(Per
: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.M.THAKER)
The
petitioner, an Agricultural Credit Co-operative Society registered
under the Gujarat Co-operative Societies Act, 1961 (hereinafter
referred to as the Act ), is a member of the respondent
no.4-Bank which is a specified society within the meaning of
Section 74(c) of the Act. The petitioner has sought a direction to
the respondent no. 2 directing him to prepare the provisional list of
voters in accordance with Rule 5 and 6 of the 1982 Rules and has
further prayed for direction to the respondent no. 2 to hold the
election of the Board of Directors of the respondent no. 4-Bank in
accordance with Rule 3-A(8) of the 1982 Rules.
2. The
petitioner has prayed for the below mentioned relief(s):-
6(a)
The Hon'ble Court may be pleased to issue a writ of mandamus or writ
in the nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order, or
direction, directing the respondent no. 2 election officer to held
election for the Board of Directors of respondent no. 4 Bank as per
the provisions of rule 3a (8) and also be pleased to direct the
respondent no. 2 to follow the provisions of rule 5 & 6 by
publishing preliminary voters list before publishing the final voters
list."
2.1
We should, at the outset, mention and clarify that the petitioner and
the respondents have jointly submitted that the Election Programme
has yet not been notified. It is in view of the said statement to the
effect that the Election Programme has yet not been set in motion
that we have entertained this petition. It is also appropriate to
mention at this stage that other petitions being Special Civil
Application Nos. 5430, 7265, 8472, 8473 of 2009 along with Civil
Application No. 7194 of 2009 raise almost similar issues. The learned
Counsel for the contesting parties have jointly requested for hearing
of the said petitions with Special Civil Application No. 9748 of
2009. Hence, all these petitions are heard and decided together by
this common judgment. Since, except some dates and events which may
differ, almost the facts are similar and the main contesting
respondent bank is common in all these petitions, for the sake of
convenience the facts stated in Special Civil Application No. 9748 of
2009 have been taken into account and recorded in this judgment. The
counsel for the respondents in all petitions have waived
notice of Rule. With consent of all advocates of concerned parties,
the petitions are heard finally.
3. The
petitioner has sought the aforesaid relief and raised the challenge
in the backdrop of the below mentioned facts:-
3.1 The
election of the Board of Directors of respondent no. 4-Bank
(hereinafter referred to as election ) are due and the
respondent no. 2 has been appointed as the Election Officer to
conduct the election. The elections are required to be conducted as
per the provisions contained in Chapter XI-A of the Act.
3.2 Under
his notice dated 6th June 2009 the Election Officer
published the provisional list of voters on 06.06.2009 and invited
objections, if any, with regard to the said list.
3.3
It appears that after the above referred notice dated 6th
June 2009 certain objections were raised claiming, inter alia, that
as per the position prevailing as on 31st March 2009 the
said voters list did not accurately reflect the factual position
(prevailing as on 31.03.2009) and several fictitious names were
appearing in the said list.
3.4 The
petitioner has also claimed that on 12th June 2009 it had
filed its objections and pointed out that the list did not reflect
the actual and accurate position as on 31st March 2009.
3.5 After
considering the objections on 18.06.2009, the respondent no. 2 passed
an order dated 23rd June 2009 directing publication of
provisional voters list in accordance with and having regard to the
decisions and instructions recorded in the order dated 23.06.2009.
3.6 As
per the claim of the petitioner society, in pursuance of the
Elections Officer's aforesaid order dated. 23.6.2009, the general
manager of the respondent No. 4-Bank, vide his communication dated
24th June 2009, invited resolutions, so as to reach on or
before 4.7.2009, from the member societies on the basis of the
position as on 31st March 2009.
3.7 The
petitioner society has claimed that pursuant to the said
communication dated 24.6.2009 sent by the respondent No. 4- Bank,
about 807 societies submitted, before or on 4-7-2009, fresh
resolutions on the basis of the position prevailing, in
the respective societies, as on 31st
March 2009.
3.8 It is also stated
that the respondent No. 4-Bank, after receipt of the resolutions from
almost 807 societies, prepared and forwarded a list, under its
covering letter dated 4-7-2009 to the election officer. The said list
has been, as alleged by the petitioner, treated and published as the
final list of voters.
