AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Mr. Thanglenmang Hangsing @ Jhonson @ Mamang, was detained by an order dated 12th August, 2003 passed by the District Magistrate, Senapati District, Manipur, under sub-section (2) of Section 3 of the National Security Act, 1980. The detention was said to be with a view to prevent him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the security of the State and maintenance of public order.

According to the pleadings in the record, the petitioner was arrested by personnel of the 25th Assam Rifles Battalion on 30.7.2003 and handed over to Lamlai Police Station along with seized articles. A case was registered at Lamlai Police Station and later transferred to Saikul Police Station. The petitioner was alleged to be involved in forcible collection of money from members of the public and collecting money from Government Departments for the Kuki Revolutionary Army (KRA), among other serious offences — activities which the detaining authority considered prejudicial to the security of the State and public order.

The detention order (dated 12.8.2003) was served on the detenu in custody on 13.8.2003. Grounds of detention were furnished on 16.8.2003 along with copies of seven documents (35 pages), including a history sheet and FIR copies. The petitioner submitted a representation dated 18.8.2003 to the State Government through the Superintendent of Manipur Central Jail requesting revocation of the detention. The Government of Manipur approved the detention order on 19.8.2003 and rejected the petitioner's representation on 25.8.2003. The Advisory Board subsequently affirmed the order of detention in meetings on 27.9.2003 and 29.9.2003.

The matter was heard by the Court with Mr. Nilamani Singh, learned senior counsel, assisted by Mr. A. Bimal, appearing for the petitioner; Mr. Jalaluddin, learned Government Advocate, Manipur, and Mr. C. Choudhury, learned CGSC, appearing for the State and Union respectively.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the detaining authority failed to inform the detainee of his fundamental right to make a representation to the detaining authority prior to the State Government's approval of the detention order, as required by Article 22(5) of the Constitution and relevant provisions of the National Security Act, 1980.
  2. Whether the detainee was informed of his right to make a representation to the Central Government for revocation of the detention order, as contemplated by Section 14 of the National Security Act read with Article 22(5).
  3. Whether the detaining authority applied its mind to the fact that the detainee was already in judicial custody and whether there was an imminent prospect of his release on bail (i.e., whether cogent reasons/compelling reasons were recorded to justify preventive detention of a person already in custody).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as placed before the Court)

