Leave
to amend.
1. The
petitioner-detenu has preferred this petition under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India for appropriate writ, order or direction
for quashing and setting aside the order dated 17.1.2008 passed by
respondent No.1-Police Commissioner, Ahmedabad City, whereby, in
exercise of power under sub-section (2) of section 3 of the Gujarat
Prevention of Anti Social Activities Act, 1985 (for short, 'PASA
Act') the petitioner has been detained as a bootlegger. In
pursuance of the said impugned order, the petitioner is detained in
jail.
Heard
the learned advocate for the petitioner and the learned AGP for the
respondents.
1. From
the grounds of detention, it appears that five offences being
CR.I.Nos. 5222, 5258 of 2006, 5047, 5329, and 5413 of 2007 under
sections 66 (1)b and 65(e) etc. under the Bombay Prohibition Act,
were registered with Naroda police station wherein country iquor was
found from the possession of the detenu. On the basis of
registration of these cases, the detaining authority held that the
present detenu was carrying on activities of selling country liquor
which is harmful to the health of the public. It is held by the
detaining authority that as the detenu is indulged in illegal
activities, it is required to restrain him from carrying out further
illegal activities i.e. selling of liquor. The detaining authority
has placed reliance on the above registered offences and statements
of unnamed witnesses. In the opinion of this court, the activities
of the detenu can, by no stretch of reasoning, be said to be
disturbing the public order. It is seen from the grounds that a
general statement that has been made by the detaining authority that
consuming liquor is injurious to health. In fact, a perusal of the
order passed by the detaining authority shows that the grounds which
are mentioned in the order are in reference to the situation of 'law
and order' and not 'public order'. Therefore, on this ground, the
subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority is vitiated on
account of non-application of mind and the impugned order, therefore,
deserves to be quashed and set aside.
3. Except two statements of
the anonymous witnesses, there is no material on record which shows
that the petitioner-detenu is carrying out illegal activities of
selling liquor which is harmful to the health of the public. In the
case of Ashokbhai Jivraj @ Jivabhai Solanki v. Police
Commissioner, Surat (2001 (1) GLH 393), having considered the
decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Ram Manohar
Lohia v. State of Bihar (AIR 1966 SC 740), this court held
that the cases wherein the detention order are passed on the basis of
the statements of such witnesses fall under the maintenance of ?Slaw
and order?? and not ?Spublic order??.
4. Applying
the ratio of the above decisions, it is clear that before passing an
order of detention of a detenu, the detaining authority must come to
a definite finding that there is threat to the 'public order' and it
is very clear that the present case would not fall within the
category of threat to a public order. In that view of the matter,
when the order of detention has been passed by the detaining
authority without having adequate grounds for passing the said order,
cannot be sustained and, therefore, it deserves to be quashed and set
aside.
5. In the result, this Special
Civil Application is allowed. The impugned order of detention dated
17.1.2008 passed by the Police Commissioner, Ahmedabad is hereby
quashed and set aside. The detenu is ordered to be set at liberty
forthwith, if not required in any other case. Rule is made absolute
accordingly. Direct service is permitted.
[M.D.
SHAH, J.]
msp
Top