Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of Judicial Opinion (Rajesh Balia, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent (workman) Gajendra R. Dhumal was initially appointed by the Municipal Corporation, Vadodara as an Assistant Draftsman in 1981. His services were later terminated without following the conditions of Chapter V-A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Subsequently he was placed on a lower post (Tracer) from about October 1985 and was reappointed on various temporary/fixed-term orders with apparent retrospective extensions and intermittent continuations beyond expiry dates.

The record included a Town Planner's letter dated 2-8-1986 indicating that work existed and recommending appointment for at least one year. The workman also worked as a Helper on a short fixed-term engagement in August 1988 (6-8-1988 to 30-9-1988). By an impugned order dated 5-11-1988, the workman's services were brought to an end.

The Municipal Corporation challenged an Industrial Tribunal award dated 30-4-1994 by filing a Special Civil Application before this Court. The Tribunal had found that the workman had been subject to reversion to lower posts, had been given fixed-term appointments with artificial breaks intended to disguise an indefinite tenure, and had worked for substantial periods on the posts in question. The Tribunal made an award in favour of the workman which led to this petition challenging that Award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the termination/reversion of the workman from the post of Assistant Draftsman amounted to illegal retrenchment in contravention of Chapter V-A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
  2. Whether the requirements of Section 25-F (i.e., the question whether the workman had worked for 240 days in the 12 months immediately preceding 5-11-1988) were satisfied so as to attract protections under Chapter V-A.
  3. Whether, if retrenchment was held invalid, the appropriate remedy was reinstatement only to the post from which he was retrenched (Assistant Draftsman) or whether reinstatement on a different post (Tracer) could be directed.
  4. Whether Section 2(00)(bb) (definitional provision concerning certain engagements appearing to be fixed-term) applied to exclude the workman from protections, given the factual matrix of artificial breaks and retrospective orders.
  5. Whether, under an operative settlement between employees and the Corporation, the workman was entitled to regularisation/permanent appointment on having worked for 720 days or more on a post.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Municipal Corporation) Arguments

  • The workman's service were of fixed-term tenure and therefore the termination could not be regarded as retrenchment attracting Chapter V-A protections.
  • There was no finding that the workman worked 240 days in the 12 months immediately preceding 5-11-1988, so Section 25-F protections were not attracted.
  • Even if retrenchment were invalid, the workman could only be reinstated to the post from which he was retrenched (Assistant Draftsman), not to Tracer.
  • The workman was highly qualified and unlikely to actually rejoin; the real aim was to obtain back wages and leave—i.e., the petitioner suggested the claim was opportunistic.

Respondent's (Workman) Arguments

  • The dispute was not confined to the termination dated 5-11-1988 but concerned the entire period of employment and the unfair treatment—specifically his reversion from Assistant Draftsman to Tracer and the practice of giving fixed-term appointments with artificial breaks.
  • The Corporation is a local authority within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution, so the full dispute concerning reversion and termination was actionable.
  • On the question of the petitioner's apprehension that the workman would not rejoin, the workman's counsel stated an undertaking that the workman would join the Corporation and serve at least three years; failing which he would not claim benefits flowing from the Award.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the Award and the pleadings and proceeded on the basis that the dispute extended beyond an isolated challenge to the termination dated 5-11-1988. The Tribunal had considered earlier events — appointment in 1981 as Assistant Draftsman, transfer/reversion to a lower post to accommodate another employee, subsequent fixed-term appointments with retrospective continuations and "artificial breaks," and the continuation of work beyond specified fixed terms without proper termination orders.

