Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 DHC 1362
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • clause (b) of Sub-section (1) of Section 4;(b)
  • Sections 18 and 19 of the RTI Act 2005
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • Section 19(8)(b) of the RTI Act.16.
  • Information Act, 2005 (RTI Act)
  • Section 2(f) of the RTI Act
  • Section 2 (j) of the RTI Act
  • Section 19(8)(b), RTI Act
  • Section 19(1) to (8).
  • Section 19(8)(b)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 DHC 1362
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • clause (b) of Sub-section (1) of Section 4;(b)
  • Sections 18 and 19 of the RTI Act 2005
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • Section 19(8)(b) of the RTI Act.16.
  • Information Act, 2005 (RTI Act)
  • Section 2(f) of the RTI Act
  • Section 2 (j) of the RTI Act
  • Section 19(8)(b), RTI Act
  • Section 19(1) to (8).
  • Section 19(8)(b)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition by National Thermal Power Corporation (NTPC) challenges an order dated 16 June 2008/2009 of the Central Information Commission (CIC) arising from an RTI appeal filed by Shri Mohd. Samad Khan, an oustee affected by the Farakka Super Thermal Power Project. The Respondent claimed entitlement to rehabilitation employment under NTPC's scheme for land oustees and pursued information under the Right to Information Act, 2005 (RTI Act) seeking a copy of a "field survey report."

NTPC informed the Respondent in 2006 that it was not aware of any such field survey report. The Appellate Authority reconfirmed non-availability and the Respondent appealed to the CIC. The CIC in an earlier order (17 December 2008) remanded to the CPIO to search for the survey report. The CPIO reported in January 2008 that no such report could be found. The Respondent again approached the CIC, which in the impugned order (16 June 2008/2009) directed, inter alia, that NTPC furnish details of communications with the Ministry of Power, pay compensation under Section 19(8)(b) of the RTI Act for losses suffered, and take remedial measures for all land oustees of the Farakka Project.

This Court stayed the CIC's directions in paras 16(ii) and 16(iii) and heard the petition. The Attorney General and counsel for the Respondent made submissions. The NTPC indicated no objection to complying with the CIC direction in para 16(i) and stated that the information had in fact been furnished, which the Respondent denied receiving. The Court directed NTPC's counsel to provide another set of documents and directed payment of Rs. 5,000 to the Respondent towards his costs in staying back in Delhi. The petition was disposed of with the CIC's directions in paras 16(ii) and (iii) set aside.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Central Information Commission exceeded its jurisdiction under Sections 18 and 19 of the RTI Act in issuing the directions contained in paras 16(ii) and 16(iii) of the impugned order.
  2. Whether the CIC had the power under Section 19(8)(b) of the RTI Act to direct NTPC to pay the Respondent compensation equivalent to the minimum scale of pay for an offered post (or alternatively Rs. 11,28,000 for an assumed peon/attendant post for a specified period), without a prior factual finding that relevant information was withheld.
  3. Whether the CIC could issue broad remedial directions requiring NTPC to take general measures to redress the grievances of all land oustees of the Farakka Project (para 16(iii)).
  4. Whether the CIC correctly determined, as a factual matter, that a "field survey report" existed and was withheld by NTPC, thereby justifying compensation under Section 19(8)(b).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (NTPC) Arguments

  • The CIC exceeded its jurisdiction under Sections 18 and 19 of the RTI Act by issuing the directions in paras 16(ii) and 16(iii) of the impugned order.
  • The power under Section 19(8)(b) does not extend to directing payment of the sums ordered by the CIC (including payment equivalent to minimum pay scales or Rs. 11,28,000), and the CIC could not have made those monetary awards.
  • The CIC had no occasion to issue broad directions requiring NTPC to take steps to alleviate economic difficulties of other land oustees (i.e., para 16(iii) was beyond its remit).

