Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Ss. 10, 11, 12, 13, 16, and 20 of the Territorial Councils Act, 1956, as well as Rules 60, 61, 62 and 70 of the Territorial Councils Rules, 1957.
  • Ss. 3, 10, 11, 43, 44, 53 and 54 of the Territorial Councils Act provision
  • Rule 78 of the Territorial Councils (Election of Members) Rules, 1957,
  • S. 13, read with Ss. 11 and 12 ot the Territorial Councils Act,
  • REPRESENTATION OF THE PEOPLE ACT
  • Jammu and Kashmir Representation of the People Act,
  • Section 13 of the Territorial Councils Act, 1956,
  • S. 81(1) of the Representation of the People Act,
  • S. 67(A) of the Representation of the People Act.
  • PUNJAB GENERAL CLAUSES ACT 1898
  • S. 117 of the Representation of the People Act,
  • provisions of R. 78, Territorial Councils Rules
  • provisions of the Punjab General Clauses Act
  • provisions of the Territorial Councils Act
  • Rule 60 of the Territorial Councils Rules.
  • Rule 78 of the Territorial Councils Rules,
  • S. 13(1) of the Territorial Councils Act.
  • S. 13 of the Territorial Councils Act
  • S. 10 of the Territorial! Councils Act
  • Provincial Jurisdiction Act, 1947,
  • Territorial Council's Act,
  • GENERAL CLAUSES ACT
  • Rule 78. Exhibit C-2
  • Rule 57(e)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Ss. 10, 11, 12, 13, 16, and 20 of the Territorial Councils Act, 1956, as well as Rules 60, 61, 62 and 70 of the Territorial Councils Rules, 1957.
  • Ss. 3, 10, 11, 43, 44, 53 and 54 of the Territorial Councils Act provision
  • Rule 78 of the Territorial Councils (Election of Members) Rules, 1957,
  • S. 13, read with Ss. 11 and 12 ot the Territorial Councils Act,
  • REPRESENTATION OF THE PEOPLE ACT
  • Jammu and Kashmir Representation of the People Act,
  • Section 13 of the Territorial Councils Act, 1956,
  • S. 81(1) of the Representation of the People Act,
  • S. 67(A) of the Representation of the People Act.
  • PUNJAB GENERAL CLAUSES ACT 1898
  • S. 117 of the Representation of the People Act,
  • provisions of R. 78, Territorial Councils Rules
  • provisions of the Punjab General Clauses Act
  • provisions of the Territorial Councils Act
  • Rule 60 of the Territorial Councils Rules.
  • Rule 78 of the Territorial Councils Rules,
  • S. 13(1) of the Territorial Councils Act.
  • S. 13 of the Territorial Councils Act
  • S. 10 of the Territorial! Councils Act
  • Provincial Jurisdiction Act, 1947,
  • Territorial Council's Act,
  • GENERAL CLAUSES ACT
  • Rule 78. Exhibit C-2
  • Rule 57(e)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Three petitions, brought under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, arise from the Territorial Council elections in Sirmur district (May–June 1957). The petitioners were unsuccessful candidates who filed election petitions under Section 13 of the Territorial Councils Act, 1956, challenging the election of the successful candidates. The successful candidates (respondents) raised preliminary objections contesting the competency of the election petitions.

