Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 of the Code.8. Rule 4 of Order XXXIX of the Code
  • Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Code).
  • Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 of the Code
  • Order XXXIX Rule 4 of the Code
  • Order XXXIX Rule 4,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 of the Code.8. Rule 4 of Order XXXIX of the Code
  • Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Code).
  • Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 of the Code
  • Order XXXIX Rule 4 of the Code
  • Order XXXIX Rule 4,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellants filed a suit for permanent injunction restraining infringement of Indian Patent Number 240893 related to “Asymmetrical Beams for Spectrum Efficiency,” along with claims for delivery up, rendition of account of profits, and damages against Respondent No. 1. An ex-parte injunction was granted on 4 October 2010, and Defendants No. 2 and 3 were impleaded after it was represented that Respondent No. 1 was selling the impugned product to them. Respondent No. 1 challenged the injunction via a Letters Patent Appeal (LPA), which was disposed of on 15 November 2010, remanding the case for compliance with Order XXXIX of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) and the principles clarified in A. Venkatasubbiah Naidu v. S. Chellappan.

Subsequently, Respondent No. 1 moved an application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 CPC, alleging that the Appellants had made false or misleading statements by filing a downloaded patent specification instead of a certified copy, and that the Appellants were aware of Respondent No. 1’s prior use of the product. The learned Single Judge suspended/vacated the ex-parte injunction without issuing notice to the Appellants or allowing them to respond to the application under Rule 4.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the ex-parte injunction granted under Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 CPC should be vacated under Order XXXIX Rule 4 CPC on the ground of alleged false or misleading statements by the Appellants.
  2. Whether the Appellants were entitled to notice and an opportunity to respond before the injunction was suspended/vacated under Order XXXIX Rule 4 CPC.
  3. The procedural propriety of the learned Single Judge’s order suspending/vacating the injunction without considering the Appellants’ affidavit and without affording them a hearing.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Indian Patent Office takes 20-40 days to supply a certified copy of the granted patent specification, making it impractical to await the certified copy before seeking urgent ex-parte relief.
  • The specification filed was never represented as a certified copy; the source was clearly indicated as downloaded from the official Patent Office website.
  • An affidavit comparing the downloaded specification and the certified granted specification was filed but not considered by the learned Single Judge, demonstrating no material difference in claims or undue benefit gained.
  • The Appellants had no opportunity to respond to the application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 CPC, which contained serious allegations against them.
  • The impleadment of Reliance Communication (Respondent No. 2) was not based on any pleading by the Appellants, and no status quo order was dictated in open court regarding this party.
  • The Appellants denied knowingly presenting filtered or selective information, suppressing material particulars, fabricating documents, or misstating facts.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The Court should not delve into the merits at this stage; if a party is found to have made false or misleading statements relating to material particulars, the injunction must be vacated.
  • The Appellants had dealings with Respondent No. 1 and were aware of prior use of the impugned product, undermining their claims.
  • No written statement or reply was filed by Respondent No. 1 to the original injunction application, but the serious allegations warranted vacating the injunction.
  • It was contended that the Appellants did not request an opportunity to file a reply during hearings on the application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 CPC.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A. Venkatasubbiah Naidu v. S. Chellappan, (2000) 7 SCC 695 Clarification of procedural compliance under Order XXXIX CPC for injunctions The Court remanded the case for compliance with Order XXXIX CPC as clarified in this precedent, ensuring proper procedural safeguards in injunction proceedings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court recognized that Rule 4 of Order XXXIX CPC empowers the Court to vacate an injunction if a false or misleading statement relating to a material particular is made without notice to the opposite party. However, the Court emphasized that the Appellants were not given an opportunity to respond or file a written reply to the serious allegations made in the application under Rule 4. The affidavit filed by the Appellants, which was intended to demonstrate no material difference between the downloaded and certified specifications, was not considered by the learned Single Judge.

Given the absence of the Appellants' written response on record and the lack of notice, the Court found it unfair to uphold the impugned order. The Court noted the importance of affording an opportunity to respond to serious allegations even in expedited proceedings under Order XXXIX. The Court observed that while the learned Single Judge’s prompt disposal of the application was legally required, justice demands that a party be allowed to controvert or respond to vital facts.