Respondent's Arguments

  • The CIC's directions were justified in the factual background of repeated attempts to obtain information and the Respondent's long wait for justice.
  • The Respondent, being poor and deprived of timely redress, was entitled to pursue relief under the RTI Act; the CIC's monetary direction is said to be justified by Section 19(8)(b) of the RTI Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, relying on the text of the RTI Act and the factual record before the CIC:

  1. Scope of CIC's function under the RTI Act: The Court observed that the CIC's core role is to ensure citizens are not unfairly deprived of information held by a public authority and accessible under the Act, subject to availability of the information and control by the public authority. The Court referenced the statutory definitions—Section 2(f) (definition of "information") and Section 2(j) (definition of "right to information")—to situate the CIC's remit.
  2. Determination of factual foundation before awarding compensation: The Court emphasized that before invoking compensation powers under Section 19(8)(b), the CIC must first determine whether the public authority in fact held and unfairly denied the information. In this case, the CIC itself described the existence of the survey report as a "disputed" question; there was no conclusive factual finding that NTPC possessed a survey report and had denied it.
  3. Nature and limits of Section 19(8)(b): The Court interpreted Section 19(8)(b) as empowering the CIC to require a public authority to compensate a complainant "for any loss or other detriment suffered" due to denial of information. The scope of this power is tied to loss caused "on account of the denial of such information." Thus, the CIC must assess and make a (even approximate) finding on the extent of loss attributable to the denial before awarding compensation.
  4. Application to the present case: Because the CIC made no finding that NTPC had in its records the survey report which it unfairly withheld, it lacked the essential factual predicate to quantify loss and award compensation. Consequently, the Court concluded there was no occasion for the CIC to issue the monetary direction in para 16(ii) or the broad remedial direction in para 16(iii).
  5. Resulting scope of permissible CIC direction: The Court accepted that the CIC may direct a public authority to produce or search for information and take administrative steps listed under Section 19(8)(a), but stressed that monetary compensation and broad policy-like remedial directions require a proper factual and legal basis within the statutory scheme.
  6. Procedural disposition: The Court set aside paras 16(ii) and 16(iii) of the CIC order as being outside the CIC's jurisdiction under the RTI Act. The Court explicitly refrained from expressing any opinion on the merits of the Respondent's underlying employment claim, leaving that to the appropriate authority or court if the Respondent pursues remedies there.
  7. Interim compliance and cost direction: The Attorney General informed the Court that NTPC had no objection to providing the information ordered in para 16(i) and that such information had already been furnished (which the Respondent denied). To resolve the immediate access issue, the Court directed NTPC's counsel to furnish another set of the documents to the Respondent by 10 March 2010 and ordered NTPC to pay Rs. 5,000 to the Respondent towards costs for staying in Delhi to receive the information.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Court set aside the Central Information Commission's directions contained in para 16(ii) and para 16(iii) of the impugned order as being beyond the scope of the CIC's powers under the RTI Act.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • NTPC is no longer bound by the CIC's monetary award and the broad remedial directions in paras 16(ii) and 16(iii) of the impugned order; those directions have been struck down by this Court.
  • The portion of the CIC order in para 16(i) (requiring NTPC/CPIO to furnish details relating to references made by the Ministry of Power and to permit inspection of relevant documents) remains effective and the Court directed compliance: NTPC's counsel was ordered to provide another set of the documents to the Respondent by 10 March 2010 and to pay Rs. 5,000 to the Respondent as costs for his stay in Delhi to receive the information.
  • The petition was disposed of in the terms recorded by the Court; an order dasti (oral order) was recorded.

Broader legal implications: The Court explicitly limited its ruling to the statutory powers of the CIC under the RTI Act and made no new determination on the merits of the Respondent's claim for employment. The Court noted that any adjudication on the employment claim by appropriate authorities or courts must proceed without being influenced by observations in this order or the impugned CIC order.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    N.T.P.C Ltd. v. Mohd. Samad Khan .

    1. The challenge by the Petitioner National Thermal Power Corporation (NTPC) in this writ petition is to an order dated 16th June, 2009 passed by the Central Information Commission (CIC) in an appeal filed by the Respondent Shri Mohd. Samad Khan.

    2. The Respondent is one of the ‘oustees’ affected by the setting up of the Farakka Super Thermal Power Project by the Petitioner at Murshidabad (West Bengal). In addition to the payment of compensation for acquisition of the land belonging to the Petitioner in terms of Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (LA), the NTPC had a scheme of rehabilitation under which employment would be offered to any one family member on the basis of educational eligibility according to the rules of the NTPC and in light of the technical experience.