4. Mr.
Vakharia learned Senior Counsel has appeared with Mr. Desai learned
advocate for the petitioner and Mr. Tushar Mehta learned Additional
Advocate General has appeared for the respondent Nos. 1 to 3. Mr.
N.D. Nanavati learned Senior Counsel with Mr. Navin Pahwa learned
advocate has appeared for the respondent no. 4-Bank Mr. B.S. Patel
has appeared in Special Civil Application No.7265 of 2009 and in
Civil Application No. 7194 of 2009. Heard the learned advocates for
the respective parties.
4.1 Mr.
Vakharia learned Senior Counsel has submitted that the impugned
decision of the respondent No. 2-Election Officer directing the list
of voters published on 4th July 2009 as the final list of
voters is contrary to Rule 5 to Rule 7 of the 1982 Rules. He has
submitted that after the provisional list of voters is published,
objections are required to be invited and only after deciding the
objections, the final list of voters can be prepared and published.
Mr. Vakharia referred to the election officer's order dated 23rd
June 2009 (placed on record at pages 30 to 38 of Special Civil
Application No. 8199 of 2009). He also referred to the subsequent
communication dated 24th June 2009 forwarded by the
respondent No. 4-Bank to the member societies in pursuance of the
election officer's aforesaid order dated 23rd June 2009.
He submitted that to cut the matter short, the letter dated 24.6.2009
can be, in the facts of the case, treated as the invitation by
specified society to its member societies to send, under Rule 5(2)
the names of the delegates. Mr. Vakharia, learned Senior Counsel
further submitted that as per Rule 6 objection against such list
should then be invited, however, indisputably the said requirement
has not been complied with in respect of the list prepared on
4.7.2009 inasmuch as the
respondent-Bank forwarded the list (prepared on the basis of
resolutions received between 24.6.2009 and 4.7.2009 pursuant to the
communication dated 24.6.2009)
to the Election Officer on 4.7.2009 branding it as final list of
voters and in view of the respondent bank's communication dated
4.7.2009, the Election Officer has passed the order on 16th
July, 2009 publishing, under Rule 7 the list (forwarded by the
respondent No. 4-Bank on 4.7.2009) as the final list of voters.
Hence the order dated 16th July 2009 is not sustainable.
4.2 Mr.
Vakharia has also submitted that the respondent no. 2-Election
Officer is obliged to conduct the election of the Board of Directors
of respondent no. 4-Bank in accordance with Rule 3A (8) of 1982
Rules, however it is clear that the election is going to be conducted
in accordance with the bye-law no. 30(1) of the respondent no. 4-Bank
and not as per Rule 3A (8). He submitted that as the said bye-law no.
30(1) is not in conformity with rule 3A (8) of the 1982 Rules
inasmuch as it provides for more than one seat in one constituency
which is contrary to Rule 3-A(8) of 1982 Rules and since the
statutory rules should prevail over the bye-laws, the election ought
to be conducted in accordance with rule 3A(8) of 1982 Rules and not
as per bye-law no. 30(1). He submitted that the respondent no.
2-Election Officer needs to be directed to conduct the election as
per Rule 3A(8). The learned Senior Counsel relied upon the decision
in case of Antakampa Milk
Producers' Co-operative Society Ltd. Vs. Sabarkantha Dist.
Co-operative Milk Producers' Union Ltd. (2004(1) GLR 310)
5. Mr.
Mehta learned Additional Advocate General for the respondent nos. 1
to 3 has submitted that if the Court considers that the decision
reported in 2004(1) GLR 310 wold be applicable in the facts of the
present case and that the number of Directors to be elected from the
representatives of Credit Co-operative Societies is not in accordance
with Rule 3A(8) then it would be necessary for the Election Officer
to conduct the election as per Rule 3A(8) and to proceed on the basis
that bye-law no. 30(1) is not in conformity with Rule 3A(8) of 1982
Rules. He, however, submitted that constituency contemplated
under Rule 3A (8) shall mean the constituency as defined under
Section 2(b) and therefore it is for the respondent no. 4-Bank to
determine its own constituency and the contention that bye-law 30(1)
does not conform to Rule 3A(8) is not justified.