  • The detaining authority failed to inform the detenu of his right to make a representation to the detaining authority before the State Government approved the detention order, contrary to Article 22(5) of the Constitution and Sections 3(4) & 14(1) of the National Security Act, 1980 — and that such failure vitiates the detention order.
  • The detenu was not informed of his right to make a representation to the Central Government for revocation of the detention order (a right under Section 14 of the National Security Act read with Article 22(5)).
  • The detaining authority did not apply its mind to the fact that the detenu was already in judicial custody and did not record cogent reasons to show that the detainee was likely to be released on bail imminently and that detention was therefore necessary — i.e., there was non-application of mind.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the Respondents' opposing arguments; the record indicates appearances by Government counsel, but their specific counter-arguments are not set out in the text provided.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kamaleshkumar Ishwardas Patel v. Union of India, (1995) 4 SCC 51 Article 22(5) imposes a dual obligation: to communicate grounds of detention and to afford the detained person the earliest opportunity to make a representation against the order. The detaining authority can also revoke the order it made. The Court treated Kamaleshkumar as authoritative on the requirement that the detaining authority must inform the detenu of his right to make representation to the detaining authority and to afford the earliest opportunity; applied its ratio to conclude that failure to inform vitiates the detention order.
State of Maharashtra v. Santosh Shankar Acharya, (2000) 7 SCC 463 Applied Kamaleshkumar's principles while dealing with a prevention order under a state preventive statute (confirming applicability of Article 22(5) principles). The Court noted that the Supreme Court in Santosh Shankar Acharya relied on Kamaleshkumar and confirmed that those principles apply to preventive detention statutes; used it to support the same conclusion in the present case.
Division Bench of this Court in Writ Petition (Cri.) No. 16 of 2003 (referenced) Followed Kamaleshkumar's decision in the context of the National Security Act, affirming the obligation on detaining authorities regarding representation. The Court cited the Division Bench decision as having applied Kamaleshkumar to NSA cases and relied on that approach in assessing the present detention order.
Hemanta Nath v. State of Assam, 1998 (2) GLT 344 Denial of opportunity to make a representation to the Central Government (when such right exists) vitiates continued detention. The Court relied on Hemanta Nath (which in turn relied on Nutan J. Patel and Kamaleshkumar) to hold that omission to inform the detainee of the right to represent to the Central Government undermines the detention.
Nutan J. Patel v. S.P. Prasad, (1996) 2 SCC 315 Principles regarding representation rights under Article 22(5) and related statutory provisions (as relied upon in subsequent cases addressing representation to State/Central authorities). The Court referenced Nutan J. Patel (via Hemanta Nath) as one of the authorities establishing that denial of opportunity to make representation to the Central Government vitiates continued detention.
Surya Prakash Sharma v. State of U.P., 1995 Crl. L.J. 2657 (SC) (referenced) Where detaining authority knows the detenu is in judicial custody, it must place cogent material on the record showing that if released he would likely commit prejudicial acts — particularly where release on bail is a realistic prospect. The Court applied Surya Prakash Sharma (based on Dharmendra Chelawat) to hold that the detaining authority should have recorded cogent reasons justifying detention of a person already in judicial custody; concluded that such reasons were absent here.
Dharmendra Suganchand Chelawat v. Union of India, (1990) 1 SCC 746 (AIR 1990 SC 1196) An order for detention of a person already in custody is valid only if grounds show (i) awareness that the detenu is in detention, and (ii) compelling reasons (cogent material) justifying further detention — including likelihood of near-term release and likelihood of engaging in prejudicial activities if released. The Court relied on Chelawat's formulation of "compelling reasons" to determine that the detention order lacked the necessary cogent materials showing imminence of release and necessity of preventive detention.
Binod Singh v. District Magistrate, Dhanbad, Bihar, (1986) 4 SCC 416 Authority on the requirement to show reasons when detaining persons already in custody; supports the need for cogent material. Cited as leading to the same conclusion that detention of a person already in custody must be supported by appropriate materials; used to reinforce finding of non-application of mind by detaining authority.
Gulab Mehra v. State of U.P., (1987) 4 SCC 302 Similar principle: preventive detention of a person in custody requires cogent reasons recorded on the grounds of detention. Also cited to support the proposition that absence of reasoning regarding imminent release or necessity of preventive detention renders the order unsustainable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a focused analysis of statutory and constitutional safeguards and how they were applied (or not) in the facts of this case. The main strands of the Court's reasoning are summarized below, strictly as they appear in the decision provided:

  1. The Court began by examining whether the detaining authority complied with Article 22(5) of the Constitution and the corresponding provisions of the National Security Act requiring that grounds of detention be communicated and that the detenu be afforded the earliest opportunity to make representation against the order.
  2. Relying on Kamaleshkumar Ishwardas Patel and subsequent authorities (including State of Maharashtra v. Santosh Shankar Acharya and a Division Bench decision of this Court), the Court reiterated that Article 22(5) imposes an imperative obligation on the detaining authority to inform the detenu of his right to make representations to the detaining authority itself before the State Government gives approval. The materials on record (grounds of detention — Annexure-A/2) did not reflect that the detenu was informed of this right; the Court deemed this omission a "serious lapse" that by itself vitiated the detention order.
  3. The Court then considered the right to make a representation to the Central Government (under Section 14 of the National Security Act read with Article 22(5)). The petitioner had not made any representation to the Central Government, and the detention order and grounds were silent as to informing him of that right. The Court, relying on Hemanta Nath (which relied on Nutan J. Patel and Kamaleshkumar), found that omission to inform the detenu of the right to represent to the Central Government likewise vitiates continued detention under the circumstances of this case.
  4. Next, the Court examined whether the detaining authority applied its mind to the fact that the petitioner was already in judicial custody and whether there was any immediate prospect of his release on bail. The Court relied on Surya Prakash Sharma and Dharmendra Chelawat for the proposition that, when detention is ordered against a person already in custody, the grounds must show (a) awareness that the person is in custody, and (b) "compelling reasons" supported by cogent material justifying detention despite custody — including an indication that the person was likely to be released in the near future and would, if released, engage in prejudicial activities.
  5. Although the grounds of detention acknowledged that the detenu was in judicial custody and asserted anticipation that he would continue prejudicial activities if released on bail, the Court found no material showing that release on bail was imminent or that cogent reasons were recorded tying imminent release to a real likelihood of prejudicial activity. The Court concluded that the detaining authority did not record reasons demonstrating the necessity of preventive detention of a person already in custody — which amounted to non-application of mind.
  6. Summing up, the Court identified three specific vices in the impugned detention order: (i) failure to inform the detenu of his right to make representation to the detaining authority prior to State approval; (ii) failure to inform him of the right to make representation to the Central Government; and (iii) non-application of mind to the fact of the detenu's judicial custody and the prospect of imminent release on bail.

Holding and Implications

Holding: For the reasons stated, the writ petition was allowed and the detention order dated 12th August, 2003 passed by the District Magistrate, Senapati District, Manipur, was quashed.

Direct Effect on the Parties: The Court ordered that the detenu be released from custody forthwith, subject to the qualification that he be released only if he was not wanted in connection with any other case.

Broader Implications: The Court's decision rests on enforcement of established constitutional and statutory safeguards (Article 22(5) and relevant provisions of the National Security Act), applying prior authoritative precedents. The opinion does not purport to create a new legal principle or novel precedent; it applies existing jurisprudence to the facts and concludes that the procedural lapses and non-application of mind rendered the detention order unsustainable.

    Thanglenmang Hangsing v. District Magistrate, Senapati District

    D. Biswas, J.:— The petitioner Mr. Thanglenmang Hangsing @ Jhonson @ Mamang was detained under the National Security Act, 1980 with a view to prevent him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the security of the State and maintenance of public order by the order dated 12th August, 2003 passed by the District Magistrate, Senapati District, Manipur. The order of detention issued under sub-section (2) of Section 3 of the National Security Act, 1980 is in challenge in this petition.

    2. It would appear from the pleadings on record that the writ petitioner was arrested by the personnel of the 25th Assam Rifles Bn. on 30.7.2003 and was handed over to Lamlai Police Station along with the seized articles. Accordingly, a case was registered against him at Lamlai Police Station. The case was transferred to Saikul Police Station. The petitioner was arrested by Saikul Police Station in a number of cases registered in different police station. The petitioner was allegedly involved in cases of forcible collection of money from members of public. Besides, he was also collecting money from Government Departments for raising funds for the outfit organization (Kukhi Revolutionary Army) and involved in a number of heinous crimes which, according to the detaining authority, were prejudicial to the security of the State and maintenance of public order. This led the District Magistrate, Senapati to pass the order of detention of the petitioner under the National Security Act. The order of detention reads as follows:

    “Whereas a police report has been laid before me that Mr. Thanglenmang Hangsing @ Jhonson @ Mamang (32) son of Mr. Thangneikhup Hangsing of Khumunom village, P.S Litan, District, Ukhrul, at present New Lambulane, P.S Porompat, District - Imphal East a member of Kuki Revolutionary Army (KRA in short) is acting in a manner prejudicial to the security of the State and maintenance of public order;

    2. And whereas, I Shri T. Pamei, District Magistrate, Senapati District, Manipur, am satisfied, that his activities are prejudicial to the security of the State and maintenance of public order under sub-section (2) of Section 3 of the National Security Act, 1980;

    3. And whereas, it is considered necessary to detain Mr. Thanglenmang Hangsing @ Jhonson @ Mamang (32) son of Mr. Thangneikhup Hangsing of Khumunom village, P.S Litan, District Ukhrul, at present New Lambulane, P.S Porompat with a view to prevent him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the security of the State and maintenance of public order.