    3. A letter dated 28th December, 1984 was addressed to the Petitioner by the NTPC asking him to submit a form with all the necessary particulars for the purposes of considering the claims for employment. The Respondent has enclosed with his reply copies of the letters dated 22nd July 1986, 18th June, 1988, 20th August 1990 sent by the NTPC to him directing him to appear for the written tests for the post of Store Keeper Grade IV and a letter dated 8th May, 1991 calling him for an interview for the same post. According to the NTPC, the Petitioner was called for interview for the post of Store Keeper but was not found suitable.

    4. It appears that the Respondent approached the Minister of State, Parliamentary Affairs and Sales Tax (Finance), Government of Bihar who then addressed a letter dated 29th November, 1991 to the NTPC in which he alluded to information received by him to the effect that the Respondent's name had been empanelled and that he had been assured of being granted an appointment against the vacancies in the near future. It is not clear whether the Respondent followed up the matter thereafter.

    5. On 8th August, 2006 the Respondent addressed an application under the Right to Information Act, 2005 (RTI Act) to the Chief Public Information Officer (CPIO) of the NTPC praying that “he be served a copy of the field survey report undertaken by the officials of the Project”. By its letter dated 6th September, 2006, the CPIO, NTPC informed the Petitioner that as per the available records “NTPC Farakka is not aware of any ‘Field Survey’ of land oustees.”

    6. The Petitioner filed an appeal on 14th November, 2006 to the Appellate Authority (RTI), NTPC. By a response dated 11th December, 2006 the Appellate Authority informed the Petitioner that “it has been reconfirmed that no such field survey has been conducted and hence no report is available.” Thereafter the Respondent appealed to the CIC.

    7. On 17th December, 2008 the CIC passed an order, inter alia, observing and directing as under:

    “The evidence is conclusive that the NTPC has made endeavors to provide jobs to all the land oustees but it has not been able to absorb at least 42 affected persons. At the instance of the Minister's intervention, a field survey was also conducted in 2005, in which the appellant participated. The appellant has. asked for a copy of the survey report, which has been denied on the ground of its non-availability. As agreed between the parties, the case is remanded to the CPIO, who should make a fresh attempt to search the relevant documents, mainly the Survey Report, as asked for by the appellant, within one month from the date of issue of this decision and furnish its copy to the appellant, failing which suitable action would be taken by the Commission in the matter, including institution of a high powered inquiry to unearth the truth. The appellant is free to approach the Commission again if he is not satisfied with the compliance of the above decision by the CPIO.”

    8. Pursuant to the above decision, the CPIO by a letter dated 24th January, 2008 informed the Respondent as under:

    “We made afresh attempt to search the relevant document and also checked with the concerned NTPC Project, i.e Farakka STPS, but no such Field survey report could be found.”

    9. This led to the Respondent again approaching the CIC.

    10. In the impugned order dated 16th June, 2008, the CIC observed in para 9 as under:

    “The question whether a formal ‘field survey report’ was prepared or not is disputed between the parties. The respondent has however not disclosed the details of the communication, which it had with the Ministry.”

    11. Thereafter the following directions were issued:

    “16. In view of the foregoing, the following decision notice is issued—

    (i) The CPIO is directed to furnish the entire details relating to the reference made by the Ministry of Power to the NTPC alongwith the replies given to the MOP, including the ‘file notings’ in the matter, within 15 working days from the date of issue of this decision. The appellant, along with Shri Gautam Kaul, who was present during the hearings, would be free to inspect the relevant documents on the date and time mutually convenient to the parties, within 15 working days from the date of issue of this decision.

    (ii) The NTPC is required to pay a suitable compensation under Section 19(8)(b) of the Act for all kinds of losses and other detriment suffered by the appellant in the process of securing justice through different ways, including accessing information that could reveal the fact about his claim for the right to work. The appellant has not only sacrificed the land, the prices of which have increased manifold, and has also missed the opportunity of working and earnings, he has been deprived of timely justice for want of information or lack of accountability of the respondent, as discussed above.