Key steps in the court's analysis:

  1. The court accepted the Tribunal's factual findings that the workman had been continuously employed as Assistant Draftsman from 1981 until December 1985 (a period exceeding four years) and that there existed a permanent post for which the workman had functioned. Because of that continuity and permanence, the first termination from the post of Assistant Draftsman required compliance with Chapter V-A procedures; the initial termination was therefore invalid.
  2. The court treated reversion to a lower post (asking an employee to work in a lower post than that to which he was appointed) as amounting to retrenchment in the circumstances of this case.
  3. The court found that subsequent employment episodes (Tracer from February 1986 after a ten-month break, and other periods up to 1988) showed that the Corporation gave fixed-term appointments with artificial breaks intended to disguise an indefinite tenure. The Tribunal's conclusion that the purported fixed-term nature was a façade was accepted.
  4. With those findings, the court held that the workman should be deemed to have continued on the post to which he was validly appointed unless lawfully retrenched, and earlier unlawful terminations had consequences when assessing appropriate reinstatement and relief.
  5. The court addressed the petitioner's argument about Section 25-F (240 days) by explaining that the wider factual dispute made the specific counting of 240 days immediately preceding 5-11-1988 less determinative; 5-11-1988 was relevant primarily as a reference date for reinstatement, not as the sole locus of the dispute. Thus the Tribunal was justified in considering antecedent illegal terminations and the overall nature of the employment relationship.
  6. On Section 2(00)(bb), the court noted the petitioner's contention was not raised before the Tribunal and therefore could not be entertained at this stage; additionally, the Tribunal's finding of an existing permanent vacancy and the existence of artificial breaks took the case out of the purview of Section 2(00)(bb).
  7. The court further relied on an operative settlement between employees and the Corporation which provided that a person who has worked for 720 days or more is entitled to be made permanent. The Tribunal had found that the workman had worked on the posts (Assistant Draftsman and Tracer combined) for more than 720 days; accordingly, under that settlement the workman was entitled to regularisation.

Having reviewed the Tribunal's findings and the broader chronology, the court concluded the Tribunal's remedy (which included declaring the terminations illegal and directing reinstatement on the post of Tracer in view of the workman's qualifications and prior service) was justified.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The petition challenging the Industrial Tribunal's Award is DISMISSED.

Direct effects and practical consequences as set out by the Court:

  • The Tribunal's Award — which found earlier terminations to be illegal and directed reinstatement (specifically reinstatement on the post of Tracer, having regard to the workman's qualifications and service record) — stands and does not call for interference under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
  • The petition is dismissed subject to the workman's undertaking: before rejoining the Corporation the workman must furnish an undertaking to serve the employer for a period of three years; if he leaves prior to three years, he must return the amount of back wages in accordance with the statement made on his behalf before this Court.
  • The Rule is discharged and the petition was dismissed with no costs awarded.

The opinion does not articulate broader precedent-setting implications; the decision is framed as resolving the parties' dispute on the facts and law as applied to those facts, and the court expressly found no ground to interfere with the Tribunal's award under Articles 226 & 227.

    Vadodara Municipal Corporation v. Gajendra R. Dhumal .

    Rajesh Balia, J.:— Rule. Mr. S.P Hasulkar, learned Advocate appears for respondent and waives service of Rule. Heard learned Counsel for the parties on merits.

    2. On reference being made, of the following question:

    3. The Industrial Tribunal, Vadodara made Award on the following terms on 30-4-1994:

    4. Aggrieved with the aforesaid Award, the Municipal Corporation, Vadodara has come up before this Court through this Special Civil Application. To understand contentions and a controversy raised before me, it would be necessary to notice brief facts as narrated in the Award. Respondent-Gajendra R. Dhumal (hereinafter called as the workman) was appointed in 1981 by the petitioner-Corporation as Asstt. Draftsman on which post he continued until when his services were wrongly terminated without following the conditions of Chapter V-A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Thereafter he was appointed on Tracer's post, lower to the post of Asstt. Draftsman from October 1985. By the order dated 9-10-1985, the workman was transferred to another department on the ground that his work in the present department was not satisfactory. However, from the record of the Municipal Corporation, it was clear, that the work of Shri Dhumal was satisfactory throughout. On the said post, workman again came to be appointed on 15-2-1986 until 31-3-1986. He; continued on the post even after 31-3-1986 without any order. On 17-5-1986, the order was issued for extending services w.e.f 1-4-1986 for a period of 3 months. Likewise thereafter appointment was continued, without termination on expiry of time, though extension orders was issued retrospectively from time to time. This was done notwithstanding the fact that from the letter dated 2-8-1986 of Town Planner it came on record that in fact the work was existing and there were recommendations for appointing the petitioner at least for a period of one year. The petitioner has raised dispute about placing him on lower post as while working on the post of Asstt. Draftsman, he was continued and the fact that he had already completed one year continuous service on the post of Asstt. Draftsman and from which post, his services could not be terminated without fulfilling conditions precedent for valid retrenchment from the post of Draftsman. While this was going on, after some time, workman was given appointment as Helper in the month of August 1988 for a fixed period from 6-8-1988 to 30-9-1988 as a Daily-wager Helper and while the petitioner made a demand for doing justice to him in respect of his status in the matter of appointment by not reverting him from the post of Asstt. Draftsman to the post of Helper, by the impugned order dated 5-11-1988, services of the respondent workman were brought to an end.

