedings under S. 24, Jammu and Kashmir Big Landed Estates Abolition Act, Samvat 2007;d) Application
  • S. 19 sub-sec. (3), Cl. (e) by the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms (Amendment) Act, 1981 (Act No. VIII of 1981) and amendment in Cl. (b) of S. 25 of the principal Act (sic).
  • provisions of the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976 (hereinafter called the Act).
  • Act of 1981 (Act No. VIII of 1981) in place of Cl. (e) of sub-s. (3) of S. 19,
  • provision of the Agrarian Reforms Act either S. 19(3), Cl. (e) or S. 25
  • K Agrarian Reforms Act, 1972 (26 of 1972); and (2) 1979 Srinagar
  • provision of S. 19, sub-s. (3), Cl. (e) by amending Act of 1981,
  • Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976,
  • Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act,
  • Act of 1981.Section 19, sub-s. (3),
  • Amendment Act of 1981
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Letters Patent Appeal)

Factual and Procedural Background

This Letters Patent Appeal arises from a judgment and decree confirmed by Hon'ble Mr. Justice S.M.F. Ali (Chief Justice) on November 28, 1972, in Civil Second Appeal No. 88 of 1971, which itself confirmed a decree of the District Judge, Bhaderwah, dated October 19, 1971.

The brief factual matrix, as narrated in the opinion, is as follows:

  • Original suit: Habib Sheikh (plaintiff) sued for a declaration that he was entitled to half of certain agricultural land as co-owner with defendant-respondent Ahmadoo alias Gul Mohd., the land being traced to a common ancestor Lassa.
  • The suit was registered on August 28, 1955, and was later compromised on September 19, 1957; the compromise decree gave the plaintiff one-quarter share in the land.
  • The defendant (respondent in the present appeal) brought a subsequent suit to cancel the compromise decree alleging fraud and non-compliance with Order XXXII, Civil Procedure Code. That suit was dismissed by the trial court on 13-6-1960, but the District Judge decreed the cancellation on June 28, 1963, and the High Court upheld that decree. As a result, the compromise decree was set aside and the original suit was revived.
  • During the revived suit the plaintiff obtained permission (order dated July 4, 1968) to amend the plaint to include a prayer for possession; the amended plaint sought declaration of title and possession.
  • The trial court decreed that the plaintiff was entitled to half the suit land. On appeal the District Judge, Bhaderwah, upheld that decree and dismissed the appeal.
  • The present appellants (including Ghulam Ahmad alias Gul Mohd.) filed a Civil Second Appeal before the High Court; the learned single Judge (the then Chief Justice) dismissed the Civil Second Appeal on November 28, 1972. Leave to prefer a Letters Patent Appeal was granted on December 22, 1972, leading to the present proceeding.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in view of the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act and particularly S. 19(3)(e) read with S. 25, the civil courts must refrain from adjudicating disputes over the agricultural land in this case and whether the matter must be referred to the Collector (Agrarian) for determination of the character of the land.
  2. Whether Full Bench and single-Bench decisions of this Court interpreting pre-amendment S. 19(3)(e) (which held such disputes were to be transmitted to the Collector) continue to apply after the amendment effected by the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms (Amendment) Act, 1981 (Act No. VIII of 1981), which substituted clause (e) of S. 19(3).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants contended that, despite the factual findings already concluded in earlier proceedings, the civil courts cannot proceed to decide the dispute over the agricultural land because the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act bars civil court jurisdiction in such matters.
  • Counsel for the appellants relied on two Full Bench authorities and various single-Bench decisions of the High Court construing provisions of the Agrarian Reforms Act (including S. 19(3)(e) and S. 25) to argue that disputes falling within S. 19(3)(e) must be transmitted to the Collector (Agrarian), who alone should determine the character of the land and hence the civil court must stay its hand pending such determination.
  • Specifically, the appellants asked for remission of the matter to the Collector (Agrarian) for a determination of whether the land fell within the definition of land under the Act, and for the civil court to refrain from adjudicating the controversy until the Collector's finding was returned.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent argued that this is a Letters Patent Appeal against concluded findings of fact reached in proceedings that were initiated before the Agrarian Reforms Act came into force (or at times when it was not in force) and that, given the circumstances, S. 19(3)(e) and S. 25 are not attracted to the present case.
  • The respondent further submitted that the amending Act of 1981 narrowed the scope of S. 19(3)(e) (by substituting the clause), and as a result the prior Full Bench ratio does not apply to the facts of the present case; therefore there is no requirement to refer the matter to the Collector (Agrarian) and the civil court retains jurisdiction to decide the dispute.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1975 J & K 33 (Rahim v. Amma Bar) Interpreted the Agrarian Reforms Act (J & K Agrarian Reforms Act, 1972) regarding the scope of Collector's jurisdiction under provisions equivalent to S. 19(3)(e). The opinion records this Full Bench as one of the authorities the appellants relied upon to show that disputes within S. 19(3)(e) should be transmitted to the Collector. The Court found this Full Bench decision distinguishable after the 1981 amendment to S. 19(3)(e).
AIR 1980 J & K 1 (Jagatu v. Badri) (reported also as 1979 Srinagar LJ 6) Decision on the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976, concerning the Collector's role in determining character of land and jurisdictional issues under S. 19(3)(e) and S. 25. Cited by appellants to support the submission that the Collector must decide disputes falling under S. 19(3)(e). The Court held this authority inapplicable to the present case after the 1981 amendment narrowed clause (e).
1980 Kash LJ 150 (Mohinder Paul v. Mst. Kailash Devi) Followed the Full Bench approach on the interplay of Agrarian Reforms Act provisions concerning jurisdiction and reference to the Collector. Referenced as part of the line of authority appellants relied upon; the Court distinguished these decisions in view of the 1981 amendment.
AIR 1984 J & K 28 (Mumma Malla v. Mohd. Padroo) (1983 Kash LJ 323) Discussed S. 19(3)(e) and S. 25 of the Agrarian Reforms Act and the Collector's jurisdiction. Included among the precedents relied upon by the appellants; the Court considered it distinguishable on account of the legislative amendment in 1981.
AIR 1963 Pat 128 (Mst. B. Fatma v. A. Ahmad) Authority on presumptions of jointness and related principles (Patna High Court decision relied upon by the single Judge). The single Judge relied on this decision (and the Calcutta decision it discussed) to support the factual finding that the land was purchased in the benami name of Lassa for the joint family; the present Court agreed with that reliance and accepted the finding of joint ownership and joint possession.
AIR 1932 Cal 538 (Calcutta High Court decision cited within AIR 1963 Pat 128) Earlier authority on the concept of purchases in benami name and resulting jointness for family benefit; used in discussion of jointness under applicable personal law. The single Judge discussed and relied on this decision (via AIR 1963 Pat 128) in concluding that Lassa was effectively a benamidar and that the property was for the benefit of the joint family; the present Court accepted those factual conclusions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in two interrelated strands: (A) statutory interpretation of S. 19(3)(e) before and after the 1981 amendment, and (B) assessment of the factual findings on jointness and benami purchase.

