Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 3, Evidence Act.
  • S. 122, T.P Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 3, Evidence Act.
  • S. 122, T.P Act,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Shri Sansar Chand filed a suit for redemption of a mortgage with possession, alleging that he mortgaged a property in May 1950 in favour of Smt. Amar Devi for Rs. 300/-. He claimed the mortgage amount was fully paid off because the mortgagee, who was in possession, felled several trees. He asserted entitlement to possession without further payment. Smt. Amar Devi denied these claims, contending no trees were cut and the full mortgage amount remained due. She further argued that Shri Sansar Singh executed a gift deed in March 1959 in favour of Shri Bharat Singh, Smt. Shakuntla Devi, and Smt. Ram Devi, thereby losing interest and locus standi to sue. Shri Sansar Singh countered that the gift was fraudulent, influenced, conditional, onerous, and revoked by a registered cancellation deed. The donees were not initially parties to the suit.

The trial Court dismissed the suit, holding Shri Sansar Singh lacked locus standi. On appeal, the District Judge found the gift defective due to lack of delivery of possession, held the mortgage amount payable, and decreed the suit. Smt. Amar Devi filed a second appeal to the High Court, which remanded the case for impleading the donees and fresh determination of the gift's validity. The trial Court then held the gift valid, no trees were cut, the mortgage amount was due, and dismissed the suit for want of locus standi. It was held that Smt. Shakuntla Devi, as legal representative, could not assert an independent title beyond that of Shri Sansar Singh.

The learned single Judge upheld the principle that legal representatives can only raise objections available to the deceased party. The present Letters Patent Appeal challenges that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Shri Sansar Singh and his legal representatives had locus standi to redeem the mortgage given the alleged valid gift deed in favour of the donees.
  2. Whether the gift deed executed by Shri Sansar Singh was valid, particularly regarding acceptance, delivery of possession, and conditions attached.
  3. Whether unilateral cancellation of the gift deed by Shri Sansar Singh was legally effective without a competent court's intervention.
  4. The legal capacity of a legal representative substituted for a deceased party to assert independent rights beyond those of the deceased.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The gift deed executed by Shri Sansar Singh was void, entitling him and his legal representatives to redeem the mortgage.
  • The gift was rightly cancelled as the donees failed to fulfill the conditions stipulated in the gift deed.
  • Possession of the property was never delivered to the donees, and the gift was not accepted by them.
  • Relied on precedent holding acceptance of a gift may be implied and that non-acceptance or dissent must be proved by the donees.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Smt. Amar Devi contended that Smt. Shakuntla Devi, as legal representative, could not assert a title independent of Shri Sansar Singh.
  • Relied on precedent that legal representatives can only raise objections the deceased party could have raised.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
V.T. Elaya Pillai v. Ramasami Jadaya Goundan, AIR 1947 Mad 165 Legal representatives cannot seek amendments or raise objections not available to the deceased party. The Court relied on this to hold that Smt. Shakuntla Devi, as legal representative, could not assert independent rights beyond those of Shri Sansar Singh.
Mt. Anandi Devi v. Mohan Lal, AIR 1932 All 444 Acceptance of a gift may be express or implied; dissent must be shown by donees to rebut presumed acceptance. The Court examined acceptance under S. 122 T.P. Act and Evidence Act provisions, concluding there was no evidence of dissent by donees and acceptance could be implied.
Muhammad Abdul Nayeem v. Jhonti Mahton, Patna High Court Application of English common law presumption of acceptance of gifts unless dissent is shown. The Court acknowledged the case but declined to fully apply the English rule, noting limitations under Indian law.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a detailed review of the factual matrix and legal submissions. It noted that the trial Court’s findings on the validity of the gift deed were unchallenged and supported by evidence. The claim of fraud, undue influence, or misrepresentation was not substantiated, and the gift was found not to be onerous. The unilateral cancellation deed executed by Shri Sansar Singh was deemed ineffective without judicial intervention.

Regarding acceptance, the Court analyzed the principle that acceptance of a gift may be implied unless dissent is proved. Since there was no evidence that the donees dissented from the gift, the Court concluded acceptance was established by implication.