    5. It is in this background that the workman's first appointment as Asstt. Draftsman and his subsequent reversion to the lower post of Tracer and his demand for post of Asstt. Draftsman on the ground that his termination from the post of Asstt. Draftsman being violative of retrenchment provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and subsequent termination of the petitioner's service even from the post of Helper led to the aforesaid question being referred to the Tribunal for adjudication.

    6. The Tribunal found as a fact that the workman has worked for two years and seven months between 1981 to 1984 on the post of Asstt. Draftsman, that there was permanent post of Asstt. Draftsman on which workman was functioning but in order to accommodate somebody else, the workman was transferred from parent department to another department. Thereafter also from 1986 to 1988, workman worked for more than 2 years with the Corporation. It also came to the finding that though the work was existing which was of permanent nature, the petitioner was offered fixed-term appointment and with artificial break meaning thereby that it was purely a camaflouge (sic.) to hide the indefinite nature of appointment and in view of this finding, the aforesaid Award was made by the Industrial Tribunal in which it also took into account the necessary qualifications which the workman has acquired in the field.

    7. It was firstly contended by the learned Counsel for the petitioner that as respondent-workman's service were of fixed-term tenure, termination of services cannot be considered as retrenchment. Secondly, it was contended that there is no finding that workman has worked for 240 days in 12 months immediately preceding 5-11-1988 so as to attract the provisions of Section 25-F of Chapter V-A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Thirdly, it was contended that even assuming that retrenchment was invalid, the workman could have been reinstated only on the post from which he came to be retrenched and could not have been directed to be reinstated on the post of Tracer. Lastly, it was contended that the workman being highly qualified man, is not likely to join the services, but only purpose of this dispute was to claim back wags (sic.) as accumulated capital and walk away with it.

    8. To allay the apprehension of the petitioner, the learned Counsel for the respondent at the very outset of the contentions as stated above, has stated on behalf of his client so far as last contention of the petitioner is concerned, that the workman undertakes to join the services of the Corporation and will serve at least for a period of 3 years failing which he would not claim any benefits flowing from Award made in his favour. Regarding other contentions, he submitted that the dispute was not merely with reference to the termination of services on 5-11-1988, but was concerning entire period of service and unfair treatment given to the workman in the matter of employment by the petitioner Corporation which is a local authority falling within the definition of “State” within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India and the dispute was wholesome dispute keeping in view the dispute concerning reversion of the petitioner from the post of Draftsman to Tracer culminating termination of service? from the post of Draftsman in the first instance and termination of employment altogether on 5-11-1988 which was mala fide apart from being violative of provisions of the Act.