A. Statutory interpretation of S. 19(3)(e) and the Collector's jurisdiction

  1. The opinion reproduces S. 19(3) as it stood in the 1976 Act, in which clause (e) read:
    “All other Cases of dispute including those where the party in possession pleads adverse possession against the recorded owner/intermediary.”
  2. The Court then sets out the 1981 substitution of clause (e), enacted by the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms (Amendment) Act, 1981 (Act No. VIII of 1981), which substituted clause (e) to read:
    “(e) any other dispute relating to or arising out of the provisions of this Act.”
  3. The Court reasons that the substitution narrowed the scope of clause (e). Whereas the earlier clause (e) covered "all other cases of dispute" (including adverse possession claims against recorded owners/intermediaries), the amended clause limits clause (e) to disputes "relating to or arising out of the provisions of this Act."
  4. On that textual basis the Court concludes that the legislative change reduced the powers conferred on the Collector (Agrarian) as they had stood under the earlier wording, and therefore the post-amendment S. 19(3)(e) does not capture the present dispute (a civil decree of joint ownership and joint possession).
  5. Consequently, the line of Full Bench and single-Bench decisions which had held that disputes falling within the pre-amendment clause (e) had to be transmitted to the Collector are, in the Court's view, distinguishable and not applicable to the facts of this case after the amendment.
  6. The Court expressly states that clauses in sub-s. (3) are to be read ejusdem generis; by narrowing clause (e) the amended provision must be read in context with the other enumerated items in sub-s. (3), and thus the earlier, broader interpretation does not survive the amendment for the present controversy.