    The NTPC is therefore directed to pay an amount equal to the total payments made so far to an employee, ‘land oustee’, who was offered employment (in the first batch) in the minimum scale of pay plus admissible allowances, in pursuance of the circular issued on 28.12.1984 to the appellant.

    Alternatively, on the assumption that the respondent was at least offered the job of a peon/attendant, keeping in view his physical fitness, including educational qualifications, he should have been paid, on an average amount of Rs. 4,000/- per month for 282 months (since January 1985 to June, 2008), which comes to Rs. 11,28,000/- (Rupees eleven lakh and twenty eight thousand).

    The Chairman, NTPC, is directed to arrange to pay the above amount, on behalf of the respondent, through a bank draft in favour of the appellant on or before July 30, 2008, failing which interest at the rate of 10 percent per annum would be applicable.

    (iii) The Chairman, NTPC is also directed to explore the ways and measures to redress the grievances of all land oustees of the Farakka Project in terms of the understanding reached between the parties on the issue of rehabilitation of the affected persons. In view of its social responsibility and the national policy to empower the deprived groups, the NTPC should take urgent steps to alleviate the economic difficulties of land oustees, the costs of which to the company would be negligible in relation to its total profits since its inception. A compliance report should be submitted to the Commission within three months as a testimony of its accountability, which is a major concern of the RTI Act.”

    12. On 29th July, 2008 while directing notice to issue in the petition, this Court stayed the directions given by the CIC in paras 16(ii) and (iii) of the impugned order. The Respondent has filed his reply to the petition.

    13. This Court has heard the submissions of Mr. G.E Vahanvati, the learned Attorney General for India and Ms. Sonia Mathur, the learned Counsel appearing for the Respondent.

    14. On behalf of the Petitioner, it is submitted that the CIC exceeded its jurisdiction under Sections 18 and 19 of the RTI Act 2005 in issuing the directions in paras 16(H) and (iii) of the impugned order, as extracted hereinbefore. It is submitted that the scope and ambit of the powers of the CIC under Section 19(8)(b), RTI Act does not extend to issuing the above directions. In any event, the CIC could not have directed payment of a sum equivalent to the minimum scale of pay in the post which was offered to other land oustees or in the post of Peon/Attendant for the period January 1985 to June 2008 aggregating to Rs. 11,28,000/-. Further, there was no occasion for the CIC to issue general directions to the NTPC to take steps to alleviate the economic difficulties of other land oustees.

    15. In reply, it is contended on behalf of the Respondent that in the background of the facts which led to the filing of the application under the RTI Act, the directions issued by the CIC were justified. It is sought to be submitted that the Respondent, being a poor person waiting for justice for several years, could not be faulted for approaching the authorities under the RTI Act for relief. The CIC's direction to the NTPC to pay the Respondent the aforementioned sum is sought to be justified with reference to the powers of the CIC under Section 19(8)(b) of the RTI Act.

    16. In the considered view of this Court, the scope of the powers of the CIC under the RTI Act is essentially to ensure that no citizen is unfairly deprived of information to which he or she is legitimately entitled to, subject of course to such information being held by a public authority and being accessible. Under Section 2(f) of the RTI Act information includes any records, documents which can be accessed by a public authority under any other law and under Section 2 (j) of the RTI Act the ‘right to information’ means “the right to information accessible under this Act which is held by or under the control of any public authority”. In the context of the present case, therefore the CIC was first required to determine if the survey report which was sought by the Respondent, was in fact a document that was available with the NTPC. The impugned order reveals that even according to the CIC, the existence of the survey report was a ‘disputed’ question. NTPC kept asserting that there was no such survey report and the Respondent kept contending to the contrary. CIC concluded that this question was a disputed one.