5.1 The
learned Additional Advocate General submitted that by the decision
dated 23rd June 2009 the respondent no. 2-Election Officer
decided the objections received in respect of provisional list of
voters published on 6th June 2009 and that therefore the
list prepared and published after addressing the decision of the
Election Officer in the order dated 23rd June 2009 is and
ought to be considered as final list of voters as contemplated under
Rule 7.
6. Mr.
Nanavati learned Senior Counsel for the respondent no. 4-Bank opposed
the petition on the ground of maintainability and submitted that in
view of provisions under Section 145(U) there is a statutory
alternative remedy by way of Election Petition and that therefore the
petition, at this stage, is not maintainable. He also submitted that
the election process has already commenced and that therefore this
Court, in exercise of powers under Article 226 of the Constitution,
would not interfere with the election process. He also submitted that
the list prepared on 4th July 2009 is prepared and
finalized after the election officer's decision dated 5.6.2009 and
23.6.2009 taken after considering the objections received pursuant to
the publication of provisional list of voters on 6th June
2009 prior to which the list was published under Notice dated
25.5.2009 and that therefore the list of voters published on 4th
July 2009 is, as rightly stated in order dated 16th July
2009, final list of voters under Rule 7 of the 1982 Rules.
6.1 So
far as the petitioner's contentions with regard to bye-law no. 3A(8)
of 1982 Rules is concerned, Mr. Nanavati addressed the said
contention on the same lines of arguments as the learned Additional
Advocate General and further submitted that there are similar rules
in various other specified societies. He submitted that so far as the
respondent no. 4-Bank is concerned, the provision regarding
constituency and number of seats is contained in the bye-law No.
30(1) and all member societies including petitioners have acquiesced
with the bye-laws since last about 50 years. He submitted that even
the petitioner has never raised any objection against the bye-laws.
He also submitted that if however the Court comes to the conclusion
that the bye-law no. 30(1) does not conform to the Rule 3A(8), then
the respondent no. 4-Bank cannot dispute the preposition that the
statutory rules should prevail over the bye-law. He was, however,
quick to add that the submission is without prejudice to the
fundamental contention that the bye-law no. 30(1) does not violate
Rule 3A(8) and there is no conflict between the two.
7. So
far as the objection against the order dated 16.7.2009 and against
the voters list prepared on 4.7.2009 is concerned, it needs to be
noted that the facts of present case are mostly similar to the facts
in Special Civil Application No. 8199 of 2009 (except some
differences in respect of facts not very material so far as point of
law is concerned). Hence, for the reasons recorded in the judgment
and order rendered in Special Civil Application No. 8199 of 2009 we,
in present case also, hold that the respondent no. 2 - Election
Officer is not justified in declaring the list given by the
respondent no. 4-Bank, as the final list of voters under and for the
purpose of Rule 7 of 1982 Rules. It is, therefore, necessary to
direct the respondent no. 2-Election Officer to invite objections in
connection with the list of voters submitted to the Election Officer
on 4th July 2009 and take appropriate decision with regard
to the objections in accordance with law.
8. Now,
coming to the contention based on the rule 3A(8) of 1982 Rules which
reads thus:-
3A(8):-
Where the area of operation of a society is in more than one village,
the number of constituencies shall be equal to the total number of
seats excluding two seats reserved under sub-section (1) of Section
74-B.
The
definition of the term constituency referred to in the said
provision is to be found in Rule 2(b) of 1982 Rules which reads:
constituency
means an electoral devision, if any, and specified in the bye-laws of
the specified societies .
9. The
petitioners claim that the bye-law No. 30(1) of the respondent No.4-
Bank does not conform to the said Rule 3A(8) inasmuch as the said
bye-law provides for more than one seat in a constituency.
10.
On perusal of the said bye-law it emerges that the membership of the
respondent No.4-Bank comprises various societies carrying on
different objective/activities i.e. the member societies are of
different types/categories such as Agricultural Credit
Multipurpose Service and Farming Co-operative Societies and
Non-agricultural Credit Society and other societies which provides
loans to their members and sale and purchase union as well as
marketing and processing societies etc.
11.