B. Factual findings on jointness and benami purchase

  • The single Judge (whose decision was under review) examined evidence and concluded that although the presumption of jointness is not native to Muhammadan law, the surrounding circumstances proved that Lassa occupied a position akin to a trustee and that purchases made by him from joint family funds were intended for the benefit of the joint family.
  • The single Judge relied on a Patna High Court decision (AIR 1963 Pat 128) which in turn discussed an earlier Calcutta High Court decision (AIR 1932 Cal 538) to support the conclusion that the property was purchased in the benami name of Lassa for the whole family; Lassa was treated as a benamidar to the extent of half share acquired by Habib (the respondent).
  • The present Court reviewed those factual and legal conclusions and agreed with the single Judge's assessment, finding no ground to disturb the conclusion that the property was joint and that the plaintiff/respondent was entitled to half the share and joint possession.
  • The Court observed that none of the courts below had directed a physical separation of the land but had declared joint ownership and joint possession and that such a decree does not fall within the ambit of disputes covered by the Agrarian Reforms Act as amended.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

APPEAL DISMISSED. The Letters Patent Appeal is dismissed and the judgment and decree of the learned single Judge (which had dismissed the Civil Second Appeal and confirmed the findings of the courts below that the plaintiff/respondent was entitled to half the suit land and to joint possession) are confirmed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The decree declaring joint ownership and joint possession (with the plaintiff/respondent entitled to half share) stands affirmed. The Court directed that the parties shall bear their own costs.
  • Effect on jurisdictional question: The Court held that, because S. 19(3)(e) was substantively narrowed by the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms (Amendment) Act, 1981, the earlier Full Bench and single-Bench authorities treating broadly-worded pre-amendment clause (e) as requiring reference to the Collector (Agrarian) are distinguishable and do not apply to the present dispute. Accordingly, a reference to the Collector (Agrarian) was not required in this case.
  • On precedent: The opinion confines the reach of the earlier line of authorities in the context of the legislative amendment; the Court treated those prior decisions as not applicable to the present facts due to the change in law. The opinion does not purport to set out a sweeping new principle beyond its statutory interpretation and factual application to this case.

Order pronounced: "Appeal dismissed." Parties to bear their own costs.

    Ghulam Ahmad And Another v. Habiba .

    Shah, J.:— The present Letters Patent Appeal arises against the judgment and decree passed by Hon'ble Mr. Justice S.M.F Ali, (Chief Justice) on November 28, 1972, (reported in 1973 J & K LR 70) as he then was passed in Civil Second Appeal No. 88 of 1971 confirming the judgment and decree passed by District Judge, Bhaderwah, on October, 19, 1971.

    2. Although the facts of the case are not very much disputed before us even then in order to elucidate the matter in controversy, we feel it necessary to narrate the brief facts out of which the present Letters Patent Appeal arises. The facts in brief are that one Habib Sheikh son of Subhan Sheikh of Tehsil Kishtwar earlier filed a suit for declaration to the effect that plaintiff was entitled to half of the land mentioned in the plaint as co-owner with the defendant-respondent Ahmadoo Alias Gul Mohd. who claimed the land through the common ancestor Lassa, who purchased the land in dispute, which is admittedly an agricultural land. The suit for declaration was initially registered on August 28, 1955, which was later on compromised on September 19, 1957 and a compromise decree was drawn up giving ¼th share of the land in dispute to the plaintiff. Subsequently the defendant/respondent in the present appeal brought a suit for cancellation of the compromise decree on the basis of fraud and non-compliance of the provisions of O. 32, Civil P.C This suit was dismissed by the trial Court on 13-6-1960, but on appeal by the defendant it was decreed by the District Judge on June 28, 1963. Thereafter a further appeal was taken to the High Court, which upheld the decree passed by the District Judge. The decree passed by the District Judge was upheld by High court and consequentially the compromise decree stood set aside and the parties were relegated to the position they occupied at the time the compromise decree was passed and the previous suit brought by the present plaintiffs for declaration stood revived. During the pendency of the subsequent suit, the plaintiff applied for permission to amend the plaint to include prayer for possession of part of the suit land, which was granted by the order of the Court on July 4, 1968. Thus the amended plaint included the prayer including that of declaration of title about possession also. Thereafter, the trial Court decreed the suit of the plaintiff holding that plaintiff is entitled to half of the suit land and, therefore, entitled to a decree accordingly. On appeal to the learned District Judge, the District Judge, Bhadarwah, upheld the decree passed by the learned trial Court and upheld the finding that the said property was the joint acquisition of the brother and the respondent was entitled to half of the share. Consequentially the appeal was dismissed.