On the issue of locus standi, the Court emphasized that a legal representative can only assert rights and objections available to the deceased party, reinforcing this with precedent. Consequently, Smt. Shakuntla Devi could not claim a better right than Shri Sansar Singh.

Holding and Implications

The Letters Patent Appeal is dismissed.

The dismissal affirms the validity of the gift deed and the consequent lack of locus standi of Shri Sansar Singh and his legal representatives to redeem the mortgage. The mortgagee’s right to recover the mortgage amount remains intact. No costs were ordered. This decision does not establish new legal precedent but confirms existing principles regarding gift acceptance, locus standi of legal representatives, and the necessity of judicial process to revoke gifts.

    Smt. Shakuntla Devi v. Smt. Amar Devi .

    H.S Thakur, J.:— This is a Letters Patent Appeal against the judgment of the learned single Judge of this Court.

    2. A few facts relevant to decide this appeal may be stated. Shri Sansar Chand filed a suit for redemption of a mortgage. It was a mortgage with possession. Shri Sansar Singh alleged that he mortgaged the property in dispute in May, 1950 in favour of Smt. Amar Devi for a consideration of Rs. 300/-. It was contended by him that the entire amount stood paid off because the mortgagee was in possession and she felled a number of trees and thereby the entire mortgage money stood paid off and that he was entitled to the possession of the property without payment of any amount. Smt. Amar Devi controverted the allegations of Shri Sansar Singh plaintiff and contended that no trees were cut by her and the entire mortgage money was due to her though she remained in possession. It was also contended by her that Shri Sansar Singh executed a gift deed on March 12, 1959 in favour of Shri Bharat Singh, Smt. Shakuntla Devi and Smt. Ram Devi. As such, it was contended that he ceased to have any interest in the landed property and had no locus standi to file the suit. It was, however, contended by Shri Sansar Singh that the gift was the result of fraud and undue influence and that it was also hit by a custom besides being onerous and not binding on the parties. It was also pleaded that it was a conditional gift and the donees Bharat Singh and others did not fulfil the condition and the gift is deemed to have been revoked. He also executed a registered deed of cancellation of gift on April 20, 1959. It may be pointed out that the aforesaid donees were not made parties to the suit. The trial Court, however, dismissed the suit holding that Shri Sansar Singh had no locus standi to file the suit.

    3. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment passed by the trial Court, Shri Sansar Singh preferred an appeal before the learned District Judge. Shri Sansar Singh died during the pendency of the appeal and Smt. Shakuntla Devi his daughter, who was also one of the donees, was substituted as a legal representative of Shri Sansar Singh. The learned District Judge held that the gift was defective because it was not accompanied by delivery of possession. He further held that since trees were not felled by the mortgagee, the entire amount of Rs. 300/- was payable to her for the redemption of mortgage. The appeal was accordingly allowed and the suit was decreed.

    4. Smt. Amar Devi preferred a second appeal before the High Court and it was held that Bharat Singh, Smt. Shakuntla Devi and Smt. Ram Devi were necessary parties. The plea, however, regarding gift was left open for a fresh decision in the presence of the said persons. The case was remanded for impleading Bharat Singh, Shakunda Devi and Ram Devi. They were also allowed to file their written statements. The issues were to be framed and a fresh decision was required to be given. The learned trial Court in compliance with the order, framed elaborate issues and considered every aspect of the case relating to the gift made by Shri Sansar Singh. The learned trial Court held that the gift was valid and could not be invalidated on any ground. The trial Court further held that no tree was cut and the entire amount of Rs. 300/- was due. Ultimately, it was found that Shri Sansar Singh had no locus standi and the suit deserved to be dismissed. The said Court considered the plea of Smt. Shakuntla Devi that she was not only a legal representative but also a donee from Shri Sansar Singh and, as such, she was competent to maintain the suit even as a donee, if not as a legal representative. The said Court, however, held that she could not set up a title independent of the title set up by Shri Sansar Singh and that she was only a legal representative and was substituted in place of Shri Sansar Singh. It was also observed that she could not superimpose her title as done e-mortgagor and that if Shri Sansar Singh was non-suited, she could not claim a better right.

