Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules 1965.20. Provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule exist in Rule 19(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958.
  • provisions of Article 320(3)(c) of the Constitution of India
  • rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.19. Perusal of Rule 14(18)
  • Rule 9(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958
  • Sub-rule (18) of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
  • ARTICLE 226 A CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965
  • Rule 14 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1985
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules 1965
  • Rule 32 in Part-IX of CCS Rules,
  • Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules,
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule.10.
  • Rule 9 of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1972.
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules.
  • Rule 14(18) of the Rules
  • Rule 14(18)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules 1965.20. Provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule exist in Rule 19(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958.
  • provisions of Article 320(3)(c) of the Constitution of India
  • rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.19. Perusal of Rule 14(18)
  • Rule 9(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958
  • Sub-rule (18) of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
  • ARTICLE 226 A CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965
  • Rule 14 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1985
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules 1965
  • Rule 32 in Part-IX of CCS Rules,
  • Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules,
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule.10.
  • Rule 9 of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1972.
  • Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules.
  • Rule 14(18) of the Rules
  • Rule 14(18)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Anil Kumar, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners (Secretary, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting & Anr.) challenged the order dated 10 July 2008 of the Central Administrative Tribunal (Principal Bench, New Delhi) in OA No. 1431 of 2006 (D.S. Manchanda v. Union of India) which set aside the petitioners' order dated 30 May 2002. The 2002 order, passed after major penalty proceedings under Rule 14 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965, imposed the penalty of withholding further increments until the respondent's retirement with a consequential permanent effect on his pension and gratuity.

Brief factual outline: The respondent joined the Ministry on deputation from the Army in 1985 as Superintending Engineer, was absorbed in 1990 and promoted to Chief Engineer in 1995. Charges were framed against him (initially in a memorandum dated 9 July 1996, amended to include a third charge on 28 July 1998) alleging, inter alia, acceptance of a lesser frame size alternator without prior approval. The respondent denied the charges, sought 77 documents for his defence (which he said were not supplied), and alleged non-supply of key material including a preliminary enquiry report by Sh. V.B. Gupta.

An enquiry was conducted (Commissioner for Departmental Enquiries appointed as Enquiry Officer), an enquiry report implicated the respondent, and the Disciplinary Authority imposed the penalty after considering UPSC advice. The respondent's revision petition was rejected; he then moved the Central Administrative Tribunal which quashed the disciplinary order on multiple grounds including violation of Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules and non-supply of certain documents. The present writ petition challenges the Tribunal's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the enquiry vitiated by non-compliance with Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules (i.e., whether the enquiry officer put to the charged officer the circumstances appearing against him in the evidence when the charged officer did not offer himself as a witness)?
  2. Whether non-supply of copies of CVC recommendations (and/or preliminary enquiry report) to the charged officer vitiates the enquiry, and whether de facto prejudice must be shown for such non-supply to invalidate proceedings?
  3. Whether the penalty imposed (withholding increments affecting retiral benefits) was validly imposed given principles and rules regarding penalties that affect pensionary benefits (including the Tribunal's view on Rule 9 of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1972 concerning presidential prerogative)?

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent denied the charges and alleged that 77 documents vital to his defence were not supplied, including the preliminary enquiry report of Sh. V.B. Gupta relied upon by the Disciplinary Authority.
  • The respondent contended that evidence against him was not put to him in compliance with Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965, since he had not examined himself as a defence witness; this omission vitiated the entire enquiry.
  • He argued that his defensive pleas and contentions were not adequately considered by the Disciplinary Authority.
  • The respondent alleged introduction of a fabricated document (a corrigendum to the amended charge sheet) and claimed unequal treatment compared to another officer (Sh. Lalit Kumar) whose similarly framed charges had been quashed by the Tribunal.
  • He asserted non-supply of UPSC advice and CVC recommendations at both stages, thereby violating principles of natural justice.