    17. In terms of section 18 of the rti act, the powers and functions of the CIC, inter alia, includes the power to conduct an inquiry into the complaint of a person who has been refused access to any information requested under the RTI Act or who has not been given a response to a request for information or access to information within the time limits specified under this Act. When a person who has been denied any information, approaches the CIC by way of an appeal, then under Section 19(8) while rendering its decision in such appeal, the CIC has the power to do the following:

    “19(8) In its decision, the Central Information or State Information Commission, as the case may be, has the power to—

    (a) require the public authority to take any such steps as may be necessary to secure compliance with the provisions of this Act, including—

    (i) by providing access to information, if so requested, in a particular form;

    (ii) by appointing a Central Public Information Officer or State Public Information Officer, as the case may be;

    (iii) by publishing certain information or categories of information;

    (iv) by making necessary changes to its practices in relation to the maintenance, management and destruction of records;

    (v) by enhancing the provision of training on the right to information for its officials;

    (vi) by providing it with an annual report in compliance with clause (b) of Sub-section (1) of Section 4;

    (b) require the public authority to compensate the complainant for any loss or other detriment suffered;

    (c) impose any of the penalties provided under this Act;

    (d) reject the application.”

    18. The ambit of the power under Section 19(8)(b) has to be determined by the scope of the powers of the CIC generally under Section 19, and as an Appellate Authority in terms of Section 19(1) to (8). The compensation payable under Section 19(8)(b) is “for any loss or other detriment suffered”, on account of the denial of the information under the RTI Act and not just about any loss or detriment suffered by the applicant. In the context of the present case if the CIC had found that the Respondent was unfairly denied by the NTPC, the information sought for by him, the CIC was next to determine the precise loss suffered by the Respondent on account of such denial of information. Thereafter it could pass appropriate orders to compensate the Respondent for the loss or detriment suffered. In the present case, there is no finding by the CIC that the NTPC had in its records a survey report which it unfairly denied to the Respondent. This factual determination was essential for the CIC to proceed to determine the loss suffered by the Respondent on account of the denial of such information. Thereafter under Section 19(8)(b), RTI Act it was in the discretion of the CIC to award compensation. Even while exercising that power a finding would have to be rendered by the CIC on the extent of loss, even approximately, suffered by the person to whom such information ought to have been furnished. This is because the compensation that has to be awarded under Section 19(8)(b) is for the loss or the detriment suffered “on account of the denial of such information” and not just about any loss or detriment suffered by such person. There is no such determination by the CIC in the present case.

    19. This Court is of the considered view that there was no occasion for the CIC to issue the directions contained in para 16(ii) and (iii) of the impugned order. Those directions were entirely outside the scope and powers of the CIC under the RTI Act. This Court has no hesitation, therefore, in setting aside the said directions in para 16(ii) and 16(iii) of the impugned order.

    20. It is, however, made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the merits of the Respondent's claim for employment with the NTPC. As and when the Respondent seeks appropriate remedies for that purpose, his case will be decided by such authority or Court concerned without being influenced by any of the observations on merits in this order or the impugned order of the CIC.

    21. The learned Attorney General for India informs the Court that the NTPC has no objection to provide information to the Respondent in terms of the directions contained in para 16(i) of the impugned order. It is submitted that such information has in fact already been furnished to the Respondent. However, the Respondent who is present in Court, denies having received any such information.

    22. Considering that the Respondent is not a resident of Delhi and has come here only for the purposes of this case, it is directed that the learned Counsel for the NTPC will arrange to have another set of the entire information and documents in terms of para 16(i) of the impugned order furnished to the Respondent by tomorrow, i.e, 10th March, 2010. Mr. Bharat Sangal, the learned Counsel appearing for the NTPC, states that if the Respondent visits his chamber tomorrow, i.e, 10th March, 2010 at 11 a.m, he will arrange to have the entire information and documents, as directed by the CIC in para 16(i) of the impugned order, furnished to the Respondent. The NTPC will also pay to the Respondent a sum of Rs. 5,000/- towards costs of his having to stay back in Delhi to receive the information. This costs will be paid to the Respondent when he visits the chamber of the learned Counsel for the Petitioner tomorrow.

    23. The petition is accordingly disposed of in the above terms. Order dasti to the Counsel for the parties under the signature of the Court Master.

    Petition disposed of.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    N.T.P.C Ltd. v. Mohd. Samad Khan .
    (Mar 9, 2010)