AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 21 Rule 1 and Order 24 of the CPC
  • Order 21 Rule 1 and Order 24 CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 21 Rule 1 and Order 24 of the CPC
  • Order 21 Rule 1 and Order 24 CPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The execution petition arises from an ex parte decree dated 22 August 2003 for recovery of Rs. 22,64,564/- with pendente lite and future interest at 9% per annum and costs of Rs. 35,653.57. The decree holder claimed Rs. 41,00,545.95 as due on 16 October 2003. The judgment debtor deposited Rs. 22,64,564/- (the principal amount) in court on 12 February 2004 and later deposited a further Rs. 18,35,982/-. Warrants of attachment were issued for Rs. 1,84,904.52 (the remaining amount), which was deposited subject to determination of whether court deposits made after institution of execution are to be appropriated first to interest (decree holder's contention) or first to principal (judgment debtor's contention). The deposit in dispute stood ordered to be kept in a fixed deposit pending determination.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether deposits made by the judgment debtor in court after filing of the execution petition are to be appropriated first towards interest and costs or first towards the principal amount.
  2. Whether, given that question of appropriation, the decree holder is entitled to the entire Rs. 1,84,904.52 deposited in court or only Rs. 66,578.17 as claimed by the judgment debtor.

Arguments of the Parties

Judgment Debtor's Arguments

  • Upon depositing the entire principal amount of Rs. 22,64,564/-, interest ought to stop running, so only Rs. 66,578.17 remained due to the decree holder towards interest until the date of deposit.
  • Relied on Nandi Investments and Enterprises v. L.M. Saravamangala AIR 2004 SC 4765.

Decree Holder's Arguments

  • Deposits should be appropriated first towards interest (and costs) and then towards principal; thus the decree holder is entitled to the entire Rs. 1,84,904.52 deposited in court.
  • Relied on Gurpreet Singh v. Union of India (2006) 8 SCC 457, Mathunni Mathai v. Hindustan Organic Chemicals Ltd. (1995) 4 SCC 26 and Meghraj & Ors. v. Mst. Bayabai & Ors AIR 1970 SC 161.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nandi Investments and Enterprises v. L.M Saravamangala AIR 2004 SC 4765 Cited by the judgment debtor (specific rule as invoked is not detailed in the opinion); the judgment was remanded to the High Court. The court noted this decision had been remanded and was therefore of no help to the judgment debtor.
Gurpreet Singh v. Union Of India. (2006) 8 SCC 457 Held (para 26) that in execution of money decrees interest ceases to run on the amount deposited to the extent of the deposit; if amount falls short, appropriation may be made first towards interest, then costs, then principal. Para 53 recognizes an exception where the judgment debtor specifies the head of deposit. The court treated this Five-Judge Bench decision as authoritative, applied its rule of appropriation (interest and costs first, then principal) subject to the stated exception, and relied on it to resolve the dispute.
Mathunni Mathai v. Hindustan Organic Chemicals Ltd. (1995) 4 SCC 26 Cited by the decree holder (specific rule or principle cited is not stated in the opinion). Included among authorities relied on by the decree holder; considered in the context of supporting appropriation towards interest first.
Meghraj & Ors. v. Mst. Bayabai & Ors AIR 1970 SC 161 Cited by the decree holder (specific rule or principle cited is not stated in the opinion). Included among authorities relied on by the decree holder.
Moolji v. Indian Railway Construction Company Limited 89 (2001) DLT 766 Held that allowing adjustment towards principal first would be against law and public policy because it would permit the judgment debtor to avoid payment of interest. The court cited this decision to support the proposition that the deposit of principal does not stop interest and that amounts must be adjusted to interest and costs first.
Tosh and Sons India Limited v. N.N Khanna 131 (2006) DLT 599 : 2006 (89) DRJ 248 Expressed the same view as Moolji (i.e., against adjusting deposits to principal first). Used to reinforce the court's conclusion that deposits should be applied to interest and costs before principal.
Bengal Silk Trading Company v. D.S Bhalla 65 (1997) DLT 219 : 1997 (40) DRJ 254 Expressed the same view as Moolji (i.e., against adjusting deposits to principal first). Used to reinforce the court's conclusion that deposits should be applied to interest and costs before principal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first noted an initial impression that references to "deposit" in Order 21 Rule 1 and Order 24 CPC might mean deposit of principal only. It then relied on the Five-Judge Bench decision in Gurpreet Singh, which held that in execution of money decrees interest ceases to run only to the extent of the amount deposited and that, where the amount deposited falls short, appropriation may be made first towards interest, then costs, then principal. The court observed that para 53 of Gurpreet Singh recognizes an exception when the judgment debtor specifies the head on which a deposit is made and notifies the decree-holder. The court found that the judgment debtor here did not intimate that the deposit of Rs. 22,64,564/- was made towards principal. The court also relied on local High Court decisions (Moolji; Tosh and Sons; Bengal Silk Trading) holding that allowing adjustment to principal first would be contrary to law and public policy. Applying these authorities, the court concluded that the principal deposit did not stop interest from running; the deposit must be adjusted first to interest and costs due on the date of deposit, and any remaining principal continues to incur interest.

Holding and Implications

The decree holder is entitled to the entire sum of Rs. 1,84,904.52 deposited in court; the execution petition is disposed of.

Direct consequences: the disputed amount of Rs. 1,84,904.52 was ordered to be kept in a fixed deposit and the decree holder is entitled to the interest earned on that deposit. The opinion sets out application of existing precedents to the facts; it does not purport to establish a new legal precedent beyond those authorities relied upon.