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners contended irregularities occurred in the supply/erection work (2 × 500 KVA diesel generator sets) and that the respondent had denied those allegations and sought to be heard in person.
  • They stated an enquiry was held (Omkarmal Kedia as Enquiry Officer), the report partly proved Articles 1 & 3, and the Disciplinary Authority, after considering UPSC advice dated 1 March 2002, imposed the penalty.
  • The petitioners asserted that a copy of the UPSC advice had been provided to the respondent along with the final order in accordance with CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965.
  • Regarding CVC recommendations, petitioners argued that in 1999 there was no provision to supply CVC advice to the charged officer (this provision came into effect only on 28 September 2000) and thus the respondent was not entitled to it for the 1999 enquiry.
  • They maintained that documents demanded were supplied (reflected in order sheet dated 2 April 1998) and that the preliminary enquiry report was confidential and not cited as a document for the charges, therefore not required to be furnished.
  • On Rule 14(18), petitioners argued substantial compliance: the respondent was generally examined on 6 April 1998 and thereafter the defence case was closed; they contended Rule 14(18) had been effectively complied with.
  • Counsel for petitioners relied on Union of India v. Alok Kumar to argue that where a rule is directory, the charged officer must plead and show de facto prejudice and that mere non-supply of CVC recommendations does not automatically vitiate proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ministry of Finance v. S.B. Ramesh (1998) 3 SCC 227 Interpreted Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules as mandatory; where charged officer not examined as defence witness, enquiry officer must put the evidence/circumstances appearing in the evidence to the charged officer; omission vitiates enquiry. The Court relied on the principle to support the Tribunal's finding that omission to put evidence to the respondent vitiated the enquiry and that Rule 14(18) was not validly complied with.
State of Bank v. Union of India (1993) 1 SC 13 Authority that it is obligatory to supply a copy of the CVC report along with the enquiry report to enable the delinquent to defend himself. The Tribunal had relied on this authority to hold that non-supply of a CVC report prejudiced the charged officer; the Court reviewed this reliance in light of other authorities.
Shatrughan Lal v. State of UP, JT 1998 (6) SC 55 Support for the proposition that preliminary enquiry reports may need to be supplied to the charged officer in appropriate circumstances. The Tribunal relied on this decision to hold that non-supply of the preliminary enquiry report prejudiced the respondent; the Court recorded that the Tribunal so found.
Kashinath Dikshita v. Union of India, 1986 (3) SCC 229 Authority cited on the supply of preliminary enquiry material and its relevance to fair defence. The Tribunal relied on this authority in concluding non-supply of preliminary report prejudiced the charged officer; the Court noted the Tribunal's reliance.
Union of India v. Alok Kumar, (2010) 5 SCC 349 Held that where a rule is directory, de facto prejudice must be pleaded and shown; non-supply of CVC second-stage recommendations does not vitiate proceedings unless they were actually considered and prejudicial. Counsel for petitioners relied on Alok Kumar; the Court summarized its holding and used it to assess whether the Tribunal properly examined if CVC notes were actually considered and whether prejudice was shown.
State of A.P. v. Dr. Rahimuddin Kamal, 1997 (3) SCC 505 Referenced in Alok Kumar as an authority on consultation/advice not being mandatory in certain contexts. Cited by the Supreme Court in Alok Kumar; the present Court noted these references when discussing the effect of non-supply of CVC notes.
Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar, 1971 (2) SCC 330 Referenced as supporting authority in the context of consultation rules and prejudice. Noted in the Court's treatment of Alok Kumar and the petitioners' argument regarding requisite prejudice from non-supply of advisory notes.
Union of India v. T.V. Patel, (2007) 4 SCC 785 Held that Article 320(3)(c) (consultation with UPSC) is not mandatory in a manner conferring a right; it is not necessary to provide UPSC advice to the charged officer prior to the final order; a copy with the final order suffices. The petitioners relied on T.V. Patel to argue UPSC advice need not be furnished prior to the final order; the Court discussed this authority in evaluating claims about UPSC advice supply.
State of U.P. v. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava, AIR 1957 SC 192 Constitution Bench authority relied upon in T.V. Patel to hold Article 320(3)(c) does not confer rights on public servants. Referenced in the Court's exposition of T.V. Patel and the limits of recourse available to a charged officer for alleged irregularities in consultation with UPSC.
Moni Shankar v. Union of India, 2008 (1) AJW 479 Illustrates that general/formulaic questions by an enquiry officer (e.g., "Are you satisfied with the enquiry?") do not satisfy analogous procedural rules requiring that evidence/circumstances be put to the charged officer. The Court used this example to support the proposition that mere general questioning does not comply with obligations to put evidence to the charged officer under analogous rules.
D.C. Aggarwal (case relied on by the Tribunal) Relied upon by the Tribunal to hold that non-supply of CVC recommendations can deprive a charged officer of a reasonable opportunity to show cause. The Tribunal invoked this authority to find prejudice from non-supply; the Court noted the Tribunal's reliance but observed that the respondent had not shown that CVC notes were actually considered by the Disciplinary Authority or caused de facto prejudice.
Tarlok Singh (referred to by the Tribunal) Used by the Tribunal in support of the proposition that evidence must be put to a charged officer under Rule 14(18). The Tribunal relied on this decision to buttress its finding regarding Rule 14(18); the Court noted such reliance in affirming that non-compliance with Rule 14(18) vitiates the enquiry.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the record of the Tribunal and the enquiry. Key elements of its step-by-step analysis are:

  1. Admitted factual premise: The respondent did not examine himself as a defence witness. The order dated 6 April 1998 records that he neither examined defence witnesses nor offered himself as a witness.
  2. Obligation under Rule 14(18): The Court emphasized that Rule 14(18) makes it obligatory for the enquiry authority to question the delinquent officer on circumstances appearing against him in the evidence so as to enable explanation and to accord reasonable opportunity (audi alteram partem). The rule was enacted to ensure that the charged officer can rebut circumstances that emerge during enquiry.
  3. Compliance scrutiny: Although the petitioners contended substantial compliance because the respondent was "generally examined" on 6 April 1998, the Court noted that there was no record showing that the specific circumstances or evidence recorded during enquiry were put to the respondent as required by Rule 14(18). The absence of any reference to the evidence or specific circumstances in the general examination led the Court to infer non-compliance.
  4. Precedential support: The Court relied on established precedents (e.g., Ministry of Finance v. S.B. Ramesh and other cited authorities) to hold that non-compliance with Rule 14(18) is a serious procedural lapse that vitiates the enquiry when the charged officer has not given a defence statement or examined himself.
  5. On CVC recommendations and preliminary enquiry report: The Tribunal had held (relying on authorities) that it was obligatory to supply the CVC report and preliminary enquiry report to the charged officer and that non-supply prejudiced the respondent. The petitioners countered with authorities (notably Union of India v. Alok Kumar and T.V. Patel) that emphasize the need to show de facto prejudice where a rule is directory or that consultation/advice (UPSC/CVC) may not confer a right to the charged officer unless the advice was actually considered.
  6. Court's assessment of CVC/UPSC point: The Court observed that the respondent failed to demonstrate that any CVC notes/recommendations were actually taken into consideration by the Disciplinary Authority or that such notes had a prejudicial effect on the outcome. The Court held that the Tribunal should have examined whether such notes existed, whether they were considered, and whether the respondent suffered de facto prejudice from non-furnishing. In the absence of evidence showing that CVC recommendations were considered or caused prejudice, the Court concluded that the Disciplinary Authority's order could not be faulted on this ground alone.
  7. Conclusion on Rule 14(18): Given the admitted non-examination as a defence witness and the absence of record showing that evidence/circumstances were put to the respondent, the Court concluded there was a valid non-compliance of Rule 14(18), and under binding precedent this vitiates the enquiry proceedings.
  8. Remedial outcome: Because the Tribunal's decision to quash the disciplinary proceedings was founded on the established principle regarding Rule 14(18) non-compliance, the Court found no reason to interfere with the Tribunal's order under Article 226.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed; the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal setting aside the punishment awarded to the respondent is not interfered with.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The penalty imposed on the respondent (withholding further increments with consequential impact on pension/gratuity) was set aside by the Tribunal and that decision stands; the petitioners' challenge to the Tribunal's order is dismissed by this Court.
  • Costs: The parties were directed to bear their own costs.
  • Precedential note: The Court applied and discussed existing authorities concerning (a) the mandatory nature of Rule 14(18) where the charged officer does not give a defence statement, and (b) the circumstances under which non-supply of consultative advice (CVC/UPSC) will vitiate proceedings. The Court required demonstration of de facto prejudice where a rule is treated as directory; however, it affirmed that non-compliance with Rule 14(18) will vitiate enquiry in the factual matrix present. The opinion does not purport to create a new legal principle beyond the application of cited precedents.