The District Judge of Sirmur sustained two preliminary objections and dismissed the election petitions on the grounds that (a) the petitions were time‑barred and (b) the petitioners had not complied with Rule 78 of the Territorial Councils (Election of Members) Rules, 1957 (security deposit requirement), such that dismissal under Rule 69 was appropriate. The present petitions to the High Court challenge those dismissals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the election petitions were time‑barred — specifically, whether the period of limitation in Section 13(1) of the Territorial Councils Act (30 days) runs from the Returning Officer's declaration of result or from the date of notification of the result in the official Gazette under Section 11.
  2. Whether the petitioners complied with Rule 78 of the Territorial Councils (Election of Members) Rules, 1957 — i.e., whether the treasury challans/receipts filed with the petitions sufficiently showed that the required deposit (Rs. 250) was made as security for costs and was at the disposal of the appropriate authority.
  3. Whether there was undue delay in invoking the High Court's supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 (whether the petitions under Article 227 were filed within the applicable time limit).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • Submitted that the Territorial Councils Rules and Act form a mostly complete code and their provisions should be given their plain meaning.
  • Argued that Section 13(1) must be read with Sections 11 and 12 so that the 30‑day period runs from the date of notification of the result in the official Gazette; therefore the election petitions were filed within time (Gazette notification dated 3‑8‑1957; petitions filed within 30 days thereafter).
  • Contended that the treasury challans accompanying the petitions, though not filled in exactly in column 2, plainly showed the deposits were made as security for costs and were available to the Secretary to the Election Department; reliance was placed on judicial authorities holding that the receipt must "show" and need not verbatim "state" the precise words.
  • Maintained that petitions under Article 227 are subject to the 90‑day rule and that these petitions were filed within 90 days after excluding time spent obtaining copies of the District Judge's order.

Respondents' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • Contended that the election petitions were time‑barred, arguing that the relevant date for limitation was the Returning Officer's declaration rather than the Gazette notification.
  • Asserted that the treasury challans were defective (pointing to particular entries in columns 2 and 3) and therefore did not satisfy Rule 78 such that the petitions had to be dismissed.
  • Argued there had been undue delay in seeking relief under Article 227 and relied on authorities (e.g., Pulin Behari v. Byomkesh Mitra) to support that contention.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nalinakhya Bysack v. Shyam Sundar Haldar, AIR 1953 SC 148 The court must give effect to the words the Legislature has used; it is not competent for a court to assume that the Legislature has made a mistake. Applied to reject the District Judge's attempt to read “date of notification” as other than notification in the official Gazette; supported the plain‑language interpretation of Section 13.
K. Kamaraja Nadar v. Kunju Thevar, AIR 1958 SC 687 The words requiring a receipt "in favour of" an authority are directory not mandatory; the essential requirement is that the receipt show the deposit is at the disposal of the authority named. Relied upon to hold that treasury challans need not verbatim state specific words so long as they show the deposit was made as security and was available to the relevant authority; supported finding compliance with Rule 78.
Harihar Singh v. Ganga Prasad, AIR 1958 Pat 287 Authority relied upon to support a strict view that a receipt may be defective if certain entries are absent. The District Judge had relied in large measure on this decision to conclude the challans were defective; the High Court reviewed and treated this authority as distinguishable from other decisions favouring a non‑literal approach.
Beli Ram v. Election Tribunal, AIR 1958 (J & K) 54 Used among decisions addressing whether a treasury receipt must literally "state" particulars or merely "show" compliance. Cited as part of a line of authority (the "Kashmir case" reference) supporting that the receipt need only show compliance; used in the comparative analysis of what constitutes adequate evidence of deposit.
Bhuvanesh Bhushan Sharma v. Election Tribunal, Farrukhabad, AIR 1958 All 587 One of several High Court decisions considering the required content of treasury receipts for election petitions. Appears as supporting authority in the discussion that literal compliance is not necessary if the receipt or surrounding circumstances show the deposit's purpose.
Gian Chand Puran Chand v. Smt. Om Prabha Jain, AIR 1959 Punj 66 Another High Court decision cited in the context of what the receipt must "show". Included in the courts relied upon to establish that the receipt's contents and surrounding circumstances are decisive, not mere verbatim wording.
Rulya Ram v. Multan Singh, AIR 1959 Punj 121 Affirms that a receipt need not repeat every word of the statute; it must "show" the deposit's purpose such that a reader can conclude the deposit was made as security for costs. Cited (by respondents) but acknowledged as supporting the petitioners' position that the challans were sufficient; used to bolster the conclusion that Rule 78 had been satisfied.
Som Krishnan v. Paras Ram, AIR 1958 Him Pra 26 Comparison between the Territorial Councils Act and the Representation of the People Act; points to greater scope for application of Civil Procedure Code procedure under the Territorial Councils scheme. Used to demonstrate the Territorial Councils scheme is distinct from the Representation of the People Act and to justify not borrowing definitions or rules from the latter where territorial legislation is clear.
Waryam Singh v. Amarnath, AIR 1954 SC 215 Article 227 (read with Article 241) confers supervisory powers on High Courts over tribunals within their territories. Relied upon to establish the High Court's jurisdiction to supervise and review the District Judge's handling of the election petitions.
Hari Vishnu Kamath v. Ahmad Ishaq, AIR 1955 SC 233 Election Tribunals fall within the supervisory jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 227. Applied to confirm that Election Tribunals are reviewable and that the High Court's superintendence is both judicial and administrative.
Pulin Behari v. Byomkesh Mitra, AIR 1953 Cal 40 Authority on delay: a delay of 2½ months in making a petition under Article 227 was considered excessive in that case. Respondents relied on this to argue undue delay; the High Court distinguished it and held the present petitions were within the 90‑day rule after excluding time for obtaining copies.
Indira Debi v. Ganga Ram, AIR 1953 Him‑Pra 60 Held that petitions under Article 227 are subject to a 90‑day limitation rule. Applied by the High Court to assess the timeliness of the present petitions under Article 227; the Court found the petitions complied with that rule.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court addressed the two principal preliminary objections in sequence: limitation and compliance with Rule 78.

