Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Swatanter Kumar, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Government issued a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act on 10.11.1986 and a declaration under Section 6 on 5.3.1987 to acquire 99 bighas 6 biswas of land in village Kapashera for a public purpose (linking Palam Diversion, NH No. 8 with Gurgaon Bye Pass). The Collector made Award No. 14/88-89 on 3.3.1989, fixing compensation at Rs. 13,660 per bigha based on average sale transactions between 28.10.1985 and 6.11.1986.

Aggrieved claimants filed references under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act to the Additional District Judge who, after permitting evidence, by order dated 29.7.2005 enhanced the market value to Rs. 15,000 per bigha. The Union of India filed three appeals seeking to set aside the 29.7.2005 judgment and restore the Collector's award. The appeals were time-barred and the appellants filed separate applications (CMs) for condonation of a 52-day delay, explaining the delay as arising from internal processing and the need to obtain and receive departmental/legal opinions.

Notices were issued and respondents were served. Respondents Nos.1–13 did not appear and were ordered to be proceeded against ex parte; respondent No.14 appeared and stated support for the appellant on merits and on condonation of delay. The court notes that the appellant cured a deficiency in court fee, leading to disposal of certain interlocutory CMs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the delay of 52 days in filing the appeals should be condoned under Section 5 of the Limitation Act.
  2. Whether the Reference Court was right in enhancing compensation from Rs. 13,660 to Rs. 15,000 per bigha in the absence of direct documentary or oral evidence proving potentiality/similarity of the land.
  3. Whether reliance on awards in adjoining or nearby acquisitions (and application of a principle of 'Annual Percentage Increase') is permissible where direct evidence is absent, and the conditions in which such a principle may be applied.
  4. Whether the Reference Court could take judicial notice (from the NCT Delhi map) that two villages were adjacent and thus justify applying the same compensation pattern without that map being exhibited or proved in evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • There was no material before the Reference Court to justify enhancement of compensation.
  • The Reference Court misapplied the principle in Ramesh Solanki v. Union of India in granting enhancement (an argument that the known principle requires positive documentary or oral evidence for enhancement).
  • The claimants failed to lead evidence regarding potentiality or similarity of the land; therefore the Court could not enhance compensation by reference to a previous award or by applying an 'Annual Percentage Increase' principle without proof.
  • Counsel relied on Kanwar Singh v. Union of India to argue that adjoining-village awards are not necessarily applicable where situation and potentiality differ.

Respondent No. 14's Position

  • Respondent No. 14 appeared and stated support for the appellant on merits and for condonation of delay.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramesh Solanki v. Union of India, AIR 1995 Delhi 358 Cited in relation to the principle of applying an 'Annual Percentage Increase' or enhancement methodology when direct evidence is not available; appellant argued it was misapplied. The court observed that the principle of 'Annual Percentage Increase' is not impermissible as a matter of law where direct evidence is absent, but such resort must be based on satisfaction of requisite ingredients; thus the principle can be applied in discretion, not as an automatic rule.
Atri & Atri v. Union of India (Ex.P1 — Award in LAC No. 877/1993) Used as a comparable award (Village Samalkhan) where notification under Section 4 was on 1.10.1986; used by the Reference Court as a basis for comparison. The court noted the Reference Court's reliance on Ex.P1 but criticized the Reference Court for taking judicial notice of adjacency between villages without evidence; the court accepted the relevance of comparable awards but required proof of similarity/potentiality before applying them.
Sita Ram v. Union Of India, 79 (1979) DLT 10 (DB) Principle that where there is large scale acquisition in adjacent villages with the same potential, the same pattern of valuation should be consistently followed by the Court. The court approved the principle as a correct legal proposition but held that the factual predicate (adjacency and same potential) must be established by evidence; it cannot be supplied by judicial notice of an un-exhibited map.
Kanwar Singh v. Union of India, AIR 1999 SC 317 Cited to support the proposition that it is not necessary to rely upon compensation in adjoining villages where situation and potentiality differ. The court recorded the appellant's reliance on this authority to emphasize that adjoining awards are not automatically applicable and that factual differences can preclude reliance on them.
Panna Lal Ghosh and Ors. v. Land Acquisition Collector and Ors., AIR 2004 SC 1179 Reiterated principles (including those in Balak Ram Gupta) about proof of potentiality/similarity required in acquisition cases. The court referred to this Supreme Court authority to support the position that the onus is on parties to prove potentiality and similarity; absence of direct evidence weakens reliance on adjacent awards.
Balak Ram Gupta (case referred to within Panna Lal Ghosh) Principle enunciated relating to the requirement of proof of potentiality/similarity (as referred to in later authorities). The court noted that Panna Lal Ghosh reiterated the principle enunciated in Balak Ram Gupta, reinforcing the requirement that factual similarity must be pleaded and proved, not presumed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two main strands: interlocutory/limitation issues and the merits on enhancement of compensation.