    3. Against the decree confirmed by the learned District Judge as stated above, the present appellant Ghulam Ahmad alias Gul Mohd. and another filed the Civil Second Appeal before the learned single Judge, which came up for hearing and on hearing the respective counsel for the parties, the learned single Judge Hon'ble the Chief Justice, as he then was, upheld the finding of fact arrived at by the two courts below in a detailed judgment discussing the law on the point and the controversy raised on fact before his Lordship and consequentially dismissed the Civil Second Appeal on November 28, 1972. Thereafter, by the order passed on December 22, 1972, his Lordship granted leave to appeal under the Letters Patent Appeal and thus the present Letters Patent Appeal.

    4. On hearing the learned counsel for the parties at length, it has been pointed out by the learned counsel for the appellants very strenuously that in the facts and circumstances of the present case despite the fact the findings of fact are concluded by the decree in the Second Appeal, the case in hand cannot proceed before the Civil Court on account of the subsequent legislation and coming into force of the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act, which clearly bars the jurisdiction of the Civil Court to adjudicate upon the matter relating to the land in dispute, which is admittedly an agricultural land. Long drawn arguments are advanced in support of the said contention by the learned counsel for the appellants relying on two Full Bench Authorities of this Court as well as single Bench authorities of this Court discussing the effect of the various provisions of the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976 (hereinafter called the Act). The two Full Bench authorities cited at the Bar are: (1) AIR 1975 J & K 33, (Rahim v. Amma Bar) a decision on J & K Agrarian Reforms Act, 1972 (26 of 1972); and (2) 1979 Srinagar LJ 6 : (AIR 1980 J & K 1), (Jagatu v. Badri) a case on Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976, and similarly following the above two decisions, 1980 Kash LJ 150, (Mohinder Paul v. Mst. Kailash Devi) and 1983 Kash LJ 323 : (AIR 1984 J & K 28). (Mumma Malla v. Mohd, Padroo). Discussing the provisions of S. 19(3)(e) and S. 25 of the Act, as it stood at that relevant time prior to the amendment effected in S. 19 sub-sec. (3), Cl. (e) by the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms (Amendment) Act, 1981 (Act No. VIII of 1981) and amendment in Cl. (b) of S. 25 of the principal Act (sic). The preponderance of the above-said decisions specifically laid down by their Lordships that the cases arising out of the dispute referred to in S. 19(3), Cl. (e) of the Act, by the force of S. 25 of the said Act shall be transmitted to the Collector (Agrarian) and it is for him to decide the character of the land, whether it falls within the purview of the definition of land given in the Act, being a question upon the determination of which depends his power to make the settlement under the Act. Thus the argument of the learned counsel for the appellant is that in view of the abovesaid decisions, the matter shall be referred and remitted to the Collector (Agrarian) for his findings and the Civil Court shall stay its hand from deciding the present matter in controversy unless the finding about the position relating to the land in question is given back by the Collector (Agrarian).

    5. Learned counsel for the respondent in reply submitted that on the one hand this being a Letters Patent Appeal against the concluded findings of fact of the case, which was initiated at the time, when the Agrarian Reforms Act was not in force as well as looking to the facts and circumstances of the present case, the provision of the Agrarian Reforms Act either S. 19(3), Cl. (e) or S. 25 are not attracted in the present case and especially after the amending Act of 1981 referred to above (Act No. VIII of 1981) the Legislature having amended the provisions of S. 19, sub-cl. (3), Cl. (e), the decree passed in the present case being not under the Act, the ratio of the abovecited Full Bench decision due to the change in law will not apply and in fact it was in order to settle at rest the controversy relating to the jurisdiction of the civil Court vis-a-vis Collector (Agrarian) that the Legislature in its widsom substituted the provisions of S. 19, sub-sec. (3), Cl. (e) as it stood in 1976 Act by providing an amendment to the said provision by the amending Act of 1981 taken away the jurisdiction which was wide enough under the previous clause, which is now made limited and, therefore, the case as it stands is not covered by the provisions of S. 19, sub-sec. (3), Cl. (e) of the amending Act, 1981, and hence S. 25 of the Act does not take away the jurisdiction of the civil Court to adjudicate upon the matter and the reference to the Collector (Agrarian) is not called for.

    6. In order to resolve the abovesaid controversy, it will be convenient to discuss the provisions of S. 19 as they stood in the 1976 Act and substituted thereafter by the amending Act of 1981.