Limitation

  1. The Court examined the text of the Territorial Councils Act (Sections 10, 11, 12, 13, 16 and 20) and relevant Rules (including Rule 57(e) which defines "returned candidate").
  2. It accepted petitioners' submission that the Territorial Councils Act and Rules constitute a largely self‑contained code whose plain language must be given effect.
  3. The Court rejected the District Judge's attempt to construe the phrase "date of notification of the result of the election" in Section 13 as other than the date of notification in the official Gazette. The Court relied on the combination of Section 11 (which requires publication in the official Gazette) and Section 12 (which fixes the term from the date of notification) to conclude that "date of notification" in Section 13(1) means Gazette notification.
  4. The Punjab General Clauses Act (S. 2(36)) defines "notification" as publication in the official Gazette and was held applicable to Himachal Pradesh by prior Order; this statutory definition reinforced the plain‑language reading. Even if that definition were ignored, the Court held that the statutory scheme (Sections 11 and 12 read with Section 13) made the meaning clear.
  5. The Court declined to import the scheme of the Representation of the People Act (and its S.67A definition) into the Territorial Councils Act because the schemes are different and the Territorial Councils Act lacks a corresponding provision.
  6. Applying these conclusions to the facts, the Court observed that the Gazette notification for all three constituencies was dated 3‑8‑1957 and therefore the election petitions filed thereafter were within the 30‑day period prescribed by Section 13(1).

Compliance with Rule 78 (Security Deposit)

  1. The Court examined the treasury challans accompanying the petitions. While noting a technical imperfection in column No. 2 (the name and address entry), the Court found other entries (including column No. 3 description: "Security for the cost of the election petition of Shri ... for ... Territorial Council constituency" and the head of account entry) made the purpose of the deposit clear.
  2. The Court placed weight on an administrative fact: a deposit‑repayment order from the Treasury Officer stating that refund could be granted only on receipt of orders from the Secretary to the Administrator in the Election Department, indicating the deposit was at the disposal of the Secretary and could not be withdrawn without his orders.
  3. The Court surveyed the authorities (including K. Kamaraja Nadar v. Kunju Thevar and several High Court decisions) holding that the statutory requirement is that the receipt "show" the deposit's purpose and that literal verbatim repetition of statutory words on the receipt is unnecessary; the receipt must permit a reasonable observer to conclude the deposit was made as security for costs and is available to the appropriate authority.
  4. Applying these principles, the Court concluded that despite the imperfect filling of column 2, the challans left no room for doubt that the deposit was the required security for costs and was available to the Secretary to the Election Department; therefore Rule 78 was satisfied.