Consequently, the Court set aside the order suspending/vacating the injunction and directed that the learned Single Judge decide the application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 afresh after giving the Appellants an opportunity to respond.

Holding and Implications

The Court’s final ruling was to set aside the impugned order suspending/vacating the ex-parte injunction and remand the matter for fresh consideration of the application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 CPC after affording the Appellants an opportunity to file a response.

The direct effect is that the learned Single Judge must reconsider the application under Rule 4 with proper procedural fairness. No costs were imposed. The Court did not establish any new precedent but reinforced the procedural principle that even in expedited injunction proceedings, parties must be given a fair opportunity to respond to serious allegations before an injunction is vacated.

    Tenxc Wireless Inc. & Anr. v. Andrew Llc & Ors. S

    G.P Mittal, J.:— The Appellants assail the order dated 30th November, 2010 passed by the learned Single Judge whereby the exparte injunction granted by the learned Single Judge vide order dated 4 October, 2010 was suspended/vacated and the case was fixed for completion of the pleadings of the parties with direction to the Respondents to file their written statements within 30 days from the date of the said order.

    2. A suit for permanent injunction restraining infringement of registered Indian Patent Number 240893 for an invention entitled “Asymmetrical Beams for Spectrum Efficiency”, delivery up, rendition of account of profits and damages was filed against Respondent No. 1. The matter came up for hearing on the application under order xxxix rules 1 & 2 of the code of civil procedure (code). On 4 October, 2010, the learned Single Judge ordered impleadment of Defendants No. 2 and 3 (Respondents No. 2 & 3 herein) as it was represented on behalf of the Appellants that Respondent No. 1 was in the process of selling its impugned product to Reliance Communication and Tata Teleservices Respondent Nos. 2 & 3 respectively. On information of an ex-parte injunction order passed against it, Respondent No. 1 preferred an LPA which came to be disposed of by this Court on 15.11.2010 The case was remanded for compliance of provisions of Order XXXIX as laid down in the Code as well as clarified in A. Venkatasubbiah Naidu v. S. Chellappan, (2000) 7 SCC 695.

    3. An application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 of the Code was moved by the Respondent No. 1 which came to be disposed of by the impugned order. The grievance of the Appellants is that the order of injunction was suspended/vacated by the learned Single Judge mainly on the ground that as per the case of the Appellants the Patent Certificate by Patent Office had been given to the Appellants on 9.06.2010 yet the Appellants had deliberately not produced the specification in respect of which the product of the Appellants had been patented in as much as the Appellants instead of filing the documents annexed to the Patent Certificate dated 9.06.2010 had filed the documents in respect of the Patent which had been downloaded from the site of the Patent Office. It had also been alleged in the application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 of the Code that the Appellants had dealings with Respondent No. 1 as he had entered into Agreement for using Respondent No. 1's technology called “Remote Electrical Tilt” and thus the Appellants' Company was aware that the Respondent No. 1 Company and its subsidiary had been using the impugned product for the last more than two years before filing of the suit.

    4. Mr. Saikrishna Rajagopal learned counsel for the Appellants has tried to explain that Indian Patent Office takes anywhere between 20-40 days to supply certified copy of the granted Patent Specification and therefore, it was not feasible for Appellant No. 1 to await receipt of certified copy of granted specification because it was praying for an urgent ex-parte ad interim order. He also tried to point out as to how Appellant No. 1 Canadian Attorneys had instructed the Indian Patent Agent to urgently obtain and transfer certified copy of the complete specification as granted. He explained that no information was withheld nor there was any question of any forgery or making false or misleading statement.

    5. It has been submitted that the specification filed by the Appellants along with the Plaint was never represented as certified copy of the granted specification and the source from which it was obtained was prominently mentioned on the document itself. It is also the case of the Appellants that comparison of the corresponding claims between the complete specification downloaded from the official website of Indian Patent Office and the complete specification as granted was also made in the Affidavit of Mr. Rajiv Pancholy filed on 28.09.2010 (not considered by the learned Single Judge) with a view to satisfy the learned Single Judge that the Appellants had not gained any undue benefit by filing the downloaded specification as against the certified copy of the granted specification.