On interlocutory matters, the court observed that the appellant corrected a deficiency in court fee (ad valorem court fee placed on file) and accordingly disposed of the related CMs for deficiency. As to limitation, the court considered the applications for condonation of a 52-day delay. The appellants explained the delay as resulting from internal processing, including obtaining and receiving the opinion of the Deputy Legal Advisor, L&B (opinion approved on 22.11.2005 and received on 25.11.2005), and subsequent processing by the Land Acquisition Collector's office. The court found these explanations, supported by affidavits, to amount to sufficient cause and allowed the condonation applications; consequently the delay was condoned and the related CMs disposed of.

On the merits, the court examined the appellant's principal contention that there was no material before the Reference Court to justify enhancement of compensation. The court acknowledged the settled legal position that enhancement of compensation ideally requires positive documentary or oral evidence. However, it also stated that where direct evidence is not available, the court may in its discretion apply principles such as an 'Annual Percentage Increase' to arrive at a fair valuation, but only if the necessary factual ingredients for such an approach are otherwise established.

The Reference Court had relied upon Ex.P1 (an award in LAC No. 877/1993 relating to Village Samalkhan) and the Supreme Court decision in Sita Ram to justify applying the same valuation pattern to adjacent villages deemed to have the same potential. The present court accepted the legal proposition from Sita Ram that identical valuation may be followed for adjacent villages of similar potential, but it emphasized that factual adjacency and similarity must be pleaded and proved.

The court identified a specific error in the Reference Court's reasoning: the Reference Court took "judicial notice" that Village Samalka and Village Kapashera were adjacent because the NCT Delhi map purportedly showed them adjacent, despite no evidence that the map had been exhibited or tendered in the reference proceedings. The present court held that there cannot be a presumption as to matters of fact and that taking judicial notice in those circumstances was incorrect. The onus to prove potentiality and similarity lay primarily on the claimants. Given the absence of direct evidence and the improper reliance on an unproduced map, the court found the enhancement ordering unsustainable.

Consequently, while accepting that comparative awards and the 'Annual Percentage Increase' principle can be used in suitable circumstances, the court concluded that here the factual prerequisites were not satisfied and the Reference Court's findings on adjacency/similarity (based on the un-exhibited map) could not stand.

Holding and Implications

Holding: (a) The applications for condonation of delay (CMs No. 2065/2006, 2068/2006 and 2081/2006) were allowed and the delay of 52 days was condoned;

(b) The court accepted the appeal partially, set aside the judgment dated 29.7.2005 of the learned Additional District Judge insofar as it enhanced compensation, and remanded the matter to the Reference Court with directions to have the parties lead evidence on the issue of potentiality and similarity (the court directed that the parties appear before the Reference Court on…………and lead evidence on that issue in accordance with law).

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The condonation applications are allowed and the appeals are permitted to be heard on the merits. The Reference Court's enhancement order is set aside and the matter is remitted for fresh evidence on potentiality/similarity; the Collector's award restoration was sought by the Union but the court only partially accepted the appeal and remanded for further proceedings rather than directly restoring the Collector's award.
  • On precedent and broader law: The court reaffirmed established principles that (i) comparative awards and an 'Annual Percentage Increase' can be used when direct evidence is absent, but only when factual prerequisites are satisfied, and (ii) factual matters such as adjacency and potentiality must be pleaded and proved and cannot be presumed by judicial notice from materials not on record. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying these established principles to the facts of this case.