    Union Of India & Anr. Petitioners v. D.S Manchanda

    ANIL KUMAR, J.

    1. The petitioners, the Secretary, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting & Anr., have challenged the order dated 10th July, 2008 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi in OA No. 1431 of 2006, titled as ‘D.S Manchanda v. Union of India’, allowing the respondent's application and setting aside the order dated 30 May, 2002 passed by the petitioners in pursuance of a major penalty proceedings under Rule 14 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 imposing a penalty in consultation with the UPSC of withholding further increments till date of the respondent's retirement with a permanent impact on his retiral benefits of pension and gratuity.

    2. Brief facts to comprehend the disputes between the parties are that the respondent joined the petitioners on deputation from the Army in the year 1985 as Superintending Engineer and he was absorbed in the year 1990. The respondent was promoted as Chief Engineer in the year 1995.

    3. While working as a Chief Engineer, on 9 July, 1996 he was served with a memorandum of charge sheet alleging that he had accepted the lesser frame size alternator without obtaining prior approval of the competent authority. The charge sheet issued to the respondent on 9 July, 1996 was amended and a 3rd charge was also alleged against him on 28 July, 1998.

    4. The respondent denied the charges made against him and demanded the supply of 77 documents, which according to him, were vital for the defense of the respondent. The respondent alleged that documents were not supplied to him. The Commissioner for Departmental Enquiries was appointed as the Enquiry Officer, who gave the enquiry report implicating the respondent.

    5. On receipt of the copy of the enquiry report, the respondent submitted a representation. According to the respondent, the pleas and contentions raised by him were not considered appropriately by the Disciplinary Authority who passed an order of punishment imposing the penalty of withholding further increments which would have the effect of denying him the last increment prior to his retirement and which would have a permanent impact on his retiral benefits. The respondent also contended that the evidence against him was not put to him in compliance with Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 though he had not appeared as his witness nor had examined any witnesses.

    6. The respondent submitted a revision petition against the order of the Disciplinary Authority dated 30 October, 2002 however, the revision petition was also rejected by the order dated 22nd February, 2005 which decision was communicated to the respondent on 11 May, 2005.

    7. Aggrieved by the punishment imposed upon the respondent, he filed an Original Application being OA No. 1431 of 2006 before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi, contending inter-alia, that the enquiry against him is vitiated as the relevant documents demanded by him were not given which included the preliminary enquiry report submitted by Sh. V.B Gupta, which was relied on by the Disciplinary Authority. It was further contended that although there was no evidence in support of charge No. 3, however, it had been held that the said charge was also substantiated. The technical plea specifically raised by the respondent was that the evidence against him was not put to him in compliance of Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 though he had not examined himself as defense witness and thus, the entire proceedings were vitiated. The respondent further contended that the pleas and contentions raised by him in his defense were not taken into consideration. Emphasis was also laid on the non-supply of the report of UPSC and the recommendations of the CVC at the first stage as well as the second stage, which were not made available to the respondent, and thus, the petitioners violated the principles of natural justice. The respondent categorically pleaded that the petitioners had introduced a fabricated document with a corrigendum to amended charge sheet, with the intention of proving the charges by hook or by crook. The respondent also raised the ground that similar charges were leveled against Sh. Lalit Kumar, Executive Engineer, who was working under the respondent however, the punishment awarded to him had already been quashed by the Tribunal.