    4. Now, therefore, I Shri T. Pamei, District Magistrate, Senapati District, Manipur in exercise of the powers conferred upon me by sub-section (2) of Section 3 of the National Security Act, 1980 as well as Home Deptt. Govt. of Manipur's order No. 17Q)/49/80-H(Pt)/212 dated 30.5.2003 make this order directing that the above said detenu/person be detained in Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa till further orders.

    3. Given under my hand and seal of this Court, this 12th August, 2003.”

    4. It appears that the grounds of detention were furnished, to the petitioner on 16.8.2003 along with copies of seven documents altogether consisting 35 pages which included the history sheet detailing various activities of the detenu, copies of the First Information Report etc. The petitioner submitted representation dated 18th August, 2003 to the State Government through the Superintendent of Manipur Central Jail for revocation of the impugned detention order. On 19.8.2003, the Government of Manipur approved the order of detention passed by the District Magistrate, Senapati and, on 25th August, 2003, rejected the representation submitted by the petitioner.

    5. We have heard Mr. Nilamani Singh, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. A. Bimal, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Jalaluddin, learned Government Advocate, Manipur. Mr. C. Choudhury, learned CGSC also argued on behalf of the Union.

    6. Mr. Nilamani Singh, learned senior counsel during the course of argument challenged the legality, validity and propriety of the order of detention on the following grounds:

    (i) the detaining authority (District Magistrate) failed to inform the detenu that he had a fundamental right to make a representation to the detaining authority before the State Government approved the order of detention as provided in Article 22(5) of the Constitution;

    (ii) the detenu was not informed of his right to make a representation to the Central Government for revocation of the detention order; and

    (iii) non-application of mind by the detaining authority (District Magistrate) to the fact that the detenu was already in judicial custody and whether there was immediate prospect of his release on bail.

    7. Mr. Nilmani, learned senior counsel submitted that the failure on the part of the detaining authority (Respondent No. 1) to inform the detenu of his right to make a representation to the said detaining authority for revocation vitiate the order of detention. Shri Nilmani pointed out that this right to represent flows from Article 22(5) of the Constitution and Section 3(4) and Section 14(1) of the National Security Act, 1980 and, therefore, any omission on the part of the detaining authority in this regard would vitiate the order of detention.

    8. The materials on record including the grounds of detention (Annexure-A/2) do not reflect that the detenu was informed of his right to make representation to the detaining authority. In Kamaleshkumar Ishwardas Patel v. Union of India (1995) 4 SCC 51, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the provisions of Article 22(5) has the same force and sanctity as in other provisions relating to Fundamental Rights. According to Hon'ble Supreme Court, Article 22(5) imposes a duel obligation on the authority making the order of preventive detention to communicate to the person detained the ground on which the order of detention has been made and afford the person detained an earliest opportunity of making a representation against the order of detention. The Supreme Court further held that the authority that has made the order of detention can also revoke it and this right of the detaining authority is inherent in the power to make the order of detention. The decision in Kamaleshkumar (supra) was also relied upon by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the State of Maharastra v. Santosh Shankar Acharya, (2000) 7 SCC 463 while dealing with a prevention order passed under the provisions of the Maharastra Prevention of Dangerous Activities of Slumlords, Bottleggers, Drug-Offenders and Dangerous Persons Act, 1981. A Division Bench of this Court in Writ Petition (Cri.) No. 16 of 2003 also followed the aforesaid decision in Kalamesh kumar (supra) while dealing with a case under the National Security Act. This Court, in para 10 of the judgment held as follows:

    “10. A bare perusal of the above provisions of law manifestly goes to show that the detenu shall be afforded the earliest opportunity of making a representation against the order of detention to the appropriate Govt. by the detaining authority who has passed the order of detention at the time of communicating the grounds on which such detention has been made and the detaining authority has the power to entertain the representation so received by him till the approval of the order of detention by the State Govt. The language of the Legislature is very clear and unambiguous to the effect that by exercising power under Section 21 of the Clauses Act, the said detaining officer can amend, vary and rescind the order as has been provided under Section 14 of the Act so referred, above. That being so, taking into consideration the above statutory provisions and applying the provisions of law enunciated by the Apex Court in Kamaleshkumar's case (supra) and Santosh Shankar Acharya's case (supra), we are of the firm opinion that the ratio of those two decisions of the Supreme Court is fully applicable in this case. Here, the detaining authority failed to consider and dispose of the detenu's representation dated 31.3.2003 so made to him. The Respondent No. 1 went wrong in not discharging the imperative duty cast on him by the statute and as such the order of detention in the case at hand appears to be illegal and invalid.”

    9. It is, therefore, clear that the provisions in Article 22(5) cast an obligation on the detaining authority to inform the detenu detained under any preventive detention law of his right, of making representation to the detaining authority before approval of the order of detention by the State Government. This is the established principle of law. In the case at hand, the detaining authority apparently did not inform the detenu of his right to make a representation before him (detaining authority). There is, therefore, a serious lapse on the part of the detaining authority. This lapse alone vitiates the order of detention.

    10. The detention order dated 12.8.2003 was served on the detenu in custody on 13.8.2003 The grounds of detention dated 14.8.2003 were furnished to the detenu on 16.8.2003 On 18.3.2003, the petitioner submitted his representation to the State Government through the Superintendent of Manipur Central Jail. The Government of Manipur approved the order of detention by an order passed 19.8.200.3 The representation submitted by the petitioner was rejected on 25.8.2003 There is obviously no delay on the part of the Government of Manipur in dealing with the representation submitted by the writ petitioner. The Advisory Board in its meetings held on 27.9.2003 and 29.9.2003 also affirmed the order of detention. It would appear from above that the representation submitted to the State Government was promptly dealt with and there is no violation of any provision of law in so far the representation to the State Government is concerned.

    11. Next point urged was with regard to the right of the petitioner to make representation to the Central Government. The petitioner admittedly did not file any representation to the Central Government for revocation of the detention order. It appears that the petitioner was not informed of his right to make the representation to the Central Government under Section 14 of the National Security Act read with Article 22(5) of the Constitution. The State respondents in their affidavit did not offer any explanation for this omission/lapse on the part of the detaining authority. The grounds of detention (Annexure-A/2) show that the petitioner was informed of his right to make the representation to the Government of Manipur represented by the Chief Secretary through the Superintendent of Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa within three weeks. There is nothing else in this communication relating to the detenu's right of representation to the Central Government. The order of detention is also completely silent on this. In this connection, we may refer to a Division Bench decision of this Court in Hemanta Nath v. State of Assam, 1998 (2) GLT 344. Relying upon the decisions in Nutan J. Patel v. S.P Prasad (1996) 2 SCC 315 and Kamaleshkumar (supra), this Court held as follows:

    “5. It is an admitted position that the detenu has not been apprised of his right to make a representation to the Central Government so much so as per detention order and grounds of detention as supplied to the detenu. There is no mention of his right to make a representation to the State Government, although subsequently, just within four days of passing the detention order, he was informed through a letter that he could make such representation to the State Government. But there again there is no information so far as the Central Government is concerned. This denial of opportunity to make a representation to the Central Government vitiates the continued detention of the detenu.”

    12. On the fact situation of this case, the ratio available in the above judgment would apply meaning thereby that the order of detention cannot be sustained for omission on the part of the detaining authority in informing the detenu of his right to make a representation before the Central Government within the purview of Section 14 of the National Security Act, 1980.

    13. The order of detention quoted hereinbefore also does not reflect that the detaining authority had applied his mind before issuing the order to the fact that the petitioner was in judicial custody in connection with criminal cases. Mr. Nilamani, learned senior counsel submitted that the settled position of law requires the detaining authority to record satisfaction that the detenu might indulge in prejudicial activities causing threat to the security of the State, if released on bail and that his release on bail is imminent.