If any particular piece of procedural scheduling information (such as the precise date for appearance before the Reference Court) was not specified in the provided opinion text, it has been reproduced exactly as in the opinion.

    Union Of India v. Parbhati And Ors

    Swatanter Kumar, J.:— Since the appellant has made good the deficiency in Court fee and the ad valorem court fee has been placed on the file, all the applications bearing CMs No. 2064/2006, 2067/2006 and 2080/2006 filed by the appellants under Section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short ‘CPC’) have become infructuous and are accordingly disposed of.

    2. CMs No. 2064/2006, 2067/2006 and 2080/2006 stand accordingly disposed of.

    3. By this order I would also dispose of the above three applications bearing CM No. 2065/2006, CM No. 2068/2006 and CM No. 2081/2006 filed by the appellant under Section 5 of the Limitation Act for condonation of delay in filing the present appeals on merits. The facts giving rise to the present appeals fall in a very n arrow compass. The appropriate Government had issued a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) on 10.11.1986 and the declaration under Section 6 of the Act was issued on 5.3.1987 intending to acquire 99 bighas 6 biswas of land situated in the revenue estate of village Kapashera for a public purpose namely ‘for linking of Palam Diversion, NH No. 8 with Gurgaon, Bye Pass vide Award No. 14/88-89 of village Kapashera.

    4. The Collector in consonance with the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’), made and pronounced the award under Section 11 of the Act being Award No. 14/88-89 on 3.3.1989 As per the award, the Collector had awarded a sum of Rs. 13,660/- per bigha for the lands acquired. The Collector took the average market value of the sale transactions between 28.10.1985 to 6.11.1986, while fixing the market value of the acquired land at the relevant time, when the notification under Section 4 of the Act was issued. Claimants were dissatisfied with the reasoning of the Collector and also alleged that the Collector had not taken into consideration any evidence, documentary or otherwise. Being dissatisfied with the award of the Collector, the claimants filed references under Section 18 of the Act for enhancement of the compensation, which in turn were referred to the learned Additional District Judge, Delhi. The learned Additional District Judge after having permitted the parties to lead evidence in support of their respective claims, vide his order dated 29.7.2005 decided the reference and enhanced the market value to Rs. 15,000/- per bigha.

    5. The Union of India felt aggrieved from the said enhancement and has filed the above three appeals praying that the records of the concerned LACs (LAC No. 1322/1993, LAC NO. 1338/1993 and LAC No. 1130/1993) be called for and the judgment dated 29.7.2005 be set aside and the award of the Collector be restored.

    6. The appeals filed by the appellants are also barred by time. For condonation of delay in filing the appeal, the appellants have also filed CMs No. 2065/2006, 2068/2006 and 2081/2006 praying that the delay of 52 days in filing the present appeals be condoned. It has been stated in the applications that after the pronouncement of the award, the file was submitted to different Departments including for seeking opinion of the Deputy Legal Advisor, L&B. The opinion was approved on 22.11.2005 which was subsequently received in the Office of the Deputy Commissioner on 25.11.2005 and the Land Acquisition Collector after receiving the opinion directed the Naib Tehsildar, LA, to process the papers and get the appeal filed within time, after completing the necessary formalities. According to them the delay has occurred for bona fide reasons and is not intentional.

    7. Notice of the appeals as well as the applications for condonation of delay was issued to the respondents. As per report of the Registry, the respondents have been served. Despite service, nobody appeared on behalf of the respondents No. 1 to 13. However, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent No. 14 appeared and made a statement that they are supporting the case of the appellant on merits as well as for condonation of delay. Vide order dated 30.3.2006, the respondents No. 1 to 13 were ordered to be proceeded against ex parte in these proceedings.

    8. There is no opposition to the application for condonation of delay and in any case for the reasons stated in the application, which are supported by affidavits, we are satisfied that the appellants have been able to show sufficient cause for condonation of delay of 52 days in filing the appeal. Consequently, the applications for condonation of delay are allowed, the delay in filing of the appeals is condoned. CMs No. 2065/2006, 2068/2006 and 2081/2006 also stand disposed of accordingly.