    8. The petitioners contested the OA filed by the respondent before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi, contending inter-alia, that irregularities were committed by the respondent and in the work of “Supply and Erection of 2 × 500 KVA diesel generator sets for 2 × 100 KV MW AIR Transmitter at Srinagar” during the period of 1987-1991. This was denied by the respondent and he wanted to be heard in person. Subsequently Sh. Omkarmal Kedia, Commissioner of Departmental Inquiries, Central Vigilance Commission was appointed as the enquiry authority by order dated 28th October, 1997. He submitted his report dated 26 May, 1998 holding that the Article Nos. 1 & 3 of the charges were partly proved against the respondent and article No. 2 was not proved. The copy of the enquiry report was given to the respondent who had submitted his representation dated 21st April, 1999. The Disciplinary Authority after examining the representation of the respondent and other relevant documents had held that the Article Nos. 1 & 3 were partly proved and Article No. 2 was not proved. Thereafter the matter was referred to the UPSC who tendered advice dated 1 March, 2002. After considering the advice of UPSC, all the relevant documents and the facts and circumstances, the Disciplinary Authority imposed the penalty of withholding further increments against the respondent. The petitioners further asserted that a copy of the UPSC advice had been provided to the respondent along with the final order passed against him in accordance with the provisions under the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965. Regarding the CVC recommendation, the petitioners contended that in the year 1999 there was no provision for supply of copy of the CVC advice to the charged officer along with the enquiry report as the provision for supply of a copy of the CVC advice to the charged officer came into force only on 28 September, 2000 vide CVC Instruction dated 28 September, 2000, which was to take effect prospectively. The respondent categorically contended that as per the CCS(CCA) Rules, there is no provision for supply of UPSC advice to the charged officer prior to issue of final order in the disciplinary proceedings. The petitioners also contended that copies of the documents as demanded by the respondent were supplied to him which is reflected from the order sheet dated 2 April, 1998. Regarding the preliminary enquiry, the petitioners contended that the preliminary enquiry made by the police after investigation are usually confidential and are made only for the satisfaction of the competent authority. Since the report of Sh. V.B Gupta was only the preliminary report and as it was not cited as documents in respect of charges, the respondent is not entitled for the same.

    9. Regarding non-compliance of Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules, of putting the evidence against the charged officer in the eventuality of the charged officer not offering himself as a witness, the petitioners contended that the respondent was examined generally on 6 April, 1998. Relying on the order dated 6 April, 1998 before the enquiry officer, it was contended that as the respondent (charged officer) did not offer himself as a witness, he was, therefore, examined by the enquiry officer and thereafter, the defense case was closed. The charged officer was also given an opportunity to submit his written brief. The petitioner, however, did not put the circumstances which came in evidence against the charged officer in compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule.

    10. The Tribunal after considering the pleas and contentions of the parties had held that it was the onerous duty of the enquiry officer to have put to the respondent the circumstances which came in evidence against him for his effective reply thus, there was a clear violation of Rule 14(18) of the Rules which had prejudiced the applicant and which would vitiate the enquiry. The reliance was also placed by the Tribunal on the case of Tarlok Singh who was charges similarly as respondent & on ‘Ministry of Finance v. S.B Ramesh’, JT 1998 (1) 319 laying down the proposition that in compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules 1965 on non examination of the delinquent as defense witness, the evidence brought against him during the course of the enquiry is a must and any omission would vitiate the enquiry and there would be prejudiced caused to the charged officer.