    Section 19, sub-s. (3), reads as under:—

    “(3) The following applications, suits and proceedings shall be disposed of by a Collector:—

    a) Proceedings under S. 56, Jammu and Kashmir Tenancy Act, Samvat 1980;

    b) Proceedings under sub-s. (2) of S. 68-A Jammu and Kashmir Tenancy Act, Samvat 1980;

    c) Proceedings under S. 24, Jammu and Kashmir Big Landed Estates Abolition Act, Samvat 2007;

    d) Application by an owner of an intermediary that the person, who claims to be cultivating the land as tenant is not a tenant but a trespasser;

    e) All other Cases of dispute including those where the party in possession pleads adverse possession against the recorded owner/intermediary.”

    By amending Act of 1981 (Act No. VIII of 1981) in place of Cl. (e) of sub-s. (3) of S. 19, the following clause is substituted:

    “(e) any other dispute relating to or arising out of the provisions of this Act.”

    7. As a result of the above substitution in Cl. (e), sub-s. (3) of S. 19, the position of law in our opinion stands distinguished from the position as it stood before the Amendment Act of 1981 and the powers conferred on the Collector (Agrarian) by earlier provisions in 1975 Act are narrowed down and thus we are of the view that looking to the controversy in the present case, wherein the decree for joint ownership coupled with the declaration of joint possession is granted the decree passed by the civil Court needs no reference to the Collector (Agrarian) under the provisions of S. 19, sub-s. (3), Cl. (e). It is an established law that the courts are fully competent to take into consideration the subsequent legislation and it is only on this proposition that appellant wanted to persuade us that in view of the enforcement of the Agrarian Reforms Act during the pendency of the appeal at various stages, the matter required adjudication with respect to the land by the Collector (Agrarian) and this Court should stay its hand from disposing of the matter in controversy before this court.

    8. The learned single Judge while discussing the evidence and the presumption of jointness with respect to the property in the hands of a Mohammadan has found that although the presumption of jointness was foreign to the concept of Mohammadan law, yet in view of the circumstances proved in the case Lassa's position was that of a trustee and any purchases made by him from the joint family funds would enure for the benefit of the joint family. Therefore, the land in dispute was declared to be joint and plaintiff/respondent was held entitled to half of the share of the land purchased by Lassa and common ancestor and therefore, they are declared in joint possession by the decree under appeal. It needs no further elaboration in view of the decision of the Patna High Court on the point reported in AIR 1963 Pat 128, (Mst. B. Fatma v. A. Ahmad) relying on a decision of the Calcutta High Court reported in AIR 1932 Cal 538 discussed by the learned single Judge that in the present case the property in dispute was purchased in the Benami name of Lassa meant for the entire family. Lassa was, therefore, a benamidar to the extent of half share, which was acquired by Habiba, the respondent in the present case and, therefore, they are found as joint owners having joint possession. We are fully in agreement with the findings arrived at by the learned single Judge and do not find any ground to disturb the said finding. This is pertinent to note that none of the courts below while passing the decree under appeal directing the separation of the land in dispute and for possession except declaration to the effect that the appellants and respondent are declared holding the joint possession and the plaintiff/respondent has a half share in the property. The effect of the above decree in our opinion has in no way covered by the provisions of the Agrarian Reforms Act and in view of the amended provision of S. 19, sub-s. (3), Cl. (e) by amending Act of 1981, the present dispute does not fall within the ambit of any other dispute relating to or arising out of the provisions of the Act and, therefore, the cases cited above of the Full Bench and the Single Bench in our opinion are distinguishable on account of the change in law. As the disputes enunciated in sub-s. (3) including Cl. (e) are to be read as ejusdem generis and cannot be separated with the preceding clause, the provision of Cl. (e) as it stood before amendment in 1976 Act does not hold the field in the present case, by the amendment of Cl. (e) of amending Act of 1981.

    9. For the reasons stated above, we find that in view of the amending Act of 1981 by substituting Cl. (e) of sub-s. (3) of S. 19 of the Act, the Legislature narrowed down the controversy and the ratio of the Full Bench decisions cited above are not applicable to the present case and clearly distinguishable in view of our findings. Thus there is no substance in the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the appellants that the case be referred to the Collector (Agrarian) for determination relating to the land in dispute in the present case. The appeal is, therefore, dismissed and the judgment and decree passed by the learned single Judge impugned in this Letters Patent Appeal are confirmed. However, in the circumstances of the present case, we direct the parties to bear their own costs.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ghulam Ahmad And Another v. Habiba .
    (Oct 29, 1984)