Jurisdiction and Delay Objection

  1. The Court reaffirmed its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 (read with Article 241) to review Election Tribunal decisions, citing Waryam Singh v. Amarnath and Hari Vishnu Kamath v. Ahmad Ishaq.
  2. Respondents' contention of undue delay relied on Pulin Behari v. Byomkesh Mitra; the Court, however, followed its earlier decision in Indira Debi v. Ganga Ram that petitions under Article 227 are subject to a 90‑day rule. After excluding the time spent obtaining copies of the District Judge's order, the Court found these petitions were filed within 90 days and overruled the delay objection.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The High Court allowed the petitions and set aside so much of the District Judge's decision dated 12‑8‑1958 as dismissed the election petitions on the grounds of limitation and failure to comply with Rule 78 of the Territorial Councils Rules. The District Judge was directed to proceed with the election petitions in accordance with law and to dispose of them expeditiously.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The dismissal of the three election petitions for being time‑barred and for alleged non‑compliance with the security‑deposit requirement was reversed; the underlying election petitions are to be remitted to the District Judge for further inquiry and trial according to law.
  • Procedural consequence: The High Court exercised its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 (read with Article 241) to correct the District Judge's preliminary rulings.
  • Costs and precedent: The Court made no order as to costs because these were the first petitions of their kind to come before the Court. The opinion does not purport to create a broader binding rule beyond the application of existing authorities and the interpretation of the Territorial Councils Act and Rules as applied to these facts.

Order supplemental: The judgment was directed to be read in all three petitions (Nos. 5, 6 and 7 of 1959).

    Sawan Ram And Ors. v. Guman Singh And Ors.

    C.

    1. These three petitions, purporting to be under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, arise out of the elections, from Sirmur district to Himachal Pradesh Territorial Council, which took place in May/June, 1957. The petitioners were candidates at the election, but were declared unsuccessful Subsequently, they filed election petitions under Section 13 of the Territorial Councils Act, 1956, challenging the election of the successful candidates, on various grounds. Preliminary objections were raised by the successful candidates (who figure as respondents here) disputing the competency of the election petitions.

    The learned District Judge of Sirmur, who was trying the election petitions, upheld two of the preliminary objections, raised by the respondents and dismissed the petitions holding that: (a) the etection petitions were time-barred and (b) the petitioners failed to comply with the requirements of Rule 78 of the Territorial Councils (Election of Members) Rules, 1957, and, therefore, the petitions were liable to dismissal under Rule 69 of the aforesaid Rules.

    2. Hence, these petitions, which purport to be under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.

    3. Arguments of the learned counsel for the contesting parties were heard at considerable length on the 8th and 9th instant. In Civil Writ Petitions 6 and 7 of 1959, learned counsel for the petitioners confined his arguments to the findings of the District Judge on preliminary issues 2 arid 3 (Issues on the points of limitation and security deposit).

    4. For reasons to be stated shortly, I have come to the conclusion that neither of the District Judge's findings can be supported.

    5. I take up the point of limitation first. Learned counsel for the petitioners took me through the provisions of Ss. 10, 11, 12, 13, 16, and 20 of the Territorial Councils Act, 1956, as well as Rules 60, 61, 62 and 70 of the Territorial Councils Rules, 1957. My attention was also invited to the definition of a 'returned candidate' to be found in Rule 57(e) of the above Rules, whereby a 'returned candidate' means a 'candidate, who has been declared elected by the Returning Officer'.