    11. Regarding the recommendation of the CVC, the Tribunal held relying on ‘State of Bank v. Union of India’ (1993) 1 SC 13 that it is obligatory on the authorities to supply a copy of the report of the CVC along with the enquiry report to enable the concerned delinquent to effectively defend the charges against him. Regarding preliminary report also, the Tribunal held that even if there is no demand for preliminary enquiry report, yet copy of the report has to be necessarily served upon the charged officer and reliance was placed on ‘Shatrughan Lal v. State of UP’, JT 1998 (6) SC 55 & Kashinath Dikshita v. Union of India’, 1986 (3) SCC (L&S) 229. The Tribunal also noted that the plea of the petitioners that the preliminary enquiry report was not relied on, cannot be sustained as one of the witnesses deposing in the enquiry had referred to the preliminary enquiry report and in such event non-supply of preliminary report has prejudiced the respondent. The Tribunal also did not approve of the penalty imposed on the respondent as it would have an impact upon his retiral benefits. The Tribunal further held that any penalty effecting any pensionary benefit post retirement is the prerogative of the President only under Rule 9 of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1972. In the circumstances, it was held that imposing penalty in such a manner which would affect the retiral benefits is not be inconsonance with law and thus, the Tribunal set aside the punishment imposed on the respondent.

    12. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties in detail and have also perused the record of the Tribunal which has been produced along with the writ petition. The petitioners have challenged the order of the Tribunal primarily on the ground, contending inter-alia, that Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules has been substantially complied with as a general examination of the respondent was effected by the Enquiry Officer, as is evident from the order dated 6th April, 1998.

    13. The petitioners also contended that provision for supply of the copy of the CVC second stage came into force only with CVC Instruction dated 28 September, 2000 and since the enquiry was conducted in the year 1999, the respondent was therefore, not entitled for a copy of the CVC report. Regarding the preliminary enquiry report, it was contended that it is not mandatory to supply the copy of the report of the preliminary enquiry. In the circumstances, it was contended that there has been no violation of any of the rules, nor principles of natural justice had been violated and the order of the Tribunal setting aside the punishment imposed upon the respondent is liable to be set aside.

    14. The learned counsel for the petitioners, Mr. Sudan has relied on (2010) 5 SCC 349, ‘Union of India v. Alok Kumar’ to contend that where the rule is merely directory, the element of de facto prejudice needs to be pleaded and shown. The learned counsel also contended that failure to supply the copy of the CVC report at the second stage advice would not vitiate the enquiry. According to him in the present case, it has not been shown by the respondent as to what prejudice has been caused to him on account of non-supply of the CVC recommendations and thus, enquiry report would not be vitiated.

    15. In Alok Kumar (Supra), the Supreme Court had considered whether it is the duty of the Disciplinary authority to furnish the report of CVC and whether supply of CVC report arises out of a statutory rule or in consonance with the principles of natural justice and whether non-supply of such a report would cause any prejudice to the officer concerned. In the facts and circumstances of the case, it was held that there was nothing on record to show that CVC recommendations had actually been taken into consideration and that the same had affected the mind of the Disciplinary authority while considering the defense of the delinquent officer and imposing punishment upon him. The Supreme Court had held that unless such reports/recommendations were actually considered and had some prejudicial effect to the interest of the delinquent officer, it would not be necessary for the Court to interfere with the departmental enquiry. In Alok Kumar (Supra), the Supreme Court therefore, did not vitiate the enquiry proceeding on the ground that a copy of the CVC second stage recommendations/reports though were not provided to the charged officer, however, it was not taken into consideration by the Disciplinary Authority. Paras 78 & 79 at page 376 are as under:-

    “78. No rule has been brought to our notice where it is a mandatory requirement for the disciplinary authority to consult the vigilance officer and take the said report into consideration before passing any order. If that was the position, the matter would have been different.