    Sundeep Industries Decree Holder v. Collector Of Customs & Another Judgment Debtors.

    Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.:— The only surviving issue in this execution petition is as to whether out of the amount of Rs. 1,84,904.52 deposited by the judgment debtor in this court, the decree holder is entitled to a sum of Rs. 66,578.17 only as contended by the judgment debtor or to the entire amount as contended by the decree holder. The answer to the said issue depends upon whether the deposits made by the judgment debtor in the court after filing of the execution petition are to be appropriated first towards interest as contended by the decree holder or first towards the principal amount as contended by the judgment debtor. If the appropriation is towards the interest first, then the decree holder is entitled to the release of the entire sum of Rs. 1,84,904.52. However, if the appropriation is towards the principal first then the decree holder is entitled to the release of Rs. 66,578.17 only.

    2. An ex parte decree dated 22nd August, 2003 was passed in favour of the decree holder for recovery of Rs. 22,64,564/- together with pendente lite and future interest @ 9% per annum from the date of institution of the suit till the date of realization. Costs of Rs. 35,653.57 were also awarded to the decree holder. The decree holder filed this execution stating that as on 16th October, 2003 a sum of Rs. 41,00,545.95 was due under the decree. The judgment debtor, on notice of the execution being issued, first deposited a sum of Rs. 22,64,564/- in this court as recorded in the order dated 21st May, 2004 in the execution. This amount was the exact amount of which the decree was passed besides interests and costs. However, on 21st May, 2004 when it was informed that the said amount had been deposited, it was not stated that the deposit was under any particular head. The order dated 21st May, 2004 itself directs the judgment debtor to deposit the balance decretal amount. Thereafter, a further sum of Rs. 18,35,982/- was deposited by the judgment debtor in the court. On the submissions of the decree holder that the sum of Rs. 1,84,904.54 remains outstanding on the decree, warrants of attachment for the said amount were issued towards the same. The amount was deposited by the judgment debtor in the court subject to the determination instant. The counsel for the judgment debtor has urged that upon the judgment debtor depositing the entire principal amount of Rs. 22,64,564/- before the court on 12th February, 2004, notwithstanding the judgment debtor having not deposited the remaining decretal amount which was towards interest and costs only, further interest ought to stop running and as such besides the amount mentioned in the decree only the sum of Rs. 66,578.17 more was due to the decree holder towards interest till the date of deposit. Reliance in this regard is placed on Nandi Investments and Enterprises v. L.M Saravamangala AIR 2004 SC 4765. However, the said judgment after recording the submissions of the parties remanded the matter to the High Court for fresh adjudication and is of no help to the judgment debtor. The counsel for the decree holder has on the other hand placed reliance on Gurpreet Singh v. Union Of India. (2006) 8 SCC 457, Mathunni Mathai v. Hindustan Organic Chemicals Ltd. (1995) 4 SCC 26 and Meghraj & Ors. v. Mst. Bayabai & Ors AIR 1970 SC 161.

    3. At first blush it appears that reference in Order 21 Rule 1 and Order 24 CPC to ôdepositö has to be reference to deposit of principal amount only since interest runs on the same only and question of cessation of interest on deposit of interest amount, which does not incur any further interest, does not arise. However, a Five Judges Bench of the Apex Court in Gurpreet Singh (supra) has extensively analyzed the provisions of Order 21 Rule 1 and Order 24 of the CPC and have held in para 26 as under:

    “26. Thus, in cases of execution of money decrees or award decrees, or rather, decrees other than mortgage decrees, interest ceases to run on the amount deposited, to the extent of the deposit. It is true that if the amount falls short, the decree holder may be entitled to apply the rule of appropriation by appropriating the amount first towards the interest, then towards the costs and then towards the principal amount due under the decree.”

    The Apex Court in para 53 of the judgment even made the above rule subject to an exception—where deposit is indicated towards specified heads by judgment debtor while making the deposit intimating the decree-holder of his intention.

    4. I have already noted above that the judgment debtor, in the present case, though first depositing the exact principal amount, at no stage intimated to the decree holder that the deposit was being made towards principal. I may notice that a Single Bench of this Court in Moolji v. Indian Railway Construction Company Limited 89 (2001) DLT 766 has also held that if the amounts were allowed to be adjusted towards the principal amount first, it would not only be against the provisions of law but would also be against the public policy inasmuch as the judgment debtor would then after depositing the principal amount delay the payment of the amount decreed towards interest and on which the decree holder would not be entitled to future interest. The same view has also been taken in Tosh and Sons India Limited v. N.N Khanna 131 (2006) DLT 599 : 2006 (89) DRJ 248 and Bengal Silk Trading Company v. D.S Bhalla 65 (1997) DLT 219 : 1997 (40) DRJ 254.

    5. Thus, the amount of Rs. 22,64,564/- deposited by the judgment debtor on 12th February, 2004 would not cease the running of interest. The said deposit will be adjusted in interest and costs first, due on that date and the balance principal amount shall continue to incur interest.

    6. In view of the above, the decree holder is entitled to the entire amount of Rs. 1,84,904.52 lying deposited in this court. The said amount was ordered to be kept in a fixed deposit. The decree holder would also be entitled to the interest earned on the said deposit: The execution petition, accordingly, stands disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sundeep Industries Decree Holder v. Collector Of Customs & Another Judgment Debtors.
    (Jul 16, 2008)