    6. Mr. Kalia contended--and in my opinion with considerable justification--that the Territorial (sic) Rules made thereunder are, more or less, a complete Code by themselves and their provisions should be given effect to without any reservation. He pointed out that while S. 10 of the Territorial! Councils Act deals with the election of members, S. 11 provides that the names of all persons elected or nominated to be members of the Territorial Council shall be published in the official Gazette by the Administrator. Section 12 further lays down that the term of office of a member of the Territorial Council shall be 5 years and that period would commence from the date of the notification of his election, or nomination under Section 11, i.e. in the official Gazette, Section 13 which deals with disputes as to elections, provides for filing of the election petitions in the Court of District Judge having jurisdiction in the area in which the constituency concerned is situated. Such petitions have to be instituted within 30 days from the date of the notification of the result of the election.

    7. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the above provisions are free from ambiguity and, therefore, the learned District Judge should have had no difficulty in holding that the three election petitions were within time. Here are the relevant dates. Nahan Constituency "Ishwar Chandra v. Hitendra Singh and another", Results declared on 29-5-57, notified in the Gazette 3-8-57 and election petition filed on 31-8-1957; Paonta Constituency "Baldev Singh v. Kalyan Singh"; Results declared on 26-5-1957, notified in the Gazette on 3-8-1957 and election petition filed on 31-8-1957. Rainka Constituency "Sawan Ram v. Guman Singh and others," Results declared on 11-6-1957, notified in the Gazette on 3-8-1957 and election petition filed on 2-9-1957.

    8. Mr. Kalia argued that in all the three cases, the election petitions were filed within 30 days of the Gazette notification and, accordingly, they were within time, having regard to the plain meaning of S. 13(1) of the Territorial Councils Act.

    9. In my opinion, this argument must prevail. In Nalinakhya Bysack v. Shyam Sundar Haldar, AIR 1953 SC 148--which has been referred to by the District Judge--their Lordships pointed out that the Court must proceed on the footing that the Legislature intended what it has said. It is not competent to any Court to proceed upon any assumption that the Legislature has made a mistake. I find that the District Judge however has laboured hard to demonstrate that the expression "date of notification of the result of the election" to be found in S. 13 of the Territorial Councils Act would not mean the date of notification in the official Gazette.

    In this connection, he has pointed out that while in Ss. 3, 10, 11, 43, 44, 53 and 54 of the Territorial Councils Act provision has been mada for notifying certain matters in the official Gazette, S. 13 of the Act, merely refers to date of the notification of the result of the election, without expressly speaking of date of notification in the official Gazette. The heading of S. 11 however runs as follows:--"Notification of results of elections:" The District Judga has brushed this aside on the ground that marginal notes are not proper guides for interpreting a statute. He has further remarked that the expression 'notification' has not been defined in the General Clauses Act.

    10. Mr. Kalia invited my attention to S. 2(36) of the Punjab General Clauses Act, 1898, whereby 'notification' means a notification published under proper authority in the official Gazette. The provisions of the Punjab General Clauses Act were made applicable to Himachal Pradesh by means of the Himachal Pradesh (Application of Laws) Order, 1948, vide notification No. 386-IB issued under the Extra-

    Provincial Jurisdiction Act, 1947, on 25-12-1948. It is, therefore, not correct to say that the definition has not been made applicable to this territory. Even if this definition be left out of consideration, the plain language of S. 13, read with Ss. 11 and 12 ot the Territorial Councils Act, leaves no room for doubt that the date of the notification referred to in S. 13(1) would be the date of notification of the result in the official Gazette under Section 11 and not the date of the declaration of the result by the Returning Officer, under Rule 60 of the Territorial Councils Rules.

    11. I further find that the learned District Judge has made an attempt to equate or reconcile the provisions of the Territorial Councils Act with those of the Representation of the People Act. I am unable to accept the District Judge's opinion that the provisions of the two Acts were intended to be similar. Under S. 81(1) of the Representation of the People Act, the period of limitation for filing an election petition--challenging an election held under that Act--would be 45 days from the date of the election of the returned candidate. Under S. 67(A) of that Act, the expression 'date of election' would mean the date on which a candidate is declared by the Returning Officer to have been elected to a House of Parliament or to a Legislature of the State.