It also comes out, on perusal of the said bye-law No. 30(1), that the
respondent No. 4-Bank has allotted representation to its member
societies on the basis of the object and activities of the
member societies. Differently put, the representation is not allotted
on territorial basis but it is allotted on the basis of objects and
activities of the member societies.
12. It
deserves to be noted that the said Rule 3A(8) belongs to the family
of Rules which pertain to Delimitation of constituencies and
the specified society's obligation to prepare the list of
constituencies for the purpose of election. The sub-Rules (1) and
(2) of the Rule 3A read thus:-
3A
Delimitation of constituencies for purpose of election.-
In every society where there are more than one constituencies, the
Secretary or where there is no post of Secretary, the Chief Executive
Officer of every such society shall, in the year preceding the year
in which election to the Committee is scheduled to be held, prepare a
provisional list of the constituencies.
(2)Such
list shall describe the limits of each constituency. A copy of the
provisional list shall be displayed with a notice to be signed by the
Secretary or where there is no post of Secretary, the chief Executive
Officer of the society on the notice board of every office or
sub-office of the society. A copy of such provisional list along
with the notice shall also be sent to the Registrar and to the
Collector.
13. The
sub-Rule (1) obliges the specified society to prepare a provisional
list of constituencies where there are more than one
constituencies.
14. The
sub-Rule (2) requires that the provisional list shall describe the
limits of each constituencies and it shall be displayed on the
notice board and a copy shall be forwarded to the Collector. When the
said sub-Rule refers to limits , it is obvious that the
reference is to the geographical or territorial boundaries/limits.
15. The
sub-Rules (3) to (7) prescribe the procedure for considering the
objections, if any, against the list of constituencies and its
finalisation. In the event the elections are required to be held
before the accounting year ends, then as per sub-Rule (9), the
Collector has to carry out the delimitation of the constituencies
before the publication of voters list. The said sub-Rule (9) reads
thus:-
Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules and the bye-laws of
the society, where the elections to the members of any Committee are
scheduled to be held before the ending of the accounting year of the
society, the delimitation of the constituencies shall be made by
the Collector prior to the publication of the list of voters.
16. The
sub-Rule (8)-which is invoked in present case has to be read, it
being part of Rule 3A, along with Sub-Rules (1) and (2) and in light
of the fact that it is part of the Rules which deal with delimitation
of societies. The said sub-Rule (8) inter alia provides that where
the area of operation of the specified society (in
present case respondent no. 4) is in more than one village, the
number of constituencies shall be equal to the total number
of seats (excluding 2 reserved seats). It is in light of the said
provision that the petitioner has submitted that the number of seats,
in any case, can never by more than the number of constituencies of
the concerned specified society.
17. The
petitioner has, so as to lend support to its contention, relied on
the judgment in the case of Antakampa Milk Producers (supra).
We should note that the issue raised in the said case was considered
and decided in different set of facts, particularly the fact that in
the said case certain constituencies did not get any
representation/seat at all. In the cited case of Antakampa Milk
Producers (supra)it was claimed
that three constituencies did not get any representation/seat since
the specified society had not allotted any seat/representation to
three member societies. Furthermore, in the said case the
constituencies were bifurcated zone or territory-wise.
Since the said case has been decided in different set of facts than
the facts posed before us, the said authority does not help the
petitioner and that therefore it is not necessary for us to enter
into further discussion or make any other observations in present
case and we do not propose to.
18. The
Rule 3A of the 1982 Rules employs phrases the limits and the
area which give indication about the scope and purport of the said
provisions as well as about the intention of the legislature.
18.1 The
usage of the said phrases, coupled with the fact that the entire Rule
3A deals with the delimitation of constituencies , make it clear
that the said provisions - including the sub-Rule (8) - are aimed at
geographical i.e. territory or zone wise bifurcation or division.
Consequently their field of operation is aimed at or restricted to
territory wise/geographically divided electorate.
The
bifurcation of electorate or creation of constituencies only on
territorial basis i.e. zone-wise bifurcation could be more
practicable in those specified societies where the members constitute
a homogenous group, however in the specified societies where the
members comprise a heterogenous group and one or two categories of
the member societies have larger presence than other categories of
member societies, a zone-wise bifurcation may not be so practicable
and the specified society may allot representation on the basis of
objects and activities of its member societies.