    5. Against the findings arrived at by the trial Court, no objections were filed by either party. It was contended on behalf of the respondent Amar Devi that Smt. Shakuntla Devi appellant could not set up a title independent of the one claimed by Shri Sansar Singh. The learned single Judge observed that it is the party's rights and disabilities that have to be considered and not those of the legal representatives. It was also observed that person who is impleaded as the legal representative of deceased-party can raise only such objections as could have been taken by the deceased-party itself. The learned single Judge has placed reliance on a decision in V.T. Elaya Pillai v. Ramasami Jadaya Goundan, AIR 1947 Mad 165, in which it was held that where the amendment sought is one which the deceased-party himself could not have asked, his legal representatives cannot ask for it.

    6. It is contended by Shri D.D Sud, vice Shri Chhabil Dass, learned counsel for the appellant that the gift made by Shri Sansar Singh being void, he as also his legal representatives were entitled to redeem the mortgage. It is stated by him that the gift was rightly cancelled by Shri Sansar Singh as the donees failed to fulfil the conditions contained in the gift deed. It is also urged that the possession of the property was not delivered to the donees as also the gift was not accepted by them. He has placed reliance on a decision in Mt. Anandi Devi v. Mohan Lal, AIR 1932 All 444. It is convenient to extract relevant observations made in the said decision:

    “……….We accept the findings of the learned Judge as regards the value to be attached to the oral evidence called on behalf of the plaintiff, and his finding that an express acceptance by Mt. Kapuri has not been proved. The learned Judge however merely finds acceptance not proved, because he disbelieves the actual case set up by the plaintiff as regards express acceptance. He never directed his mind to the vital question as to whether there was proof of acceptance within the meaning of S. 3, Evidence Act. It has been argued here by counsel for the respondents that the only acceptance under S. 122, T.P Act, contemplated by that section is an express acceptance. We however do not find anything in the section to limit acceptance to an express acceptance, and we must take it that acceptance may be either express or implied. As the learned Judge has not considered the question of an implied acceptance based upon circumstantial evidence at all, we must consider it. It has been argued by counsel for the appellant that the law in India based upon S. 122. T.P Act, is similar to the Common Law of England with regard to acceptance. There is no doubt that in England the law is that acceptance of a gift will be presumed unless dissent is shown. That would mean that in this case, it would be for the defendants to prove that Mt. Kapuri had dissented from the gift. Lord Halsbury in his Laws of England (Vol. 15, p. 418) says:

    “Express acceptance by the donee is not necessary to complete a gift. It has long been settled that the acceptance of a gift by the donee is to be presumed until his dissent is signified, even though he is not aware of the gift, and this is equally so although the gift be of an onerous nature or of what is called an onerous trust.

    This rule of law has been applied to India by a single Judge of the Patna High Court in the case of Muhammad Abdul Nayeem…Plaintiff v. Jhonti Mahton Another…Defendant .. We however are not prepared to go so far. If S. 122 stopped short at saying that the gift must be accepted by or on behalf of the donee as it would be natural for any person to accept a non-onerous gift, we might be prepared to hold that the English law applied in India.”

    The aforesaid observations in the above quoted decision do not help the appellant. The acceptance of a gift can be either express or implied. In fact, there is no evidence on record to show that the donees had dissented from accepting the gift.

    7. The learned trial Court has also held the gift to be valid. No objections have been filed to the findings of the trial Court. We have gone through the evidence adduced before the trial Court. It is not proved that the gift was based on any fraud, undue influence or mis-representation. It is also not an onerous gift. No doubt, Sansar Singh executed a registered deed of cancellation of gift but it was an unilateral act. The gift deed could be cancelled only by resorting to legal remedy in a competent Court of law. As such, we are not satisfied that the possession of the property was not delivered to the donees or they had not accepted the gift.

    8. For the foregoing reasons, we are of the view that there is no merit in this appeal. As such, the Letters Patent Appeal is dismissed but with no order as to costs.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Shakuntla Devi v. Smt. Amar Devi .
    (Apr 2, 1985)