    6. Regarding impleadment of Reliance Communication, it has been pointed out that status quo order was not dictated by the learned Single Judge in the open Court and therefore the Appellants could not point out to the learned Single Judge that there was no pleading in the Suit against Respondent No. 2. It has been submitted that impleadment of Reliance Communication in the Suit was not pursuant to any pleading by the Appellants and the Appellants in the circumstances had no opportunity to point out the error in the order.

    7. Admittedly, notice of the application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 of the Code was not issued to the Appellants so as to get its response thereon. Respondent No. 1 who was aggrieved by the ex-parte injunction order has admittedly neither filed the written statement nor any reply to the application under order xxxix rules 1 & 2 of the code.

    8. Rule 4 of Order XXXIX of the Code empowers the Court to vacate an order of injunction if the party has made a false or misleading statement in relation to a material particular and the injunction was granted without giving notice to the opposite party.

    9. The Appellants have a grievance against the impugned order mainly on the ground that the Appellants had not been afforded the opportunity of filing the written response to the Application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 of the Code moved by Respondent No. 1 nor the Affidavit filed by Mr. Rajiv Pancholy was considered. If the learned Single Judge would have had the material, it would have been established that :-

    a. The Appellants have not knowingly presented filtered and selective information.

    b. The Appellants have not suppressed or concealed material particulars.

    c. The Appellants have not fabricated any document.

    d. The Appellants have not mis-stated any facts.

    e. There is no material difference in the principal independent claims in both versions of the complete specification; and consequently f. The Appellants have not gained any undue benefit by filing the complete specification downloaded from the official website of the Indian Patent Office.

    10. Mr. Dushyant Dave, learned senior counsel for the Respondents, however, supports the impugned order on the ground that the Court is not to go into the merits of the case and once a party is found to have made a false or misleading statement in relation to a material particular an injunction order is bound to be vacated.

    11. In the Application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 of the Code very serious allegations had been leveled against the Appellants. It was highly unfair to have condemned the Appellants and accuse it of making false statement or putting up filtered and selective information without obtaining a written response from the Appellants. Since written response of the Appellants of the Application filed under Order XXXIX Rule 4 of the Code is not on record, we are unable to appreciate the respective contentions raised on behalf of the parties and the findings reached by the learned Single Judge.

    12. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has clarified that the discretion exercised by the lower Court should not be interfered with by the Appellate Court merely because it favours a differently plausible view. It has been vehemently contended before us by Mr Sai Krishna, Advocate, that despite fervent requests made to the Learned Single Judge to permit the Appellant/Plaintiff to file a Reply to the subject Application under Order XXXIX Rule 4, this request was ignored. Mr Dave, learned Senior Counsel for the Defendant/Respondent has equally vehemently submitted that such a request was not voiced by the Appellant on any of the days when the Application was listed for hearing. Unfortunately, record of the proceedings are reticent on this point. Since the pervading perception of the Learned Single Judge was that the Plaintiff had knowingly made false or misleading statements in relation to material particulars, the Plaintiff should have been afforded an opportunity to controvert the Defendant's statements. We should not be understood to find fault with the speedy dispatch with which the Learned Single Judge had decided the Application under Order XXXIX Rule 4. This is in fact what law requires. However, the interest of justice may be undermined if an opportunity to controvert or respond to vital facts is not given. It is for this reason that we have taken the present view.

    13. Even if, the learned Single Judge had preferred to keep the application under order xxxix rules 1 & 2 of the code pending, it was essential to obtain a response from the Appellants in respect of serious allegations. In this view of the matter, the impugned order cannot be sustained. The same is accordingly set aside. The learned Single Judge may decide the application under Order XXXIX Rule 4 of the Code afresh after giving the opportunity as aforesaid. No costs.

    14. Pending applications also stand disposed of accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tenxc Wireless Inc. & Anr. v. Andrew Llc & Ors. S
    (Dec 22, 2010)