Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Badar Durrez Ahmed, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs instituted a suit seeking, inter alia, a permanent injunction, relief for copyright infringement, delivery up, rendition of accounts and other reliefs to restrain the defendants from illegally using the plaintiffs' software products.

Summons were issued and served on the defendants but no one appeared for them. On 17.09.2007 the court directed that the defendants be proceeded against ex parte and the plaintiff was directed to lead ex parte evidence by filing evidence affidavit(s).

The plaintiff filed the affidavit of Mr. Ravi Lal Thapa (PW-1), who is the constituted attorney of the plaintiff company, and exhibited documents marked PW-1/1 to PW-1/8.

According to the plaint, Plaintiff No.1 is a German company that developed enterprise-scale software (including early products such as SAP-RF1 and later SAP R/3) and Plaintiff No.2 is its Indian subsidiary. Defendant No.2 is alleged to provide ERP and eCRM services and training (and to run a BPO), operating from premises in Kolkata; Defendant No.1 is the managing director of Defendant No.2.

The plaintiffs allege that their software programs are tailor-made, copyright-protected products requiring individual licences even for educational or training use, and that the defendants were providing training using the plaintiffs' software (examples alleged to be SAP R/3, ABAP/4) as shown in Exhibits PW-1/5 and PW-1/6 taken from the defendant No.2's website.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendants used the plaintiffs' software without authority or a valid licence, thereby infringing the plaintiffs' copyrights in the software.
  2. Whether the plaintiffs, as registered owners of the copyrights in the software programmes, are entitled to a decree of permanent injunction and other reliefs claimed in the plaint (including delivery up and rendition of accounts).
  3. Whether, in view of the defendants' failure to appear and the consequent inability to ascertain illegal profits or actual damage, the court may award punitive damages and, if so, in what amount.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The plaintiffs asserted ownership of the copyrights in the software programmes (software falling within the meaning of Section 2 (ffc) and Section 2 (o) of the Indian Copyright Act, 1957).
  • The software is purpose-specific, user-specific and licenced separately for each user; licences are required even for educational and training purposes, and training may only be imparted by authorised partners.
  • The defendants were allegedly imparting training using the plaintiffs' software without authorisation or licence, as evidenced by Exhibits PW-1/5 and PW-1/6 taken from the defendant's website.
  • Given the unauthorised use, the plaintiffs sought permanent injunctions, delivery up, rendition of accounts and damages (including punitive damages) against the defendants.

No representative appeared or advanced any arguments on behalf of the defendants; the proceedings were conducted ex parte against them.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Time Incorporated v. Lokesh Srivastava & Anr., 2005 (30) PTC 3 (Del) Authority that the court may award punitive damages where defendants have failed to participate and actual accounts/assessment of profits cannot be made. The court relied on this precedent (as one among several decisions) to justify awarding punitive damages to the plaintiffs given the defendants' failure to appear and the impossibility of estimating illegal profits or actual damages.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded on the basis that the plaintiffs had produced an affidavit by their constituted attorney (PW-1) and documentary exhibits (Ex-PW-1/1 to Ex-PW-1/8), which supported the factual averments in the plaint and remained uncontroverted because the defendants did not appear.

The court accepted the plaintiffs' assertions that the software programmes in question are copyright-protected computer programmes (falling within the statutory definitions cited) and that licences are required even for educational and training use, with authorised partnerships required for imparting such training.

The court noted the material taken from the defendant's website (Exhibits PW-1/5 and PW-1/6) as evidence that the defendants were training students using the plaintiffs' software without authorisation or licence.

Because the plaintiffs' evidence went uncontroverted, the court concluded they were entitled to a decree of permanent injunction against the defendants for unauthorised use of the software.

Regarding the plaintiffs' claim for rendition of accounts, the court observed that, due to the defendants' non‑appearance, it was not possible to estimate illegal profits or quantify actual damages. Nonetheless, relying on precedent that permits awarding punitive damages in such circumstances, the court determined it could award punitive damages as an alternative to an exact accounting of profits.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The suit was decreed in favour of the plaintiffs in terms of the prayers contained in paragraphs 25(a) and 25(b) (as recorded in the judgment). The court further awarded punitive damages to the plaintiffs in the sum of Rs 2,50,000 and ordered that the suit be decreed with costs; the formal decree was to be drawn up.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the plaintiffs obtained a permanent injunction and related reliefs as claimed (per the specified paragraphs of the plaint) against the defendants for unauthorised use of the plaintiffs' software.
  • The court awarded punitive damages (Rs 2,50,000) because, in the absence of defendant participation, an account of illicit profits could not be constructed; the award was supported by existing authority permitting punitive damages in such circumstances.
  • The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal precedent; it applies established principles (and cites an earlier decision) to the facts of this ex parte case.