    14. It would appear from Surya Prakash Sharma v. State of U.P, 1995 Crl. L.J 2657 (SC) that if the detaining authority is aware of the fact that the detenu is in judicial custody at the time of making the order of detention, such authority must bring on record cogent materials in support of the averments made in the grounds of detention that if the detenu is released on bail, he may indulge in serious offences causing threat to the public order. This decision in Surya Prakash Sharma (supra) is based upon the ratio in Dharmendra Suganchand Chelawat v. Union of India, (1990) 1 SCC 746 : AIR 1990 SC 1196, where the Hon'ble Supreme Court held as follows:

    “19. The decisions referred to above lead to th??? conclusion that an order for detention can be validly passed against a person in custody and for that purpose it is necessary that the grounds of detention must show that (i) the detaining authority was aware of the fact that the detenu is already in detention; and (ii) there were compelling reasons justifying such detention despite the fact that the detenu is already in detention. The expression “compelling reasons” in the context of making an order for detention of a person already in custody implies that there must be cogent material before the detaining authority on the basis of which it may be satisfied that (a) the detenu is likely to be released from custody in the near future, and (b) taking into account the nature of the antecedent activities of the detenu, it is likely that after his release from custody he would indulge in prejudicial activities and it is necessary to detain him in order to prevent him from engaging in such activities.”

    15. From paras 7 and 9 of the grounds of detention (Annexure-A/2), it would appear that the detaining authority was aware that the petitioner was in judicial custody in connection with a number of cases of serious nature. The detaining authority was, therefore, under an obligation to record reasons justifying detention of the detenu already in judicial custody. In this context, the statements made in paragraph 9 of the grounds of detention (Annexure-A/2) are quoted below:

    “9. From the points enumerated above, it is clearly seen that you, Mr. Thanglenmang Hangsing @ Johnson @ Mamang (32) is a dangerous hard core member of so-called gang namely - Kuki Revolutionary Army (KRA) who carried out prejudicial activities which disturbed the public order affecting public tranquility. In view of your prejudicial activities in the proximate past, it is reasonably be anticipated that you would continue to act in the manner prejudicial to the maintenance of public order in case you are released on bail. Thus, the application of normal criminal laws against you is not at all effective and some alternative preventive measure is therefore, immediately called for.”

    16. It would appear that detenu's release or prospect of his imminent release has not been considered by the detaining authority. This amounts to non-application of mind. What is stated by the detaining authority is — “it is reasonably be anticipated that you would continue to act in the manner prejudicial to the maintenance of public order in case you are released on bail”. There is no mention that the detenu was likely to be released on bail immediately for which his detention under the preventive law was the only option with the detaining authority in order to prevent him from indulging in pre judicial activities posing threat to the public order. An order of detention, like the one at hand, cannot be justified having been passed in anticipation of prejudicial activities to the maintenance of public order and, that too, without placing the materials on record on the basis of which the satisfaction has been drawn that the detenu was likely to be released from custody. The decision in Binod Singh v. District Magistrate, Dhanbad, Bihar (1986) 4 SCC 416 and Gulab Mehra v. State of U.P, (1987) 4 SCC 302 also lead to the same conclusion.

    17. It would, therefore, appear that the impugned order of detention suffers from the following vices:

    (i) the detenu was not informed of his right to make representation before the detaining authority before the order of detention was approved by the State Government;

    (ii) the detaining authority did not inform the detenue of his right to make representation to the Central Government as an authority which can revoke the detention order; and

    (iii) non-application of mind by the detaining authority to the fact that the detenu was in custody and his release on bail was imminent.

    18. For the reasons above, the writ petition is allowed and the order of detention dated 12th August, 2003 passed by the District Magistrate, Senapati District, Manipur is hereby quashed. The detenu be released from custody forthwith, if not wanted in connection with any other case.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Thanglenmang Hangsing v. District Magistrate, Senapati District
    (Feb 13, 2004)