    The scheme of the Territorial Council's Act, however, is different. As remarked earlier, where the Legislature has deemed it proper to draw up a different scheme for elections to the Territorial Councils, and the language of the statute is not ambiguous, there would be no justification to borrow from the provisions of the Representation of the People Act in order to ascertain whether a particular election petition filed under the Territorial Councils Act is within time or not. Mr. Kalia rightly pointed out that in the Territorial Councils Act and in the rules made thereunder, there is no provision corresponding to that contained in S. 67(A) of the Representation of the People Act.

    In an earlier decision of this Court, reported in Som Krishnan v. Paras Ram, AIR 1958 Him Pra 26, II had occasion to compare the scheme under the Territorial Councils Act with that of the Representation of the People Act. In that connection, I pointed out that under the Territorial Councils Act, there was greater scope for the application of the procedure laid down in the Civil Procedure Code to the trial of election petitions than under the scheme of the Representation of the People Act.

    12. To sum up, therefore, I am clearly of the opinion that the expression "date of notification of the result of election" to be found in S. 13(1) of the Territorial Councils Act would be the date of such notification by publication in the official Gazette by the Administrator, as required by S. 11. In all the three cases now--before this Court--the Gazette notification was issued on 3-8-1957. The three election petitions were filed within 30 days thereof and, therefore, would be clearly within time.

    13. That brings us to the question as to whether the petitioners had complied with the requirements of Rule 78 of the Territorial Councils Rules, whereby they were required to enclose with the election petition a Government treasury receipt showing that a deposit of Rs. 250/- had been made by them, in favour of the Secretary to the Administrator in the appropriate department as security for costs of the petition.

    The petitions admittedly were accompanied by challans (receipts) for Rs. 250/-, each. The District Judge has, however, held that the entries in the second and third columns of these challans were defective and, therefore, the requirements of Rule 78 had not been satisfied. It is true that in column No. 2) (name and address of the person on whose behalf money is paid), the entry runs thus: "Secretary to the Administrator, Himachal Pradesh, in the Election Department". Strictly speaking, column No. 2 should be filled in only when the deposit is made, not by the petitioner personally, but by some agent or other person acting in his behalf. Column No. 3 (full particulars of the remittance and of the authority, if any) contains the following entry: "Security for the cost of the election petition of Shri Baldev Singh/Sawan Ram/Ishwar Chandra for Paonta/Rainka/Nahan Territorial Council constituency".

    In column No. 4, the amount of Rs. 250/- has been entered, while column No. 5 (Head of account) contains the entry

    "Central Civil Section P--Deposits and advances Part II Revenue Deposits (Deposits for election petitions)."
    Even though column No. 2 had not been correctly filled in, I should have thought that the challans left no room for doubt that the petitioners had deposited a sum of Rs. 250/- each by way of security for costs, as required by Rule 78 and the same was available to the Secretary Election Department. The learned District Judge took a contrary view, basing his opinion largely, upon the ruling contained in Harihar Singh v. Ganga Prasad, AIR 1958 Pat 287. Mr. Kalia for the petitioners invited my attention to K. Kamaraja Nadar v. Kunju Thevar, AIR 1958 SC 687, wherein their Lordships were pleased to indicate that:

    "The words 'in favour of the Secretary to the Election Commission' used in Section 117 are directory and not mandatory in their character. What is of the essence of the provision contained in S. 117 is that the petitioner should furnish security for the costs of the petition, and should enclose along with the petition a Government Treasury receipt showing that a deposit of one thousand rupees has been made by him either in a Government Treasury or in the Reserve Bank of India, is at the disposal of the Election Commission to be utilised by it in the manner authorised by law and is under its control and payable on a proper application being made in that behalf to the Election Commission or to any person duly authorised by it to receive the same, be he the Secretary to the Election Commission or any one else. If, therefore, it can be shown by evidence led before the Election Tribunal that the Government Treasury receipt or the challan which was obtained by the petitioner and enclosed by him along with his petition presented to the Election Commission was such that the Election Commission could on a necessary application in that behalf be in a position to realize the said sum of rupees one thousand for payment of the costs to the successful party it would be sufficient compliance with the requirements of S. 117"
    .