    Sap Ag v. Somaya Kanti Dutta

    Badar Durrez Ahmed, J.:— This is a suit filed for, inter alia, a decree of permanent injunction, infringement of copyright, delivery up and rendition of accounts, and to restrain the defendants from illegally using the software products of the plaintiffs. Summons of the suit were issued and duly served upon the defendants. Nobody appeared on behalf of the defendants and on 17.09.2007, the defendants were directed to be proceeded against ex parte. The plaintiff was directed to lead its ex parte evidence by way of filing evidence affidavit(s).

    2. The plaintiff has filed the affidavit of Mr Ravi Lal Thapa (PW1), by way of evidence. The said Mr. Ravi Lal Thapa is the constituted Attorney of the plaintiff company. The documents have also been exhibited as PW-1/1 to PW-1/8.

    3. As stated in the plaint the plaintiff No. 1 is a company incorporated in Germany and is involved in developing enterprise scale solutions. The Plaintiff No. 2 is the Indian subsidiary of the plaintiff No. 1. The defendant No. 2 is alleged to be engaged in the business of providing Enterprise Resource Planning and eCRM services to various clients including providing training in ERP software. It is also alleged that the defendant No. 2 is running a BPO service and managing its business from fourth floor, Garia Ghat Shopping Complex, 153, Rashbehari Evenue, Kolkatta. The defendant No. 1 is the Managing Director of the defendant No. 2.

    4. As averred in the plaint, the plaintiff No. 1 had, in the 1970's developed the SAP-RF1 computer software which was an automatic accounting and transaction processing programme, which was the first enterprise resource planning solution that enabled organizations in the deployment of their resources in the most efficient way for achieving maximum productivity. In 1992 the plaintiff No. 1 introduced SAP R/3. The software programmes of plaintiff are user specific and not available off the shelf.

    5. The software products are purpose specific and tailored as per the requirement of its clients. The licence agreements are also purpose specific and, therefore, cannot be used by any other person/organization without a valid licence from the plaintiff except for the purpose for which it is licensed. Hence, there are separate licences for each user. Being a copyright protected product, the permission/licence has to be taken from the plaintiff even for using the software for educational and training purposes. Consequently, the plaintiff has partnerships with specific entities for this educational and training purpose. And, therefore, without the plaintiffs' authorization or licence, no education or training can be imparted by any person on the plaintiffs' software.

    6. As per averments contained in the plaint, the plaintiff No. 1 is the sole and whole owner of copyrights in respect of the software programmes developed by it. The computer programmes fall within the meaning of Section 2 (ffc) of the Indian Copyright Act, 1957 and is also included in the definition of literary work as per Section 2 (o) of the said Act. According to the plaintiff, the defendant has been training students using the software programmes like SAP R/3, ABAP/4 etc of the plaintiff as would be apparent from the material Exhibits PW-1/5 and PW-1/6 placed on record which has been taken from the website of the defendant No. 2.

    7. The allegations made in the plaint have been supported by the affidavit evidence of Mr. Ravi Lal Thapa (PW-1) as well as the documents exhibited as Ex-PW-1/1 to Ex-PW-1/8 and the same have gone uncontroverted. Therefore, being the registered owner of the copyrights in the said software programmes, or the said software programmes, the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree of permanent injunction in their favour and against the defendants who have been using the said software without any authority or valid licence from the plaintiffs.

    8. Accordingly, the suit is decreed in terms of prayers contained in paragraphs 25 (a), (b) and (b), [i.e, both the sub-paragraphs numbered as (b)].

    9. Insofar as the prayer for rendition of accounts in paragraph 25 (c) of the plaint is concerned, since the defendants have failed and/or neglected to appear in these proceedings, it would not be possible to even make an estimate of the illegal profits earned by the defendants and the actual damage caused to the plaintiffs. However, in such circumstances, the court is not powerless and can award punitive damages as has been held in several decisions including Time Incorporated…Plaintiff; v. Lokesh Srivastava & Anr.…Defendants Ex Parte.: 2005 (30) PTC 3 (Del).

    10. Thus, the plaintiff is also entitled to a decree of punitive damages against the defendants which I quantify at Rs 2,50,000/-. The suit is decreed as indicated above with costs. The formal decree be drawn up.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sap Ag v. Somaya Kanti Dutta
    (Feb 25, 2008)