Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972,
  • Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972
  • Rule 41 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.
  • Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972,
  • Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972
  • Rule 41 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.
  • Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Manmohan Sarin, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was a Constable (Executive) in the Delhi Police. Along with another constable, he demanded illegal gratification and extorted Rs. 1,000 from a person named Kundan Singh. The disciplinary charges were substantiated and proved, and the Disciplinary Authority ordered the petitioner's dismissal from service.

The petitioner challenged the dismissal before the Central Administrative Tribunal (OA), which was dismissed on 19 August 1993; a review was dismissed on 4 October 1993. A belated writ petition filed in 2002 challenging the dismissal was dismissed on 27 May 2002. On 16 February 2005 the petitioner represented for grant of compassionate allowance under Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972; this representation was rejected. An OA challenging the rejection was filed (OA 1005/2006) and dismissed on 24 May 2006. The present writ petition impugns that dismissal/rejection.

The court has perused an elaborate judgment of the learned brother analyzing Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, the OM dated 22 April 1940 and entitlement to compassionate allowance where dismissal is on account of grave misconduct. The court agrees that the impugned order of the Tribunal deserves to be set aside, and it remands the matter for fresh consideration.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a dismissed employee (dismissal for grave misconduct involving proven dishonesty) is entitled to compassionate allowance under Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.
  2. Whether an isolated incident of grave misconduct can be determinative of entitlement to compassionate allowance, or whether the entire service record must be considered.
  3. Whether Rule 41 prescribes any time limit for making a claim for compassionate allowance and how belated claims should be treated.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The solitary incident (the 1987 extortion/demand for gratification) should not be determinative of entitlement to compassionate allowance because the petitioner's overall service record was otherwise satisfactory and commendable.
  • The petitioner sought grant of compassionate allowance under Rule 41 (representation made on 16 February 2005), albeit many years after dismissal.

Respondent / Authorities' Position

  • The authorities rejected the claim for compassionate allowance, primarily relying on the solitary incident of proven misconduct (the 1987 incident) as the basis for denial.
  • The Tribunal affirmed the rejection (OA dismissed), and the impugned order upheld that rejection, which is now set aside by the court for failing to consider the entire service record.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds from the following observations and legal points stated in the opinion:

  1. The court expressly agrees with the earlier detailed analysis (by the learned brother) of Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 and the OM dated 22 April 1940 concerning compassionate allowance and dismissal for grave misconduct, and accepts the conclusion that the impugned order should be set aside.
  2. The petitioner did not produce any material or evidence in support of his compassionate allowance claim along with the writ petition (specifically, no medical records were produced). Because of this lack of material before the court, the matter must be remanded to the competent authorities for fresh consideration of the claim in its entirety.
  3. The court recounts the facts of proven misconduct (extortion of Rs. 1,000 from Kundan Singh) which led to dismissal; those charges were substantiated beyond doubt.
  4. The court holds as a legal principle for consideration of compassionate allowance that the entire service record must be considered. An isolated incident of misconduct, however grave, cannot alone be determinative, although dishonesty in service is a significant and relevant factor to be weighed alongside other considerations (such as financial and personal circumstances).
  5. With respect to timing, the court notes that Rule 41 does not prescribe any time limit for making a claim for compassionate allowance; typically, claims arise contemporaneously with cessation of employment and pension determination. The court observes a judicial trend of reconsidering belated compassionate allowance claims, though discordant decisions exist. In this case the petitioner filed his claim nearly 17 years after dismissal. The court refrains from pronouncing on the justifiability of the delay and leaves the issue of delayed submission to the Competent Authority to consider on the facts, including whether the need for allowance arose belatedly.
  6. Because the authorities focused mainly on the 1987 incident and failed to consider the petitioner's complete service record and other relevant factors, the impugned order must be set aside and the matter remanded.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The impugned order is set aside and the matter is remanded to the competent authorities for fresh decision within one month in light of the court's observations.