    My attention was also invited to Beli Ram v. Election Tribunal, AIR 1958 J and K 54, Bhuvanesh Bhushan Sharma v. Election Tribunal, Farrukhabad, AIR 1958 All 587 and Gian Chand Puran Chand v. Smt. Om Prabha Jain, AIR 1959 Punj 66. In the Kashmir case, a Division Bench of that High Court while dealing with a similar provision in the Jammu and Kashmir Representation of the People Act, pointed out that:

    "The word 'show' has got a distinct and different connotation from the word 'state' and its scope is wider. This word being used in S. 125, it is not necessary that the receipt by itself should state the various particulars. But all that is necessary is that it should be seen either on a plain reading of the receipt or from a consideration of the surrounding circumstances that the particulars mentioned in S. 125 have been complied with. It is obvious, therefore, that the Legislature did not intend a literal compliance of S. 125 and that is why it has used the word 'show' and not the word 'state'."

    14. Similarly in the Allahabad case, a Division Bench of that High Court remarked that:

    "Under S. 117 of the Representation of the People Act, the person filing the election petition has to enclose with the petition a Government treasury receipt showing that a deposit of Rs. 1,000/- has been made by him, either in a Government treasury or in the Reserve Bank of India, in favour of the Secretary to the Election Commission as security for costs of the petition."

    "It is to be noticed that the word used in S. 117 is 'showing' and not 'stating'. The use of the word 'show' indicates that the contents of the receipt should be such that any one who looks at the receipt can arrive at the conclusion that the deposit had been made in favour of the Secretary to the Election Commission. Consequently the language of S. 117 cannot be held to require that the receipt enclosed with the petition must have the words 'in favour of the Secretary to the Election Commission', recorded on it. The entry on the receipt of the number of the account or a sufficient description of the account would be quite sufficient to show that the amount has been so deposited and that it is entirely at the disposal of the Secretary to the Election Commission, so that the deposit in the bank is a deposit in his favour"
    .

    15. In the Punjab case, dissenting from the view expressed in AIR 1958 Pat 287, a Division Bench of the Punjab High Court held that:

    "What is of the essence of the provision contained in S. 117 is that the petitioner should furnish security for the costs of the petition, and should enclose along with the petition, a Government Treasury receipt showing that a deposit of one thousand rupees has been made by him either in a Government treasury or in the Reserve Bank of India, is at the disposal of the Election Commission to be utilized by it in the manner authorised by law and is under its control and payable, on a proper application being made in that behalf, to the Election Commission or to any person duly authorised by it to receive the same. A literal compliance with the terms of Section 117 is not at all necessary. Besides, the language of Section 117 does not say that the receipt should in so many words 'state' that the amount has been deposited as security for costs of the petition; it is enough if on reading together all the entries in the receipt it is made reasonably clear that the deposit is by way of security for costs of the petition."

    It can be shown by evidence led before the Election Tribunal that the Government treasury receipt or challan which was obtained by the petitioner and enclosed by him along with the election petition was such that the Election Commission could, on a necessary application in that behalf, be in a position to realize the said sum of rupees one thousand for payment of the costs to the successful party".