    79. In the present case, firstly, no such rule has been brought to our notice and secondly, there is nothing on record to show that the alleged notes of the CVC were actually taken into consideration and the same effected or tainted the findings or mind of the authority while passing the orders of punishment. Thus, in our view, the findings of the Tribunal cannot be sustained in law. Unless the Rules so require, advice of the CVC is not binding. The advice tendered by the CVC, is to enable the disciplinary authority to proceed in accordance with law. In absence of any specific rule, that seeking advice and implementing thereof is mandatory, it will not be just and proper to presume that there is prejudice to the concerned officer. Even in the cases where the action is taken without consulting the Vigilance Commission, it necessarily will not vitiate the order of removal passed after inquiry by the departmental authority. Reference in this regard can also be made to the judgment of this Court in the cases of State of A.P v. Dr. Rahimuddin Kamal: 1997 (3) SCC 505 and Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar: 1971 (2) SCC 330.”

    16. Though the Tribunal has held relying on D.C Aggarwal's case (supra) that non-supply of CVC recommendations has deprived the respondent of a reasonable opportunity to show cause against the enquiry report which ultimately affected the substantial rights of the respondent to effectively defend himself. However, the learned counsel for the respondent is unable to show as to how the CVC recommendations were taken into consideration by the Disciplinary authority, and how the case of the respondent has been prejudiced. It was incumbent upon the Tribunal to have considered whether there were any such CVC Notes or recommendations which had a direct bearing on the enquiry in question and whether such recommendations or Notes were actually taken into considerations by the Disciplinary authority while passing the impugned order and whether the respondent had suffered de facto prejudice as a result of non-furnishing of advice. In absence of these factors, the order of the Disciplinary authority imposing penalty on the respondent cannot be faulted, nor can the order of the Tribunal to this effect be sustained on this ground that the copy of notes/recommendation of CVC were not provided to the respondent.

    17. The learned counsel for the petitioner has also relied on (2007) 4 SCC 785, ‘Union of India v. T.V Patel’ holding that where the Disciplinary authority sought advice of the UPSC before imposition of penalty on the delinquent officer, it was not necessary for the Disciplinary authority to make available the copy of the advice tendered by the UPSC to the delinquent officer so as to enable him to make effective representation to the punishment proposed, on the ground that the provisions of Article 320(3)(c) of the Constitution of India are not mandatory and it does not confer any right on the public servant, so that the absence of consultation or any irregularity in consultation process or in furnishing a copy of the advice tendered by the UPSC, if any, does not afford the delinquent Government servant a cause of action in a Court of law. In this case the Disciplinary authority had sought advice of the UPSC which was tendered. After the Disciplinary authority passed the order, a copy of the advice tendered by the UPSC was also sent along with the copy of the final order imposing the penalty on the delinquent officer. In the circumstances, the question to be determined by the Supreme Court was whether a copy of advice tendered by the UPSC is to be furnished along with the order of penalty or before passing an order imposing final penalty. Referring to Rule 32 in Part-IX of CCS Rules, it was held that the rule contemplating “along with a copy of the order passed in the case by the authority making the order” would mean the final order passed by the authority imposing the penalty on the delinquent government servant. Consequently, relying on the judgment of the Constitution Bench in AIR 1957 SC 192, State Of U.P v. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava, it was held that the provisions of Article 320(3)(c) of the Constitution of India are not mandatory and they do not confer any rights on the public servant so that the absence of consultation or any irregularity in consultation process or in furnishing a copy of the advice tendered by the UPSC, if any, does not afford the delinquent Government servant a cause of action in a Court of law. Para 25 at page 793 of T.V Patel (Supra) is as under:-

    “25. In view of the law settled by the Constitution Bench of this Court in the case of Srivastava (supra) we hold that the provisions of Article 320(3)(c) of the Constitution of India are not mandatory and they do not confer any rights on the public servant so that the absence of consultation or any irregularity in consultation process or furnishing a copy of the advice tendered by the UPSC, if any, does not afford the delinquent government servant a cause of action in a court of law.”