19. An
important feature of the sub-Rule (8) is that the words the number
of constituencies precedes the words the total number of
seats , hence it follows that it is the number of constituencies
which shall be equal to the number of seats.
The
petitioner claims that in the case of the respondent No. 4-Bank the
number of seats is more than the number of constituencies and thus
the bye law 30(1) is not in conformity with Rule 3A(8) and therefore
the election should not be permitted to be held as per bye-law 30(1).
20. The
objection of petitioner does not deserve to be entertained mainly for
two reasons viz (a) it appears that the petitioner is overlooking
important provision; viz. Rule-43 of the 1982 Rules and (b) the
petitioner has missed the stage and lost the right to raise such
objection.
21. We
may take the second point, first. It is pertinent that it is not the
case of the petitioner that the provisional list of
constituencies and thereafter the final list of
constituencies were not published as per sub-Rules (2) and
(7) of Rule 3A and/or were not forwarded to the Registrar and the
Collector.
21.1 Thus,
it is not unsafe to proceed on the premise that the requirement and
procedure under sub-Rules (2) and (7) of Rule 3A were duly followed.
21.2 When
the petitioner did not raise any objection under and as per sub-Rules
(5) and (6) of Rule 3-A, it lost the right to raise objection on any
ground including the ground raised in petition i.e. number of
constituencies vis-a-vis number of seats.
22. Besides
this, while urging the said contention, the petitioner is missing the
provision under Rule 43 of 1982 Rules.
22.1 The
said sub-Rule 43 inter alia prescribes the procedure for voting where
more than one seat are to be filled in one constituency (or where
there are no separate constituencies) and reads thus:-
43.
Procedure for voting where there no separate constituencies or more
than one seat to be filled in one constituency.- In cases where there
are no constituencies defined in the bye-laws or where more than one
seat is authorised in the bay-laws for a constituency, voting in so
far as these seats are concerned shall be recorded in accordance with
the following provisions namely:-
(a)
Every voter shall be entitled to give as many votes as there are
seats for filling which votes are to be taken but no voter shall give
more than one vote to any one candidate.
(b)
The voter shall make a mark on the ballot paper with the instrument
supplied for the purpose on or near the symbols of the candidate or
candidates for whom he intends to vote, so however, that no part of
any mark so made shall appear in the space provided for other
candidate. The voter shall thereafter fold the marked ballot paper so
as to conceal his vote and insert the folded ballot paper into the
ballot box and without undue delay leave the polling station
22.2 On
reading of the said Rule it emerges that reference of sub-Clause (a),
in the context of the petition, is apposite at this stage.
22.3.
It is evident from the words or where more than one seat is
authorised in the bye laws for a constituency in the said Rule-43
that the said Rule contemplates and envisages that in a set-up of a
specified society there may be more than one seat for one
constituency.
The
only requirement which the said Rule mandates is that the bye law of
the specified society must authorise more than one seat for a
constituency.
22.4
The said provision holds additional weightage in view of the fact
that it finds place amidst the provisions which deal with the stage
of voting or voting procedure.
22.5
The sub-clause (a) of Rule 43 further substantiates the position that
the 1982 Rules do envisage a situation where there may be more than
one seat for a constituency. The sub-Clause (a) provides that:
every
voter shall be entitled to give as many votes as there are
seats for filling...
When
the said sub-clause, and particularly the words give as many votes
as there are seats in the said sub-Clause (a), are read with the
words or where more
than one seat is
authorised in the bye laws for
a constituency , it
emerges that under the 1982 Rules a situation has been envisaged,
upon taking into account a possibility, wherein a specified society
may allot larger representation to a particular category of society
in one constituency and so as to take care of such situation the
Rules have also prescribed the procedure for voting when one
constituency has more than one seat.
As
per the said sub-clause (a) the only restriction which is imposed is
that a voter cannot give more than one vote to one candidate.
22.6
Considered from another angle and perspective the said sub-Rule
confers or guards the voters' right to cast equal number of votes as
there are seats to be filled up and it also upholds the right of a
specified society to allot representation to its member societies
depending on their number/strength i.e. to provide for (in its
bye-laws) as many seats as it considers appropriate.