    9. I have carefully considered the rival contentions raised before me and perused the Award. It is true that had it been a case of examining legality of termination simpliciter in the context of provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, on finding retrenchment being illegal, the ordinary consequence would have been to reinstate the workman on the same post from which he was retrenched, i.e revival of status quo as existing at the time of termination with necessary consequence flowing therefrom as the facts and circumstances of the case may require. However, from the perusal of the Award and facts stated above, it is apparent that dispute which was referred did not relate merely to the question of termination on 5-11-1988, but the dispute related to treatment given to the workman 2 since his appointment as Asstt. Draftsman and thereafter asking him to discharge duties of Tracer by giving him appointments on fixed term basis with artificial breaks. If viewed from this point 2 of view, in my opinion, none of the contentions raised by the learned Counsel for the petitioner sustain scrutiny. The undisputed fact is that the petitioner was appointed as a Draftsman way back in 1981 on which post he worked right up to December 1985, i.e he was continuously employed as Draftsman for a period of more than 4 years. Therefore, his services as Draftsman could not have been terminated without following the procedure. If that is the position, the very first termination of the workman being in violation of the provisions of the Act from the post of Asstt. Draftsman was invalid. Even asking an employee to work on the lower post to one on which he was appointed, amounts to retrenchment. Again thereafter the workman was employed as Tracer from 4 February 1986, i.e after about break of 10 months which was a post lower than Asstt. Draftsman. If termination of services of workman from the post of Asstt. Draftsman was invalid, the consequence shall be that he would be deemed to have continued on the post of Asstt. Draftsman and entitled to that status unless lawfully terminated from that post. Be that as may be, again from December 1986 till May 1987, the workman has completed more than 1 year's continuous service on the post of Tracer which also was terminated without following procedure and was illegal. Thereafter, in August 1988 the petitioner was again given appointment yet on lower post of Helper. Therefore, it is not merely termination w.e.f 5-11-1988 was in question, but the action of the Corporation thoughout the period was in question and the Tribunal was justified in taking into consideration the fact of earlier illegal termination and offering lower post while adjudicating the dispute referred to it. As is apparent from the Award, termination from the post of Asstt. Draftsman as well as from the post of Tracer itself was found illegal and void, it was justified in holding retrenchment to be illegal and directing the petitioner-Corporation to reinstate the workman on the post of Tracer looking to his qualifications and keeping in view of the previous service record, if not on the post of Draftsman—the post on which he was first appointed. It is also to be noticed that keeping in view nature of dispute referred to for adjudication by the Tribunal, the question of actual working for 240 days immediately preceding 5-11-1988 was not much of relevance. Date 5-11-1988 was only relevant for the purpose that as on 5-11-1988, the workman was actually in employment, his reinstatement should have been from that date. However on what post, was to be determined, depending upon finding about the previous post held by the petitioner and the circumstances in which he was terminated from those posts and whether earlier terminations were valid or invalid. So far as the question of applicability of Section 2(00)(bb) of the Act is concerned, in my opinion, this contenion is not open to be raised in this case inasmuch as the same was not raised before the Tribunal. Moreover, in view of clear finding that there was permanent vacancy against which workman was working and periodical appointments were offered only for the purpose of creating artificial break, takes the case put of purview of Section 2(00)(bb) of the Act. In this connection, it is also to be stated that though the appointment order when issued, spoke of fixed term appointment, yet the services on expiry of such term did not come to an end automatically on expiry of the term, but the workman was continued on the post without any order. Once the workman's appointment ceased to be a fixed term appointment, subsequent issue of an order giving a fixed term appointment with retrospective effect will not attract the provisions of Section 2(00)(bb) of the Act.

    10. One more fact may be noticed. Parties are in agreement that as per settlement operating between employees and Corporation, a person who has worked for 720 days or more, he is entitled to be made permanent. If that be so, leaving aside the case of retrenchment being legal or illegal, on the basis of operative settlement between the parties, the workman was entitled to be regularised on the post on which he has actually worked for 720 days or more. As per the finding of the Tribunal, workman has undoubtedly worked on the post of Asstt. Draftsman and Tracer taking together for more than 720 days. Under the settlement itself, therefore, the workman was entitled to be regularised and offered permanent service rather than 4 getting marching orders. In that view of the matter, Award made by the Tribunal is preeminently just and does not call for any interference under Articles 226 & 227 of the Constitution of India. In view of my aforesaid conclusions, this petition has no force and is hereby dismissed subject to the observations that before joining with Corporation, the respondent-workman shall furnish an undertaking about his serving the employer for a period of 3 years and in case he leaves the job before 3 years, he shall return the amount of backwages in terms of statement made before this Court on his behalf as noticed above. Rule discharged. No costs.

    11. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vadodara Municipal Corporation v. Gajendra R. Dhumal .
    (Feb 14, 1995)