    18. The next contention on behalf of the petitioner is about the non-compliance of the Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. According to the petitioners, Rule 14(18) was substantially complied with. Perusal of the record, however, reveals that it is an admitted case that the respondent did not examine himself as a witness. Since the respondent had not examined himself as witness, it was incumbent upon the enquiry officer to put evidence adduced against the respondent during the enquiry to him in compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. The said rule had been enacted with a view that whatever evidence comes in the enquiry, explanation may be sought to rebut the circumstances, which would be in consonance with the principle of reasonable opportunity and audi alterm partum as inbuilt in the principles of natural justice. On perusal of the record, the order dated 6th April 1998 is categorical in stating that the respondent had neither examined any defense witnesses nor had he offered himself as a witness. Thereafter the respondent was generally examined by the Inquiry Officer, however whether or not the circumstances that came in evidence against the respondent was put to him has not been shown. In similar matters involving the same purchases, the charged officers were only put the charges which were framed against the charged officer. In the circumstances, in absence of any thing it is to be inferred that the evidence which was recorded during the enquiry was not put to the respondent in compliance with Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.

    19. Perusal of Rule 14(18) clearly reveals that it is obligatory upon the enquiry authority to question the delinquent officer on the circumstances appearing against him in the evidence, for the purpose of enabling him to explain any circumstance. As there is no reference to the evidence brought on record or circumstances appearing against the applicant, hence the general examination, a copy of which has also not been produced despite ample opportunity to the petitioner, it is apparent there was not a valid compliance of Rule 14(18) of the CCS(CCA) Rules 1965.

    20. Provisions analogous to Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rule exist in Rule 19(21) of Railway Servant (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1958. In the matter of Moni Shankar v. Union of India, 2008 (1) AJW 479, an enquiry proceeding was conducted in which the following questions were put to the Charged Officer: “please state if you plead guilty?” ; “Do you wish to submit your oral or written arguments? ; “Are you satisfied with the enquiry proceeding” and “Can I conclude the enquiry?”, were held to be not in compliance of rule 9(21) of railway servant (discipline & appeal) rules, 1958 as such type of questions did not reveal the evidence adduced in support of charges against the charged officer.

    21. In Ministry of Finance v. S.B Ramesh, (1998) 3 SCC 227 the Supreme Court had held the Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1985 to be mandatory. The Apex Court had upheld the decision of the Tribunal holding that the order of the Disciplinary Authority was based on no evidence and that the findings were perverse, on the reasoning that even if the Enquiry Officer had set the applicant ex parte and recorded the evidence, he should have adjourned the hearing to another date to enable the applicant to participate in the enquiry thereafter. Or even if the Enquiry Authority did not choose to give the applicant an opportunity to cross-examine the witness examined in support of the charge, he should have been given an opportunity to the applicant to appear and then proceeded to question him under Sub-rule (18) of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules. The omission to do this was construed to be a serious error committed by the Enquiry Authority. This also cannot be disputed that if the charged officer has examined himself as a witness then it will not be obligatory to examine the charged officer under Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules. However, in the absence of any defense statement by the charged official, it was mandatory on the part of the enquiry officer to examine him under Rule 14(18), and the non-compliance of which will vitiate the enquiry proceedings.

    22. Consequently, the order of the Tribunal quashing the enquiry proceeding on account of non-compliance of Rule 14(18) of CCS(CCA) Rules 1965 by not putting the evidence adduced before the enquiry officer in support of the three articles of charge to the charged officer vitiates the enquiry proceeding, cannot be termed to be illegal or un-sustainable so as to require any interference by this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

    23. In the circumstances, the order of the Tribunal setting aside the punishment awarded to the respondent does not require any interference in the facts and circumstances of the case and the writ petition is therefore, dismissed. The parties are however, left to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India & Anr. Petitioners v. D.S Manchanda
    (Mar 10, 2011)