Implications for the parties and administration:

  • The competent authority must reconsider the petitioner's claim for compassionate allowance under Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, taking into account the petitioner's entire service record and other relevant factors (financial and personal circumstances), and not treating a single isolated incident as automatically determinative.
  • The competent authority may and should consider the delay in filing the claim (the petitioner's claim was made approximately 17 years after dismissal), but the court has left assessment of the justifiability of that delay to the authority itself and has not ruled on whether the delay is fatal.
  • The petitioner did not provide supporting material (no medical records) with the writ petition; the remand necessarily contemplates consideration of evidence and material that the competent authority finds relevant in deciding the claim afresh.
  • No new legal precedent was announced by the court beyond these determinations; the court applied existing principles (as set out in the learned brother's analysis) and directed reconsideration on the facts.

Order: Matter remanded for fresh decision within one month; impugned Tribunal order set aside.

    Ex. Asi Shadi Ram v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi And Ors.

    Manmohan Sarin, J.:— The comprehensive and elaborate judgment of my esteemed brother analyzing provisions of Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, OM dated 22nd April, 1940 and the entitlement to compassionate allowance where dismissal from service is on account of a grave mis-conduct or charge, have been perused. I am in agreement with the conclusion reached that the impugned order of the Tribunal in the instant case deserves to be set aside.

    2. Considering the chequered history of this litigation spanning over nearly two decades, one could have considered deciding the question of entitlement to compassionate allowance in the exercise of extra-ordinary writ jurisdiction itself to avoid further delay.

    3. However, the petitioner has not produced along with the writ petition any material or other evidence in support of his claim for compassionate allowance. No medical records have been produced. The matter, therefore, has to be remanded to the authorities for being considered in its entirety.

    4. In the instant case, petitioner who was a Constable (Executive) in the Delhi Police along with another constable demanded illegal gratification and extorted Rs. 1000/- from one Kundan Singh. The charges against the petitioner were substantiated and proved beyond doubt culminating in the order of dismissal of the petitioner being passed by the Disciplinary Authority.

    5. Petitioner challenged the order of dismissal in OA filed before the Central Administrative Tribunal. OA was dismissed on 19th August, 1993. Review was also dismissed on 4th October, 1993. Petitioner belatedly filed a writ petition in 2002 challenging the order of dismissal. Same was also dismissed on 27th May, 2002. It was on 16th February, 2005, petitioner made his representation for grant of compassionate allowance under Rule 41 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. This was rejected leading to the filing of OA before the Tribunal. The Tribunal directed the authorities to pass a reasoned order in consonance with Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules and the Government Instructions/Guidelines. The respondent again rejected the claim for compassionate allowance vide an order dated 24th February, 2006.

    6. Petitioner filed OA 1005/2006 challenging the said order of rejection. The OA was dismissed vide orders dated 24th May, 2006 which is impugned in the present writ petition. As observed earlier, the impugned order deserves to be set aside as the authorities have primarily considered the solitary incident of 1987 and have failed to consider the entire service record. Petitioner claims that said incident by itself cannot in this otherwise satisfactory and commendable record.

    7. I am in agreement with the finding that for the purposes of considering grant of compassionate allowance, entire service record needs to be considered and an isolated incident of misconduct, however, grave, cannot be determinative of the issue even though dishonesty in service is a significant and relevant factor to be considered among others such as financial and personal circumstances of the concerned employee.

    8. As regards the time when claim for compassionate allowance may be made. Rule 41 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 does not prescribe any time limit. However, normally the occasion for claiming compassionate allowance arise contemporaneously with the cession of employment and determination of pension and other benefits. The trend of judicial pronouncements has been to process the claim for compassionate allowance even though belatedly made. A number of judicial pronouncements have been noted by my learned brother in para 32 of his judgment, where the Courts have directed reconsideration of the claim for compassionate allowance even though belatedly made. There have been discordant notes also in this regard. In the instant case, petitioner has sought compassionate allowance nearly 17 years after dismissal from service. I refrain from making any observation on this aspect as it would be of the Competent Authority to consider the justifiability of the claim for compassionate allowance, including the aspect of delayed submission based on all relevant factors, such as the circumstances of the petitioner and the need of the same having arisen belatedly, if so urged.

    9. The impugned order is accordingly set aside and matter remanded to authorities for decision afresh within a month in the light of observations made hereinabove.

    10. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ex. Asi Shadi Ram v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi And Ors.
    (Feb 22, 2008)