    9. Now, coming to the merits of the appeals. The contention of the learned counsel appearing for the appellant is that there was no material before the learned Trial Court to arrive at a finding leading to enhancement of the compensation payable to the claimants. It is also contended that the Court has misapplied the principle in the case of Ramesh Solanki v. Union of India AIR 1995 Delhi 358 in granting 12% enhancement. The known principle is that the compensation payable to the claimants can be enhanced only on the basis of positive documentary and oral evidence. The claimants having failed to lead any evidence, either with regard to the potentiality or similarity of the land, the Court could not have enhanced the compensation with reference to the previous award and applied the principle of ‘Annual Percentage Increase’. Keeping in view the pleadings of the parties, the Reference Court had framed the following issues:—

    “(i) What was the fair market value of the land in dispute at the time of notification u/s 4 of the Act and what amount of enchanced compensation, if any, the petitioner is entitled?

    (ii) Relief.”

    10. Issue No. 1 was answered in favour of the claimants and by enhancing the compensation payable @ 15,000/- per bigha instead of Rs. 13,660/- as granted by the Collector. There is hardly any merit in the contention raised on behalf of the appellants that the principle of ‘Annual Percentage Increase’ cannot be applied as a preposition of law. It is a settled principle that wherever direct evidence is not available, the Court in its discretion, if otherwise satisfied of ingredients for enhancement of compensation in terms of the scheme of the Act, it cannot be said that resort to such a principle is impermissible in law. The learned Judge, relied upon Ex.P1, the award in LAC No. 877/1993 Atri & Atri v. Union of India relating to Village Samalkhan, where the notification under Section 4 was issued on 1.10.1986, and the notification in the present case was subsequent thereto. It is a well accepted cannot of law governing the acquisition proceedings that the potential location, utility of the land would have to be similar before the compensation awarded in the lands of the adjacent villages or adjacent areas can be made the basis for awarding the compensation. While the learned Reference Court rightly relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Sita Ram v. Union Of India. 79 (1979) DLT 10 (DB) in comingto the conclusion that where there is large scale acquisition of lands in various villages which are adjacent to each other and have the same potential, then the pattern of evaluation the same valuation should be consistently followed by the Court. But where the learned court erred in recording findings is apparent from paragraph 12 of the judgment which reads as under:—

    “12. Although there is no evidence on record that Village Samalka and village Kapashera are situated adjacent to each other, yet I am of the view that judicial notice can be taken of this fact because in the map of NCT Delhi both these villages have been shown adjacent to each other.”

    11. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant relied upon a judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Kanwar Singh v. Union of India AIR 1999 SC 317 to state that it is not necessary for the court to rely upon the compensation awarded to the claimants of the adjoining villages for the situation and potentiality of the lands in the adjoining villages were different and there cannot be a dispute to this preposition.

    12. There cannot be a presumption in relation to matters of fact. The fact must be pleaded and proved in accordance with law. In our view, the learned counsel could not have taken a judicial notice of the fact that the NCT map of Delhi showed both the villages adjacent to each other and therefore they would be entitled to the same compensation. To this extent, we are unable to sustain the findings recorded by the Court. The onus was on the parties, primarily on the claimants, to prove the potentiality and similarity between the acquired lands of the adjacent villages. In the case of Panna Lal Ghosh and Ors. v. Land Acquisition Collector and Ors. AIR 2004 SC 1179, again the Supreme Court reiterated the principle enunciated in the case of Balak Ram Gupta. There is no direct evidence on this issue and the reliance placed upon by the learned Court upon the map of NCT of Delhi which was neither exhibited on record nor was tendered in evidence, does not appear to be a correct approach of law. In view of the aforestated circumstances, we accept this appeal partially and set aside the award dated 29.7.2005 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Delhi, and remand the matter back with the direction that the parties would appear before the Reference Court on…………and lead evidence on that issue in accordance with law. This direction, we are issuing in the interest of justice and to ensure that the compensation awarded to the owners of the lands are in accordance with law. The Court cannot overlook the fact that the acquisition is not a voluntary sale on the part of the claimants. It is a compulsion where the claimants are left with no choice but to surrender their lands in accordance with law. To give advantage to the State on such pleas may not be a legal approach in consonance with the scheme of the Act because to give just and fair market value of the land as it existed at the time of the notification is the obligation of the State.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India v. Parbhati And Ors
    (Apr 27, 2006)