    16. Rulya Ram v. Multan Singh, AIR 1959 Punj 121, cited by learned counsel for the contesting respondents, if anything, helps the petitioners. There, following AIR 1958 SC 687, a Division Bench of the Punjab High Court observed that:

    The law does not require that every word of Section 117 must appear on or be repeated verbatim in the receipt. The receipt is required to 'show' that the amount of Rs. 1,000/- was deposited as security for costs of the petition, which means that the contents of receipt should be such that anyone who looks at it could arrive at the conclusion that the deposit had been made for the purpose mentioned in the Section. Where; therefore, the purpose for which the deposit was made is sufficiently clear and any one who looks at the receipt can have no doubt that the deposit was made as security for the costs of the petition referred to in the receipt, it cannot be said that the receipt is in any way defective.

    17. In Civil Writ Petition No. 7 of 1959, the petitioner, Shri Ishwar Chandra, filed in this Court a "Deposit repayment order and voucher Ex. C-l" submitted by him in September, 1958, to the Treasury Officer, Nahan, seeking a refund of the sum of Rs. 250/- deposited by him as security under Rule 78. Exhibit C-2 is the order thereupon of the Treasury Officer, Nahan, dated 2-9-1958. That order says that refund could be granted only on receipt of orders from the Secretary to the Administrator in the Election Department in whose favour the deposit had been made. Shri Ishwar Chandra made a statement on oath in this connection to this Court on the 8th instant. He was also cross-examined by the other side.

    18. It is thus abundantly clear that although column No. 2 of the challans was not properly filled in, nobody--neither the petitioners nor the Treasury Officer--had any doubt that the sum deposited was otherwise than (Sic) by way of security for costs and the amount was available to the Secretary to the Election Department and could not be withdrawn without his orders. I have, therefore, no hesitation in holding that the requirements of Rule 78 had been complied with.

    19. In view of what has been said above, I must hold that the election petitions were wrongly dismissed by the District Judge on the preliminary objections raised by the respondents as to limitation and security deposit.

    20. As was pointed out in Waryam Singh v. Amarnath, AIR 1954 SC 215, Article 227 of the Constitution, read with Article 241, confers on this Court powers of superintendence over all tribunals functioning within the territory of Himachal Pradesh. In Hari Vishnu Kamath v. Ahmad Ishaq, (S) AIR. 1955 SC 233, it was further held that Election Tribunals are subject to the superintendence of the High Court under Article 227. The superintendence is both judicial as well as administrative.

    21. It is, therefore, obvious that this Court is competent to reverse the findings of the District Judge on both the points referred to in this judgment and direct a further inquiry into the election petitions according to law. Mr. Aukta contended that there has been undue delay in filing these petitions under Article 227 and, consequently, no relief should be granted. Reliance was placed on Pulin Behari v. Byomkesh Mitra, AIR 1953 Cal 40, where a delay of 2 1/2 months in making a petition under Article 227 was considered excessive. Mr. Kalia, on the other hand, pointed out that this Court has already held (vide Indira Debi v. Ganga Ram, AIR 1953 Him-Pra 60) that petitions under Article 227 would be subject to the 90-day rule. I see no reason to revise that view. I find that these petitions have been made within 90 days of the District Judge's order, after excluding the time spent in obtaining copies of his order. This objection, therefore, must be overruled.

    ORDER

    22. In the exercise of the Dowers conferred on this Court by Article 227, read with Article 241, of the Constitution, I allow these petitions and set aside so much of the decision of the District Judge, Sirmur dated 12-8-1958 in Election Petitions Nos. 3-S/2 of 57, 4-S/2 of 57 and 5-S/2 of 57, respectively, as purports to dismiss them on grounds of limitation and failure to comply with the provisions of R. 78, Territorial Councils Rules (subject-matter of Issues 2 and 3). The District Judge is directed to proceed with these petitions in accordance with law and dispose of those as expeditiously as possible.

    23. Since these petitions are the first of their kind to come up before this Court, I make no order as to the costs of these petitions.

    24. This judgment will be read in all the three petitions Nos. 5, 6 and 7 of 1959.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sawan Ram And Ors. v. Guman Singh And Ors.
    (Apr 14, 1959)