23. The
Rule 43, inter alia, takes care of such allotment and protects the
right of voters in the segment having higher allotment of
representation in the same manner as the voter in other segment.
24.
Though it may prima facie appear that there is conflict between the
two provisions however in view of the respective objects and fields
of operation of Rule 3A and Rule 43 there wold not be any conflict.
When Rule 3A and Rule 43 are examined in juxtaposition it emerges
that the object as well as the field of operation of the said two
provisions are different inasmuch as the former deals only with
constituencies bifurcated on territorial/zone basis. Even
otherwise on harmonious construction both provisions can stand and
operate.
25. Hence,
the petitioner does not appear to be right and justified in its
second contention with regard to bye-law 30(1) to the effect that it
is contrary to Rule 3A(8). The said contention is not sustainable and
it overlooks the provision under sub-Rule 43, which, as aforesaid,
envisages more than one seat in one constituency and even prescribes
the procedure for voting in the cases where there are more than one
seat in a constituency.
26. In
the aforesaid view of the matter the contention does not impress us
and we do not find merits. The contention cannot be accepted and it
fails.
27. As
an upshot of the foregoing discussion the order dated 16.7.2009 is
set aside and it is directed that the list prepared and forwarded by
the respondent No. 4-Bank on 4.7.2009 shall be treated as provisional
list of voters and further procedure in accordance with the 1982
Rules shall be followed. The election officer shall take all
necessary steps so as
to
hold and conclude the election without delay and in accordance with
the Rules. The petition is, accordingly partly allowed. Rule made
made absolute to the aforesaid extent and effect.
So
far as the writ petition being Special Civil Application No. 8472 of
2009 (Rampar Seva Sahkari Mandli Ltd. & Ors. vs. The State of
Gujarat & Ors.) is concerned the petitioners have prayed, inter
alia, for direction to the respondent authorities to conclude the
election process of Managing Committee of Shree Rajkot District
Cooperative Bank Ltd, Rajkot i.e. respondent no. 4-Bank in Special
Civil Application No. 9748 of 2009.
In
writ petition being Special Civil Application No. 8473 of 2009
(Jambudi Seva Sahkari Mandali Ltd & others vs. State of Gujarat &
others) the petitioners have prayed, inter alia, for direction to the
respondent authorities to conclude the election process of Managing
Committee of Shree Rajkot District Cooperative Bank Ltd, Rajkot and
has also prayed that the respondent authorities be restrained from
appointing custodian.
In
the aforesaid Civil Application No.7194 of 2009 (Vithalbhai
Hansrajbhai Radadia and others vs. State of Gujarat and others) the
applicants have prayed that it may be impleaded as party respondent
no. 5 in Special Civil Application No. 5430 of 2009.
In
writ petition being Special Civil Application No. 5430 of 2009
(Vithalbhai Hansrajbhai Radadia and others vs. State of Gujarat and
others) the petitioners have, inter alia, prayed for directions to
the respondent authorities to take steps in accordance with law for
constitution of Managing Committee of Shree Rajkot District
Co-operative Bank Ltd and restrain the authorities from exercising
powers under Section 74-D of the Act.
In
writ petition being Special Civil Application No. 7265 of 2009 (The
Rajkot Lodhika Co-operative Sales and Purchase Union Ltd & ors
vs. Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Gujarat State & Ors) the
petitioners have prayed, inter alia, that the notice dated 25th
May 2009 publishing the provisional voter's list be set aside and the
respondent authorities i.e the respondent no. 1-the Registrar,
Co-operative Societies, Gujarat State may be directed to hold the
election for the Board of Directors of the respondent No. 4-Bank.
In
view of the decision in SCA No. 9748 of 2009 and the aforesaid
direction other or separate order is not required in SCA Nos. 5430,
7265, 8472, 8473 and in CA No. 7194 of 2009 and the said petitions
and the application stand disposed of in terms of this judgment and
order.
In
view of the aforesaid directions and particularly direction to hold
and conclude the election without delay in accordance with Rules any
order restraining the authorities from exercising powers under
Section 74-D will not be necessary.
(Ms.
R.M.Doshit,J.)
(K.M.Thaker,J.)
Suresh*
Top